Which is better? Harry Potter or Twilight?

Yemi Hikari 2012/01/01 23:49:09
Add Photos & Videos
I've noticed that there are a lot of these questions on sodahead and other sites. There aren't many versus though between other fandoms and thus I decided to make have a versus series going.

That also said, don't base your decision on like and dislike.
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest

  • Auran331 2013/07/20 19:22:38
    Harry Potter
    Twilight is s**t no offense cray people.
  • Euxvst 2013/06/06 20:06:47
    Harry Potter
    I once liked Twilight, but now I dislike it.
  • Charlie Receski 2013/01/19 04:26:39
    Harry Potter
    Charlie Receski
    Charles Receski here! I vote for Harry Potter hands down, J.K. Rowling's work has renewed public interest in magic and the supernatural world; I always loved magic stories that eschewed monotheistic dogmas condemning magic. Bella Swan is so bland that Alucard of Hellsing would sit in a catatonic state and mope for several hours if he drank some of her blood. "Hey Alucard, you want to... uhh sir?" Dracula: "urgh, I feel so depressed... my badass personality has been extinguished from an inferno to damp ashes". Few hours later... "Whoah! I just had a freaky dream of being emo, but I'm all better now!"
  • waternymphxD 2012/06/28 18:54:16
    Harry Potter
    A. Nobody in twilight can ACT!! B. Harry potter is much more clever,original and thought-provoking than twilight which is lazy and rushed. C. The main characters in twilight make me want to PUNCH them they are so gay and corny while the Harry potter characters make me want to be them they are so unbelievably cool:)
  • heartsonfire 2012/06/28 16:44:09
    Harry Potter
    Harry potter of course. Twilight is kinda boring.
  • Kiersten 2012/06/27 02:00:21
  • antonella 2012/04/30 07:54:44
    TWILIGHT is the best movie ever <3
  • Bella Cullen 2012/04/25 06:49:56
    Bella Cullen
    cedric diggory or draco malfoy cedric diggory draco malfoy
  • ☣Lady Gothika☣ ™ 2012/04/25 03:09:15
    Harry Potter
    ☣Lady Gothika☣ ™
    THT A EZY Q.
  • Tori Childers 2012/04/25 01:28:47
  • Heaven 2012/04/10 23:47:25
    Harry Potter
    Harry Potter just has more of a purpose. It was about friendship, bravery, courage, sorrow/remorse, a bit of romance, and stepping up when the odds are not in your favor. Harry Potter has more of a broader audience unlike Twilight which sticks to only 10-25 year olds. I watched Harry Potter when I was in preschool because that's how appropriate and good it was. Harry Potter is a classic while Twilight is just a best seller.
  • ValleyOfTheDolls 2012/04/02 00:36:59
    Harry Potter
    I'm not the best person to answer this because I'm a die hard Potterhead and I really don't know much about Twilight. I never really got into Twilight to be honest. Iv'e loved Harry Potter since I was 7 and the reason I started the series is because I knew how popular they were and I wanted to see what the big deal was and I feel in love with the series. I usually start liking things just because I want to see if they really are as great or as bad as people say they are. So that's why I decided to give Twilight a go. I really didn't want to read them that much because of what iv'e heard from a lot of people. Especially about vampires sparking...Anyway one of my best friends is a huge fan so she begged me to read them and I admit I was curious to see what was so great about them. I started reading the first one and I don't remember much about it because I read it a few years ago and haven't picked up a Twilight book since. All I remember is that I didn't have much of a opinion on it and I found it quite boring. I didn't even finish the whole thing. But then again that was about 2 years ago and I am a bigger reader than I was then. I honestly hated reading about 2 years ago so that might have been one reason I didn't like the. Now I finish about 2 or 3 books a week. I think i'll try to read the Twilight series again and see what I think about them this time around. I may like them more. But I don't think i'll ever like Twilight as much as Harry Potter.
  • Gupriela 2012/03/19 02:03:34
  • StrawberryYouth 2012/02/29 08:54:20
    Harry Potter
    HARRY POTTER! J.K. Rowling gave me my childhood by writing Harry Potter. <3
  • i<3draco 2012/02/15 23:10:47
    Harry Potter
    Twilight is a craze.
    Harry Potter is a lifestyle. :)
  • SlytherinStorm 2012/02/08 21:58:23
    Harry Potter
    Harry Potter. I think, because Harry Potter is an "adventure-kinda romantic story, with a few twists" and Twilight is fully "romance". I've never seen Twilight, so I'm not going to rant about it. But, I have to admit, looking at the Twilight trailers, I can tell that Harry Potter is way better :D Plus, WE WANT CEDRIC BACK!
  • Kiersten Slyther... 2012/06/27 02:01:39
  • middleschoolgirl224 2012/02/05 13:34:50
    Harry Potter
    All the way...been a harry potter fan for awhile and im staying one forever <3
  • Strawbe... middles... 2012/02/29 08:55:45
  • happy_idiot 2012/02/02 16:16:30
  • FrozenHeart 2012/02/01 22:22:58
    Harry Potter
    Harry Potter had a great story and likable characters. Twilight had well... a useless main character and a stupid sparkling vampire. Sparkle
  • MusicIsMyBoyfreind 2012/01/29 13:41:19
    Harry Potter
    In a million years!!!!
  • Madi 2012/01/22 05:20:09
    Harry Potter
    Dear Stephanie Meyer,
    This is how twilight should've happened,

    Once upon a time there was a sparkling vampire who loved a stupid pale girl.
    Harry potter thought that was stupid.
    So he killed them.
    And they all lived happily ever after. ( except the vampire and his dumb girlfriend)
    The end.
  • waysideqwe 2012/01/21 00:03:17
    Harry Potter
  • waysideqwe waysideqwe 2012/01/21 00:12:54
    another reason also... our bella and theirs
  • Yemi Hi... waysideqwe 2012/01/25 02:46:33
    Yemi Hikari
    That fact is out of date though. Breaking Dawn (Part 1) actually beat out the bottom four movies. It will be as will its sequel hard pressed to beat out the last four though.
  • Luna 2012/01/15 15:03:07
    Harry Potter
    twilight is just a bunch of pale people talking in monotones about how much they love each other. and they look constipated. Harry Potter is an epic series written by an epic author!
  • ParaTime♥ 2012/01/15 10:22:25
    Harry Potter
    I like twilight but am starting to slip away from it as I think the sparkling is weird.....
    And real vampires have fangs! It makes the hotter ;P
    But HP is well better! :)
  • MichelleluvsRonWeasley 2012/01/10 21:30:18
    Harry Potter
    OH MY... GODRIC'S HOLLOW! Why would anyone like twilight more than Harry Potter? As you can see from my username, I am a HUGE Harry potter fan. Plus, Twilight only teaches you that it's important to have a boyfriend. Harry Potter teaches about good vs evil, how important love, friends and family is, and it tells everyone to believe in magic... The right kind. Not the kind with a world where there are vegetarian vampires who sparkle. You know, one girl in my class saw me reading Harry Potter, and she likes Twilight, so we kinda started arguing, and I couldn't refrain from saying "She likes the sparkly vampire and the gay Warewolf who fight over the ugly girl." Oops... I probably just offended a whole lot of Twilight lovers. Please don't hate me!
  • Yemi Hi... Michell... 2012/01/11 08:19:24
    Yemi Hikari
    Did she have a response back to that one?
  • Michell... Yemi Hi... 2012/01/15 16:17:38
    Nope! Yeah, I'm awesome ;)
  • Jbug799 2012/01/06 07:57:31
    Harry Potter
    Harry Potter...Twilight is ok but its lacking something. The books were ok..but Harry potter was better!!
  • paramorefan11 2012/01/05 18:54:45
    Harry Potter
    i have always liked Harry Potter more then Twilight, im not saying that i dont like Twilight because i do, i just like Harry Potter better
  • nr13complicted 2012/01/05 16:26:38
    You can't compare them, the one is about a boy who goes on adventure, Twilight is about an impossible romance...
  • Connor ... nr13com... 2012/01/11 07:52:54
  • Jane Constant 2012/01/05 03:23:23
    Harry Potter
    Jane Constant
  • Little Wonders 2012/01/04 23:59:27
    Little Wonders
    not a big fan of either. so...none of the above:P
  • DragonSlayer 2012/01/04 21:02:54
    Harry Potter
    :O ur crazy
    funny harry potter
    funny harry potter
    funny harry potter
    funny harry potter
    funny harry potter
  • Mrs.Lautner <3 2012/01/04 20:53:21
    They're equal...
    Mrs.Lautner <3
    I love them both!!!!
    Breaking Dawn Poster
    Harry Potter Poster
  • Yemi Hi... Mrs.Lau... 2012/01/05 00:02:17
    Yemi Hikari
    The poll wasn't about like or dislike though...

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.


2014/04/20 21:12:02

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals