Quantcast

Which Romantic Comedy Was the Biggest Bomb?

SodaHead Slideshows 2010/10/11 19:00:00

SLIDESHOW: Which Rom-Com Was the Biggest Bomb?

1 of 8

"Life as We Know It"

Do you really want to see a movie where the best line is clearly, "Sweetie, you have poo on your face"?
  1. "Life as We Know It"

    "Life as We Know It"

    Do you really want to see a movie where the best line is clearly, "Sweetie, you have poo on your face"?

  2. "The Switch"

    "The Switch"

    Also known as the "turkey baster" movie that sparked Jennifer Aniston's war with Bill O'Reilly, this dud debuted in eighth place in its opening weekend, grossing just $8.1 million.

  3. "Killers"

    "Killers"

    Katherine Heigl unwittingly marries an assassin (Ashton Kutcher), and nobody cares. The film debuted at No. 3 at the box office with about $15.8 million in its opening weekend.

  4. "Sex and the City 2"

    "Sex and the City 2"

    "Sex and the City 2" made only $37.1 million in its opening weekend. It came in 2nd behind the week-old "Shrek Forever After," made $20 million less than the first "Sex" movie and fell far short of expectations.

  5. "The Back-Up Plan"

    "The Back-Up Plan"

    More pregnancies, more poop jokes and Jennifer Lopez phoning it in ... no surprise that "The Back-Up" plan only came in second at the box office with $12.3 million.

  6. "The Bounty Hunter"

    "The Bounty Hunter"

    "The Bounty Hunter" came in third place on its opening weekend making only $21 million at the box office, even though Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler made up a fake relationship to promote it.

  7. "27 Dresses"

    "27 Dresses"

    Katherine Heigl had another mediocre opening with her "always a bridesmaid" movie "27 Dresses," which came in second place at the box office with $23 million.

  8. "Going the Distance"

    "Going the Distance"

    Turns out, nobody wanted to see a movie about Drew Barrymore and her real-life boyfriend Justin Long. The film came in fifth place in its opening weekend, earning only $6.9 million.

Which Romantic Comedy Was the Biggest Bomb?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
"Life as We Know It" was a flop as we know it at the box office this weekend, as former "Grey's Anatomy" star Katherine Heigl failed to deliver.

The rom-com bomb about two opposite sex frenemies who are forced to adopt an orphaned toddler earned a ho-hum $14.6 million in its opening weekend.

"The Social Network," the movie about the origins of Facebook that manages to make Justin Timberlake look even cooler than he already did, snagged the top spot at the box office for the second weekend in a row, raking in $15.5 million.

Is anyone really surprised by this?

Forget that "The Social Network" is getting amazing reviews, great word of mouth and Oscar buzz. We had the unfortunate occasion to see the trailer for "Life as We Know It" last weekend before seeing -- you guessed it -- "The Social Network," and two minutes into the clip we knew it was unspeakably bad. Here are our top 5 reasons why:

1. The ending was ruined in advance as it was totally obvious the two characters (who hate each other) fall in love
2. Gratuitous poop jokes
3. We knew right away we'd never pay to watch this movie, but we might catch it on TBS (where it will inevitably air every third Friday night)
4. Is Josh Duhamel really a movie star?
5. Is Katherine Heigl really a movie star?

In fact, the Heigl-as-movie star issue seems to be creeping up on her. Following her big hit with "Knocked Up" (which was overrated in our opinion), her last few romantic comedies have been duds. Same goes for Jennifer Aniston ("The Switch) and Jennifer Lopez ("The Back-Up Plan").

Is the romantic comedy dead, or are we just sick of the same-old actresses acting out the same-old plots?

Click through our slideshow, and let us know ... which recent romantic comedy was the biggest bomb?

Read More: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101010/ap_en_mo/us_bo...

Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • gingertwin2 2010/10/19 04:19:22
    "The Switch"
    gingertwin2
    I saw Life as We Know It and like it. It was rather adorable and had a lot of humor that parents will like.
  • Katty 2010/10/14 20:24:36
    None of the above
    Katty
    i loved life as we know it! and i havent seen most of these but bounty hunter wasnt good at all
  • JohnDeuxTrois95 2010/10/13 16:21:37
    None of the above
    JohnDeuxTrois95
    how about romantic comedies in general?
  • InvaderXion420 2010/10/13 13:01:30
    "The Switch"
    InvaderXion420
    My wife loves Heigl so I have to vote against The Switch, which I haven't seen either but I don't really need to. And as far as the question if Duhamel is really a movie star, the answer is : NO! He suxxorz.
  • kurosaki-kun 2010/10/13 05:17:22 (edited)
    None of the above
    kurosaki-kun
    I don't really like romantic comedies unless I'm in the mood for it. I didn't think The Switch was that bad. Compared to The Bounty Hunter it was a better movie.I'm not that crazy about the cast particularly Josh Dushamel or however his name is spelled. He's just another pretty boy actor to me with no substance. Though I've had some fave actors that are mediocre at best and win me with charm but he's not the exception. In essence I do think he's terrible.
  • Pakki 2010/10/12 14:50:04
    None of the above
    Pakki
    +1
    The Notebook.
    The movie should have resembled the book. Instead it grabbed onto a stereo type and was ruined.
  • kurosak... Pakki 2010/10/13 05:25:33
    kurosaki-kun
    I liked The Notebook but never read the book. I do believe you though when you say it's better than the movie. They tend to change a few things in the book sometimes when they adapt it to film. Sometimes also the casting tend to ruin it too.
  • Pakki kurosak... 2010/10/13 23:36:32
    Pakki
    Very short book. Easy read. The characters are completely different. Read it and you will hate the movie. It was very disappointing. Awesome book, my wifes favorite.
  • Alexis 2010/10/12 13:27:55
  • Big C 2010/10/12 10:42:17
    None of the above
    Big C
    +1
    Gigli

    gigli

    EXTREME FAIL!
  • kurosak... Big C 2010/10/13 05:22:32
    kurosaki-kun
    +1
    Definitely, that movie was so Hollywood. Just a terrible movie hated the cast, but it was on cable so I decided to give it a try.
  • Toria 2010/10/12 05:56:50
    "Life as We Know It"
    Toria
    Katherine Heiggl was a better actress when she was just another hungry acting student on Gray's. She didn't used to have such a stiff forced smile. It's been a long time since hollywood had a good pair who could do both comedy and romance at the same time. Poo just isn't funny it's old, tired and boring.
  • ɟʇʇoɔs 2010/10/12 03:51:47
    None of the above
    ɟʇʇoɔs
  • Potato Chips 2010/10/11 23:38:41
    None of the above
    Potato Chips
    +1
    I think it is sad how the romantic comedy genre has been given such a bad name. Love has its cliches, I guess.
  • ««Gingey, the Master Debate... 2010/10/11 23:20:05
    None of the above
    ««Gingey, the Master Debater of Þ|-|Дэ†»»
    Killers was so freaking stupid..
  • Alive 2010/10/11 23:09:25 (edited)
    None of the above
    Alive
    killers and 27 dresses :D .. but i haven't seen life as we know it or the switch :O
  • Nikki 2010/10/11 21:30:23
    "The Switch"
    Nikki
    the switch was a complete bomb
  • None of the above
    υяsυℓα  vεηgεαηcε ►нαя∂ cσяε sтяαιgнт ε∂gε◄
    Romantic Comedy fails as a genre.
  • kurosak... υяsυℓα ... 2010/10/13 05:23:46
    kurosaki-kun
    +1
    I agree sometimes it works but most of the time..it's just something I rather not watch.
  • MOMMA THOMAS 2010/10/11 20:18:58
    None of the above
    MOMMA THOMAS
    A BOMB IS A BOMB, IS A BOMB, IS A BOMB! ALL OF THE ABOVE, AND MORE. NEED BETTER WRITERS,....FOLKS WANT QUALITY, NOT THIS "CHEAP" STUFF.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/25 10:17:13

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals