Quantcast

Tommy Mottola Takes Credit for Mariah Carey's Stardom: Could She Have Done It Without Him?

SodaHead Celebs 2013/01/07 15:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Record exec Tommy Mottola has written his memoir, “Hitmaker.” In the book, he says that his ex-wife Mariah Carey would be nothing without him. Carey has repeatedly charged that during their four-year marriage, Mottola was controlling and that he emotionally abused her.

The two met when the “American Idol” judge was just 23 years old and Mottola was in his forties. They began having an affair until he divorced his wife and the mother of his two kids. She rose to stardom under his tutelage, selling 15 million copies of her first release. But after years of what she called “a private hell,” the couple divorced in 1997.



In his book Mottola writes, “If it seemed like I was controlling, I apologize. Was I obsessive? Yes. But that was also part of the reason for her success." He acknowledges that she came to the partnership with the talent. He says, "That may be the best voice you've ever heard in your life!" But he maintains that it was because he didn’t let her take a break that she became the star she is today. What do you think? Would Mariah Carey be famous without Tommy Mottola?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • TKramar 2013/01/09 17:34:34
    No
    TKramar
    Many highly talented people struggle for years, and many never make it big, irrespective of talent. Carey needed either him, or someone like him, to advance. That's how music works. And of those who DO make it, many are quickly forgotten. Most bands do not have the enduring popularity of someone like the Rolling Stones--and even the Stones aren't that popular in current entertainment circles.
  • polock 2013/01/09 16:56:13
    Yes
    polock
    If you have talent and a desire to succeed you can do it without someone who was looking to make his "dime" on her abilities. he left his family to make money off of a talent half his age. shame on you. Shame on Mariah for falling for this family wrecker.
  • Watermusicranger 2013/01/09 16:29:13
    Yes
    Watermusicranger
    Stardom is a crap-shoot for anyone.
  • danthemanholt 2013/01/09 05:21:10
    Yes
    danthemanholt
    I'd be obsessed with her too if I were in a relationship with her. Who wouldn't be obsessed with her if they were with her. She's one of the most beautiful women in the world, and she has a beautiful personality. Although I wouldn't be emotionally abusive and I'd make sure she has her own identity and space to herself but I'd always be there for her.
  • Jrogers 2013/01/09 03:31:07
    Yes
    Jrogers
    I really dont believe he could hit the notes that she does. It is her singing that made her famous
  • RJeffreySavlov 2013/01/09 01:10:02
    No
    RJeffreySavlov
    +1
    He was in the right place at the right time.
  • rich 2013/01/09 00:30:53
    Yes
    rich
    She had the will, and the talent is tremendous, so yes, it would have been recognized, surely.
  • nicesteve 2013/01/08 23:59:30 (edited)
    Yes
    nicesteve
    Some of those Italians can be so arrogant at times. Mariah has enough talent
    to make it on her own. And if she applies good common horsesense in her
    business discisions, she will. And unlike Tommy, most Italians have the good
    sense and consideration for others to not allow the fact that they're Italian go to
    their heads, and practice good social stewardship.
  • stevegtexas@aol.com 2013/01/08 17:53:58
    No
    stevegtexas@aol.com
    No, probably not....but thats what friends are for right?!?!? Is this question stirred up by the fact that she is doing the SUPERBOWL halftime? or is it Beyonce? superbowl ticket 2013 Beyonce swim suit Mariah carey swim suit
  • Shellz 2013/01/08 17:42:58
    Yes
    Shellz
    With that VOICE anything is possible for Ms. Carey!!!!!
  • Michael 2013/01/08 16:44:46
    Yes
    Michael
    Yes she would have done ok for sure. But as famous as she has been, to do on her own? I'd highly doubt. It takes a team of people to make someone famous. And it's not just talent...it's MARKETABLE talent that gets one noticed. That's the reality. Mariah just so happens to be one if the greatest female vocalists EVER and not only that she happens to be one of the best looking women youve seen. thats a very rare (and marketable) combo. Women who sing like that dont usually have a body like that; that makes her super unique and not since Yma, Ella, and Billie has there been a better female vocalist. Not adele, not christina aguilera, none of them. Not even Whitney can quite touch her. Mariah also has a unique timbre to her voice, arguably the most unique since Paula Abdul.
  • Matt Michael 2013/01/09 16:02:38
    Matt
    "better" is very subjective - there are probably 100 opera trained singers who are technically "better" than her - Dame Kiri Te Kawana, Joan Southerland, Miria Callas etc etc etc
    as far as pop singers go though, she is up there with the best of them.

    personal taste comes into who one considers to be a great female vocalist - personally I prefer Haley Westenra, Charlotte Church, Laura Pausini and Sissel to be more suited to my ear... then the likes of the Mariah Careys, Norah Jones's and Celine Dion's
  • Michael Matt 2013/01/12 14:51:09
    Michael
    I should've specified for the popular music world. I'm quite certain there's some Italian opera singer out there would wipe the floor with Mariah in technique.
  • Bob Anderson 2013/01/08 15:55:56
    No
    Bob Anderson
    +1
    no she wouldn't be chit without him , she is to stupid to have made it on her own
  • mrdog 2013/01/08 15:55:31
    No
    mrdog
    She is a star???? bark
  • SUPREME COSMIC POWER, (SCOPO) 2013/01/08 15:52:01
    Yes
    SUPREME COSMIC POWER, (SCOPO)
    We're fans of Ms. Mariah Carey and from the same City and we can say she would definitely have succeeded without Mr. Mottola evnthough his help in accelerating her career can't be denied. It is wrong to bite the hands that pushed a person up to the top to become a star
  • Siefimn 2013/01/08 15:42:23
    Yes
    Siefimn
    Of course. She is one of the greatest singers in history. Who the hell is Tommy Mottola?
  • rebeccasrevenge 2013/01/08 15:09:05
    Yes
    rebeccasrevenge
    Although his position in the record industry probably made it a lot faster for her to achieve stardom that was all it did.
  • trap flapper 2013/01/08 14:54:08
    Yes
    trap flapper
    +1
    Yes. Unless of course Mariah has been lip sync-ing all these years and the tremendous voice we hear on all those recordings is really Tony Mottola!!!!
  • L.A. woman 2013/01/08 14:50:25
    No
    L.A. woman
    How has her career been since she left him? Case closed.
  • courtney.epperson.96 2013/01/08 14:02:40
    Yes
    courtney.epperson.96
    She sings like an angel.
  • Nat™ 2013/01/08 13:43:18
    Yes
    Nat™
    +1
    Her talent speaks enough for it.
  • Richard M. Nixon 2013/01/08 13:29:28
    Yes
    Richard M. Nixon
    Of course. This is a prime example of "jumping on the band wagon".

    prime jumping band wagon
  • ruthannhausman 2013/01/08 12:08:33
    Yes
    ruthannhausman
    +2
    With her voice, odds are in her favor that she would have, although one can never be sure. He's just a typical non-talent who is riding on the coattails of his talented "client." He probably had a lot to do with her current success, yes; however, could she have achieved that same kind of success without him, that's the real question. No one can honestly state one way or the other. I'm betting, however, that her talent would have driven her right to the same location she is now. And maybe even happier in her personal life.
  • rebrandingnigeria.clubs 2013/01/08 09:45:46
    Yes
    rebrandingnigeria.clubs
    She slept with him to get a recording contract and married him for her selfish reasons until she was comfortable enough to gain her independence.
    BEHIND EVERY SUCCESSFUL WOMAN THERE IS A BIG MAN.
  • tikiteek 2013/01/08 08:54:33
    Yes
    tikiteek
    If she belives in test tubes.
  • disclaimer 2013/01/08 06:16:23
    Yes
    disclaimer
    +1
    Reminds me of George Michael taking credit for the beatles.
  • MLor 2013/01/08 05:27:25
    No
    MLor
    +1
    She is a star because of her voice & talent. Enough said.
  • Resp 2013/01/08 04:55:15
    No
    Resp
    They were a team and had a chemistry that succeeded. One without the other is not the same.
  • Max7 Resp 2013/01/08 17:14:55
    Max7
    I don't think that they were a team, he was an older man with a young wife and he ruled with a iron fist. This is why she got out of the relationship. I'd say that Mariah has risen to great heights without Tommy Mottola, and presently she is really happy and still extremely successful.
  • Leslie Goudy 2013/01/08 04:51:53 (edited)
    Yes
    Leslie Goudy
    +1


    She was so beautiful before he started making her over

    mariah carey before mottola started making her over
    beautiful
  • POWERSH... Leslie ... 2013/01/08 14:06:51
    POWERSHAKER
    +1
    You got that right, but that first picture is Whitney Houston. What does she have to do with Mariah Carrey? lol
  • Leslie ... POWERSH... 2013/01/08 18:45:42
    Leslie Goudy
    +1
    I didn't even notice that on the 1st picture. I brought them up and they had them all mixed up. Sorry. I was looking for one in particular i saw many years ago in a Dr. Office. I will leave it up there to see if anyone else notices lol
  • POWERSH... Leslie ... 2013/01/08 19:53:38
    POWERSHAKER
    +1
    Oh. Okay. No problem. :)
  • Resp Leslie ... 2013/01/08 19:37:35
    Resp
    +1
    Is she White, Black, or Blonde?
  • Flamingo Flame Gem *AFCL* 2013/01/08 04:27:43
    Yes
    Flamingo Flame Gem *AFCL*
    +1
    Tommy Mattola tried to ruin her career during their divorce....Now she is doing better without him. Mattola is a jerk. Once a jerk always a jerk.
  • Max7 2013/01/08 04:21:22
    Yes
    Max7
    +1
    With that voice, with him or without she was destined to be a hit. She proved that when he was no longer in her life, she never missed a beat.
  • MLor Max7 2013/01/08 05:28:35
    MLor
    Nuff said!
  • Max7 MLor 2013/01/08 17:19:13
    Max7
    +1
    Last night Mariah Carey was on the Barbara Walters show, and this woman without a doubt has very successfully risen to the top, and without the help of Tommy. Many of her awards are due to her own writing and compositions. Tommy must have some motive for what he wrote, could be jealousy!
  • barby karring 2013/01/08 04:01:10
    Yes
    barby karring
    He probably contributed to her getting there to the top at a faster rate in timing' she would have gotten there on her own but not without a struggle young singers go through in getting loaded into the business.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/06/19 02:27:01

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals