Quantcast

Are Old People Stealing Teens' Jobs?

SodaHead Living 2010/07/14 13:21:40
Related Topics: Food, McDonald's, Job
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Are you a teenager looking for a job? You might have to compete with Grandma.

Employees old enough to retire are outnumbering teens in the workplace for the first time since at least 1948, the New York Daily News reports.

The number of people aged 65 and older in the labor force averaged 6.6 million in the first half of this year. There are only 5.9 million workers between 16 and 19 in the labor force, according to the Labor Department.

Another eye-opening stat: There are now 1.13 older workers for every teen, compared with 0.5 a decade ago.

But you can't really blame Granny. The financial meltdown has forced seniors to stay in the workforce longer than they may have intended, Alicia Munnell, director of the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, told the Daily News.

"Older workers need to replenish their 401(k) plans, so those who have jobs are clinging to them rather than retiring," she said.

Even if you want to work at McDonald's, the older folks may have dibs on your job. In food preparation and serving -- the top category for teens -- employment fell by 242,000 among 16- to 19-year-olds, while rising by 128,000 among those 55 and older from 2000 to 2009, the News reported.

Are Old People Stealing Teens' Jobs?

Read More: http://www.nydailynews.com/money/2010/07/14/2010-0...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Redneck 2010/07/14 13:33:44
    No
    Redneck
    +11
    The elderly are more dependable, better common sense, and have valuable life experiences. As long as people want to work, let them work.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • nicholas williams 2012/11/20 14:22:12
  • Cassy 2010/08/31 00:24:14
    No
    Cassy
    +1
    Not all elderly people own their own homes as some have suggested. Some are actually still paying of debts from putting their kids through college.
  • A 2010/08/20 10:16:52
    No
    A
    +1
    I agree that the elderly aren't "stealing" anything. A job is a job and everyone competes. That being said, I think that employers should consider the future of the following generations when hiring. These sorts of jobs are typically teen jobs and without teens taking them, we could have some backlash in big business later on.

    Employers are essentially taking away valuable life experiences from teenagers that could help them to "man-up" and become more responsible. Also, all parents do not pay for their children because they have the same mob mentality of this thread (go get a job and make yourself useful); it's a catch 22.

    Everyone knows that both groups need jobs but by hiring the elderly in place of a teen we could be looking down the throat of a never-ending bad economy full of people who grew up not having jobs at all.

    How are they ever supposed to learn responsibility if no one gives it to them? If living with mommy and daddy is so simple, why won't the elderly ask for help from the children they raised. Their children owe it to them and then the focus could be shifted towards taking care of their parents rather than the upcoming generation.
  • Eric 2010/07/19 16:15:41
    No
    Eric
    Jobs are not "stolen". Jobs are earned, based on work ethic, education, dependability, etc. Perhaps if teens had better education, work ethics, etc, they would not be having "their" jobs stolen.
    Teens today are the first generation that is less educated than their parents, overall. Maybe if they would at least complete high school they would have better chances.
    Employers have a right, and obligation to the shareholders, to hire the best available help.
  • NinjaZombieslyr 2010/07/19 02:09:02
    No
    NinjaZombieslyr
    thats a mean word to say to te elderly...
  • disinter 2010/07/18 23:59:06 (edited)
    No
    disinter
    No, but government is via the minimum wage.
  • Jim 2010/07/18 23:20:51
    No
    Jim
    Older people are better workers, more dependable, and don't feel like they are owed anything like the y generation does... We have 3 generations working where i work and the older workers work circles around high school and collage kids... maybe the younger workers should learn a lesson from older workers that in the real world mommy isn't there to do your work for you...
  • ASPEN Jim 2010/07/19 07:21:33
    ASPEN
    +2
    As a 16 year old with a job on my families ranch I would have to agree with you. Though not all teenagers fall under the category of being undependable nor believe they are owed everything they don't work for but sadly the Majority are. I am blessed to have parents who taught and instilled good work ethics in all 10 of us (I'm the youngest) . There are no hand outs on this ranch.

    Besides Older people are the best teachers.
  • Jim ASPEN 2010/07/23 09:18:28
    Jim
    You are a wise young woman...Have a great Life...
  • ASPEN Jim 2010/07/23 20:02:50
    ASPEN
    Thank You Jim.
  • Brightsprite62 2010/07/18 22:00:06
    No
    Brightsprite62
    No job belongs exclusively to teens. It is the decision of the person hiring to determine who will and will not get a job. If an older person is more qualified and able to do the job then he has as much right to it as a teen.
  • ASPEN Brights... 2010/07/19 07:22:19
  • cruc1bl3 2010/07/18 07:40:42
    No
    cruc1bl3
    No, they are just voting for amoral scum who are.
  • JustinMata 2010/07/18 04:00:01
    No
    JustinMata
    +1
    Young people are just getting lazier with their iPods and Facebook and crap.

    Go old people!
  • ASPEN JustinMata 2010/07/19 07:24:30
    ASPEN
    +1
    I agree but not all teens have iPods or Cell Phones etc. I don't own either. My parents have always told us that if we want fancy toys we best find a way to pay for them. I take that as great advice.

    teens ipods cell phones parents told fancy toys pay advice teens ipods cell phones parents told fancy toys pay advice
  • Gir 2010/07/18 02:24:17
    Yes
    Gir
    How dare they take our jobs!? We should deport them to nursing homes in Florida! IT'S THE ONLY LOGICAL SOLUTION!!
  • Bandolier 2010/07/18 00:30:58
    Yes
    Bandolier
    But nine times out of ten they are better employees...
  • Shrek 2010/07/18 00:28:38
    Yes
    Shrek
    I can understand that the economy is bad. But the economy is bad for everyone, not just the elderly. The elderly have much more federal support than any other age group in America. The elderly typically get social security, retirement pay, have benefits, own their own home, are members of discount programs like AARP, and typically have more money lying around than the average teen.

    The teen market is a very important marketplace. Teens are more likely to place the money earned back into the economy. Teens need the experience and resume backing more than the elderly. More and more teens are living on their own, and not by choice. The economy is forcing a lot of teens to work before they want to and before they should have to. Their is virtually no support for a teenager in the situation that finds himself on the streets. Teens typically dont own homes and don't have a social security or retirement check coming in.

    Most elderly work out of pride, not necessity. Is pride more important than our children's futures?
  • Clarissa the Porcelain Liberal 2010/07/18 00:21:51
    No
    Clarissa the Porcelain Liberal
    They have to eat too.
  • Alan_Scott 2010/07/17 22:12:13
    No
    Alan_Scott
    +1
    Given the choice between someone with a lifetime of experience and someone who's going to flirt with and give freebies to every guy or girl who comes in, who would you hire?
  • Molōn labe 2010/07/17 13:37:39
    No
    Molōn labe
    If given a choice between a senior and a teen... I chose the senior. Not only can you depend on them, you can also learn from them.
  • carmen58 2010/07/17 08:28:38
    Yes
    carmen58
    And we all know how McDonald's will fatten your wallet....
  • Knowing360 2010/07/17 06:27:35
    No
    Knowing360
    A job is a job is a job. Either you apply and get hired or you don't.
  • wtf12345 2010/07/17 02:49:37
    No
    wtf12345
    +1
    No, everyone has the right to work. I do believe though that every teen that graduates from High School must server at least 2 years in the military so they can grow up and learn responsibility.
  • ChrisK1969 2010/07/16 14:40:56
  • Capuchin Monkey 2010/07/16 13:45:31
    Yes
    Capuchin Monkey
    Don't forget the 30 year olds out here stealing teen jobs.
  • den 2010/07/16 11:05:44
    No
    den
    +1
    you could just as well say that teens are stealing old peoples jobs.; such ideas are meaningless
  • DonAlexander 2010/07/16 07:27:11
  • JasmineMoniqueBell 2010/07/16 06:07:17 (edited)
    Yes
    JasmineMoniqueBell
    Its ok because granny will be dead in no time and I'll be there to take that old bags place! Oh and just another thing to all you rotten good for nothing judgemental hateful stupid pompous ignorant rude inconsiderant vile bigots who are using this as a excuse to bash the teens gang up on us and attack us for no reason (when you were one yourself and just jealous because you nolonger have the youthful vibrance and vibrance we possess and obviously are miserble bitter old farts who wish you could clean up your piece of rubbish lives but can't go back. also jealous because we are the FUTURE) and stereotype here you go..... thats what you guys are FAILURES.



    miserble bitter farts clean piece rubbish lives stereotype guys failures
  • mik-mik Jasmine... 2010/07/16 06:42:17
    mik-mik
    oh youre so rude......
  • Hammerhead 2010/07/16 05:14:07
  • Matton 2010/07/16 05:03:03
    No
    Matton
    That's impossible the old people were here first,...It could only be the teens who steal the old peoples jobs. Its like saying i cut you in line and i deserve to be first! WAKE UP PEOPLE!
  • QuitBlamingBush 2010/07/15 23:39:16
    No
    QuitBlamingBush
    +1
    I live in California. Illegals have stolen jobs away from our citizens. Carpentry, painting, lawn care, house cleaning and many other blue collar jobs have been taken away by these people. Teens looking for work should be out in the streets protesting against these illegals. That will never happen because most teens are liberal minded. It's politically correct to attack senior citizens for taking jobs from teens. If you dare speak out against illegal Mexicans stealing jobs, then you are racist. Something is wrong with this picture.

    jobs teens speak illegal mexicans stealing jobs racist wrong picture
  • Ojos40 2010/07/15 23:14:52
    No
    Ojos40
    +1
    On the whole, teenagers don't have the work ethic that employers need.
  • HOSS 2010/07/15 21:33:59
  • METALheadMom 2010/07/15 20:59:08
    No
    METALheadMom
    BITE ME!!!
  • John Al... METALhe... 2010/07/16 11:10:25
    John Alverez
    bet the little brat above, metal head mom has a great work ethic. lots of adults don't have a great work ethic either, other wise there wouldn't be so many public assistance handouts, everyone that lines up at the mail box for disability checks and the food stamp program is sick. many of those people don't need food stamps.
  • marcuss LIBERALS ARE IDIOTS 2010/07/15 19:25:57
    No
    marcuss LIBERALS ARE IDIOTS
    +2
    NO! the illegal invaders in many states are taking most of those jobs. They are also taking construction jobs that AMERICAN CITIZENS NEED!
  • Texas Johnny 2010/07/15 18:32:10
    No
    Texas Johnny
    Employers want people they depend on. Teens seem to be too picky about their job choices and are not seeing the big picture and tend to fly off the handle and quit when things get a little tough.
  • wtf12345 Texas J... 2010/07/17 02:51:22
    wtf12345
    So true. While I was growing up in PA, I was a apprentice cabinet maker with no pay. I loved working with wood.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 12 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/05/20 00:23:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals