Question Fun

Is it a good idea to defenestrate your baby?

Butch Cassidy May 01, 2008 21:00:00

Yes
No
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • +1
    Scars Remain (aka Vicki) August 26, 2009 03:00:51
    Scars Remain (aka Vicki)

    No

    Those poor children! What a stupid thing to do, if they land wrong, it could maybe break their neck!

    poor children stupid land wrong break neck
  • +1
    gillahooley August 09, 2009 20:18:25
    gillahooley

    No

    i get nervous when people take my son and put him above their heads. if anybody dropped my kid off a balcony they'd be going right after him. bunch of damn idiots.
  • +1
    IsraeliteRian84 August 08, 2009 07:48:09
    IsraeliteRian84

    No

    WTF?! These people deserve to die!
  • +1
    Shigyrl_7 August 04, 2009 17:27:05
    Shigyrl_7

    No

    I just tried to watch the video on here. Those people need to be flung from 20 feet and see how they like it. Those babies were absolutely terrified. I actually had to stop the video midway because I could not handle watching it.
  • +1
    wow-really August 03, 2009 06:08:32 (edited)
    wow-really

    No

    Ah ! Once again the stupidity that occurs in the name of religious beliefs.
    It will take for one of those poor babies to turn the wrong way, land on their heads and die, before people get their heads out of their own asses, and stop this foolishness.
    God help those poor babies..
  • +1
    Mindy August 03, 2009 05:00:54
    Mindy

    No

    would get you arrested here in the USA.
  • +1
    BIG ARCH August 03, 2009 00:13:42
    BIG ARCH

    No

    Simply insane.
  • +1
    Dwight Mann August 02, 2009 21:40:16
    Dwight Mann

    No

  • +1
    Strix August 02, 2009 19:46:40
    Strix

    No

    I can't believe the question is even being asked.
  • +1
    Demonn00bSlayer August 02, 2009 09:28:48
    Demonn00bSlayer

    Yes

    Well, it's not a good a good IDEA, but I think it's totally harmless. Unless there's some horrible accident, of course.
  • +2 / -1
    Shigyrl_7 Demonn0... August 04, 2009 17:29:06
    Shigyrl_7
    Your an idiot. Do you realize how easy it is to injure an infant. Those people are risking the lives of babies who do not have the ability to control all their limbs. Hence the risk of injury or death is tremendous.
  • +1
    Demonn0... Shigyrl_7 August 04, 2009 17:50:55
    Demonn00bSlayer
    Your an idiot too. in that video, not one of those babies got hurt. Did you even watch it??
  • +2 / -1
    Shigyrl_7 Demonn0... August 04, 2009 17:58:43
    Shigyrl_7
    Have you ever heard of brain trauma. Since their little sculls are still soft and not completely closed major damage could of been done. We will never know because the video only covered the babies being dropped. Not what happened days after. Yes I did watch the video. You obviously don't have children. Otherwise you would not have made such a foolish remark.
  • +1
    Demonn0... Shigyrl_7 August 04, 2009 18:04:30
    Demonn00bSlayer
    Whatever. So what if I don't have kids, and don't call my OPINION foolish! Respect my opinion, and GTFO of here and back in the kitchen wereyou belong (ED reference...)
  • +1 / -1
    ~Stay O... Demonn0... August 04, 2009 22:45:35 (edited)
    ~Stay Out Of My View~
    You've never heard of shaken baby syndrome then, huh? Give me your name, so I can send it to social services ahead of time, so they can just come and take your kids, as soon as they are born... to avoid you killing them and winding up in jail. You obviously wouldn't be a fit parent.
  • +2 / -1
    Demonn0... ~Stay O... August 05, 2009 10:23:14
    Demonn00bSlayer
    Go fuck yourself, you have no right to assume I would be a bad parent. Obviously i'm not gonna do that shit, and who asked you anyway?
  • +2 / -1
    ~Stay O... Demonn0... August 05, 2009 20:49:35
    ~Stay Out Of My View~
    It's not an assumption. It's based on what you wrote. The very fact that you see nothing wrong with it, shows carelessness and immaturity. If you can't deal with the truth, that's your own issue, but don't be suprised when Social Workers take away your kid someday because you're an idiot and saw 'nothing wrong with it' and end up in jail. If you don't believe me, watch the news and take the hint from all of the parents on here, that have been educated in child rearing and have heard of Shaken Baby Syndrome. BTW, your response speaks volumes to just how 'mature' you are and how much business you'd have, being a parent. Right there, are some screwed up kids, waiting to happen.
  • +1
    Demonn0... ~Stay O... August 06, 2009 09:05:43
    Demonn00bSlayer
    I never said there was nothing wrong with it, i'm just saying it's not a good idea, but as long as no one is hurt I see nothing wrong with it. Get your facts right before you go criticizing people. Oh, and just cuz I 'see nothing wrong with it', does not mean I will do it to my kids if I have any!
  • +1
    gillaho... Demonn0... August 09, 2009 20:23:08
    gillahooley
    meant to give you a thumbs down, not up
  • Demonn0... gillaho... August 10, 2009 14:56:18
    Demonn00bSlayer
    Hahaha karma's a bitch.
  • +1
    gillaho... Demonn0... August 15, 2009 16:46:20
    gillahooley
    karma? karma has nothing to do with my cursor being in the wrong spot
  • +2 / -1
    Shigyrl_7 Demonn0... August 04, 2009 23:49:18
    Shigyrl_7
    Right there you show why your opinion is foolish and obviously lacks maturity. You know what is great about being in this country I am free to comment on your opinion and its value.
  • +1
    Demonn0... Shigyrl_7 August 05, 2009 10:23:47
    Demonn00bSlayer
    And what's also great is that I am allowed to have an opinion, even if you think it's wrong.
  • +1
    gillaho... Demonn0... August 09, 2009 20:21:25
    gillahooley
    oh my god somebody didn't like your opinion, you get over it. respect should be earned not simply given. i don't respect anybody who thinks its o.k. to throw babies over a balcony whether they get hurt or not. its not smart.
  • Demonn0... gillaho... August 10, 2009 14:56:52
    Demonn00bSlayer
    I don't respect dicks like you.
  • +2
    gillaho... Demonn0... August 15, 2009 16:47:03
    gillahooley
    frankly i don't give a shit if you respect me or not, i was just giving my 2 cents.
  • +1
    Demonn0... gillaho... August 18, 2009 14:22:40
    Demonn00bSlayer
    I quit talking about this subject, it's fucking stupid and filled with idiots who beleive their opinion is RIGHT.
  • +1
    gillaho... Demonn0... August 23, 2009 18:30:14
    gillahooley
    aren't most of the questions on here like that.
  • sexikitti Demonn0... March 02, 2010 06:44:26
    sexikitti
    have u ever heard of shaken baby syndrome? if the babies head is moved even at a slightly higher velocity the delicate viens in the brain will burst causing lethal amounts of pressuse in the babies skull therefore crushing the brain and killing the baby. it doen't take that much force to do this to an infant.
  • +1
    Melis August 02, 2009 08:36:10
    Melis

    No

    Did you hear all the chanting and commotion that insued with that act!! CHAOS I tell you!!
    T hear chanting commotion insued act chaos here may be a possibility of the baby bouncing off the sheet and onto the ground due to the height they are throwing them from!!
  • +2
    teachaman August 02, 2009 03:47:31
    teachaman

    Yes

    Sure it is ... IF you live in a devastatingly overpopulated backward culture. If you kill the kid, so what!!
    There's a quarter million replacements weekly, right? If you happen to live in a culture that has advanced past the late bronze age, however, it may not be such a great thing....
  • sexikitti teachaman March 02, 2010 06:48:04
    sexikitti
    but its still a baby.....a living breathing life that deserves more then to be ened because of a culture.......would u stand there and watch someone throw ur baby of that balcony?
  • +1
    JDLogan August 02, 2009 01:44:41
    JDLogan

    No

    This is a moronic behavior.
  • +1
    USAF Vet Dan August 02, 2009 01:38:01
    USAF Vet Dan

    No

    IDIOTS!!!
  • +1
    sexikitti August 02, 2009 01:20:21
    sexikitti

    No

    What will happen if one of the people holding the sheets lets go? The baby could die! That is so wrong and scary. It's a belief but how could a mother stand by and watch the life she held inside her for 9 months and not be horrified!
  • +2
    Right Winger August 01, 2009 23:44:51
    Right Winger

    No

    Shake milk not babies
  • +1
    flyFisher0461 August 01, 2009 23:09:10
    flyFisher0461

    No

    The practice looks fairly innocuous on the surface, but seems like shaken baby syndrome could be the end result. The relativistic moralist will defend the practice by saying that we in the west don't undestand the culture, I say this practice is wrong in any culture.
  • +1
    Bigoot August 01, 2009 22:19:22
    Bigoot

    No

    IF they were in the USA, they would be charged with reckless endangerment, but in India, it is not a big deal.

    Very dangerous for the child.

    But, whatever floats their boat!
  • +1
    Brosia August 01, 2009 22:11:52
    Brosia

    No

    It is not a good idea to chuck your baby out the window. Unless they can fly.
  • +2
    dfree August 01, 2009 22:05:43
    dfree

    Yes

    as i viewed tis video and listened to the "anchors"..i felt i was listening to msnbc/ india...sorry but the words "bizzare and barbaric" were used to describe this regious practice?..humm..religious practice, were any babies even hurt? or have there been any injuries to any babies ever ? this information was not conveyed??..why not? a relative question? or am i too much of an open minded asswipe to think this is not a problem...so toss your baby ..and may your god bless you as your religious ideals..as best as possible...this report was nothing more then a judgement piece..and too confu\se it with anything else?..in my opinion ...would be wrong...
1 2 3 4 5 Next » Last »
Hot on SodaHead

More Community More Originals

or
Cancel