Quantcast

Who Should Play Ana in 'Fifty Shades of Grey' Movie?

SodaHead Slideshows 2012/05/10 15:45:36

SLIDESHOW: Who Should Play Ana in 'Fifty Shades'?

Amanda Seyfried
3 of 10

Amanda Seyfried

We kept picturing 26-year-old Seyfried as we read the best-selling novels, but she doesn't seem to be on the short list for the role, at least not yet.
  1. Jennifer Lawrence

    Jennifer Lawrence

    Lisa Parker from Fiftyshadesfilm.com told MTV News she hopes an "it" girl like 21-year-old Lawrence will express interest in the role. She's a little curvier than Ana, though …

  2. Kristen Stewart

    Kristen Stewart

    Stewart would make sense for a few reasons: She has the right look, she's nearly the right age (22) and the "Fifty" series actually began as "Twilight" fan fiction.

  3. Amanda Seyfried

    Amanda Seyfried

    We kept picturing 26-year-old Seyfried as we read the best-selling novels, but she doesn't seem to be on the short list for the role, at least not yet.

  4. Lily Collins

    Lily Collins

    Fans are rooting for "Mirror Mirror" star Collins, who is exactly 23, to get the part. She does have the "innocent" look down …

  5. Alexis Bledel

    Alexis Bledel

    In a Twitter poll, fans suggested the pretty "Gilmore Girls" actress for the part. Her blue eyes are perfect, but she's already 30 years old …

  6. Allison Williams

    Allison Williams

    Lisa Parker from Fiftyshadesfilm.com told MTV that a "probable next 'it' girl like Allison Williams" would work. The "Girls" actress (and daughter of Brian Williams) is the right age, but she wouldn't be our pick.

  7. Emmy Rossum

    Emmy Rossum

    In a Twitter poll, fans suggested 25-year-old Rossum for the role. We're not really feeling it ...

  8. Felicity Jones

    Felicity Jones

    Lisa Parker from Fiftyshadesfilm.com told MTV "someone wanting to take a career leap like Felicity Jones" could work. While the 28-year-old British actress isn't very well-known here, her looks are nearly perfect.

  9. Emilia Clarke

    Emilia Clarke

    The "Game of Thrones" actress is the right age, and she does look a bit like how we picture Ana.

  10. Katie Cassidy

    Katie Cassidy

    Lisa Parker from Fiftyshadesfilm.com expressed interest in 25-year-old Cassidy, who has appeared on "Melrose Place," "Supernatural" and "Gossip Girl." We don't really see it ...

Who Should Play Ana in 'Fifty Shades of Grey' Movie?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
"A pale, brown haired girl with blue eyes too big for her face." That's how innocent yet alluring 23-year-old Anastasia Steele is described in the not-quite-but-almost-pornographic trilogy "Fifty Shades of Grey," and fans are dying to know which young actress is going to play her in the upcoming movie.

While we kept picturing 26-year-old Amanda Seyfried as we read the best-selling novels, she doesn't seem to be on the short list for the role, at least not yet.

"We're looking forward to someone submitting (pun intended) their name for consideration of the pivotal role of Ana," Lisa Parker from Fiftyshadesfilm.com told MTV News. "Maybe an 'it' girl like Jennifer Lawrence; a probable next 'it' girl like Allison Williams; or someone wanting to take a career leap like Felicity Jones, Emilia Clarke or Katie Cassidy."

Parker conducted a quick Twitter poll, and fans' top three choices were Emmy Rossum, Alexis Bledel and going with an unknown. Around the blogosphere, fans are also rooting for "Mirror Mirror" star Lily Collins, who is exactly 23, and Kristen Stewart, who would make sense for a few reasons: She has the right look, she's nearly the right age (22) and the "Fifty" series actually began as "Twilight" fan fiction. No word yet on who will play the emotionally wounded, S & M-loving billionaire Christian Grey...

From J-Law to Amanda Seyfried to K-Stew, click through our slideshow and let us know: Who should play Ana in the "Fifty Shades of Grey" movie?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Rammstein 2012/05/10 18:55:39
    Alexis Bledel
    Rammstein
    +13
    The world is a sad sad place if they're making movies based off of FANFICTION PORN

    I hate the world

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • mary.price.7334 2012/09/08 02:31:53
  • ~HopelessRomanticM17~ 2012/08/13 04:31:56 (edited)
    Kristen Stewart
    ~HopelessRomanticM17~
    +1
    She's good being a bad actress for bad movies.
  • birdie1224 2012/08/13 04:30:00
    Jennifer Lawrence
    birdie1224
    I think jennifer would be perfect for it she could just die her hair and wear blue contacts. But looking at felicity jones she would be perfect also
  • Jensola 2012/07/22 17:44:19 (edited)
    Felicity Jones
    Jensola
    I don't know her, but when I got to her in the slideshow I was like WOW, that is Ana!!

    felicity jones

    Just NOT Kristen Stewart and PLEASE not Alexis Bledel. Ana is supposed to be pretty in an unconventional way, and that girl isn't! She's also not sexy which Ana is at times. Plus she annoys the hell out of me!
  • Edie 2012/07/20 20:10:31 (edited)
    Felicity Jones
    Edie
    I voted for Felicity Jones. But I want Alexandra Daddario of Percy Jackson & White Collar to play Ana. No one else above fits the description except Alexis Bliedel, but i think she looks TOO innocent when Ana will need to be sexy at times. Alexandra fits the description to a T. The Long brown hair, alabaster skin, BLUE eyes to big for her face & pouty lips. She has an innocent beauty requiring no makeup, yet at 26, she looks 22 & is mature enough for the steamy scenes. No one above comes close. Alexandra Daddario Alexandra Daddario
  • Louise Gale 2012/07/13 08:52:02
    Alexis Bledel
    Louise Gale
    Amanda Seyfried. NO NO NO. So not Ana.
  • timea.czutor 2012/07/05 21:54:54
    Kristen Stewart
    timea.czutor
    I think Nikki Reid ( Rosalie- Twilight Saga) or Ashley Greene ( Alice - Twilight Saga) would be perfect for Ana. And 110% for Ian Somerhalder for Christian Grey xoxo
  • amandaWANDERLUST 2012/06/28 04:53:32
    Felicity Jones
    amandaWANDERLUST
    +2
    Honestly can people step away from the popular choices and actually look at all those girls... Felicity Jones and Emilia Clarke are the only 2 who LOOK the part of Ana.. GET IT TOGETHER PEOPLE
  • Jensola amandaW... 2012/07/22 17:51:56
    Jensola
    Exactly, I have never seen Felicity Jones before, but I chose her!!
  • Laurie Perry 2012/06/06 16:19:48
    Jennifer Lawrence
    Laurie Perry
    Jennifer Lawrence seems a popular choice, but I also realllllly think Emmy Rossum would be a great Ana! http://www.ranker.com/list/an...
  • Meesh 2012/05/29 00:30:38
    Emilia Clarke
    Meesh
    Emilia Clarke is PERFECT for the role of Ana!!

    http://www.imdb.com/media/rm2...
  • cathie Meesh 2012/07/18 03:24:54
    cathie
    +3
    I agree! I think she would look very good with Ian Somerhalder!
  • Frances_Planas 2012/05/26 23:23:19
    Jennifer Lawrence
    Frances_Planas
    I voted Jennifer Lawrence but I like Amanda Seyfried as Ana, Jennifer Lawrence should play Kate! Love Ian Somerhalder for the role of Christian Grey!
  • Theresa2000 2012/05/21 16:42:49
    Jennifer Lawrence
    Theresa2000
    I actually changed my mind after reading the whole series yesterday and today...LIsa Parker should play Kate, Ana's best friend...the look is almost perfect. FELICITY JONES should be the one to play Ana....her look is damn near perfect, her build is right...everything.
  • Aly 2012/05/20 21:25:55
    Kristen Stewart
    Aly
    Amanda Seyfried would ruin this movie. She doesn't have the right look. And she's just sick & twisted especially in the movie "Chloe" I can't see her doing it. She's not sexy. And NO she does not fit the role...are you serious...she's pale and has huge blue eyes..ugly ugly ugly. She's been in too many movies..I can't see her getting kinky with a guy...just not her scene. Keep her ass in movies like Mean Girls.
  • Jensola Aly 2012/07/22 17:51:27
    Jensola
    But Ana is pale and has huge blue eyes!!? And it's NOT ugly.
  • kris 2012/05/19 13:31:00
    Amanda Seyfried
    kris
    Amanda Seyfried matches the description perfectly && the girl can act. amanda seyfried
  • Hales 2012/05/17 23:06:01
    Amanda Seyfried
    Hales
    I just heard about KStew and if so she could pair up with Rob Pattinson, but all I could thinnk off is, "Oh hell no. We've suffered their sex scenes in Breaking Dawn!" X___X
  • britt 2012/05/15 22:40:07
    Kristen Stewart
    britt
    +1
    Kristen stewart and Ian shomerhalder how ever you spell his name are perfect for this role . I just don't under stand this book is sex base so this wouldn't even be considered rate R this will be rated XXX lol and only sundance theaters usually plays those type of movies not the real theaters how in heavens name are they going to make this a movie idk! But if Ian shomerhalder plays MR.Grey I'm totally seeing the movie !
  • Flamingolady 2012/05/15 17:28:25
    Amanda Seyfried
    Flamingolady
    This girl looks more like the description, but why in the world would they make a movie out of this book? I hear it is porn, so they will likely ruin their careers if it is true to the book.
  • Quazar 2012/05/15 15:29:10
    Allison Williams
    Quazar
    +2
    I picked from the choices but I attached my real choice: Miss Piggy Pictures
  • JCD aka... Quazar 2012/08/13 09:20:27
    JCD aka "biz"
    I like the star, is the lady a sheriff?
  • Happy_Evil_Dude 2012/05/15 06:58:16
    Amanda Seyfried
    Happy_Evil_Dude
    +1
    None of the above, these girls will only stuff up their careers by starring in such tripe.
  • Aly Happy_E... 2012/05/20 21:28:04
    Aly
    +1
    You obviously haven't seen Amanda Seyfried in "Chloe." That movie ruined her for me. She's twisted and a little "escort" in it... Stop putting it down, its a great book. Move along & don't vote if you don't like it! :D
  • Happy_E... Aly 2012/05/21 06:41:17
    Happy_Evil_Dude
    1. I have seen Chloe, which was a relatively fine movie.

    2. This is a public forum. I have every right to vote on any question whether I like the subject or not.

    3. Just like my opinion on it being tripe, is just mine (although it is shared by 95% of the population), that this is a great book is purely your opinion.
  • Resp 2012/05/15 06:18:43
  • Happy_E... Resp 2012/05/15 06:57:10
    Happy_Evil_Dude
    +1
    It's Twilight s&m porn fan fiction that somehow got published
  • Resp Happy_E... 2012/05/16 03:29:13
  • Singerar 2012/05/15 03:04:23
    Amanda Seyfried
    Singerar
    Amanda with brown hair....or Emilie Clark (she's wonderful in Game of Thrones)
  • sandra 2012/05/14 23:45:08
    Kristen Stewart
    sandra
    Kristen Stewart is the only one I ever heard of, in this list. I don`t watch new shows.
  • Happy_E... sandra 2012/05/15 07:02:02
    Happy_Evil_Dude
    +1
    Ever heard of The Hunger Games? Jennifer Lawrence is the star of that.
    Ever heard of Mamma Mia? Amanda Seyfried is the star of that.
    Ever heard of Phil Collins? Lily Collins is his daughter.
  • sandra Happy_E... 2012/05/15 14:03:46
    sandra
    +1
    I know Phil Collins from the group Genesis .
    I heard of Mamma Mia , never seen these movies. Never heard of these actresses.
    thanks for the knowledge.
  • Happy_E... sandra 2012/05/15 22:18:26
    Happy_Evil_Dude
    +1
    You're welcome.
  • jere.chievres 2012/05/14 20:19:03
    Jennifer Lawrence
    jere.chievres
    +1
    None of the above.
  • goldienurse1 2012/05/13 23:53:21
    Felicity Jones
    goldienurse1
    I sure hope that the movie will be "R" rated to allow for more license to appropriately recreate the book on the big screen!!! Placing it at a " PG-13" rating would do such an injustice to the storyline. Remember--this is an ADULT story--not every story needs to be translated to try to capture the "PG-13" crowd only!!!!
  • Aly goldien... 2012/05/20 21:33:32
    Aly
    +3
    I heard it will be an 18 and up audience... but people will watch it if they want regardless. You can find way worse stuff online anyways Haha Great book & excited to see it in a movie!:)
  • bluebird 2012/05/13 10:51:34
    Kristen Stewart
    bluebird
    KRISTEN STEWART!!!
  • Jtiny 2012/05/12 12:07:24
    Kristen Stewart
    Jtiny
    +1
    oh idk, it kinda sucks cuz ive read MOU before, n i just can't bring myself to imagine anyone but KStew in that role!
  • mae 2012/05/12 02:13:46
    Lily Collins
    mae
    Lily Collins--she will fit this roll very well.
  • Mini Twuby 2012/05/12 01:05:12
    Amanda Seyfried
    Mini Twuby
    I don't even know what the books about or movie LOL I just think Amanda Seyfried is the best actress so yeah :P

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/25 20:43:18

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals