Quantcast

There is a Headphone Wars: Beats vs. Bose, which is your choice?

BIG BAD JOHN R. 2012/05/15 15:20:11
Bose Around-Ear ($94.88)
Beats Solo HD ($199.99)
Undecided
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Headphones Wars features two popular models of headphones being compared side-by-side with a set of controlled elements. We picked ten songs, all streaming at 320kbps from Spotify, from a variety of genres and decades, and spent some time listening with both devices. Feel free to conduct your own trials with these tracks, great for testing any audio component. Today we're comparing the popular Beats Solo HD with the more modest (and more modestly priced) Bose Around-Ear basic model. Let's meet our test tracks!


beats_HDsolo.jpg

Beats Solo HD ($199.99)

Key Features: Power, Style

The main problem with Beats is the inability to shake the feeling you are listening to a really stellar pair of headphones underwater. The bass frequencies are noticeably boosted and this makes listening to vocal and guitar heavy rock feel kind of washed out, especially when compared to any other set of phones sporting a better balance. The Strokes especially tune sounds pretty bad and off kilter. Nirvana sounded like it had a constantly garbled rumble in the background. But just using the Beats for an extended listening session, you tend to forget this flaw, especially in the older recordings.

Beats can get very loud and very soft while maintaining a good balance of frequencies (minus that one gaping flaw). They actually tend to sound more balanced when cranked up to 11, especially with more recent recordings.

Beats perform surprisingly well with the softer genres like jazz and classical, where feeling the timbre of the instruments is paramount to the perception of quality. You can taste the trumpet like you're the one blowing the notes. But the imbalanced frequencies makes this another losing category.

They look very, very cool, even if they aren't the most comfortable over-the-ear set in the world. The aesthetic is clearly branded and chic. You've probably seen them everywhere from public transportation to that music video you just watched. With a colorful red wire, super portability, and an extra cable for talking on your phone (think Apple's earbud/mic combo), Beats definitely fit well into your life if you're using your phone to listen to music while traveling/commuting.

Beats were built for pop, that much is clear. Nothing sounded as good, or as punchy, or as loud as the Katy Perry tune, with all the close seconds being older pop numbers like Destiny's Child and D'Angelo. If you're religiously top 40 or anything hip-hop/R&B;, these might be the phones for you.

Bose Around-Ear ($94.88)

Key features: Balance, Comfort

The Bose headphones achieve a much more pronounced balance of high and low frequency, making for a better instrumental blend. Although Bose can't maintain the punch of the Beats bass when turned low, do you really need them to?

Bose maintains most of the punch of Beats, but in a much more balanced fashion. You feel the kick, but there is no annoying rumble on distortion heavy tracks like The Strokes and Nirvana. We do have to admit, the trumpet on the Miles Davis track doesn't feel as crisp and organic for some reason. And the Bose phones may not be able to get quite as loud as Beats, but there aren't many situations where you need your headphones to get to near-deafening loudness.

The Bose phones aren't as portable or slick looking as Beats, but they feel more tenuous on your head (they don't push in as much). The cushions sit around your ears instead of on them, which is much more pleasant, and although they aren't the sports car of headphones, they still look pretty sleek.

For anything with distortion and plenty of crash cymbal, you'll be very sorry you went with Beats over Bose. But for certain aspects of pop tunes, especially heavily compressed ones, Beats definitely have a power edge.

Range: 8 Levels: 6 Balance: 9 Comfort: 7 Aesthetic: 4 Musical Versatility: 9

Bose wins on points, but perhaps you feel differently. Let us know how you feel if you own a pair, or which other headphones you'd like to see stacked up next to each other, in the comments.




Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • FF5 Addict 2012/05/15 23:25:21
    Beats Solo HD ($199.99)
    FF5 Addict
  • metalmania17 2012/05/15 21:02:21
    Undecided
    metalmania17
    +1
    Jenson.

    jenson headphones
  • Veritas 2012/05/15 19:16:45 (edited)
    Undecided
    Veritas
    +1
    I have two skull candy's and I like them both. Also use a pair of Shure's for my guitar, but they're not for iPod use.
    skull candy plaid headphones
  • BIG BAD... Veritas 2012/05/16 18:09:51
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    +1
    I have the skull candy's Skullcandy Aviator Headphones and I think they are great. The only reason I want beats is for the base! It is so off the chain! Skullcandy Aviator Headphones

    I"ve got the pair on the left
  • sean 2012/05/15 17:52:06
    Undecided
    sean
    Beats are overatted and I've never used Bose before so I couldn't choose.
  • Beat Magnum True Hero 2012/05/15 17:22:01
    Undecided
    Beat Magnum True Hero
  • Rachel 2012/05/15 15:38:44
    Undecided
    Rachel
    +1
    Sennheiser HD 800.

    sennheiser hd 800
  • sean Rachel 2012/05/15 17:50:08
    sean
    +1
    Aren't those like $1500
  • Rachel sean 2012/05/15 17:51:56
    Rachel
    Yes. It is.
  • BIG BAD... sean 2012/05/15 17:51:58
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    which ones
  • sean BIG BAD... 2012/05/15 17:55:29
    sean
    The sennhieser headphones.
  • BIG BAD... Rachel 2012/05/15 17:51:22
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    +1
    Never head of it, tks, I'll check it out
  • BIG BAD... Rachel 2012/05/15 18:01:11
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    +1
    1800.00 is a little out of my price range to listen to music on the go
  • Rachel BIG BAD... 2012/05/15 18:04:45
    Rachel
    .... then I'd go for Bose. :-)

    Because I haven't tried Beats Solo. But if it's like the Lady Gaga beats ... I'd go for Bose still.
  • BIG BAD... Rachel 2012/05/15 18:13:36
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    +1
    oK, best of luck and that's for texting text me anytime.
  • BIG BAD JOHN R. 2012/05/15 15:29:40
    Beats Solo HD ($199.99)
    BIG BAD JOHN R.
    Beats Solo HD ($199.99) is on my wish list. I'm a big fan of Beats, My computer has Beats, and I love it. They have the best sound in my opinion. I have Skullcandy Roc Nation Aviator headphones review: Jay-Z-approved ... And they are a great head phone but great isn't blowing me away/ Beats rocks and there is no way around them if you want the best sounds in my view its Beats. I have been in the music game since I was a kid and I have a sound system that most people would die for.


    beats

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/21 14:17:34

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals