Quantcast

Are Doctors more evil than good?

Anthony Souls 2012/04/23 01:22:35
Related Topics: Doctor, Doctors
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • doctorwhofan~Tatae~BN-4 2012/04/23 02:02:31
    No
    doctorwhofan~Tatae~BN-4
    And if you think otherwise, maybe you should refrain from going to hospitals
  • Anthony... doctorw... 2012/04/23 02:06:12
    Anthony Souls
    Doctors are more evil than good: or more apathetic than good: where would you have people go, if people need medical help, even if it's from apathetic doctors.

    In any event, you always hear about doctors prescribing incorrect medicines, doctors negligent in their duties, and operations where instruments are left in others. If doctors aren't more evil (apathetic) than good (caring), than how do you explain the abundance of stories to the contrary?

    Take care,
  • c.stuar... Anthony... 2012/04/23 02:14:49
    c.stuartHardwick
    RE: "you always hear about doctors ... negligent in their duties,". Indeed, these incidents are more dramatic and newsworthy than the million and million of cases of people going to the doctor, getting the correct treatment, and then not needing to go any longer. You cannot take such cases out of context.

    You cannot honestly describe air travel, say, as dangerous because plain loads of people die in fiery torment, yet ignore the reality that, on a passenger mile basis, air travel is not only by far the safest form of transportation, it is also far safer than staying home.

    You must look at the whole picture.
  • Anthony... c.stuar... 2012/04/23 02:32:07
    Anthony Souls
    Hardly, doctors are always misdiagnosis patients, and not treating patients on a lower income level fairly. That is just a given. If you are unaware of this, then you haven't been to any low income clinics/emergency rooms in your life.

    Almost always, they will forgo tests that are apparent even to the patients, and the patients, indeed, have to ask for them; they will also treat you apathetically, and through arrogance or neglect, diagnosis you with a condition that you don't even have: just so they can say that they "treated" you.

    Obviously, people stating otherwise come from good health care programs that sees them more than 4 minutes.

    Take care,
  • Anthony... doctorw... 2012/04/23 02:08:29
    Anthony Souls
    P.S. Also all of the incorrect diagnoses that are from:
    1. Not doing their job correctly.
    2. Not giving them tests which would arrive at a cause.
    3. Going with excuses:
    a. It's all in your mind.
    b. It's some condition when it's not.
    c. Not listening to what you say, and stating a problem that doesn't correspond with your symptoms.

    Take care,
  • Just me... Anthony... 2012/04/23 02:35:50
    Just me ∞ijm♥G☮F♀U∞
    Doctors make diagnoses based on the info provided to them by the patients. Then, they have to ask the appropriate follow up questions by use of algorithms. If a patient doesn't supply the correct answer to a question by either playing up a symptom or down playing a symptom, it throws everything off and can potentially make the doctor make the wrong diagnosis. Furthermore, it's the patients insurance company that dictates what tests the patient can have. They would rather put the patient through a bunch of piddly little tests wasting the patients and the doctors time and those results will be inconclusive and direct the need for the bigger tests which are tests the doctor wanted to order in the first place. Just b/c patients dont think what the doctor has diagnosed doesn't correspond with their symptoms doesn't hold water with me. There are sooo many symptoms that can be symptoms of numerous ailments and in turn, a patient can be diagnosed with a disease and not have all of the symptoms yet. Doctors arent God even though I've known and worked with a few who thought they are, but doctors are people and they make mistakes, too. Part of having a good doctor is being a good patient. Go to your appointments with a list of ALL medications and supplements you take and the cor...&
    Doctors make diagnoses based on the info provided to them by the patients. Then, they have to ask the appropriate follow up questions by use of algorithms. If a patient doesn't supply the correct answer to a question by either playing up a symptom or down playing a symptom, it throws everything off and can potentially make the doctor make the wrong diagnosis. Furthermore, it's the patients insurance company that dictates what tests the patient can have. They would rather put the patient through a bunch of piddly little tests wasting the patients and the doctors time and those results will be inconclusive and direct the need for the bigger tests which are tests the doctor wanted to order in the first place. Just b/c patients dont think what the doctor has diagnosed doesn't correspond with their symptoms doesn't hold water with me. There are sooo many symptoms that can be symptoms of numerous ailments and in turn, a patient can be diagnosed with a disease and not have all of the symptoms yet. Doctors arent God even though I've known and worked with a few who thought they are, but doctors are people and they make mistakes, too. Part of having a good doctor is being a good patient. Go to your appointments with a list of ALL medications and supplements you take and the correct dosages and frequency you take them no matter how insignifcant you might think they are. Know what pharmacy you use and have the correct phone & fax number for them, track your blood pressures and glucose levels when you have disease like hypertension or diabetes. Having a list of your allergies to medicines and the reaction you have to them does wonders and keep a running list of procedures, surgeries, major tests and the results along with your vaccination history with you as the medical field is moving towards EMR (electronic medical records) and there are days when such systems go down. We listen to what you say, but when you come in complaining of a specific problem which has a major specific symptom, it's pretty easy for us to start narrowing down possible problems. It doesnt mean we aren't listening to you, we are trying to direct you to answer the questions we have to quickly narrow down what is wrong with you. If you don't like your particular doctor, move on.
    (more)
  • Anthony... Just me... 2012/04/23 02:55:14
    Anthony Souls
    I'm just stating facts, not acting like doctors are super heroes with all the answers:

    1. They should at least ask questions about the information you give them; I put together all the information that I need to ask them beforehand, and they don't take any time to inform me of what information they even find informative. A patient can't self-diagnosis themselves, they need to know what the doctor should know and shouldn't. All of my experience with doctors shows that they don't even know how to communicate on this necessary level: not just this one doctor, but every doctor I've ever been to, maybe it's a low income doctor problem.

    2. They should inform you of why they are taking your blood, why they are giving you tests, and what they think the cause is: none of this information is ever given to me until after the results are back. Until then, I have no information as to what I just went through and why: are you telling me that this doesn't happen on a normal basis?

    3. I'm fully aware of the patients responsibilities, perhaps the doctors aren't aware of theirs. They expect the patient to treat themselves without any involvement from them. 4 minutes is hardly an appropriate amount of time to see someone, or am I wrong? Are doctors so magnificent that they can diagnosis a problem...





    I'm just stating facts, not acting like doctors are super heroes with all the answers:

    1. They should at least ask questions about the information you give them; I put together all the information that I need to ask them beforehand, and they don't take any time to inform me of what information they even find informative. A patient can't self-diagnosis themselves, they need to know what the doctor should know and shouldn't. All of my experience with doctors shows that they don't even know how to communicate on this necessary level: not just this one doctor, but every doctor I've ever been to, maybe it's a low income doctor problem.

    2. They should inform you of why they are taking your blood, why they are giving you tests, and what they think the cause is: none of this information is ever given to me until after the results are back. Until then, I have no information as to what I just went through and why: are you telling me that this doesn't happen on a normal basis?

    3. I'm fully aware of the patients responsibilities, perhaps the doctors aren't aware of theirs. They expect the patient to treat themselves without any involvement from them. 4 minutes is hardly an appropriate amount of time to see someone, or am I wrong? Are doctors so magnificent that they can diagnosis a problem in under 4 minutes?

    4. People are obviously brainwashed by:
    1. Going to Doctors when they have great insurance, so they don't know anything else.
    2. The media, which paints this image to the public that doctors do the job because they care about the plights of the patients: perhaps some do, but hardly the majority.

    Take care, thanks for the response.
    (more)
  • meg 2012/04/23 01:27:56
    No
    meg
    Depends what doctors you associate your self with I guess.
  • Anthony... meg 2012/04/23 01:29:45
    Anthony Souls
    Low income ones, LOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
  • meg Anthony... 2012/04/23 01:31:33
    meg
    Not sure never been to one, of all the cheap things my family has sacrificed I don't think our health was ever one of them, except for maybe the comfort of out sleeping situations, never had a comfortable bed always very very cheap.
  • Anthony... meg 2012/04/23 01:34:04
    Anthony Souls
    Well, when you have to choose between paying the rent and food, against the high costs of medical coverage :P We will see which you choose. :P

    Take care,
  • meg Anthony... 2012/04/23 03:19:49
    meg
    I haven't come to that yet, but I'm under my grandfather's health insurance not my parents so I really don't know how it works like that but current'y I can't see that far in the future.
  • Pixie·Ÿ... Anthony... 2012/04/23 02:05:52
    Pixie·ŸŸMzAwesome♠ƤĦĂĔŢ♠
    I find they are better doctors they do it to help people not money. Mine is a low income one and she s amazing, she s also a newer doctor and maybe not burned out. Plus she is super sexy too...
  • Chieki 2012/04/23 01:26:49
    Other (Explain)
    Chieki
    Some may be, when driven by greed and/or the inability to truly care about their patients wants and needs
  • Anthony... Chieki 2012/04/23 01:30:14
    Anthony Souls
    Or the love of greed, since they aren't rich enough yet :P LOL

    TC
  • Chieki Anthony... 2012/04/23 01:32:11
    Chieki
    That too...
  • YodaHead 2012/04/23 01:23:27
    Yes
    YodaHead
    +1
    ... just the evil ones though.
  • Anthony... YodaHead 2012/04/23 01:25:25
    Anthony Souls
    Lol, Doctors today lacks morals, and that is why Doctors of today's age sucks; they are too indifferent about the plights of others, and prescribes medicines that will gain them more money.

    TC
  • c.stuar... Anthony... 2012/04/23 02:16:06 (edited)
    c.stuartHardwick
    That's a pretty broad blanket you are wielding.
  • Anthony... c.stuar... 2012/04/23 02:37:06 (edited)
    Anthony Souls
    Indeed, yet a true one: every doctor that I've ever been too treated me with apathy and contempt, when I am the most polite and respectful patient ever: I have all the information set fourth just like everyone suggests; I explain everything thoroughly as I can; and I try to give them the benefit of the doubt in the office; however, I am not stupid, and these reasons promotes my truth:
    1. they see me for 4 minutes.
    2. They don't test me: I have to mention tests, which is in fact something that I shouldn't.
    3. I have to ask about the side effects and why are you drawing my blood: there is absolutely no transparency in how you are being treated.
    4. They don't ask you any questions to help diagnose you: you have to supply ever bit of information, and hopefully you don't leave out anything important.
    5. And so on and so fourth: mostly blaming your problem on an nonexistent "it's all in your mind" methodology over a practical scientific one.

    Take care,
  • Occy c.stuar... 2012/04/23 10:26:10
    Occy
    How does one,"weld a blanket " ?

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Living

2013/06/19 23:21:01

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals