Quantcast

'Teen Mom' Amber Portwood Picks Prison Over Rehab: Would You Rather Go to Prison or Rehab?

SodaHead Celebs 2012/06/08 19:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Back in December, "Teen Mom" star Amber Portwood managed to get out of a five-year jail sentence by agreeing to complete a drug rehab program, but last week in court she told a judge that she couldn't finish it. She agreed to go to prison instead. She told ABC News, "In my situation, I felt in the program there were a lot of eyes on me. And it was very uncomfortable. I was not using my anti-psych medication even."

Portwood's legal trouble began in 2010, when she was charged with three felonies for hitting her ex-fiance Gary Shirley in front of their daughter. She managed to get off with two years of probation, but violated her probation when she got in a fight and was found with prescription medication that she didn't have a prescription for. She also attempted suicide on a few occasions. So, this whole ordeal has got us wondering. If you were in Amber Portwood's shoes -- which, for your sake, we hope you aren't -- would you pick prison or rehab?

amber portwod
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Seras Superstar 2012/06/08 20:03:33
    Rehab
    Seras Superstar
    +30
    "I felt in the program there were a lot of eyes on me. And it was very uncomfortable."

    Wait until you get into prision.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • AngelaDuke 2012/06/09 20:58:23
    Rehab
    AngelaDuke
    +2
    At least then I'm getting help, not behind bars, could get out early and have a better chance of not being back (or raped)
  • WetLushRei 2012/06/09 20:34:37
    Rehab
    WetLushRei
    +1
    Being in prison you technically are in rehab... but at least in rehab you're free
  • ohsmith ☮ R P ☮ 2012 ☮ 2012/06/09 20:23:03
    Rehab
    ohsmith ☮ R P ☮ 2012 ☮
    +1
    This shows what level her IQ is....DUMB!
  • PokerFace 2012/06/09 20:08:36
    Rehab
    PokerFace
    +1
    at least u have a chance of recovering
  • Jada_Ringo 2012/06/09 19:45:55
    Rehab
    Jada_Ringo
    +1
    Ehh, I've been in a mental hospital a couple of times already in the past 2 years(3 times in the past 2 months) I'm used to people watching me. But Prison, I'd probably cry.
  • Cinna 2012/06/09 19:41:27
    Prison
    Cinna
    +1
    The hell, sodahead? I clicked on rehab. Erg...But yeah, rehab. Never prison, rehab.
  • Sister Jean 2012/06/09 19:20:43
    Rehab
    Sister Jean
    never had that awful choice
  • dekecds 2012/06/09 19:05:54
    Prison
    dekecds
    +1
    While the rehab itself is definitely a better option, I understand.
    My sister was in a similar situation with drugs and the "eyes watching me" concept goes over the top quite a bit. I learned that in a situation like that, the prison sentence and restitution is much smaller under the plea bargain than a straight conviction.
    That being said, the rehab option is usually attached to a failure clause that allows the court to apply full penalty in the event that the probation and rehabilitation fail.
    When you couple that with the near impossible schedule you must follow to satisfy your probation officer and any restitution levied (which is partially based on the job you probably lost due to the arrest), you just can't win.
    Before seeing the facts of my sister's situation I thought, Wow, what a loser that you can't seem to stick to a measly probation mandate. After seeing her struggle with her new job, making $1700 less, and the restitution to the state of no less than $800 a month for 9 months, plus the weekly 24 hour notices of required non-negotiable community service,and twice weekly rehab (not to mention a ten year probation term), I can understand why she decided to take the one year prison sentence.
    Maybe this girl is in the same type of situation. In my sister's ...
    While the rehab itself is definitely a better option, I understand.
    My sister was in a similar situation with drugs and the "eyes watching me" concept goes over the top quite a bit. I learned that in a situation like that, the prison sentence and restitution is much smaller under the plea bargain than a straight conviction.
    That being said, the rehab option is usually attached to a failure clause that allows the court to apply full penalty in the event that the probation and rehabilitation fail.
    When you couple that with the near impossible schedule you must follow to satisfy your probation officer and any restitution levied (which is partially based on the job you probably lost due to the arrest), you just can't win.
    Before seeing the facts of my sister's situation I thought, Wow, what a loser that you can't seem to stick to a measly probation mandate. After seeing her struggle with her new job, making $1700 less, and the restitution to the state of no less than $800 a month for 9 months, plus the weekly 24 hour notices of required non-negotiable community service,and twice weekly rehab (not to mention a ten year probation term), I can understand why she decided to take the one year prison sentence.
    Maybe this girl is in the same type of situation. In my sister's case, the result of failure in the rehab/probation option (revocable for the full 10 year duration mind you) would be a 15 year prison sentence. Better to try first and then "volunteer" for the prison sentence plea terms.
    (more)
  • flyingseaturtle BN 2012/06/09 18:56:29
    Rehab
    flyingseaturtle BN
    That is what I would have picked. It is her life and her choice ;-)
  • Kibbles 2012/06/09 18:45:32
    Rehab
    Kibbles
    +2
    Although I don't think I would make it to either, my mother would end me the second she found out these were my options. Momma didn't raise no fool.
  • Callaway 2012/06/09 18:44:33
    Rehab
    Callaway
    +1
    Rehab everytime for her however based on her past history, intelligence, and general attitude she chose correctly. MTV should be real proud of that POS program ranks in importance right up there with Dog, the Kardouchians, Swampmen and the rest of the cotton candy crap programming thats served up each week by the networks.
  • Andy 2012/06/09 18:19:34
    Rehab
    Andy
    Maybe she will get the help she needs in prison...sad, very sad.
  • Platinum Fangs 2012/06/09 18:06:36
    Prison
    Platinum Fangs
    +2
    It's cheaper than rehab.
  • the judgebigdogeagle 2012/06/09 18:01:58
    Rehab
    the judgebigdogeagle
    Prison is not a playground. it is a serious place.Never been Never want too
  • hello kitty 2012/06/09 17:58:17
    Rehab
    hello kitty
    it helps you, prison doesn't.
  • waternymphxD 2012/06/09 17:55:22
    Prison
    waternymphxD
    +3
    Rehab scares me more than prison for some reason... I guess it's the thought of being with people who are in the same way screwed up as you are
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/06/09 17:24:36
    Rehab
    Medulla Oblongata
    +1
    I could survive rehab. I don't think I could survive prison.
  • Papillon 2012/06/09 17:20:56
    Prison
    Papillon
    +1
    She can rehab in prison. Probably better that way; there won't be any eyes on her and she won't have to worry about the bills for perhaps 28 months. That is what most residential rehabs favor. Not 10 days like pax with his new age crap.

    She won't be influenced by people places or things. If no residential treatment is available to her, then prison is the best place for her. Residential rehab is probably much harder than prison rehabs will ever be, and that is the best place for her.

    Failing that, prison will work wonders for her if she uses the tools.
  • Lakota ... Papillon 2012/06/09 20:53:13 (edited)
    Lakota Deviant
    People aren't "influenced by people" in prison? I have little belief that prison systems actually reforms people but is rather a punishment. I doubt this person wants to use the tools or can. She obviously didn't want to use the tools in the rehab program which was too difficult for her.
  • Papillon Lakota ... 2012/06/09 21:17:03
    Papillon
    Mm hmm.
  • Greenbay 2012/06/09 17:18:35
    Rehab
    Greenbay
    It's way nicer what an idiot
  • Papillon Greenbay 2012/06/09 17:22:47
    Papillon
    +1
    A mile in her shoes...
  • DICELISHOUS 2012/06/09 17:16:51
    Rehab
    DICELISHOUS
    Im not trying to go prison .....i wouldnt survive.!!
  • Papillon DICELIS... 2012/06/09 17:23:38
    Papillon
    You never know how much strength you have until pressed to use it. It's just a bunch of rooms, after all.
  • darlenedoskas1969 2012/06/09 17:02:36
    Rehab
    darlenedoskas1969
    ...but then, I am a woman grown, with much life experience, and have totally gotten over the idea that I am "ten feet tall and bullet proof", and know everything I need to know...

    the average teenager hasn't... hells, lots of them won't ever grow out of it
  • Bearish 2012/06/09 16:58:17 (edited)
    Prison
    Bearish
  • Greenbay Bearish 2012/06/09 17:19:30
  • Papillon Bearish 2012/06/09 17:25:28
    Papillon
    Residential rehab is harder than marine corps' basic training. Takes more balls than most people have.
  • Bearish Papillon 2012/06/10 14:24:53
  • Papillon Bearish 2012/06/10 15:40:37
    Papillon
    And this concerns me how? If you didn't like it the first time, why'd you go back? Shat? What the hell is that?
  • Bearish Papillon 2012/06/10 20:01:07
    Bearish
    "Residential rehab is harder than marine corps' basic training"
    Bwahahahahaha
  • Papillon Bearish 2012/06/10 22:35:52
    Papillon
    Ever do it old school? Daytop village in the old days? You wouldn't laugh.
  • Pops 2012/06/09 16:56:07
    Rehab
    Pops
    I think rehab is a smidgen better. But not if she can get the anti-psych mads she needs in prison.
  • Kuruptsoul 2012/06/09 16:47:31
    Rehab
    Kuruptsoul
    It really depends on how long they want to keep her stuck in the system. I'm sure they will cut her sentence down... They just said 5 years to scare her.
  • Papillon Kuruptsoul 2012/06/09 17:28:47
    Papillon
    No. The sentence has built in good time. If one keeps his nose clean, 1/3 to 1/2 is automatically shaved. They don't give out 5 years to scare someone. They mean it. It's up to the convict to get the sentence reduced.
  • frank 2012/06/09 16:11:32
    Rehab
    frank
    +1
    I'll take Rehab any day of the week to Prison.
  • hollowpointxkilljoy 2012/06/09 16:07:13
    Rehab
    hollowpointxkilljoy
    +3
    Prison isn't just a free ride and that's what she thinks she's going to get. It is a lot harder than she probably even dreams. My cousin was in prison 7 years and what people don't realize is that when you're stuck in prison, life outside goes on. People grow and change and society progresses without you. And when you get out you realize that things will never be the same as they were before. You'll be entering a whole new world and basically trying to start your life over again. Relationships will be affected by it, and what does she think about how her daughter feels right now? I don't think she cares.
  • Papillon hollowp... 2012/06/09 17:30:29
    Papillon
    +1
    She can't care. She has to concentrate on herself before putting her energy into kids. Thank God for grandma.
  • J. Gomez 2012/06/09 16:04:46
    Prison
    J. Gomez
    +1
    You can probably serve less time in prison than in rehab plus you can still do drugs in prison if you choose.
  • Papillon J. Gomez 2012/06/09 17:31:10
    Papillon
    What a genius.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/19 22:25:47

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals