Quantcast

Is Zoo at Fault for Polar Bear Knut’s Death?

SodaHead News 2011/03/21 15:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
He may have been the world’s most popular polar bear, a Walt Disney story come to life. Rejected by his mother just days after his birth in a Berlin Zoo five years ago, Knut the cuddly polar bear, grew into an international superstar, garnering thousands of Facebook followers and landing on the cover of Vanity Fair magazine.

Now, in the wake of his unexpected death at age 4 at the Berlin zoo on Saturday, shocked fans are desperate to know what killed the bear. Polar bears typically live 15-20 years or longer in captivity and ABC News reported that one of the biggest trending topics on Sunday on Twitter was “how did he die?”

Knut’s keeper at the zoo said the bear was by himself in his enclosure and was not sick when he died. Zoo officials planned to conduct a post-mortem on Monday to search for clues as to what felled Knut, who was coming into breeding age and was the equivalent of an 18-year-old human man.

Among the potential causes of death experts suspected were the psychological trauma of being captive, parasites or diseases that sometimes fester at zoos and the outside possibility that Knut swallowed a sharp object tossed in his pen by a visitor.

In the end, it’s also possible Knut died of something much simpler: a broken heart caused by the early separation from his mother.

Is zoo to blame for Knut’s death?

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • psycho 2011/03/21 15:23:04 (edited)
    Undecided
    psycho
    +8
    How the hell are we supposed to know? At least it wasn't killed by some scumbucket like Sarah palin for a fur coat. It is a shame how mankind treats animals and this one was such a nice guy.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • 2011/11/07 06:41:47
    Yes
    You can tell by watching his latest video's that he was not nearly as healthy as the larger females they obviously dominated when came to eating more of the food. He was also very broken hearted and it had nothing to do with losing his mom it had to do with losing Thomas Dorflien... He should not have been put in there with three females in the wild male polar bears live alone and he was too young to feel comfortable with 3 female adults.
  • vgt1107 2011/04/10 19:30:29
    Undecided
    vgt1107
    nobody knows what really happened. death is death, if he wasn't slaughtered the zoo shouldn't be directly blamed until they find evidence against them.
  • ~Sophie~ 2011/03/29 23:23:40
    Yes
    ~Sophie~
    Polar bears belong in the wild, not caged up.
  • jazznique 2011/03/29 15:30:54
    Yes
    jazznique
    he was so sute!!!!!!!!!!
  • CorieStauffer 2011/03/25 04:22:18
    No
    CorieStauffer
    Even if he did die from some sort of psychological trauma due to the early separation from his mother, (which I think is unlikely considering how many years since but I guess it could be possible), his mother rejected him so if they hadn't taken him away, he would have died a lot sooner. They did the best they could in that case and gave him four more years than he would have had.
    Really should be waiting for the autopsy results before jumping to conclusions...
  • Lana 2011/03/22 14:54:26
    Yes
    Lana
    We will never know the truth, ever ! If you look at the video of the last few seconds of his poor life it does appear that he may have been poisoned. We will never know for sure how or by whom.
    He is gone, now we must save the ones remaining. R.I.P. little guy , we love and miss you. It appears that you may have been better left alone, I am so sorry !
  • Fire 2011/03/22 14:39:28
    Undecided
    Fire
    Why would a zoo want to kill something that there trying to protect?
  • Chris - The Rowdy One! #187 2011/03/22 14:31:34
    Undecided
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    How can I know? I do not have the facts at hand.
  • ed 2011/03/22 14:18:18
    Yes
    ed
    as far as not doing enough to protect the bear from outside harm and danger. I'm sure it wasn't intentional, but a polar bear is dead.
  • Chris -... ed 2011/03/22 14:31:58
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    maybe it was global warming.
  • ed Chris -... 2011/03/22 14:47:36
    ed
    ...could be...it was a POLAR bear in Germany...
  • turtledove123 2011/03/22 13:32:27
    No
    turtledove123
    I highly doubt that anyone from the Zoo would intentionally kill an animal. The people there love animals. They try their best to keep them happy and healthy. Now some of the ignorant people who come to the Zoo could have done something stupid that could have caused his demise. That poor bear. I used to hate the idea of zoos. However, as someone pointed out to me, if not for zoos, then kids may not ever see the actual animal. Most zoos are humane, loving and caring. I feel sorry for the animals, but that is better than them being a coat or someone's pet.
  • Tigger Too 2011/03/22 12:58:47
    Yes
    Tigger Too
    +1
    If the Berlin Zoo is intent upon keeping wild animals in cages or enclosures, then they should be held responsible for the animals' health. I'm not saying that Knute couldn't have died of some sort of natural causes, but it isn't likely. He was at the height of polar bear health at his age. If he did die from a parasite or from swallowing something sharp thrown into his enclosure, then the zoo medical personnel should have noticed that something was wrong with him.

    It's sad that in order to save species of the world's animals, mankind is forced to lock them up and enact forced breeding practices to sustain the species. Poor little Knute had such a short and sad little life.
  • yippeekayay 2011/03/22 12:27:40
    Undecided
    yippeekayay
    Good grief. Who cares?
  • Tom 2011/03/22 09:25:59
    Undecided
    Tom
    Almost clicked YES but then decided against it -- why? because the zoo has the responsibility for all animals in its' care.

    However, it would appear that the question implies malicious intent or poor husbandry. While I suspect the answer will be NO, since the post mortem is pending all any rational individual can do is wait for results
  • intolerantrwj 2011/03/22 09:13:59
    Undecided
    intolerantrwj
    ......... I would hope it was not the fault of the Zoo, but we shall see
  • Deb 2011/03/22 07:07:12
    No
    Deb
    Cannot judge the zoo until the evidence is in.
  • Myrle Hulme 2011/03/22 06:42:11
    No
    Myrle Hulme
    We won't know untill the postmorton is done, but why would the Zoo kill one of its main attractions?
  • Edible_toad 2011/03/22 06:26:42
    Undecided
    Edible_toad
    We don't even know how he died, how the hell can we place the blame anywhere.
  • kent 2011/03/22 05:35:27
    No
    kent
    someone dropped their cell phone into his compound ...and god called.

    Yes that's ridiculous, and so is most of this crud of how it died.
    A necropsy will tell you how ....unless God called and there is no physical evidence except the cell phone.
  • chief 00 2011/03/22 05:07:47
    Undecided
    chief 00
    Who cares? it's an animal. Let PETA deal with that.
  • thє вluє wαndєrєr 2011/03/22 04:58:14
  • Marinna 2011/03/22 04:09:50
    Undecided
    Marinna
    i guess well find out soon
  • Anna 2011/03/22 03:58:41
    Undecided
    Anna
    I don't know. I can find out online, but I don't trust zoos that much.
  • holdenferall 2011/03/22 01:53:25
    No
    holdenferall
    +1
    I don't think so. We always want someone to blame these days. Sometimes these things just happen.

    Polar bears are perhaps my favorite animal in the world, so I'm certainly not callous to this loss.
  • Anna holdenf... 2011/03/22 04:04:49
  • holdenf... Anna 2011/03/22 04:06:41
    holdenferall
    Sounds like cardiac arrest
  • concerned dude 2011/03/22 01:51:09
    No
    concerned dude
    +1
    stuff happens
  • julianna 2011/03/22 01:44:30
    Undecided
    julianna
    I dn't know awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
  • akgold 2011/03/22 01:41:35
    No
    akgold
    +1
    Little reason to think so, and who are these dumb ass experts you refer to?
    Knut and his brother were rejected by their mother. This happens often when the mother senses something wrong with offspring. In nature few have the luxury of wasting energy raising young that will die from defects. The zoo saved him, gave him the life he had for the time he had. It is sad but hardly surprising he died so young. In the wild he would have died within hours as an infant once he was abandoned. Starvation or freezing, neither as attractive as the 4 years he did have.
  • magic_is_might BN-0 2011/03/22 01:29:04
    Undecided
    magic_is_might BN-0
    How are we supposed to know...?
  • Undecided
    υяsυℓα  vεηgεαηcε ►нαя∂ cσяε sтяαιgнт ε∂gε◄
    Can't tell until the results come in, but I doubt it. Sometimes these things just happen.
  • ankhorite 2011/03/22 01:16:58
    Undecided
    ankhorite
    +1
    "In the end, it’s also possible Knut died of something much simpler: a broken heart caused by the early separation from his mother."

    Bull. Nor did he die of a broken heart caused by the suicide of his first keeper, the man who fed him as a baby, a couple of years ago.

    Whatever killed poor Knut, it wasn't this sentimental nonsense. I never saw him in person, but admired him very much from afar and hoped he'd have a long life and many cubs.

    We can't know if the zoo was at fault until the necropsy provides more info.
  • sally 2011/03/22 00:37:38
    Yes
    sally
    ZOOS ARE EVIL!!!!!!!! Just kidding. I don't really know. I went to zoo for the first time last year on a school wildlife field trip and it was fun hanging out with my friends but I didn't like having to see the animals in a small caged area...
  • daylight 2011/03/22 00:25:53
    Undecided
    daylight
    I don't like zoos and won't support them anymore. I think its so mean to capture animals, bring them here and lock them up in cages just to make money for the city.
    Here in Houston you pay like 22 dollars a person to get into the Zoo.
  • akgold daylight 2011/03/22 01:34:45
    akgold
    Very few zoos buy animals from the wild. They were born and bred in captivity. How much profit do you think Houston makes from their zoo? I bet nothing, I bet there is a zoological society that raises money to support the zoo beyond what admissions pay for. Zoos are at the forefront of saving endangered species.
  • daylight akgold 2011/03/22 03:29:41
    daylight
    But if you are right about saving endangered species, and I was an endangered species in a Zoo, I would want to die. There's no freedom, they are caged, their natural instincts are caged,life for them is captured and jailed.
  • akgold daylight 2011/03/22 04:10:35
    akgold
    You would have no idea you were captive if that is where you are born. Starving, being prey, watching your babies being eaten in front of you ,poachers, disease, fire. Yeah. A nice life in a comfortable habitat would be so much worse.. babies eaten poachers disease fire yeah life comfortable habitat polar bear enclosure babies eaten poachers disease fire yeah life comfortable habitat lion enclosure babies eaten poachers disease fire yeah life comfortable habitat tiger enclosure babies eaten poachers disease fire yeah life comfortable habitat tiger exhibet
  • daylight akgold 2011/03/22 04:30:33
    daylight
    You can show me all the pics, been there. In one of my responses to someone else , I said - only the wild life ranches would work for freedom. But Zoos stinks!
    Its heart breaking to see the beaten down animals in their little cages (jails sells) and watch them walk from one end to the other, pacing back and forth over and over.
  • keeper 2011/03/22 00:04:09
    No
    keeper
    Knut was such a big attraction and money maker for the zoo, I don't think they would have knowingly killed him.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Fun

2013/05/23 16:05:20

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals