Quantcast

Was Jennifer Lawrence Too 'Fat' for 'The Hunger Games'?

SodaHead Film 2012/03/28 13:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Last week, Jennifer Lawrence expressed insecurities about being cast as Katniss, the lead role in "The Hunger Games." On "Letterman" she lamented, "I'm a troll. I hate myself. I think the movie is great, but their biggest mistake was me!" That's obviously a bunk statement, but critics aren't going to boost her self-esteem any with the comments they've been making about her weight in reviews of the movie.

According to New York Magazine, critics from The Hollywood Reporter, the New York Times, Salon, Variety, and others are calling attention to Lawrence's apparent lack of... well, hunger. She's not being "starved into submission" as the book suggests. Lawrence says it was a conscious decision, but critics are using terms like "womanly figure," "baby fat," and "well-fed" like they're bad things. Was Jennifer Lawrence really too big to play Katniss in "Hunger Games"?

jennifer lawrence
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Lisey 2012/11/09 14:36:50
    No
    Lisey
    That is so ridiculous. She's absolutely beautiful.
  • Kurt 2012/09/22 17:17:49
    Yes
    Kurt
    She could dropped 10-15 lbs for the role.
  • annaberry96 2012/06/07 21:26:37 (edited)
    No
    annaberry96
    This doesn't even matter in the movie. People wouldn't of paid attention to it anyways. And still? She is not fat. Being "starving" is a minor detail in the movie. It doesn't matter. And for those who voted yes, How many books have you read that turned into a movie? Alright. Now how many big details and minor details were left out of the movie? It doesn't matter if she was too big or too small. She is not fat. She is perfect.

    And you guys that votes yes; You're all saying 'well, she's not fat. She's a great actor. But...' The question is "Was Jennifer Lawrence Too 'Fat' for 'The Hunger Games'?" Alright. So you're saying in all your comments that she is not fat, and she is a great actor.

    What's the problem? When you click 'No', does it automatically say that you said yes or something?
  • Samantha 2012/05/12 06:08:59
    Yes
    Samantha
    +1
    A person her age and height no she's not fat. But to play and emanciated teenage girl yes. Way too fat.
  • gummi bear39 2012/05/07 01:10:53
    Yes
    gummi bear39
    +1
    It's not that she's fat, because she's not, but couldn't they have done some sort of makeup on everyone in the districts to at least make them LOOK like they are starving people? Everyone looked like normal, healthy human beings. That's not how they were described in the books at all...
  • whatever 2012/04/27 14:09:15
    No
    whatever
    she's really great at the movie..and she's really pretty.. saying she's ''TOO FAT'' is just stupid
  • deert whatever 2012/09/08 18:31:18
    deert
    So true
  • TheDeadAreLiving 2012/04/18 00:11:49
    No
    TheDeadAreLiving
    Sure the people from District 12 were supposed to be emaciated, but I think she played her role perfectly. Who cares if she has a bit of chub? I think she's very pretty and she's a very believable and lovable Katniss.
  • macy 2012/04/13 05:06:03
    No
    macy
    Seeing people call movie stars "fat" today is sick. What kind of message does that send? Not just, "you should be as thin as a movie star" but "you should be thinner". This is why we have problems with anorexia in this country.
  • raquel 2012/04/12 20:11:23
    No
    raquel
    in the couple of scenes where she did have to wear "fitted" clothes i was like "I want that body" she was fit and some my have a beef with you not being able to see her ribs but in the book she isnt starving and isnt over-feed, Gale and Katniss hunt and trade so they have a fair amount of food.
    all females in my oppinion (me included) always have insecurities about their bodies and personalities and abilities. i think she is very talented and i was impressed with her portrail of Katniss.
  • Kurt 2012/04/12 07:15:48
    No
    Kurt
    Kudos to the casting crew. She is perfect among others. Now get on with the 2nd and 3rd productions.
  • Kurt Kurt 2012/04/12 07:23:44
    Kurt
    Had anyone seen her in Winter Bone? Unforgetable work.
  • ViRGiNiA_97 2012/04/11 23:07:09
    No
    ViRGiNiA_97
    No way! She's perfect just the way she is! Gosh, I hate today's society and their obsession over skin and bones. Smh...
  • Kat 2012/04/10 12:01:46 (edited)
    No
    Kat
    +2
    She's not fat at all, not everybody likes anorexic looking females or idiotic critics.
  • Padfoot 2012/04/08 06:15:01
    No
    Padfoot
    +2
    No i think she was perfect for the role as she was meant to be well fed for where she lived!
  • ☠megan_massacre☠ 2012/04/08 05:15:09 (edited)
    No
    ☠megan_massacre☠
    +3
    Definitely not!! She was a great Katniss! You call this fat?
    Jennifer Lawrence
  • darafina ☠megan_... 2012/04/09 13:55:44
    darafina
    +2
    That's not starving for sure.
  • ☠megan_... darafina 2012/04/10 01:25:09
    ☠megan_massacre☠
    Oh?
  • Maurice... ☠megan_... 2012/04/13 05:18:33
    Maurice Tillman
    Technically, "starving" is the lack of nutrients over a certain period of time. A person can starve in matter of a week and not live long enough to become skinny, if a person is dehydrate. Skinny is due to prolonged starvation, mixed with a small amount of water.
  • sahealic 2012/04/06 16:52:18
    No
    sahealic
    +1
    She was amazing as Katniss!
  • Katniss 2012/04/05 18:39:28
    No
    Katniss
    +1
    No! She's gorgeous, and it's not healthy to look like you're dying.
  • darafina Katniss 2012/04/09 13:56:55
    darafina
    +2
    That's the point of the movie....they are all dying from starvation...the people in the districts.
  • Katniss darafina 2012/04/12 02:46:27
    Katniss
    I know, but even for a movie you shouldn't be forced to look like a corpse.
  • Maurice... Katniss 2012/04/13 05:20:17
    Maurice Tillman
    If the movie requires one to look like a starving person, they should. Mat Damon did it before...I think Madonna did all throughout the later 90's, lol! Just joking. Just joking...
  • Princess 2012/04/05 01:47:47
    No
    Princess
    +1
    Jennifer Lawrence is amazing. Shes perfect the way she is. Your stupid if you think otherwise.
  • Flamingolady 2012/04/04 18:30:21
    No
    Flamingolady
    +4
    She is perfect as she is. Hollywood needs to get over the skin and bones theme.
  • UnicornVine81 2012/04/04 15:48:57
    No
    UnicornVine81
    +2
    She wasn't the exact body type I pictured in my head, but Having an ED like I do I find it really had to say/tell anyone that they fat. No one is perfect. Plus she's an amazing actress and so, so beautiful. She's an excellent choice for Katniss. She plays the part so well, so it's hard to picture someone different.
  • Maurice... Unicorn... 2012/04/13 05:21:22
    Maurice Tillman
    You have ED? I didn't think women got ED...
  • Jim 2012/04/04 13:03:30 (edited)
  • BubbaGrrl 2012/04/04 09:51:28
    No
    BubbaGrrl
    +1
    NOOOO WAAYYY !!! OMFG she id BEAUTIFUL !!!! and i want that body !!
  • Ashley Tale 2012/04/04 01:53:28
    No
    Ashley Tale
    +1
    Are you crazy????
  • dSavanna 2012/04/04 00:00:42
    No
    dSavanna
    +1
    I may not like her face, but at least she has a REAL body!!!
  • Rebecca 2012/04/03 15:44:28
    No
    Rebecca
    +1
    you hvae to be kidding right!!! what the FUUUUUUUCK
  • Ober 2012/04/03 06:50:27 (edited)
    No
    Ober
    +3
    Should the character she is playing be more skinny than she is? Yes.
    Should they let an actress starve herself just to make it more accurate. No.
  • S123 2012/04/03 01:32:43
    No
    S123
    +1
    I think she looks healthy. No, she dosn't look like she is being "starved into submission" because she isn't starving! That's a good thing!
  • Cassidy Evans 2012/04/03 01:30:51
    No
    Cassidy Evans
    +2
    Like we need another starved actress running around...
    She did a wonderful job
  • Chris0623 2012/04/02 17:02:25
    No
    Chris0623
    +3
    She looked fine for the character. She can hunt which helps her not to be anorexic skinny. She performed amazing in this film.
  • Kutikate 2012/04/02 16:36:28
    No
    Kutikate
    +1
    Course not!!!!!!!!
  • hey.im.maddi 2012/04/02 04:04:07
    No
    hey.im.maddi
    +2
    If Jennifer Lawrence is "fat" then Heaven help me.
  • edward roman 2012/04/02 01:21:25
    No
    edward roman
    +2
    please people dont destroy this life,she is an amazing actress and so beautiful
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 18 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/22 22:26:06

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals