Quantcast

Who's The New Spider-Man?

SodaHead Film 2010/05/28 02:46:01
You!
Add Photos & Videos
The new “Spider-Man” movie is being spun, with a director and an opening date nailed down. The director is Marc Webb, who helmed last summer's indie hit, "(500) Days of Summer." The premiere date is July 3, 2012. But the question most people want answered remains a mystery: who’s going to take over the tights from Tobey?
 
Since Tobey Maguire and Kirsten Dunst will not be returning to this installment of the film franchise, which is an origin story, the hunt is on for a new leading man. According to The Hollywood Reporter, director Marc Webb has started to narrow down the casting list.
 
And the final five are…(drum roll please)….
 
1.   Jamie Bell, who first made a splash in “Billy Elliot,” his film debut from 2000. He is also scheduled to star in “The Adventures of Tintin” for director Steven Spielberg.

2.   Alden Ehrenreich was discovered in a bat mitzvah video, of all things, by Steven Spielberg, of all people. Ehrenreich has already starred in Francis Ford Coppola’s “Tetro” and has a role in Sofia Coppola’s upcoming “Somewhere.”

3.   Frank Dillane played the young Tom Riddle in the last Harry Potter film. And that’s it. Well, he would certainly fulfill the “Unknown To Play Spidey!” headline.

4.   Andrew Garfield appeared in Terry Giliam’s “The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus” and in the British “Red Riding” trilogy. He’s the oldest actor of the bunch, at 27. Too old to play young Spidey?

5.   Josh Hutcherson is on the other end of the age scale, the youngest of the group at 17. His recent credits include “Zathura” and “Journey to the Center of the Earth.” Despite his relative youth, he’s perhaps the most experienced of the actors in contention for the role.
 
Who gets your vote to don the coveted Spider-Man tights? Do you like any of these finalists, or do you have a candidate of your own in mind?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • pamela chaoski... 2010/05/29 13:57:07
    pamela
    She would also be a great pick to continue catwoman from Batman. After all when Michelle Pfiffer played the role, there were still a fair amount of lives left.
  • LiTtLe LoVe BuNnY <3 ! 2010/05/28 22:22:10
    Josh Hutcherson
    LiTtLe LoVe BuNnY <3 !
    +2
    josh hutcherson is my love i watch all of the movies he is in my favorite is the vampires assistant
  • myblood... LiTtLe ... 2010/05/28 22:43:50
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +1
    Oh, I love him. He is magnificent! I love him so so much!
  • LiTtLe ... myblood... 2010/05/28 22:44:48
    LiTtLe LoVe BuNnY <3 !
    +1
    cool i like justin bieber tooo
  • myblood... LiTtLe ... 2010/05/28 22:58:00
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +1
    Eh. He's okay. :)
  • y so se... LiTtLe ... 2010/05/29 02:57:29
  • stahlnacht 2010/05/28 22:12:54
    Frank Dillane
    stahlnacht
    +2
    But I don't really think there should be a fourth movie...
  • TacoSauce stahlnacht 2010/05/29 18:13:05
    TacoSauce
    I don't think it's an actual fourth.
    I think it's just another set, with a new director and all.
    A sort of redemption for the Spiderman name.
  • stahlnacht TacoSauce 2010/05/30 04:07:36
    stahlnacht
    I know its an alternate origin movie, but I still don't think something like that should be done. Just look at the Hulk movies and the Punisher movies.
  • TacoSauce stahlnacht 2010/05/31 22:17:19
    TacoSauce
    But the new Hulk movie was amazing; the one with Edward Norton.
    But I can definitely see where you're coming from. You've just got to hope that a director will finally get it right.
  • stahlnacht TacoSauce 2010/06/01 08:22:25
    stahlnacht
    +1
    I guess, I did like the one with Norton in it.
    I can't believe that that big green brain dude was there too.
    The ending was probably the best part of the movie...they're leading up to the Avengers, its pretty obvious now, what with Thor and Iron Man. The Hulk was also one of the founding members.
  • TacoSauce stahlnacht 2010/06/03 02:10:44
    TacoSauce
    Big green brain dude? lol
    Yeah but it's gonna be the New Avengers. Which is better, in my opinion.
    I'm excited for the Captain America movie.
    And I'm sure they'll cast Megan Fox as Spiderwoman.
  • stahlnacht TacoSauce 2010/06/03 02:16:07
    stahlnacht
    Which Spiderwoman? There have been a few of them..
    Captain America! Woohoo!

    But I'm still in the stage of wanting to see Thor Odinson!
  • TacoSauce stahlnacht 2010/06/03 18:01:22
    TacoSauce
    The one from the New Avengers. avengers

    haha. yeah, Thor should kick ass. Definitely looking forward to that.
  • stahlnacht TacoSauce 2010/06/04 03:20:40
    stahlnacht
    Ah her.
  • R2 2010/05/28 22:07:12
    Josh Hutcherson
    R2
    +2
    hes good
  • CitizenErased 2010/05/28 21:58:41
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    CitizenErased
    +2
    spidey
    SPIDERDOM!
  • Julez 2010/05/28 21:36:23
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    Julez
    +2
    i like spiderman the way he is.
  • BryanMonteMoneyRox! 2010/05/28 21:03:23
    Josh Hutcherson
    BryanMonteMoneyRox!
    +2
    i dont know why this happens in movies...if ur gonna star in a film series dont just quit keeping going till the end
  • GreenDay+MCR=<3 2010/05/28 20:45:53
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    GreenDay+MCR=<3
    +2
    i think they should just leave it as toby. they shouldnt change it.
  • Grizzle 2010/05/28 20:40:52
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    Grizzle
  • Micheal Needs A Username 2010/05/28 20:18:39 (edited)
    Frank Dillane
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    i think Frank Dillane would be good for the role, he did a great job in Harry Potter, and i haven't even heard of the other actors or any of the movies they've been in. but i have to ask, why the hell do they need 4 Spider Man movies?? 3 was good, but 4 is stretching it.
  • COMALite J Micheal... 2010/05/28 22:23:23 (edited)
    COMALite J
    +2
    I think they’re starting a new franchise. This is a new origin movie, just like the first Spider-Man movie.

    Think of it as like “Batman Begins.” It’s not a continuation of either the Tim Burton nor (gag!) Joel Schumacher movies. It was the start of a whole new franchise, and was the first live-action Batman movie to roughly match the animated movie “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm” in overall quality. The new franchise continued with “The Dark Knight,” easily the best Batman — nay, the best superhero — movie ever made to date.
  • Micheal... COMALite J 2010/05/28 22:54:05 (edited)
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    ahh okay, thats better. thank you for that. I agree, the Dark Knight is easily the best superhero movie ever made. i wonder if this next Spider Man will be half as good.
  • BloodMist COMALite J 2010/05/28 22:54:06
    BloodMist
    +1
    Yeah, unfortunately, considering the circumstances, this will probably be the opposite, with this movie being like the Joel Shumacher movies, comparatively.
  • myblood... Micheal... 2010/05/28 22:52:44
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +2
    I agree that Dillane did an excellent job in HP. It's between, for me, Josh Hutcherson and him.
  • Micheal... myblood... 2010/05/28 22:57:29
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    Josh Hutcherson looks too much like a kid to me, but he may be able to pull it off
  • myblood... Micheal... 2010/05/28 22:59:07
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +2
    Yeah, he is only seventeen, but can anyone tell me how old SpiderMan was in the original comics? I think he was supposed to be a high schooler, so...
  • Micheal... myblood... 2010/05/28 23:03:42
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    Wikipedia does say he's a teenage high schooler, so you're right, i guess i'm just thinking of a collage student because of the last movies
  • myblood... Micheal... 2010/05/28 23:04:42
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +2
    Yeah, that's what I was wondering. So Josh would do well. But I think Dillane would play an excellent role too.
  • Micheal... myblood... 2010/05/28 23:26:02
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    eh i guess so, still doesn't look nerdy enough, but i guess we'll see what happens :) and yeah, i think he'd do great
  • myblood... Micheal... 2010/05/28 23:34:19
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    +1
    That's true, he doesn't look nerdy much.
  • Micheal... myblood... 2010/05/28 23:46:21
    Micheal Needs A Username
    +1
    no not really..
  • COMALite J myblood... 2010/05/28 23:57:33
    COMALite J
    +1
    The original Peter Parker, just after becoming Spider-Man:
    peter parker spider-man
    He was indeed a nerdy high-school teenager. That was a major part of his appeal to comics-reading kids. The previous teen superheroes were mostly sidekicks of adults heroes, like Robin, Speedy (Green Arrow’s sidekick), Kid Flash, etc. Captain Marvel (Billy Batson, not Marvel Comics’ deceased Kree warrior) was a notable exception, but he turned into a full-fledged adult when he said his magic word (unlike Captain Marvel Jr., who was his — you guessed it — sidekick).

    Who could a kid identify with more? A grown-up from another planet who pretends to be a mild-mannered reporter, or a teenager who gets powers from some accident? And which would said kid rather be: a sidekick who takes orders from a grown-up superhero, or a superhero in his own right, with nobody knowing that he’s just a kid (this is also why Captain Marvel was so popular a generation previously, with DC Comics resorting to litigation against Fawcett Comics because Superman simply coudn’t compete against him in the marketplace of children’s fantasies)?
  • myblood... COMALite J 2010/05/29 22:03:20
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    And everyone is asking why they are going for another Spiderman movie....here you go.
    And which is why Hutcherson would play a better Spiderman than the other guys, of whom I know three of them are in their twenties.
  • COMALite J myblood... 2010/05/30 01:01:13 (edited)
    COMALite J
    Well, Hollywood makeup artists are pretty good at making actors in their twenties or even thirties look like teenagers (think: Michael J. Fox in the “Back to the Future” trilogy). So the really important criteria is who has the acting chops to pull off the role. What he looks like is less important, because Hollywood can pretty much make him look the part.

    That said, they can only do so much. If they do pick a truly young actor, he could play the role realistically for longer, thus allowing for a longer series of movies before they have to reboot yet again with a new version of the franchise, as they’re having to do now.

    This is also the reason (Spoiler Warning for any Star Trek: The Next Generation fans who’d been trapped in a sub-space dimension for the past decade and only recently escaped and haven’t seen “Nemesis” yet, nor knows what happens in it!! If this is you, stop reading now!!!)



    that Data died in “Nemesis” — he’s supposed to be an unaging android, but Brent Spiner is noticeably aging. He simply could not play the role realistically much longer.
  • myblood... COMALite J 2010/05/30 12:20:19
    mybloodturnstoalcohol
    Yes, as you said, Hollywood can do things, but it is much better for an actor who is about the right age to play the person. I like what you said about having to "reboot the franchise". You're completely right. As the actors grow older, it's harder to make them seem the age of the characters, so they have to make the movies with new actors, and then the process repeats.
  • Greta 2010/05/28 20:14:34
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    Greta
  • Angus 2010/05/28 19:50:40 (edited)
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    Angus
    +1
    Obama for he has been weaving a great web of lies and deception. He would make a great Spider Man......... LOL
  • Mike 2010/05/28 19:36:10 (edited)
    None of these are Spidey. My pick is...
    Mike
    +1
    This movie is gonna suck harder than the first three

    Way to take a childhood memory and donkey punch it

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/25 11:42:05

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals