What did you think about Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows part 1?

Story Writer~In Books I Trust~ 2010/11/27 19:19:50
Add Photos & Videos
I personally think it was nothing like the book, since I finished reading it right before I saw the movie. I remembered everything from the book that happened in part 1, and only saw 1 or 2 things that were the same. But that's just my opinion. What did you think of it?
Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest

  • ShamWOW!! 2010/12/25 00:35:02
    Loved it
    Of course the book is beter, but i think my friend loved it too because (and she had no previous harry potter knowledge at all) she wanted to have a haryy potter movie marathon the next weekend (and we did)
  • ♪♫♥JOBROS LOVER♥♫♪ 2010/12/22 04:44:08
    Loved it
    ♪♫♥JOBROS LOVER♥♫♪
    I loved it but I prefer the book...
  • hannah 2010/12/18 21:13:12
    Loved it
    I thought that a lot of it was the same compared to the other mocies they made. it was actually really good. I liek the visual effects on TTOTB went to see it again two days later, the only complaint I have is that htye messed up the part with Xenophilius/ where they took luna. I was looking forwardt o the crumplehorned snorcack hiorn blowing up : )

    I know my grammar sucks in this commenyt
  • captkirk999 2010/12/04 02:40:18
    Loved it
    I liked it. The so called nude scene between Harry and Heroimine was not really that bad. What was really creepy was seeing Harry in a bra when they made Harry's friends look like him.
  • jasper_holic 2010/12/01 22:14:45
    Loved it
  • aditi 2010/11/29 13:36:46
    Loved it
    it was good........ waiting for part 2
  • Judy1998 2010/11/29 04:53:39
    Loved it
    it was so alike. it was the closest it got to to any of the books
  • SEAHORSE 2010/11/29 04:10:57
    Loved it
    I thought it was amazing compared to all the other movies. it seems i forgot just how much i LOVED harry potter. Its the ultimate fantasy
  • lydia 2010/11/28 23:19:39
    Loved it
    i've really given up on them following the books completely. without being mad about everything that doesn't follow i can enjoy the movie more.
  • mariabk 2010/11/28 13:53:52
    Loved it
    i loved it :D thought it was awesome
    but i have a confession to make, i haven't read the book sooo maybe the book is better but it doesn't matter to me :D
  • Jesus Freak and proud of it 2010/11/28 13:06:35
    Loved it
    Jesus Freak and proud of it
  • Christine 2010/11/28 05:38:19
    Loved it
    I really loved it. I'd like to see it again after rereading the book, but I thought it was very good. I think the people who are like "oh, I hated it." or "it wasn't close enough to the book" are crazy. The not close enough to the book part is probably true, but I didn't really think so. But that opinion will probably change. But I don't see how people couldn't like it. Even if you're not a fan of HP it was a very good film anyway.
  • -Obliviate- 2010/11/27 23:17:08
    None of the above
    haven't seen it, so should i see it?
  • Story W... -Oblivi... 2010/11/28 01:50:40
    Story Writer~In Books I Trust~
    it was good, just not as good as i hoped. i think that it would be a good movie to see.
  • -Oblivi... Story W... 2010/11/28 01:55:25
    cool i'll try it out
  • ♫ idealshine ♫ 2010/11/27 21:05:09
    Loved it
    ♫ idealshine ♫
    it was really good! (I can´t wait for the 2 part of the movie)
  • BGIRL_ROX 2010/11/27 20:54:51
    Loved it
    I hadn't read the book in a while, so my memory of it wasn't good...however the movie did have many things I remembered from the book! I guess I didn't actually forget that much then :)
    but I won't start comparing and contrasting book to movie until AFTER the final installment! Can't wait for that!
    (in short: MOVIE WAS AWESOME!!!)
  • J 2010/11/27 20:09:51
    It was ok
    It wasn't the adaptation of a book to movie I've ever seen but I could help but think that if I hadn't read the book I'd have been so totally lost.
  • NadineIkumapayi 2010/11/27 20:06:43
    It was ok
    i didn't read the book but it was a good movie with a very sad end=( i'll miss dobby
  • Tibby 2010/11/27 19:39:52
    Loved it
    I think it's amazing. I had also read the book before I saw the film, but I don't think it was that different. In fact, I find this movie one of the best Potter movies so far. Of course, movies will never be as good as books, but in my opinion, this one is actually pretty close. Waaaay better than fifth and sixth movie.
  • XxXxX 2010/11/27 19:24:28
    Loved it
    I thought it was a decent movie. But then again i havent read the book.
  • invaderalexgetCRUNKorDIEXD 2010/11/27 19:24:15
    It was ok
    I didn't really like it.They ended the movie at the good part like when Voldermort came. Or else the movie was very boring
  • TasselLady 2010/11/27 19:20:58
    I don't know. I'm going to go and see it this afternoon! I can't wait! I've looked forward to seeing it for a while now. I saw the ones before and got a kick out of them!!!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.


2015/12/01 11:04:46

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals