'Skinny' Website Calls Kate Upton Fat: So True or So Wrong?

PHAT. Pretty hot and tempting.

She's PHAT

These "Skinny Gossip" girls are seriously jealous. They feel so insecure with themselves that they starve themselves stupid trying to be happy with their body that they can't be happy with a woman who is beautiful, curvy, REAL, healthy, and happy with herself. I tried the starving/purging route at one point, but it made me feel worse about myself. Kate has REAL boobs, REAL hips, and REAL beauty. Obviously she isn't "too fat" or Sports Illustrated wouldn't have had her on the cover. Duh.

She looks natural I think they forgot what natural beauty looks like, no phony breasts she definatley has natural breasts.

She looks normal, if she's fat were screwed. Whoever wrote that is sick. Bunch of jealous hags?

She is so gorgeous! How could anyone say she is fat? SO confused by the picture of beauty now a-days.

She's fat. I'm real fat.

how is that fat seriously? if thats fat then i must be obese! you people are stupid (who voted she was fat)

That is such a pathetic publicity stunt on Skinny Gossip's part.

Publicity stunts are always awkward. They got what they wanted, but they won't know how to handle it.

wowww.

How could 70 people have answered "So True?"

REALLY?


No Thanks...I'll take Kate!

Comparing scarecrows to a girl? Too true. She looks healthy.

Kate has a cute butt.

Sorry but that's a bit biased. Kate is in a photoshoot with Photoshop, perfect lights, a good pose and in a professional photoshoot. Those other girls:
Girl #1 has too much Photoshop:

Girl #2 is Snejana Onopka on the runway, a bad pose, no Photoshop, bad lights and unprofessional photoshoot. She's happily married now.

Girl #3 is Magdalena Frackowiak with, again, on the runway, a bad pose, no Photoshop, bad lights and unprofessional photoshoot. She's a gorgeous, unique beauty.

I think comparisons are good ideas to prove your point, but you should really be less biased and more fair and balanced when comparing pictures. If you are comparing women with Kate Upton, you should have used good pictures of those women or an un-pro picture of Upton.

On the other hand, you claim to work for Skinny, so YOU are fairly biased yourself. True?

Kate is not fat. That was the point. Skinny girls are too skinny. Sorry. You won't be able to change my mind. You find excuses, but no flaws...that's bias.

Snejana Onopka (Is too thin, like I said):



Magdalena Frackowiak (Is too thin, like I said):



Kate Upton (This girl is NOT fat):

http://www.infdaily.com/wp-co...

I'm not biased, I just pointed out that if you want to compare, put good photos of ALL OF THEM. And by the way, Kate is not fat. Just needs to tone some more. She has nice calves and a pretty face. Is she fat for a model? Yes. Is she too generic and commercial for a runway model? Yes. But for a person, she's ok.

Where are her boobs?

I assume you mean on the two skinny girls...

You have to click on the link to find Kate Upton...and you have no problem finding hers.

Hello! Uh...no! She's hot!

This is a healthy woman without extra fat, but she does have breasts and hips. Gee! Women are supposed to have breasts and hips. Skinny Girl bitches that people tell her to her face that she's too skinny? Maybe she IS, but the reality is that larger women take much more crap for their weight, even when it's in the normal range, that poor little skinny, who says she's not anorexic, but posts a 'starving tip of the day.' Is THIS what Skinny thinks is beautiful? What crap! (edited to add picture)

Reminds me of a praying mantis with the big head and stick figure.

The truth is that being ultra thin can also be a health risk.

Can be worse than being fat.

Yes, it can, and just as life threatening when taken to extremes.

To me this girl is way slim. She may be the right weight but too many bones.

I don't think she's in normal weight range for anyone but those in the fashion industry. She is, IMHO, unhealthily thin. I'd bet, given that she has very little body fat, that she doesn't even have regular menstrual cycles, as without bodyfat, the body doesn't produce adequate amounts of estrogen and other hormones.

Her name's not crap. You know her name? Who she is? No? Then you have no right to judge.
That's Polish model Magdalena Frackowiak on the runway, with no Photoshop, a bad pose that makes her look skinnier than she really is and bad light. This is her in a real photoshoot, with probably as much Photoshop as Upton:

Boy are you reading a lot into the whole point. I did NOT say that the woman's name was crap. I said that the standard of beauty that says that a woman of normal weight is too fat and that a woman who is underweight is the standard is CRAP. It IS crap. If you look at the legs of your model, she's super skinny. I'll bet you a bunch that the one in the bra is being enhanced not with photoshop, but with falsies to give her more in the breast department than she really has.

The point is that a person who writes under the name of Skinny Girl disses anyone who has normal breasts and hips as trash, says she doesn't promote anorexia, but publishes a starving tip of the day (which sounds like promoting anorexia to me), and seems to think that normal breasts and hips are something to fear. THAT IS CRAP.

If you fear normal weight as well as taking offense and reading something into a post which wasn't there, you need to look at your own attitude as well.

1) I didn't say you stated the girl's name was crap. You understand sarcasm? Or are you Sheldon Cooper?
2) Skinny Gurl is not saying that skinny is standard. She is saying that for her and our community, skinny is what's ok. Not for others, FOR US.
3) Magdalena IS one of the skinniest models (size 2), but I don't think she looks unhealthy. It IS possible to be THAT skinny without sacrificing health, especially if your body is built like that (small frame). But the picture you posted makes her look skinnier than she really is. And of course the breasts are Photoshopped, just like Upton's in many editorial shoots.
4) "Starving Tips" is a hyperbole. Her usual "Tips" are on how to stop binging (drink tea after a meal, don't restrict for too long, etc), how to stop wanting junk food (thinking about all the fat and calories and the little to no nutrients), how to encourage yourself to keep exercising (treating yourself afterwards with stuff you like), etc, etc.
5) We don't fear normal weight. I myself am normal weight! Many girls there are overweight (even obese) hoping to become thin. I just want to be thin, not average. Why? Because I think it looks good. Because I don't want to be like any other person. Because we all know that at size 14, average isn't what it used to be years ago.

direct quote from you: "Her name's not crap."

Skinny Gurl's comments are totally out of line. I don't care what you want. It's your choice, but her comments about a good looking woman who is not fat and not trashy because she has curves are TOTAL CRAP. And, so are you, if you think women who have breasts and hips look like whores out for a cheap f.

Here's what Skinny Gurl said, I take extreme exception to it. Oh, and by the way, I've heard far more dissing of fat women than I've ever heard of skinny, too.


"Is this what American women are 'striving' for now? The lazy, lardy look? Have we really gotten so fat in this country that Kate is the best we can aim for? Sorry, but: eww! Fashion is supposed to be aspirational—and the kind of people who aspire to look like this shop for clothes at Wal-Mart. She looks like she would work in the back of a motorcycle shop in Nashville and give [a sexual favor] for $25."

If you think this is ok, fine. It's rude and as unhealthy as the health this stupid woman thinks are ok to post as starving tips. You don't need to respond. I'm through with you.

"If you think this is ok, fine."
Thank you ;-) Finally someone open-minded that respects another opinion

Only a fagot would think so. These queers wish they looked like Lady GayGuy, who virtually NO ONE thinks is remotely attractive unless they themselves look like a Cuss Bono clone. they hate on an incredibly sexy women like Kate.

She isn't slender and curvy like most hot models but proportionate to her body. I wouldn't call her fat and I wouldn't call her skinny she's right in the middle.

Lol. Catty bitches.

Let me tell you all about how Kate is too fat.... as soon as I finish masturbating to her photo.

Oh hell no! That is a woman I'd take to my bed. :D She is gorgeous!!!

They are perfect examples of jealous and highly insecure little girls.

"big floppy boobs" Yeah well, at least she has boobs and doesn't have a figure of a bony prepubecent little boy. :)

That's retarded.

the skinny girl site promotes bulimia and anorexia. Its the perfect example of body stereotyping that tells women of all ages and sizes that their idea of what is perfect is what goes. I don't think any body type is perfect per se. It's the confidence that anyone has in their own skin that makes someone attractive.