Who Should Replace Jennifer Lopez on 'American Idol'?

by SodaHead Slideshows Posted 2012/07/09 14:00:00

Related Topics: Jennifer Lopez, Adam Lambert, American Idol, Judge

1 of 8

Adam Lambert

A source tells E! that "Idol" has been talking about glam rocker and season eight runner-up Adam Lambert "for over a month."

Adam Lambert

A source tells E! that "Idol" has been talking about glam rocker and season eight runner-up Adam Lambert "for over a month."
Victoria Beckham

Posh Spice made a surprisingly warm and charming "Idol" guest judge, and she'd provide some necessary eye candy in the absence of Jennifer.
Kanye West

The latest crop of judges has been criticized for being "too nice" -- and we all know Kanye doesn't fall into that category.
Taylor Swift

How hilarious would it be to have Swift and Kanye on the same panel? Swift is funny, talented and appeals to a younger demographic -- but she probably doesn't need the money badly enough to do it.
Perez Hilton

The catty gossip blogger made no secret of his desire to be an "X Factor" judge -- and again, he could help with the "too nice" problem.
Katy Perry

She's funny, sexy and talented -- and she seems to want to be on TV. "Idol" would be lucky to have her!
Kelly Clarkson

She's the first "Idol" winner and one of its biggest stars, and she isn't afraid to speak her mind. Kelly, we'd tune in to watch you!
Carrie Underwood

Who's more all-American than season four winner Carrie Underwood? "Idol" has a lot of country fans, and she certainly delivers in the eye-candy department, too.

Who Should Replace Jennifer Lopez on 'American Idol'?

7,224 votes
Read all 223 opinions
Lightning Report View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

	Adam Lambert
	Perez Hilton
	Victoria Beckham
	Katy Perry
	Kelly Clarkson
	Carrie Underwood
	Taylor Swift
	Kanye West

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Adam Lambert	2,350 votes	33%
	Perez Hilton	146 votes	2%
	Victoria Beckham	397 votes	5%
	Katy Perry	1,164 votes	16%
	Kelly Clarkson	1,409 votes	20%
	Carrie Underwood	1,198 votes	17%
	Taylor Swift	359 votes	5%
	Kanye West	201 votes	3%

Say it isn't so, J-Lo! Jennifer Lopez isn't planning to return to "American Idol," E! News reports, even though Fox is trying their best to keep her. So who might join the judges' panel in her place? Glam rocker and season eight runner-up Adam Lambert.

"They have been talking about Adam for over a month," a source tells E!. "He personifies the show, and will be a popular choice right from the start. He knows what it's like to be on the receiving end of the judges' comments, he has a human touch, and they know they can't go wrong if they bring him on. He would be able to bring a unique perspective to the show. People love him."

Indeed, we DO love Adam, and we still think he was robbed when Kris Allen beat him back in 2009. But in the absence of Simon Cowell, J-Lo has become the "star" of the show, and her A-list appeal won't be easily replaced.

But wait -- there's more bad news! E! reports that Randy Jackson "may well not be part of the new line up," and a Steven Tyler source says his "Idol" future is "up in the air." From Lambert to Perez Hilton to Katy Perry, click through our slideshow and let us know: Who should replace Jennifer Lopez on 'Idol'?

+21

Add a comment above

Sinister Ken Doll™ 2012/07/09 19:17:36

Adam Lambert

+11
if he's on, then i'll definitely watch!

>> See Replies

More polls by SodaHead Slideshows

~TimelordGallifrey~ 2012/10/24 18:06:15

Adam Lambert

If he's on, then I'll definitely watch!!!!! My vote goes to the most talented Adam Lambert, his voice is out of this world, amazing! Adam should be judging, he is very honest and honesty is what American Idol needs! He is my everything!! He is my role model, savior, light and love<3. He is also one of my heroes!

reply
Cris 2012/08/30 16:37:13

Adam Lambert

My vote goes to the most talented Adam Lambert, his voice is out of this world,amazing! Adam should be judging, he is very honest and honesty is what American Idol needs!

reply
Money Mcgee 2012/07/26 00:16:29 (edited)

Victoria Beckham

one Taylor s. hasn't been in the game long enough to judge anyone. two Kanye w. can't rap, all he say how he got everything everybody else wants really . a real artist rap ABOUT REAL LIFE SITUATION AND THINGS PEOPLE GO THROUGH . or try to relate his/her to audience. a real artist speaks the truth . honestly i don't even know why he famous .and 3 Adam l. look like he needs to be judge ,what is he wearing hello Hollywood.Any way if you want to hear a real artist copy and paste this url in your brower

http://www.youtube.com/watch?...

reply
etandom 2012/07/13 16:46:12

Katy Perry

+2
Anyone of them because j lo cannot sing.

reply
Willy 2012/07/13 13:05:13

Kelly Clarkson

How about Bob Seger. I might start watching again if he is on there

reply
freakoutnow... cuz mom's here 2012/07/13 11:09:30

Adam Lambert

+1
Adam, Kelly, and Carrie would be great because they've DONE AMERICAN IDOL AND CAN UNDERSTAND WHAT THE CONTESTANTS ARE GOING THROUGH CAUSE THEY'VE BEEN THERE. Adam is talented and young so he knows what music is cool now plus he's a relevant now because he's making his bread and butter churning out hits right now and he's not someone living on past success (Steven Tyler, for example) or other talents (J-Lo, for example her music lives off her looks and dance skills more than her singing ability). Also if Lambert were on AI as a judge I definately watch again beyond the auditions (this upcoming year cuz of the tragedy of Phillip Phillips beating the more talented Jessica Sanchez has currently got me soured on American Idol) so AI make it happen!

reply
SharonS... to freakou... 2012/07/18 20:51:08

You can forget more than one ex-idol on the judge panel producers would never go for it.

reply
freakou... to SharonS... 2012/07/19 00:24:13

I never said all of the replacements had to be former American Idol contestants. One of them could replace J-Lo while the other spot (Steven Tyler's) could be filled with a music legend like Bon Jovi, Bob Seger, Alice Cooper, Cyndi Lapauer, etc. Randy's spot (if he ever decided to leave/he was forced out) should be filled with someone who gives more critiques and technical judging but is less harsh than Simon Cowell was but just as honest.

reply
Mike Fast 2012/07/12 04:31:40

Carrie Underwood

If J-Lo doesn't return to idol, I vote for Carrie Underwood. But it just won't be the same without Jennifer Lopez. The sincerity, experience, and empathy she shares with the contestants (and us) are compelling reasons to watch every week.

reply
Madi 2012/07/12 03:49:29

Kelly Clarkson

I really don't like Adam Lambert at all. But then again I would never watch American idol so it doesn't concern me at all. Kelly Clarkson would be a good choice I think though.

reply
SharonS... to Madi 2012/07/18 20:52:02

How can you not like Adam Lambert if you know nothing about it. Is there some other reason that you may be ashamed of?

reply
Madi to SharonS... 2012/07/24 00:13:03

I dislike his music. I have heard it on the radio you realize. I don't have anything against him as a person. But thank you for ignorantly implying that I'm a homophobe.

reply
Rebecca 2012/07/12 01:59:15

Adam Lambert

+1
the rest of the choices are stupid. kelly or Carrie would be good choices too

reply
jere.chievres 2012/07/12 00:03:18

Taylor Swift

Or Kelly Clarkson.

reply
Tennessee3501 2012/07/11 22:50:18

Taylor Swift

Can you just imagine the ratings the show would get if Taylor Swift and Kanye West were both judges and had to sit next to one another?

reply
LunarRain 2012/07/11 19:20:13

Adam Lambert

+1
He has been through that journey and is a good singer and I think would give good advice for it.

reply
Bill 2012/07/11 16:09:15

Taylor Swift

+1
How about Judge Judy

reply
Margaret Jacobson 2012/07/11 16:08:29

Victoria Beckham

how about halle berry ??

reply
cheryl speight 2012/07/11 14:53:59

Adam Lambert

+1
...because, Adam Lambert is still rather new to the national music scene, is very charismatic, has a good sense of what types of music "young," america really likes, dances and work out to, and will purchase. However, most importantly, like a Jennifer Lopez, he's not just talking a music from an "arm-chair," Oh I'm famous standpoint, he lives it, has paid some dues to do it, he actually does for a living now...not back in the day, or 20 years ago,, he performs it, and is very very good at commanding a stage and american audiences demand he perform his music or songs for them ... because he also looks very good doing his thing and could be a gay Elvis(?)!.

reply
OnlyOpinionthatMatters 2012/07/11 11:38:40

Taylor Swift

Love taylor her music actually has meaning

reply
SharonS... to OnlyOpi... 2012/07/18 20:54:23

Ha!

reply
Wm Kabrich 2012/07/11 10:44:26

Taylor Swift

How about someone with talent this time Ms Lopez is a hack

reply
moo 2012/07/11 09:01:00

Carrie Underwood

Carrie Underwood we need a little bit country on the Television show.

reply
beach bum 2012/07/11 08:55:15

Katy Perry

katy

reply
RepubliTurd Hater 2012/07/11 08:12:04

Katy Perry

Honestly couldn't care less, Idol's a waste of time to watch. If I had to pick one though it would be Katy Perry, she'd keep it interesting to say the least.

reply
LUFXIII 2012/07/11 07:27:33

Victoria Beckham

she can do it

reply
El Prez 2012/07/11 06:52:30

Adam Lambert

+1
No one! Close down the show and leave us in peace.

reply
art1ej 2012/07/11 03:57:18 (edited)

Kelly Clarkson

+1
Why not the first winner & most successful idol....

reply
SharonS... to art1ej 2012/07/18 20:53:10

Success isn't always measured in money or fame.

reply
art1ej to SharonS... 2012/07/19 07:10:56

yes i know but why wouldn't you go with the first ever winner....id like to see what kelly brought to the table as well...

reply
AlliCat 2012/07/11 02:58:01

Adam Lambert

+2
:3 I absolutely love Adam and would watch Idol every night just to see him.

reply
BobbyOdd 2012/07/11 00:57:36

Carrie Underwood

but I think the midget guy from Jackass would be great on the show!

reply
BobbyOdd to BobbyOdd 2012/07/11 00:59:37

or maybe just a lone pair of DDD breasts.

reply
Chuck 2012/07/10 23:50:52
BobbyOdd to Chuck 2012/07/11 00:58:23

lol

reply
art1ej to Chuck 2012/07/11 03:58:12

+2
LOL.he came second on the show so america didn't care if he was a "queer"...its about musical talent....

reply
Chuck to art1ej 2012/07/11 23:48:21

You're right, "America didn't care". And therein lies the PROBLEM with America, today. They don't care. They have been brainwashed to believe that they are UNworthy to judge, and therefore they don't. Political correctness seems a lot easier and they have forgotten that protecting the innocence of children is not their responsibility. Priests and coaches, or boy scout leaders and whomever else, it's okay, just do your thing with little boys and if you get caught, you can either buy your way out; lie your way out, or maybe you can strike a deal for some "help" from our mental health professionals. Yep, you're right, America really don't care! After all, homosexuality, whether it's with consenting adults or manipulating little boys, it's all "NORMAL" behavior and soon with Obama and Harry Reid, and a few other sickos, all homos will be able to marry and just have a good old time. But rest assured, the war has begun!

reply
art1ej to Chuck 2012/07/12 05:24:52

+2
What they were meant to judge him being gay??? its no ones business but his own....
you do know that most child molesters are straight males right???...
they should be able to marry if you have a problem with them dont be gay or get married to a guy...im not insecure so i dont have a problem......

reply
Chuck to art1ej 2012/07/15 00:47:39

Well, hooray for you! YOU don't have a problem ! Ha. The fact of the matter is; homosexuality IS a mental illness, an abnormal physical attraction for the same sex and THEY want to be accepted as normal so badly that they have twisted the 'PROBLEM" aspect around and are claiming the straight people are the ones with the problem and YOU are stupid enough to fall for that crap. NO I don't agree that straight people produce more child molesters; that is pure nonsense. Was coach Sandusky of Penn St. considered "straight"? Is all those Catholic Priests considered, "straight"? And they are all child molesters. Be it little boys or little girls. Homosexuals are PREDATORS just like any other child molester. They are mentally confused and need treatment, whether you agree with that or not.

reply
art1ej to Chuck 2012/07/15 05:55:25

+1
Its not a mental illness you bigot......bible thumper at its stupidest.....

of course i wont agree either does any health professional......so whatever have fun being ignorant.....

reply