Quantcast

Would Aretha Franklin Make a Good 'American Idol' Judge?

SodaHead Music 2012/07/15 21:26:25
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Ever since Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler announced that they’d be leaving “American Idol,” rumors have been flying about who will replace them as judges. Now, one music superstar has volunteered her services: 18-time Grammy Award winner Aretha Franklin.

In addition to her many Grammys, Franklin, 70, became the first woman inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Though she is best known for 1960s hits such as “Respect” and “Baby I Love You,” Rolling Stone has described Franklin as the greatest female singer of all time.

Apparently, in an email to CNN on Saturday, Franklin said that she has long been a fan of “American Idol” and would love to join the cast as a judge. The Queen of Soul also suggested Patti LaBelle as a sidekick. According to CNN, “Fox declined to comment on Franklin on Saturday night.” But adding a judge of Franklin’s caliber may be just what the network needs to do to boost ratings.

What do you think SodaHeads? Would Aretha Franklin make a good “American Idol” judge?

Aretha Franklin

Read More: http://www.cnn.com/2012/07/14/showbiz/aretha-frank...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Meako 2012/07/15 21:41:54
    Yes!
    Meako
    +6
    Yes, the Queen would be magnificent.. she has lost a lot of weight since she was sick....!! love me some Aretha, R-E-S-P-E-C-T.............

    aretha lost weight

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • frequen... 4gotten... 2012/07/17 19:32:49
    frequent–antagonist
    Mindless name calling will only make one sound mindless. Singers come and go. She may have sang a few songs that had been one considered popular by the worlds populace, but in the end she is nothing special. She has done absolutely nothing special. And now, she has let herself go. I will give her no respect, nor will I ever. That does not make me a baby. It makes my mindset and opinion differing from yours; but not a baby.
  • All American 2012/07/15 23:56:52
    Yes!
    All American
    +2
    I think she would be a good judge, but she wouldn't be good for ratings.
  • Charmaine 2012/07/15 23:54:15
    Yes!
    Charmaine
    +1
    I LOVE ARETHA FRANKLIN SHE IS TALENTED AND MAKES AMAZING MUSIC!!!
  • Tennessee3501 2012/07/15 23:51:17
    Yes!
    Tennessee3501
    She would be great with Taylor Swift sitting on one side of her and Kanye West on the other. They would not be able to get past her to tear each other apart, but the ratings would soar!
  • mae 2012/07/15 23:42:07 (edited)
    No!
    mae
    +2
    Aretha would make a great judge anywhere--I think she would be of better service on America Has Talent, and especially, The Voice.
  • JohnT mae 2012/07/16 01:19:32
    JohnT
    +1
    You brought up a good point. Idol is for the kiddies so she most likely would be a better fit for any of the others. I am not much of a Idol fan because of age discrimination on no one being over 28 or something like that.
  • voice_matters 2012/07/15 23:28:12
    No!
    voice_matters
    out of touch with today's music
  • Catch224u 2012/07/15 23:19:17
    Yes!
    Catch224u
    +1
    If people would give her " R E S P E C T "
  • Gloria 2012/07/15 23:17:37
    Yes!
    Gloria
    +2
    Maybe too good!
  • retrograve 2012/07/15 23:16:31
    Yes!
    retrograve
    +1
    I think anybody would make a good judge if they can sing and know how to tell people 'No, sorry, this isn't the career for you.'
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/07/15 23:01:11
    Yes!
    Medulla Oblongata
    +2
    If she does get chosen, I still won't watch next season. I'm all Idol'd out.
  • Charmaine Medulla... 2012/07/15 23:55:04
    Charmaine
    +1
    same here...I LOVE ARETHA FRANKLIN!!!
  • JohnT Medulla... 2012/07/16 16:21:55
    JohnT
    +1
    Makes two of us, I am tired of the tween girls selecting a lousy average singer in a popularity contest rather than the most talented. I won't watch it either.
  • HiYa 2012/07/15 22:46:36
    Yes!
    HiYa
    +1
    I think she's be amazing. She certainly has serious vocal skills.
  • BystroffC 2012/07/15 22:40:00
    Yes!
    BystroffC
    +1
    One of the more awesome performers of our time! Of course she would be a good judge.
    J Lo? C'mon. She can't really sing.
  • Informed Voter 2012/07/15 22:39:46
    Yes!
    Informed Voter
    +2
    Aretha Franklin would bring repectability and credibility to anything she chose to put her hand to.
  • 30stmFantasy 2012/07/15 22:34:28
    No!
    30stmFantasy
    No. Not only does she take too long to make her point but SHE IS A FUR HAG - just like that disgusting Jlow.
  • rawrimamoocow 2012/07/15 22:33:55
    No!
    rawrimamoocow
    +3
    Adam Lambert god dammit!!!!!
  • Torchy 2012/07/15 22:32:56
    Yes!
    Torchy
    +3
    The woman has been through it all in the music/entertainment industry. She's more than qualified to be a judge on a waning talent competition show.
  • Lulu's Mom 2012/07/15 22:18:46
    Yes!
    Lulu's Mom
    +1
    Yes, and she wants too! That is she would have to say to me, and she would be in!
  • msteresa87 2012/07/15 22:06:33
    Yes!
    msteresa87
    +1
    dear God....Yes!!!!
  • No!
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    +2
    She's way too damn ugly. Their ratings would plummet. Like it or not, people judge celebrities by appearance.
  • Autumn Jerry (... 2012/07/15 22:16:01
    Autumn
    I don't think an 18-time Grammy award winning music legend would be the reason ratings plummet. And you're the only judging Aretha Franklin by her looks.
  • Jerry (... Autumn 2012/07/15 22:27:04
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    I disagree. We judge each other by looks. Is it wrong? Yes.
  • Meako Jerry (... 2012/07/15 22:54:35
    Meako
    +2
    OMG I just looked at your pictures, how in the HELL can you call someone else UGLY.....geeshhhh
  • Jerry (... Jerry (... 2012/07/15 22:56:56
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    +1
    Meako made the reply below and immediately blocked me so that I can't respond. Yes, you're right; that's why I'm not a judge on American Idol. Rude bit**.
  • BystroffC Jerry (... 2012/07/15 22:44:31
    BystroffC
    +1
    First of all, for shame. Secondly, she is not young. And third, who cares? Do we care if Susan Boyle is plain? I don't.
  • SOUL4REAL Jerry (... 2012/07/15 23:36:21
    SOUL4REAL
    +1
    WOW! I know you didn't go there? Aretha Franklin is a power house in the music industry and her looks,she looks gorgeous,she is growing old gracefully. Who are you to judge how "God" created her? You're a blank! "God" don't make mistakes,She's beautiful in her own right and "Respect" her as The "Queen" that she is!
  • Clare Jerry (... 2012/07/16 15:24:55
    Clare
    What are you smoking... Ugly look at you.
  • Jerry (... Clare 2012/07/16 17:04:22
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    Right, and I'm not a judge on American Idol. Aretha is a Hippo. She can hardly even speak.
  • Clare Jerry (... 2012/07/16 17:12:39
    Clare
    Ok but that doesn't mean you have to post mean things about her on here because in your opinion you wouldn't like her as a judge.
  • Jerry (... Clare 2012/07/16 17:34:44
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    Now, that being said, she made some spectacular music and had an amazing voice.
  • Clare Jerry (... 2012/07/16 17:37:58
    Clare
    What do you mean by "had"
  • Jerry (... Clare 2012/07/16 18:55:41
    Jerry (Iron Priest)☮ R ☮ P ☮ 201
    It's not what it used to be.
  • Mrs. maggot 2012/07/15 21:53:31
    Yes!
    Mrs. maggot
    But I'm not sure her health is good....
  • Yvette Walker 2012/07/15 21:43:28
    Yes!
    Yvette Walker
    She has been in the business for years.
  • BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROC... 2012/07/15 21:42:47
    Yes!
    BOOGIE-WOOGIE-MUSIC-MAN-ROCK-N-R
    *****
  • Meako 2012/07/15 21:41:54
    Yes!
    Meako
    +6
    Yes, the Queen would be magnificent.. she has lost a lot of weight since she was sick....!! love me some Aretha, R-E-S-P-E-C-T.............

    aretha lost weight
  • SOUL4REAL Meako 2012/07/15 23:38:01
    SOUL4REAL
    +1
    Isn"t she lovely?
  • Charmaine SOUL4REAL 2012/07/15 23:55:50
    Charmaine
    +1
    SHE IS GORGEOUS!!!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Fun

2013/06/19 03:33:59

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals