Quantcast

Will Peyton Manning End TebowMania?

SodaHead Sports 2012/03/20 16:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
TebowMania may have come to an abrupt end on Monday, March 19, 2012, when legendary former Indianapolis Colts quarterback Peyton Manning chose the Denver Broncos as his next football team. At least, that's what sports blogger Eric McErlain confidently states on The Daily Caller.

Broncos quarterback Tim Tebow certainly had a magical run, with the ability (or lack of ability) to not play well for three quarters and step up in the fourth when it matter most. Tebow led the Broncos to an AFC West division title and the playoffs -- for the first time since 2005. However, while TebowMania was able to overcome the Pittsburgh Steelers, Tebow's unconventional throwing motion and inconsistent play help the New England Patriots destroy the Broncos in the divisional round.

Many criticized top Broncos football executive and two-time Super Bowl quarterback John Elway last season for not fully committing to Tebow, but no one can question his latest move now. The bottom line is Manning is going to play for the Broncos and is an all-time great. Tebow had one magical run. Manning's had a magical career.

In fact, according to The Daily Caller, "all indications are that the kid who was on top of the world just a few months ago is up on the trading block, and probably available for no more than a handful of lower-round draft picks. That’s one heck of a tumble to take." It sure is. Do you think Peyton Manning single-handedly killed TebowMania?

tim tebow peyton manning

Read More: http://dailycaller.com/2012/03/19/peyton-manning-e...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • boneman1 2012/03/20 16:35:19
    Yes
    boneman1
    +6
    I like Tebow, but talent-wise he's just not in the same class as Peyton. Of course you could say that for just about anybody.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Krystle 2012/03/20 23:18:33
    Yes
    Krystle
    +1
    It seems that way since they signed Peyton
  • Vision of Verve 2012/03/20 23:09:16
  • Hanna 2012/03/20 22:48:40
    No
    Hanna
    +1
    It will continue at the local bible-thumper church.
  • Sterling 2012/03/20 21:50:30
  • gregaj7 2012/03/20 21:10:11 (edited)
    No
    gregaj7
    +3
    "Tebow-mania" will follow Tim to his next team, unless Denver decides to keep him as back-up or they can't trade him. Denver's signing of Manning is the BIGGEST mistake in franchise history, and they will regret every penny when Manning is permanently injured and forced into retirement. If Tebow is no longer there, then the back-up is Adam Weber.
  • LOTR_HP~RWAC~CFM 2012/03/20 20:42:17
    Yes
    LOTR_HP~RWAC~CFM
    One can only hope.
  • Louis Contreras 2012/03/20 20:02:17
    Yes
    Louis Contreras
    It would be nice if they can find a place for Tebow.
  • MLor 2012/03/20 20:01:00 (edited)
    Yes
    MLor
    For 100 million dollars, I would think so. We'll take Tebow in KC! *wishful thinking* I guess we ended up with Brady Quinn...we'll see. Saint Louis needs some help, might be an idea.
  • Tuna 2012/03/20 19:55:08
    No
    Tuna
    +3
    We got screwed; David Gerrard for a Qback, why?? We will take Tebow; he is a winner; a winner in high school, a winner in college, and a future winner in the NFL. miami dolphins
  • Tuna Tuna 2012/03/20 19:58:02
    Tuna
    +4
    Remember Chad Pennington?? took my Dolphins to the play-offs in his first year down here?? He got re-injured and was gone. $95 million for Manning and I bet he doesn't last all 16 games. perfectville 1972 perfect season
  • MLor Tuna 2012/03/20 20:03:32
    MLor
    +1
    I hear ya, he would've been good there too. Either the Dolphins or Chiefs, oh well, waddarya gonna do?
  • Tuna MLor 2012/03/20 20:06:03
    Tuna
    He's probably gonna end up in Jax and we get David Gerrard; we got Matt Moore from Carolina last year, he is better than Gerrard. We got Chad Henne coming back from injury; how do we end up with Gerrard?
  • MLor Tuna 2012/03/20 20:10:30
    MLor
    You got me...o_O I don't know why we keep Cassel. When he's good, he's great; when he's bad he is AWFUL!
    Ya know, Saint Louis could use some Tebow.
  • Tuna MLor 2012/03/21 11:47:21 (edited)
    Tuna
    +1
    Cassel was GOOD at N.E. when Brady went down; I like what Romeo is doing in K.C. Chad Henne is good but our team was built for Ronnie & Ricky not a drop back QB. Everyone says we can't find a replacement for Marino. I say our problem is finding a replacement for Coach Shula; Shula didn't have all-star players; mega-million dollar atheletes; Shula made them good.
  • fitz Tuna 2012/03/21 14:36:31
    fitz
    Garrard is going to surprise some people in Miami. I've seen him win games running and throwing while under great pressure. Remember, he played for a pretty hopeless team excepting Drew Jones.
  • Tuna fitz 2012/03/21 14:46:52
    Tuna
    I just revert back to my Fins turning down Drew Breez for Dante Culpepper; I am tired of the NFL retreads down here. We need to take our boy Henne or Tebow and build around them like we did for Marino. Our YOUNG defense is going to be good but you just don't win many NFL games with 10 points, 13, 14, 17. I remember the good ole days when the defense just didn't match up on any goven Sunday and we had to score 45-50 points to win. I don't think Gerrard is capable of putting up the numbers.
  • ☢SCORPIO™ 2012/03/20 19:41:11
    No
    ☢SCORPIO™
    +4
    All hype aside, the Bronco's just blew off both feet with this decision. Manning may or may not be able to help the team to a Super Bowl.
    By signing him they now run the risk of him taking another hit that knocks him out for another season. Obviously, the Colts knew a bit more about his condition and chose not to take the risk.
    On the other hand,..... now they have guaranteed one thing,..... they will have to play against Tebow for at least a decade as he will continue to haunt this decision
    Oddly enough, hardly any mention has been made of the narcissist, idiot-on-a-stick,... team owner Pat Bowlen, who is rivaled only by Cowgirl's owner Jerry Jones.
    I'm sure he had a lot to do with this decision, just like his stupidity in firing Mike Shanahan.
  • Steve Johnson 2012/03/20 19:28:22
    No
    Steve Johnson
    +2
    No, but TebowMania will probably move out of Denver, most likely Jacksonville. Jacksonville is a struggling franchise and could use Tebow's celebrity more than Denver, which has had a storied history, including two Super Bowl wins.

    I don't think that Mannning will get the Broncos over the hump. But he's a clear improvement over Tebow.
  • The Sane One 2012/03/20 19:26:03
    Yes
    The Sane One
    God, i hope so.
  • abner peabody 2012/03/20 19:00:34
  • Bronar 2012/03/20 18:42:32
    No
    Bronar
    +1
    Even if Tebow ends up second string or on another team he will have his followers.
  • DougR 2012/03/20 18:23:35
    Yes
    DougR
    +1
    Broncos Tebomania that is. As a die hard Broncos fan since Elways early days, I had my hopes that this would happen but didn't want to get to excited. Now I am excited. Probably the first time since Elway retired. Looking forward to Manning & the Broncos this season. Tim will find his place, the good Lord will see to that. Good luck Tim.
  • MLor DougR 2012/03/20 20:16:49
    MLor
    For 90some million, he better produce! Not looking forward to playing the Bronco's here in KC...:-[ OMG!!! GONNA BE UGLY!
  • DougR MLor 2012/03/21 15:21:52
    DougR
    +1
    It's always tough in KC, some of the best games ever have happened there. Gonna be an exciting season hopefully.
  • Sebastian 2012/03/20 18:22:39
    Yes
    Sebastian
    +1
    Tebow-mania was a very strange...some say miraculous, string of games where the struggling quarterback somehow managed to rally his team to victory at the last minute. He put up a valiant fight, but the fact remains that he's a below-average QB and Denver is MUCH better off with Manning under center, even a 75% PM is better than 110% Tebow. Just stating the facts here.
  • Sterling Sebastian 2012/03/21 01:55:20
    Sterling
    Ya you're right, Peyton Manning had an astoundingly better completion percentage than Tebow did his first year as a starter... (Tebow: 46.5% Manning: 56%), a MUCH better td/int ratio... (Tebow: 12/6 Manning 26:28) and of course a WAYYYY better QB rating... (Tebow: 72.9 Manning: 71.2).

    Erm... well he must have at least gotten WAY more yards per completion right? ... (Tebow: 6.38 Manning: 6.5).

    And remember Tebow wasn't even set up in an effective offense for his style of play, every first down they did the same play (except one notable exception against the Steelers), he didn't get any reps in practice the year before, or in the off-season (because of the lock-out), and he was on a team that didn't want him with a coach who didn't believe in him.

    I agree, that Peyton Manning, a veteran QB is better than Tebow. I'm just wondering why people aren't willing to give Tebow the time they will give every other QB?
  • Q 2012/03/20 18:16:58
    Yes
    Q
    +1
    Tim Tebow will have an NFL career as a backup quarterback wherever that may be? He may be wildly popular with the religious right but there's a reason why he fell so far in the draft.
  • Rocko 2012/03/20 18:11:57
    Yes
    Rocko
    +3
    it has too they cant have 2 showmen i think his days in denver are numbered for sure
  • Heisenberg 2012/03/20 18:08:02
    No
    Heisenberg
    +2
    Peyton Manning may end Tebowmania in Denver, but I'm pretty sure another team will offer Tim Tebow a better deal. I'd be willing to bet you he might go play for Kansas City, Miami, or Arizona within the next year or two.
  • MLor Heisenberg 2012/03/20 20:17:59 (edited)
    MLor
    +1
    HOPE SO! Chiefs or Dolphins, but I think those are filled. Damn!
  • realist 2012/03/20 18:04:37
    Yes
    realist
    +2
    tebow will be on a bench somewhere. where he belongs.
  • luvguins 2012/03/20 18:03:43
    No
    luvguins
    +1
    Not if he is traded to a team whose state is filled with evangelical christians. They will go gaga over his faith based antics.
  • onetirednurse 2012/03/20 17:56:56
    No
    onetirednurse
    +2
    Tebow will be popular wherever he ends up. I watched some of the Denver Nuggets vs Dallas Mavericks game last night with my husband. I saw a lot of Manning jerseys in the crowd.
  • ..::localeye::.. 2012/03/20 17:52:08
    No
    ..::localeye::..
    +1
    Tebow will be traded...I'm just curious to see where he goes. He seems like the perfect specimen for Belichick and the Patriots.
  • BigKwell 2012/03/20 17:48:47
    Yes
    BigKwell
    +1
    Tebow can't throw anyway. Looks like Denver's going back to the Super Bowl.
  • ..::loc... BigKwell 2012/03/20 17:52:39
    ..::localeye::..
    +1
    Super Bowl???...not really.
  • mich52 2012/03/20 17:45:40
    Yes
    mich52
    +1
    At least when it comes to Denver...
  • Freeranger 2012/03/20 17:33:53
    Yes
    Freeranger
    +1
    Probably. The only reason the egotistical Manning went to Denver is that he knows he wouldn't have had free rein in San Francisco with Harbaugh at the helm. The Broncos are so punch drunk right now, they're gonna lick his shoes, which is what he wants.
  • dv 2012/03/20 17:09:59
    Yes
    dv
    +2
    Peyton is awesome

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/23 04:02:10

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals