'Skinny' Website Calls Kate Upton Fat: So True or So Wrong?

No... she is perfect... not skinny... not fat...

Too bad I am an ugly old fart - - or I would chase that! .. haha!

Shes not fat nor is she super skinny. Shes beautiful and who ever wrote that shes "lardy" is probably jealous because shes ugly inside and out.

She is a super hot woman, and would charge alot more than $25, if u know what I mean ;)

Shes sexy. She's not a twig but she's far from fat. She's perfect.

I agree with you. She isn't fat. She is sexy and perfect! Everyone else who thinks other was is just jealous.

White I completely disagree that she is fat, I must say she's rather... brick-shaped. A lot of women are sticking up for her saying she's "just curvy".... I'm sorry but no, being average weight does not guarantee curves. She's got a fairly large bust but barely any difference between her waist and hip - not very feminine.
Please note that I am not trying to insult her body or imply that I or anyone else has a superior body, I just feel that she is rather shapeless - I do agree that she has pretty much no defined waist.

And I don't necessarily think that this is "so true", I had meant to put "so wrong"...

looking at your picture I understand your comment... YOU have NO figure at all, being jealolus is even more unattractaive then looking like a 12 yr old boy

I don't think that she's jealous, she was just stating her opinion, she even said that she wasn't trying to insult Kate's body. You don't have to be rude and insult her.

not a insult just stating the truth( she changed her pic)

why can ppl call a sexy curvy woman fat, & mean things but I cant state that she looks like a 12 yr old boy?? she changed her pic from before showing a full pic that she had no boobs , no hips & Looked like a boy.... ( I know its only ok to say something mean when you say it to a larger person BUT cant say anything to skinny ppl ) ...... Go have a hamburger maybe you will not be so angry...

But she wasn't saying that Kate was fat, she just said that her waist and her hips were almost at the same level. She was just saying her opinion. I dont think it was very kind of you to try to insult her looks. Of course she would change her picture after what you said. I would too. Also it is NEVER ok to say something mean to anyone, regardless of they are large or thin.

Is your reading comprehension so low that you can't figure out she wasn't insulting Kate? And judging from her pic she obviously has a very nice and fit body. I would be willing to bet anything that you are a fat pig who is jealous, miserable and could never pull off wearing a two piece bathing suit without scaring little kids . Now quit eating so much and get off the couch for a change. You're probably one of those people who drives around the parking lot for 10 minutes looking for a really close parking spot so you don't have to walk too far.

LOL sweety Iam a very sexy woman... & I bet I could bet your a** I am at the gym 4 to 5x a week for 90 mins at a time... While some my call me " fat" Iam 5'10 180 lbs 36dd 32 in waist & wear btwn a size 10-12 & Iam over 40 & My husband LOVES the way I look ( I still get carded ) I walk in a room & own it beacuse I never let little tiny Bit**s get to me.. & men LOVE the way I look I dont wear a 2 piece bcz thats scanky.. NO need to show off ... If you have it show it with class & confidence & BTW the average size of american woman is size 14. & I live in the jersey shore area & walk to the beach 8 blks to then back about 3 or 4 x s a week ...

OK I must admit that does sound pretty hot, I actually like that tall, thick Amazon look. My girl's about 5.9 and similar in size. There is nothing wrong with a 2 piece as long as it fits well though. But description sounds too good to be true, pics or it didn't happen lol

She isnt fat. Fat is when someone gets on a scale and it reads "one at a time please"

lolol..

HAHAHAHAHA!!

We are hearing from a group that promotes a serious disease, trying to justify it and make it "normal", right? She posts "Starving Tip Of The Day" Note the word "starving", translated into "anorexia". Being proud you are who you are, if you are naturally thin is one thing. To promote starving to b e thin is a sickness. So why would anyone even listen to this stuff, let alone make "news" from it? Has anyone seen what anorexia and bulimia can do to someone? They are called eating DISORDERS! Do a web search! It is horrendous! These are diseases based on a mental illness where people imagine being bone thin, literally, is still not thin enough! It destroys their health! Self image issues that KILL many due to this type of thinking and disease. This started when media pushed thinner and thinner women as beautiful, such as the model "Twiggy" years back, and people claimed Marilyn Monroe as fat! Now many of our women are dying due to this crazy thinking. She talks about people saying thin people are ostracized? Yet, look what she is doing!! Two wrongs do not make a right! Anorexics are not naturally thin! So, again, why do we care what these people say, when they are in denial of their own disease and health issues??

Anorexia is a mental illness. Choosing to eat less or burn more calories than you take in isn't anorexia. Get a life.

the one on the left looks like a " woman" the one on the right looks like a young teenage girl... I guess it depends on your pref. If you like a woman or little girl

The one on the right looks like she got too excited at McDonald's, gross.

Then they should call it "Nutritional tip of the day" instead of "Starving tip of the day"

she is perfect... The disgusting anorexic low lives who think that she is fat can all crash and burn or (crack your tailbone and break a leg) lol .

I don't know her but I would kill to have a body like hers. Thanks to this article I now know someone I could hypothetically kill.

I hate women that have rib bones showing through. She is just about right.

But some people are naturally really thin

Real men want REAL women!

All women are real, regardless of size.
If she has a vagina, she's a real woman.

I date girls with this type body over super skinny girls. Skinny girls r to boney nd bruse me. Haha. I've dated every kind of girl out there. Love the average ones best.

She looks great to me.

I'm not familiar with Kate, but her picture shown here looks good.:) far from fat...natural breast are definately the way to go, they look fabulous..

Um just look at her she is a straight stick! This website is just messed up

Yes, in all the right places.

If this is fat then I love fat women. Give me a women to have something to hold onto.

So totally hot..

great looking body

I'm currently looking for someone so out of condition as Kate have been all my life.

She's beautiful