Quantcast

Does One's 'Right to Speak' Trump the Rights of Others to 'Not Listen'?

Melizmatic 2012/05/18 18:13:37
Yes! MY 'right to be heard' is more important than everything else in existence.
No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
You!
Add Photos & Videos
So okay...

A friend of mine recently shared a really interesting article online, advising men on the proper way to approach an unknown woman they are attracted to without creeping her out.

interesting article online advising proper approach unknown woman attracted creeping

A paragraph contained therein caught my attention:

It basically stated that one of the biggest mistakes that many men make is not understanding and/or respecting the feedback, (both verbal and physical) that they receive from women during such an approach.

Even if given a negative response, many times some men will still try to pursue the woman in question anyway, and that's a huge red flag to the woman because such behavior sends a clear message:

His desire to interact with her is more important to him than the woman's right to be left in peace.

woman behavior sends clear message desire interact important womans peace

This got me to thinking about human interaction in general, and of course as it pertains to this website, specifically.

Let's take gender and sexuality out of the equation; and look at it from the perspective of debate and (much more common, on SH) arguments.

Many people here constantly site their "right to free speech" as justification for saying 'whatever they please to whomever they please, in whatever way they please.'

I do whatever I want cartman

And while that's not actually what the first amendment guarantees, that's still okay... as long there's also the clear understanding that no one else is 'required' to agree with them.

Nor does anyone have to sit there and listen to them, nor engage them in conversation.

Yet many people here, both male and female alike, seem utterly oblivious to this concept for some odd reason.

Even after being told that further dialog with them is not wanted, many people still try to press forward with the conversation, as if only their desire to engage the other person matters.

reason told dialog people press conversation desire engage person matters

Often, these kinds of members will go on to make nuisances of themselves, by constantly continuing to address a person who has made their disinterest clear... then heaven forbid that they find themse
lves blocked because they wouldn't leave others alone; these people are usually the first ones to start whining about cowardly behavior and complaining about their "rights" being impeded.

whiner

So with all that in mind, I ask you now; are folks like this right?

Does their 'right to speak their minds' supersede the rights of everyone else to ignore them?


What say you?

And you all should know 'the rules' of engagement by now; but just in case, here they are, yet again:

This post is in the 'Living' category, not 'News & Politics, (with a side of Religion)' for a reason.

Please keep all discourse of that nature in its appropriate forums, and maintain basic respect for others.

Thanks.


play nice

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Ruby Dear - The Fangirl of ... 2012/07/12 03:36:27
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Ruby Dear - The Fangirl of PHAET
    +1
    I like how much you think Melz :)
  • Melizmatic Ruby De... 2012/07/12 03:47:09
    Melizmatic
    +1
    Aw, thanks.

    shucks
  • Queen B 2012/07/11 18:23:08
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Queen B
    +2
    I like your point as it pertains to this site....it's why the block button was created, even if there are those who choose not use it or think it shouldn't even be an option. That's their prerogative, but it doesn't mean those who don't want further interaction with someone who is making a nuisance of themselves shouldn't also have the prerogative to simply click the button and poof...no more nuisance. It's my right to not be annoyed by random trolls, creepers, spammers and troglodytes in the short time I'm on here.
  • Melizmatic Queen B 2012/07/11 19:08:36
    Melizmatic
    +2
    Thanks.

    It's like chitterlings. (Hear me out.)

    chitterlings

    I can't stand the damn things; they look and smell atrocious and so I cant even imagine them tasting good.

    That's my opinion.

    But does that mean that I'm allowed to ban OTHER people from eating them, just because I personally don't find them appealing?

    Nope.

    Free will.


    Perpetually arguing or tolerating constant verbal abuse doesn't make anyone 'better' than anyone else.
  • Xerxes,Phantom of PHAET 2012/07/11 17:12:29
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Xerxes,Phantom of PHAET
    +1
    My existence is no more important than any one else
  • Melizmatic Xerxes,... 2012/07/11 17:13:51
    Melizmatic
    +2
    Too bad so many people seem to think otherwise.

    It seems like most people these days act like like the meaning of life is to "prove" how much more important they are than everyone else.
  • Xerxes,... Melizmatic 2012/07/11 17:49:44
    Xerxes,Phantom of PHAET
    +2
    Work retail and you will meet everyone of them
  • Melizmatic Xerxes,... 2012/07/11 17:58:31 (edited)
    Melizmatic
    +3
    I did; for the longest time while I was in school, along with waiting tables.

    Customer service is one of the most emotionally draining and thankless fields of work in existence.
  • Xerxes,... Melizmatic 2012/07/11 18:00:19
    Xerxes,Phantom of PHAET
    +2
    Totally agree
  • Top Shelf® (oyo) 2012/07/11 17:10:16 (edited)
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Top Shelf® (oyo)
    +1
    any woman that doesn't give any

    cue that she would be interested,should not

    be approached.i was never into the "cold call"

    thing.growing up,we always looked for any

    positive body language-like extended eye contact-

    that let us know if an approach would be wise.

    we called it "tippin'," as in the female tipping

    a prospective guy off that she was interested.


    lioness fangs
    people that try and force their way into a
    conversation are wrong,sad and probably
    damn lonely.
  • Greatkibble 2012/05/28 03:37:05
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Greatkibble
    +3
    But heaven have mercy on this poor soul if he HAD to listen to every whine, complaint and worry the people in his life constantly keep bringing up.
  • Magniloquence 2012/05/20 21:50:03
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Magniloquence
    I say every person's right SHOULD stop where another's begins. It doesn't always happen in real life.
  • Melizmatic Magnilo... 2012/05/21 00:22:37 (edited)
    Melizmatic
    +2
    Again and always, I couldnt care less what you think.

    Obvious sock-troll is obvious, and your opinion isnt welcome on posts of mine.

    Kick rocks.
  • JDLogan 2012/05/19 14:33:14
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    JDLogan
    +1
    I love cake! And freedom! Do you have any freedom cake?

    People constantly talk about their "rights", but rarely about their "responsibilities". You cannot have one without the other, and it isn't a right if it interferes with the rights of others.

    So, if I want a nice day in the hammock in my yard, I have the right to expect others to be reasonably quiet, but if I expect complete silence, I am now infringing on their right to get things done. You can drive your motorcycle or sports car down the street, I will hear it and maybe not like it, but you are within your rights. Now if you rev the engine and squeal the tires and have removed the muffler, things have swung the other way, you are now infringing on my right to a reasonably quiet afternoon in my hammock. With my cake.
  • Melizmatic JDLogan 2012/05/20 00:57:39
    Melizmatic
    +1
    Um... okay.
  • Tunnel Vision 2012/05/19 12:57:21
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Tunnel Vision
  • Melizmatic Tunnel ... 2012/05/20 00:58:10
    Melizmatic
    +3
    Not when I bake it myself.
  • Lady Whitewolf 2012/05/19 11:32:45
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Lady Whitewolf
    +3
    NUFF SAID
  • Feria~THEZombieSlayingB!tch... 2012/05/19 02:23:13
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Feria~THEZombieSlayingB!tch of PHAET!~Badass Incarnate~
    +4
    I always say that. Your rights are no more important than mine.
  • Piper 2012/05/19 01:48:44
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Piper
    +1
    I probably should have chosen the cake option. I don't think any of what you've mentioned is about "rights", exactly. Unless speech becomes harassment or slander, it is all just a personal choice, whether one chooses to listen, walk away, or block. I don't think any of those choices are necessarily wrong.
  • Deliciously Melicious 2012/05/19 01:23:10
  • SA 2012/05/19 01:20:53
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    SA
    +2
    A truly EXCELLENT post Melz!! ;-)
  • Melizmatic SA 2012/05/19 02:04:50
    Melizmatic
    +3
    Thank ya kindly.
  • La 2012/05/19 00:47:53
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    La
    +4
    It's like one neighbour has the right to enjoyment, including playing loud music. But the other neighbour has the right to enjoyment too, which may be having quiet around them. When the loud neighbour interferes with the quiet neighbour's enjoyment, that's private nuisance. You have rights as long as you are not depriving someone else of their rights.
  • CREW grand 2012/05/18 23:54:09
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    CREW grand
    +1
    The best way to attract a woman is not to approach or pursue her.
    Women aren't interested in men showing interest in them.
    They're interested by men's accomplishments and potential.
    As far as blocking, it should only apply to direct contact, such as email.
    The right to control one's personal email should certainly exist.
    When people here say they want blocking removed, they're not referring to that.
    They're referring to the blocking that occurs in the public forum area.
    An individual should not have the right to control a public area.
    If kids are playing in my yard, I have the right to erect a fence to keep them out.
    If they're playing in a public park, I have no right to erect a fence there to section off part of it and keep them out, just because I personally find kids annoying.
    If I felt they were becoming particularly unruly in the park, I would summon those with the responsibility as moderators, the police, who would decide whether the kids were truly being a nuisance, or if I were just being too uptight.
    The problem is that many people here view their question as their personal yard, when instead their question just represents one of the many benches in a public park.

    Don
  • La CREW grand 2012/05/19 00:49:08
    La
    +1
    Um....the mods can't be everywhere. If someone constantly replies to you and you don't like it, the mods probably aren't going to stop it.
  • Melizmatic CREW grand 2012/05/19 02:06:08 (edited)
    Melizmatic
    +3
    'Space bar' and 'indentations', Don.

    They're your friends; please use them.

    And MY own questions ARE my "yard." Sodahead staff generated questions are 'the park.'

    If you don't like it then go start another web site of your own.
  • Mechelle 2012/05/18 22:34:33
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    Mechelle
    +2
    Same same in my book.
  • tredzwater 2012/05/18 22:22:36
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    tredzwater
    +4
    Besides, continuing to force your attentions on anyone is just plain bad manners. It makes people think no one ever taught you to be polite. It shames those who brought you up.

    (Unless, of course, they taught you such behavior, deliberately.)
  • oldlady 2012/05/18 21:31:25
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    oldlady
  • elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard 2012/05/18 21:17:09 (edited)
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    +6
    I always hated seeing on TV people standing on sidewalks or streets, screaming from the bible, trying to shove their religion down other people throats, especially when they get their kids to do it too.
  • flyingseaturtle BN 2012/05/18 21:08:59
    No, Every person's rights stop where another's rights begin.
    flyingseaturtle BN
    +3
    This is my basic philosophy ;-)
  • Flowers 2012/05/18 19:47:40
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Flowers
    +3
    Well said! When I'm told the perso doesn't want to continue the conversation I make one last effort to try and come to a common ground but that's not always possible. I certainly don't continue to the point of harassment, because like you said (so eloquently!) my right to speak doesn't trump ones right to ignore.
  • Lulu's Mom 2012/05/18 19:09:06
  • Chris- Demon of the PHAET 2012/05/18 19:05:10
    Chocolate Decadence Cake! Om nom nom....
    Chris- Demon of the PHAET
    +8
    God I love cake...
    Oh right, your question; i have nothing to add except "Well said Melz." It's funny how the rules of basic good manners still apply, and yet they are often forgotten.
  • Melizmatic Chris- ... 2012/05/18 19:07:26
    Melizmatic
    +6
    Thanks, hon.

    chocolate cake
  • 'Zedd 2012/05/18 19:02:26
  • Melizmatic 'Zedd 2012/05/18 19:06:38
    Melizmatic
    +6
    >>>"...no one has any 'right' that supercedes another person's 'right'...Quite simple, really."<<<

    You'd think that wouldn't you?

    However judging just by how many folks act, it seems that you would be wrong.
  • 'Zedd Melizmatic 2012/05/18 19:14:36
  • Melizmatic 'Zedd 2012/05/18 19:15:02
    Melizmatic
    +4
    I don't disagree.

    Cheers.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Fun

2013/06/19 07:09:42

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals