Quantcast

Should 'Teen Mom' Go to Prison for Hitting Her Child's Father?

SodaHead TV 2010/12/28 18:00:00
Related Topics: Reality Show, TMZ, Mtv, Action
You!
Add Photos & Videos
A star of MTV's "Teen Mom" could get up to three years in prison for allegedly beating her baby's father on three occasions in front of the child.

TMZ reports that Amber Portwood, 20, punched and slapped Gary Shirley, 24, at least three times between August 2009 and July 2010, some of which was caught on tape and aired on the MTV reality show.

In the video footage, Portwood is shown hitting and insulting Shirley in the presence of their daughter, while he asks her to stop. She continues to hit him until he leaves.

According to TMZ, if Portwood is found guilty of all charges she could be faced with three years in prison and a $10,000 fine.

Officials said told TMZ that an investigation was not launched until footage of the attacks aired on "Teen Mom."

Should the actions depicted in this video put Portwood behind bars?

Read More: http://www.tmz.com/2010/11/19/teen-mom-amber-portw...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • sailor jimbo 2011/01/17 21:38:58
    sailor
    thanks for the laughs. the conversation that was happening was funny from where I am sitting. cheers
  • jimbo **ǝpɐןq... 2010/12/29 14:31:15
  • Arrogant jimbo 2011/01/15 00:00:23
    Arrogant
    +1
    feces...lol. You dont have very many opportunities to use that one. lol
  • sailor Arrogant 2011/01/17 21:16:56
    sailor
    lol ..... sorry i was eavesdropping, forgive me. but the conversation as I was reading it was so funny.
  • sailor jimbo 2011/01/17 21:14:08
    sailor
    lol
  • Robbb 2010/12/29 14:06:24
    No
    Robbb
    There is not much point in locking up every low class bit of garbage in the country There does not seem to that much harm done and I doubt if the tax payer is all that interested in sending her to boarding school. I mean If I were him I would just avoid her if she didn't change her tune. My wife of 40 years now tried this on on me not long after we were married. I just hit her back once, good. that put the motivation out of her to do it again. I cant really see the point in putting her in goal for 3 years.
  • FantasyAuthor 2010/12/29 14:04:51
    Undecided
    FantasyAuthor
    Normally it is the guys who are mean to the ladies but since it is the lady being mean to the guy I would say that he mostlikely decieved getting hit for something he did or didn't do for the mother or her child.
  • Invader... Fantasy... 2010/12/29 15:37:26
    InvaderXion420
    Sooo by your logic, because some men do things, they all do right? So, just because he is a man he deserves to be beaten? You sicken me, for real.
  • Fantasy... Invader... 2010/12/30 00:07:30
    FantasyAuthor
    Normally a guy is the one who hurts the women but since it is the women hurting the guy than the guy mostlikely have done something wrong.
  • Arrogant Fantasy... 2011/01/15 00:03:58 (edited)
    Arrogant
    Wow...just wow. Id request a refund from your college tuition. You're wasting your money, and they are wasting their time. Can't teach someone how to not be stupid.
  • Fantasy... Arrogant 2011/01/15 12:39:29
    FantasyAuthor
    I didn't learn this from the college that I am going to. This is just my opinion and my opinion only.
  • Arrogant Fantasy... 2011/01/20 09:21:39
    Arrogant
    I realize that. Im still at a loss for words. Your opinion is astoundingly ridiculous. Thats my opinion only...Good day.
  • Fantasy... Arrogant 2011/01/20 14:15:00
    FantasyAuthor
    Ok. Good day to you as well. Does it help if I say that I am sorry for misusing a wrong word? I meant to say I didn't I am not stupid and that I am never going to be stupid(I don't know what was wrong with me the day and time that I had written that)
  • Hawkeye Fantasy... 2010/12/29 19:00:00
    Hawkeye
    "Normally it is the guys who are mean to the ladies "

    THIS is no longer accepted as true.. There has been reason to believe that this sort of thing happens far more with the female being the guilty party then was previously believed.. It has NOW taken on a contemtious lead for being the "LEAST reported Crime"..
  • Fantasy... Hawkeye 2010/12/30 00:09:12
    FantasyAuthor
    +1
    The only time that I have seen a women hurting a men was when I had watched the Chicago movie. Other than that one time, I have never seen/heard of a women hurting a men. I normally is the guy who hurts the women.
  • Kat Fantasy... 2011/01/03 16:24:11
    Kat
    There's a really good reason you don't hear about women abusing men very much - Pride & Embarrassment. Admitting that a woman thumped them isn't usually something men share.
    On the other hand, women share more easily, with friends in group & with family. Historically, there has been more support for abused women than men. With women, they're seen as a victim worthy of sympathy. With men, they're simply seen as weak, by both sexes.
  • Fantasy... Kat 2011/01/04 00:54:01
    FantasyAuthor
    True.
  • sailor Fantasy... 2011/01/17 21:21:12
    sailor
    not true! there are many cases of women being the abuser. wow! I can't believe that you are not / were not aware of that. ABUSE IS AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY CRIME THAT AFFECTS MEN / WOMEN / CHILDREN / GRANDPARENTS etc.. ALL CAN BE THE ABUSED, OR THE ABUSER.
  • Fantasy... sailor 2011/01/17 23:56:11
  • sailor Fantasy... 2011/01/18 01:25:06 (edited)
    sailor
    : ) didn't mean to come off as being to hard. very sensitive subject. very emotional issue.
  • Fantasy... sailor 2011/01/18 01:41:43
    FantasyAuthor
    +1
    That is fine.
  • sailor Fantasy... 2011/01/18 02:25:51
    sailor
    = )
  • Fantasy... sailor 2011/01/18 02:33:33
    FantasyAuthor
    +1
    I feel that anything that you want to ask can be asked here on Sodahead.
  • sailor Fantasy... 2011/01/18 02:38:58
    sailor
    yup
  • Fantasy... sailor 2011/01/18 02:41:31
    FantasyAuthor
    +1
    That is why you can see that I have asked more questions than I do answer!
  • Arrogant Fantasy... 2011/01/20 09:22:23
    Arrogant
    Have you bothered to look outside of the movie "Chicago"? lololol
  • Fantasy... Arrogant 2011/01/20 14:15:46
    FantasyAuthor
    No I haven't. Any suggestions?
  • vamp-gal Fantasy... 2011/01/16 20:37:01 (edited)
    vamp-gal
    I've heard of a woman who was beating a man, for no reason whatsoever, and do you know what happened?
    The guy phoned the police and they started laughing at him!

    Another time, a woman hits a guy and all the woman said was "he was beating me" and he was the one who got locked up!

    I, obviously, don't know these people, but they are real cases, where this has actually happened to people.

    This is the world we live in, and it's sickening x
  • Fantasy... vamp-gal 2011/01/17 02:14:06
    FantasyAuthor
    I am sorry that these stories had happened(for real).
  • Hawkeye 2010/12/29 13:50:35
    Yes
    Hawkeye
    +1
    ABSOLUTELY!!

    Unless,, as in the case so many times where the woman sexually molest a teen aged boy,, she is simply,, "Too GOOD looking to go to jail."...
  • Rico (oYo) 2010/12/29 12:55:39
    Yes
    Rico (oYo)
    +2
    Equal Opprotunity.

    If HE had hit HER there'd be noone even asking this question.
  • Dixienc 2010/12/29 12:54:09
    Undecided
    Dixienc
    I would think that some serious counselling would be the first step here. Some of the responses I see on this post are disturbing to say the least. Having been a counselor in a Domestic Violence Shelter I can't begin to tell you of the cases of men being abused as much as some women and never reporting it so the woman could get the help she needed because of attitudes like this. "he's a wuss", "what a pansy", that kind of thing. Men will NOT report abuse because many cops would treat them like this. In a hell of a lot of cases the men either ended up DEAD or severly beaten. Most men, now I did say MOST, are conditioned from birth that boys do not hit girls. To hit back even in self defense goes against everything they've been taught while growing up. Most simply choose to just walk away from the whole situation which in effect means they walk away from their children also. When they're gone the woman's anger is directed elsewhere.....usually towards the children. Just because a man doesn't strike back does NOT mean he's a wuss or a pansy. Spousal abuse should be reported and dealt with equally! But because of the types of attitudes displayed here it's often not and then it escalates into something much worse. We dealt with a case of a woman tying her husband up while he slept ...
    I would think that some serious counselling would be the first step here. Some of the responses I see on this post are disturbing to say the least. Having been a counselor in a Domestic Violence Shelter I can't begin to tell you of the cases of men being abused as much as some women and never reporting it so the woman could get the help she needed because of attitudes like this. "he's a wuss", "what a pansy", that kind of thing. Men will NOT report abuse because many cops would treat them like this. In a hell of a lot of cases the men either ended up DEAD or severly beaten. Most men, now I did say MOST, are conditioned from birth that boys do not hit girls. To hit back even in self defense goes against everything they've been taught while growing up. Most simply choose to just walk away from the whole situation which in effect means they walk away from their children also. When they're gone the woman's anger is directed elsewhere.....usually towards the children. Just because a man doesn't strike back does NOT mean he's a wuss or a pansy. Spousal abuse should be reported and dealt with equally! But because of the types of attitudes displayed here it's often not and then it escalates into something much worse. We dealt with a case of a woman tying her husband up while he slept and beating him almost to death with whatever she could get her hands on. Took him years to come back from the beating. He had TRIED to get the law to do something but of course there were those "attitudes" against his "manhood". He stayed to protect his kids. He almost died to protect those kids. Thankfully the courts finally woke up and believed what he had been trying to tell them and took the kids and put her somewhere she could get the help she needed.
    (more)
  • apachehellfire65 2010/12/29 12:31:22
    No
    apachehellfire65
    prisons a bit extream.
  • mrdog 2010/12/29 12:04:42
    Yes
    mrdog
    +1
    1. What the court decides I support. 2. Age twenty is teen? 3. Spousal abuse is a No No for either spouse.

    Bark
  • Isma'ila (God has heard)! 2010/12/29 11:34:02
    Yes
    Isma'ila (God has heard)!
    +1
    Yes she should. There is no excuse for abuse.
  • QueenBridget 2010/12/29 11:02:56
    Yes
    QueenBridget
    +2
    Yes! If a man did that he would be in jail no question so why isnt it the same for her?
  • tatiana2608 2010/12/29 09:07:51
    Yes
    tatiana2608
    +1
    OMG that girl is psycho!!! that girl needs to go to some anger management classes...
  • Xx ☠Shadow's Darkness xX 2010/12/29 08:57:50
    No
    Xx ☠Shadow's Darkness xX
    she might have a reason.....
  • bleueyed Xx ☠Sha... 2010/12/29 10:26:11
    bleueyed
    +2
    There's no reason or excuse for hitting someone.
  • Xx ☠Sha... bleueyed 2010/12/29 10:27:03
    Xx ☠Shadow's Darkness xX
    so she hit him for no reason ??

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/24 03:16:57

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals