Quantcast

Would Britney Spears Make a Good 'X Factor' Judge?

SodaHead Celebs 2012/03/09 21:02:22
You!
Add Photos & Videos
"The X Factor" has been tossing around a lot of names following the abrupt ousting of Paula Abdul and Nicole Scherzinger. Whitney Houston is obviously out of the question, and Janet Jackson had to back out because she had prior commitments. The latest name attached to the position is Britney Spears, and it sounds like she's interested, but there's a big gap between their offer and her request. According to E! News, she wants $16 million. "X Factor" only offered $10 million.

A couple of weeks ago, creator and judge Simon Cowell said in a conference, "I'm fascinated by Britney. The fact that she's one of the most talked about — not just pop stars but people — in the world today, means that you've got this star power. This girl has resilience. I would think that if she's managed to sustain a family, a career, which is tough, this would be a walk in the park. I would be fascinated to hear what she has to say. She's still hot, she's still having hit records and she's still controversial. There's a reason for that." Do you think Britney Spears would be a good addition to "X Factor"?

britney spears

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • T raww<3 2012/03/10 01:59:05 (edited)
    No
    T raww<3
    +17
    I don't think people should be able to judge someone on their talents unless they are talented in that area too, and considering Brittany spears is a horrible singer and sounds like a baby when she sings then she definantly does not deserve the right to judge others on their singing skills

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • nokie 2012/03/12 14:52:18
    No
    nokie
    +3
    she can't sing well. She's an entertainer;a performer.Not a vocalist. she can coach them on selling themselves to the audience, but she has no place judging their singing skills.
  • rph3636 nokie 2012/03/12 15:46:39
    rph3636
    Yes she could be selling to the audience, especially the male audience for about two bits if they care to go that route.
  • Monolith 2012/03/12 14:52:08
    Yes
    Monolith
    +1
    As long as she goes skinhead again!
  • morgannelson 2012/03/12 14:51:27
    No
    morgannelson
    +4
    She never had true talent - unless using your sex to sell auto-tuned crap is considered talent.
  • harley oldman 2012/03/12 13:30:54
    Yes
    harley oldman
    ...YEP...!
  • shounen_girlRN 2012/03/12 12:50:59
    No
    shounen_girlRN
    +3
    maybe a judge in dancing...but in singing nope...she sounds like she has an upset stomach!!!!......=P
  • janet shounen... 2012/03/12 14:59:29 (edited)
    janet
    OK ,,LOL,,, That is the most hilarious analogie I have heard yet,,, still LMFAO!!! : )

    Thanks for making me laught this fine morning : )
  • Aksana 2012/03/12 12:47:16
    Yes
    Aksana
    l like her so yes
  • helua Nan 2012/03/12 11:43:19
    Yes
    helua Nan
    Matia Bazar
  • David (oYo) 2012/03/12 10:13:47
    Yes
    David (oYo)
    Britney Spears is exceptionally pretty and attractive. Why not?
  • Sexuall... David (... 2012/03/13 05:57:08
    Sexuallobster
    what does that have to do with judging singing ability? Oh wait, nothing. Kinda like her career.
  • David (... Sexuall... 2012/03/13 09:40:13
    David (oYo)
    She's a bloody good singer actually.
  • Sexuall... David (... 2012/03/14 03:03:54
    Sexuallobster
    you must be kidding..
  • David (... Sexuall... 2012/03/14 09:46:38
    David (oYo)
    Well I think so.
  • The•Dungeon•Master 2012/03/12 08:09:51
  • bobbie 2012/03/12 07:37:34
    No
    bobbie
    +1
    she would be to nice and give to much slack when they suck...lol
  • katt 2012/03/12 02:52:25
    No
    katt
    +1
    i think she has come a long way getting her life back on track but she hasn't paid her dues yet in experience
  • jackie 2012/03/12 02:48:48
    Yes
    jackie
    +1
    Yes! Go Britney
  • Bob DiN 2012/03/12 01:04:48
    No
    Bob DiN
    +2
    She'll be to smashed to know what's going on.
  • Wendi 2012/03/11 21:48:28
  • skull+crossbones 2012/03/11 20:43:49 (edited)
    Yes
    skull+crossbones
    +1
    She's successful and seems like a nice enough person, I guess, I'm not wildly enthusiastic, pretty indifferent, but you know, whatever XD x
  • Aly Hart 2012/03/11 20:25:03
    No
    Aly Hart
    +2
    If they want a music star on the judge's panel, they should at least make it someone who HAS talent.
  • Saye Saye 2012/03/11 13:33:06
    Yes
    Saye Saye
    +1
    as much as her life dipped when she was acting out..she does have a long history of musical talent.
  • JCLadybug Saye Saye 2012/03/12 03:40:37
    JCLadybug
    The musical talent part is questionable.
  • sm237 2012/03/11 13:14:45
    Yes
    sm237
    +1
    Why not....
  • rachel.n.limburg 2012/03/11 10:53:04
    Yes
    rachel.n.limburg
    i love britney spears i will never lie
  • Bruce Carrubba 2012/03/11 07:41:44
    No
    Bruce Carrubba
    +4
    She can't sing so how can she judge.
  • Megagenie 2012/03/11 07:33:56 (edited)
    No
    Megagenie
    +2
    What she's gonna do if she can't make it to be a part of the X Factor Judge? Throw a tantrum and shave her head and attack someone's car again?

    I don't trust Britney at all. They should just simply get someone who has a clean record, is more talented and competent than Britney Spears, knows how to be fair and square and has had no violation of any laws at all.
  • †ADAM.† 2012/03/11 07:19:51
    No
    †ADAM.†
    +2
    no just no -.-
  • nothingbutthetruth 2012/03/11 06:54:13
    Yes
    nothingbutthetruth
    +2
    I always give people the benefit of a doubt.
  • Ghosty 2012/03/11 06:11:02
    No
    Ghosty
    +2
    NOPE NOPE NOPE
  • shyheartbreak30 2012/03/11 06:07:28
    No
    shyheartbreak30
    +4
    I love britney, but she is really the last person who should giving anyone career advice. They might as well ask Lindsey Lohan! I like them both, just not a good choice for that show!
  • Summer 2012/03/11 05:45:46
    No
    Summer
    +2
    NO!!! that is all..
  • Ameera 2012/03/11 05:29:42
    Yes
    Ameera
    +1
    might be interesting
  • disclaimer 2012/03/11 04:45:41
    Yes
    disclaimer
    +2
    She's talented and she's got a story behind her. Why the hell not?
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/03/11 04:40:19
    Yes
    Medulla Oblongata
    +1
    It's possible. I doubt I'll be able to watch the show, anyway, because it coincides with other shows I watch, whenever the second season premiers.
  • Hey! I like your eyes<3 2012/03/11 04:19:26
    Yes
    Hey! I like your eyes<3
    +2
    Either way, it wouldn't matter to me because I don't watch The X-Factor.
  • pinkcupcake 2012/03/11 03:58:02 (edited)
    Yes
    pinkcupcake
    +1
    yes, she most definently would. i couldn't agree more with what simon cowell said. britney has been in the business 13 years and is still selling out arenas and making # 1 hit records, songs and videos. people can talk about how she "sucks" all day, but i don't think they should talk until THEY'VE been in the music biz for over a decade and still on top (even after personal troubles). also, i think it's funny that someone who's "not talented" can win star search, a place on the mickey mouse club and give some of the most legendary performances OF ALL TIME! (anybody remember the 2000 vma performance?) britney is a superstar and x-factor would most definently benefit from her being a judge on the show.
  • sherie 2012/03/11 03:49:43
    No
    sherie
    +5
    Please tell me they aren't considering her! I would have to stop watching. Would she lip sync?
  • Ev Rom sherie 2012/03/12 01:09:06
    Ev Rom
    She would lip sync her questions LOL

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/20 00:49:56

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals