Quantcast

Would Britney Spears Make a Good 'X Factor' Judge?

SodaHead Celebs 2012/03/09 21:02:22
You!
Add Photos & Videos
"The X Factor" has been tossing around a lot of names following the abrupt ousting of Paula Abdul and Nicole Scherzinger. Whitney Houston is obviously out of the question, and Janet Jackson had to back out because she had prior commitments. The latest name attached to the position is Britney Spears, and it sounds like she's interested, but there's a big gap between their offer and her request. According to E! News, she wants $16 million. "X Factor" only offered $10 million.

A couple of weeks ago, creator and judge Simon Cowell said in a conference, "I'm fascinated by Britney. The fact that she's one of the most talked about — not just pop stars but people — in the world today, means that you've got this star power. This girl has resilience. I would think that if she's managed to sustain a family, a career, which is tough, this would be a walk in the park. I would be fascinated to hear what she has to say. She's still hot, she's still having hit records and she's still controversial. There's a reason for that." Do you think Britney Spears would be a good addition to "X Factor"?

britney spears

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • T raww<3 2012/03/10 01:59:05 (edited)
    No
    T raww<3
    +17
    I don't think people should be able to judge someone on their talents unless they are talented in that area too, and considering Brittany spears is a horrible singer and sounds like a baby when she sings then she definantly does not deserve the right to judge others on their singing skills

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • _OhMyGodney_ 2012/06/19 00:25:12
    Yes
    _OhMyGodney_
    I think she'll give good advise. She may not have the best voice ever but Britney's been in the game for over 13 years now and she knows what she's talking about. She knows talent and I think she's one of the best performer's alive. I think she'll give great advise.
  • te722 2012/03/21 21:43:07
    No
    te722
    janet jacksn is best brittany rhi bey they all copied from the queen you are going to put the students in the teacher seat
  • Dave 007 2012/03/18 12:19:42
    No
    Dave 007
    She's too stupid.
  • cc 2012/03/17 18:30:40
    No
    cc
    Brittany is a dancer and an exibitionist. She can carry a tune, she is...or WAS in good shape and could pull it off. I don't know anything about X-Factor but I'm sure they don't have $16m for some washed up pop singer. If she wants that much money she needs to shed her fat, slap on some lingerie and get to flaunting it if she's got it. Simon obviously likes her.
  • Pistol Pete 2012/03/15 19:47:24
    Yes
    Pistol Pete
    I think that anyone who watches mindless drivel like X Factor, Dancing with the Stars, American Idol, etc. are LOW IQ people and would accept someone like Brittany Spears. I have nothing against her. But, she has never accomplished anything in her life except selling a lot of tickets and albums. And, of course, made a TON of money. Again, being a Capitalist myself, I applaud that and have nothing against her making money.

    But, my point is that the same IQ level that are her fans are the same IQ level that watches X FACTOR!
  • dzzshadz 2012/03/15 04:29:06
    No
    dzzshadz
    She is nice looking but can't really sing. So how can she judge another persons ability.
  • Katelyn:D 2012/03/14 19:20:49
    Yes
    Katelyn:D
    I honestly think she would, but she truly cant sing therefore she wouldn't be a good instructor or coach
  • art1ej 2012/03/14 06:40:45
    No
    art1ej
    shes not a singer nor does she have any talent besides being a dancer
  • eliotbatchelor 2012/03/13 13:14:31
    No
    eliotbatchelor
    No X Factor would be better.
  • Sexuallobster 2012/03/13 05:50:45
    No
    Sexuallobster
    The girl can't sing, why the hell should she judge a kareoke contest?
  • ShamshirMkII 2012/03/13 05:16:05
    No
    ShamshirMkII
    NEXT! And please, bring in an ACTUAL singer.
  • wpsegura 2012/03/13 03:22:23 (edited)
    No
    wpsegura
    Need someone who can actually sing and not just lip synch....although she is a good performer
  • PortaPocketGal 2012/03/13 03:03:54
    No
    PortaPocketGal
    the girl is asking WAY too much. $16 million...are you SERIOUS?!?!
  • Royo 2012/03/13 01:38:49
    No
    Royo
    I don't even count the X-Factor as a show anymore. Still, Britney would definitely bring the show to a very timely demise.
  • deejazz 2012/03/12 22:57:46
    No
    deejazz
    TALENTLESS LIPSYNCHER....is she gonna judge lip-synchers....??... then yeah.....!!!....come on she can't even carry a tune... horrible excuse for a popstar really...but the embodyment of fabricated pop...horrible excuse for anything entertainment-wise...
  • Care bear 2012/03/12 20:47:29
    Yes
    Care bear
    I really want britney spears to win it all and yes she can be the judge for Ex Factor she is the one for me
  • SilveryRow 2012/03/12 20:12:53
    No
    SilveryRow
    Bah, I'm not sure really, I think the whole programme needs an overhaul
  • Edie 2012/03/12 19:57:11
    No
    Edie
    Talk about the bottom of the heap Brittney cannot even keep on own life straight. Why would anyone think she has enough upstairs after all of the drugs she has put in her system to judge anything?
  • Tennessee3501 2012/03/12 19:55:40
    No
    Tennessee3501
    I would like to see Randy Jackson, Paula Abdul and Simon Cowell all re-unite to judge the X-factor.

    If they need extra judges, Taylor Swift should be hired!

    Kanye West was considered, but he indicated that he would be shouting out an affirmative vote for Beyonce after every round.
  • joshuab3 2012/03/12 19:19:37
    Yes
    joshuab3
    yes! i think she'd be a more of a train wreak than Paula could ever dreamed of being! she'd make the show worth watching ,just to see it all play out.
  • Chantelle Martin 2012/03/12 19:00:51
    Yes
    Chantelle Martin
    i will join
  • andrew 2012/03/12 18:33:36 (edited)
    No
    andrew
    +1
    What's X factor? Why does is it always have to be some looney tune celeb? They should fill the spot the same way they pick contestants on the show.
  • cassie.leavitt 2012/03/12 18:08:48
    No
    cassie.leavitt
    Whats with all the crazy chicks? First I hear Mariah and now Britney? Here is a novel idea how about we pick a sane talented female to fill the empty spot. The position calls for not only judging but mentoring. Do we really need more of the above mentioned "talent".
  • ten thousand and ONE fists 2012/03/12 17:55:43
    No
    ten thousand and ONE fists
    I don't know what is funnier: the fact that people think she has a great voice, or the fact that they still love her despite her past as a teenage sensation like bieber & co.

    That being said, here's the only britney-related song I enjoy. It's worth your time trust me
  • Groundskeeper Willy 2012/03/12 17:41:46
    No
    Groundskeeper Willy
    X_factor for "Trailer parks are us", maybe ..
  • Dynasty Fighter 2012/03/12 17:22:41
    Yes
    Dynasty Fighter
    Hell yeah i love you britney
  • mordenj 2012/03/12 17:14:25
    Yes
    mordenj
    She'll be a good judge for dancing. Singing maybe. But, the real reason she would be a good judge is that it would bring good publicity to the show.
  • spizznel 2012/03/12 17:02:50
    No
    spizznel
    People can become famous for many reasons but when a teenager lucks into a flash career then rolls into all the muck that happens to those who get there too soon, it actually is tragic. Britney would not be an inspirational mentor for a talented new artist with that X-Factor, but she could inspire contestants without talent as long as they had some kind of asset.
  • Cathy 2012/03/12 16:53:24
    No
    Cathy
    +1
    If she have to judge singing then no, but dancing yes!
  • Tenness... Cathy 2012/03/12 19:59:57
    Tennessee3501
    +1
    Nancy Grace and Casey Anthony should be hired to judge the show together! Think of the ratings! LOL !
  • Cathy Tenness... 2012/03/14 19:15:15
    Cathy
    +1
    LOL :o) !!
  • BayAreaTransplant 2012/03/12 16:26:36
    No
    BayAreaTransplant
    +1
    I think she would suck as a judge and mentor.
  • ShaZakLar 2012/03/12 15:45:42
    Yes
    ShaZakLar
    yes.. I was debating whether or not I would watch the show again.. but if she's on I probably would!
  • rph3636 2012/03/12 15:42:01
    No
    rph3636
    Judge?, she has judgement, I wonder where it is, she must be sitting on it.
  • Deb Thiessen 2012/03/12 15:27:04
    No
    Deb Thiessen
    $16 million???? What a greedy little so and so. Like she hasn't made enough money already??? That they offered her $10 million is a bit much. Surely Simon could find someone who is not only 'controversial' but also talented too. Someone the contestants could actually respect for her talent, as opposed to her sexy moves.
  • mordenj Deb Thi... 2012/03/12 17:16:40
    mordenj
    Considering that she would have to spend a lot of time in England (which is inconvenient for her since she lives in LA), she has a right to demand whatever contract she wants. It's not like she's under any obligation to accept that position. And, how do you know $16 million is not just a bargaining number that she will eventually lower?
  • Couri 2012/03/12 15:26:28
    No
    Couri
    +1
    Seriously? She's famous for her melt downs, not her "singing ability"
  • EFRENGRDZ 2012/03/12 15:22:57
    No
    EFRENGRDZ
    +1
    My britney hurts
  • Di 2012/03/12 15:13:20
    Yes
    Di
    +1
    I think she would be an asset to the show!
  • wampage 2012/03/12 14:54:57
    Yes
    wampage
    +2
    One more reason to NOT watch the show.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/06/19 10:16:27

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals