Which is better: Harry Potter!!!! or Twilight...?

by Sarah (Potterhead forever) Posted 2011/11/25 15:35:34

Related Topics: Twilight, Harry Potter, Debate, Potter, Better

Read More

24 votes
Read all 26 opinions
View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)	18 votes	75%
	twilight.... (explain)	4 votes	17%
	Neither (explain)	2 votes	8%

These are probably two of the most opposite fanbases and its like theyres always a debate. Which do you like better?

Add a comment above

Yemi Hikari 2012/01/03 00:07:14

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
There are so many things that make Harry Potter better then Twilight. Harry Potter actually adresses the fact that some relationships are abusive in the emotional and mental manner, as with Ginny and Dean and she broke up with him where Bella let Edward control her on most issues.

reply
Jordan Thomas 2011/12/09 19:54:59

twilight.... (explain)

I'd actually go for both but! Twilight is amazing and I have every on on DVD (except Breaking Dawn, Obviously!). There both equal!

reply
Baby Lucy :$ 2011/11/29 19:44:32

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
Watched it for years it's class! Never seen twilight

reply
Pierced Princess 2011/11/25 23:39:26
kayakosaeki 2011/11/25 19:30:08

twilight.... (explain)

Jacobs cute

reply
AnnieIsCool12 2011/11/25 18:56:56

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
Harry Potter is so much better than Twilight, the books are so amazing!

reply
vamp-gal 2011/11/25 17:22:15

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
Harry Potter has so many messages to children and adults, male and female. It teaches
Loyalty,
Love, (Mothers love (Lily, Narcissa), and many more,
standing up and fighting for what you believe in,
not everything is as it appears on the surface (Snape and more),
women are just as strong as men in a battle,
appreciate the things you take for granted (like family and friends),
Relationships develop overtime and are realistic,
The characters grow and evolve overtime...

... you know what, I could go on forever :P

reply
Sarah (... to vamp-gal 2011/11/25 17:27:29

+1
IKR!!! i didnt really ecplain cause it would have taken me FOREVER:) theres just so much more to it than people think:)

reply
shahid86 2011/11/25 16:10:34

twilight.... (explain)

It reminds us, that love can happen not in humans, it is the gift of god that cannot be negleted

reply
Sarah (... to shahid86 2011/11/25 16:25:37 (edited)

It a frickin story about lovesick vampires and werewolves fighting over a prissy chick... HP shows that no matter how stong an evil is it can be defeated and that love conquers all

reply
shahid86 to Sarah (... 2011/11/25 17:17:04

You are absolutely right.

reply
Sarah (... to shahid86 2011/11/25 17:19:51

I thought u like twilight?

reply
shahid86 to Sarah (... 2011/11/25 17:27:31

Yup, but somethings can't be expressed, what do you think?

reply
Sarah (... to shahid86 2011/11/25 17:28:20

I just meant that you said i was right when i was totally insulting twilight...

reply
shahid86 to Sarah (... 2011/11/25 17:32:02

Yeah, everyone has their opinion that can't be changed. You don't like twilight, its ok!

reply
Yemi Hi... to shahid86 2012/01/03 00:08:35

+1
Twilight isn't about love, it is about lust. There is a big difference between the two and the story that actually deals with the elements of love is Harry Potter...

reply
Connor ... to Yemi Hi... 2012/01/11 08:32:09

I've seen a lot of what you've said about Harry Potter vs Twilight...and I LOOOOVE it!

reply
Yemi Hi... to Connor ... 2012/01/11 10:01:29

Thank you.

reply
Sarah (... to Yemi Hi... 2012/01/19 22:35:21

Ok then whats the "big difference" between love and "lust"

reply
Yemi Hi... to Sarah (... 2012/01/25 03:11:47

I could write a long entry about what the difference between the two is but that would take time so I just went and found something someone else wrote that says pretty much what I would have said.

http://www.kissmegoodnight.co...

To quote this page, "By definition alone the two differ in that, love is based on an affinity while lust is based solely on desire." Bella and Edwards relationship is built on desire. Bella wants Edward because he is what she sees as perfection. Their relationship also lacks a mutual respect for each other.

reply
Dolly 2011/11/25 15:46:06

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
Harry.freakin.potter. I don't really know.

reply
leah 2011/11/25 15:43:31

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

uuuuuuuuuuugh that's really hard..... i LOVE both, but I've been with HP since i was 5... from the beginning to the end, movies and books... i have been there. versus twilight, which I've been with since i was like 11.

reply
User Deactivated 2011/11/25 15:39:02

Neither (explain)

+1
I'm a 27 year old male..I don't think either is geared towards me. To each their own, but I'm not a fan.

reply
♥NinjaKittenLovesYou♥ 2011/11/25 15:38:29

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+2
twilight sucks :S

reply
Red Pixy 2011/11/25 15:38:27

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

+1
i love harry potter cause it's so interesting, but twilight is so boring!

reply
Sarah (Potterhead forever) 2011/11/25 15:36:40

Harry Potter!!!!! (explain)

It just AWESOME!!!! and Twilight sucks...

reply