Should Miley Cyrus have posed topless for Vanity Fair?

by SodaHead Gossip Posted 2008/04/28 17:20:56

3,582 votes
Read all 3,473 opinions
Lightning Report View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artistic shot.	825 votes	23%
	No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.	1,550 votes	43%
	Here's what I think....	1,207 votes	34%

Miley Cyrus is speaking out about her 'near nude' shot in this months Vanity Fair. The photo, which was shot by the renowned Annie Leibovitz, shows the 15 year old Disney star topless with a satin sheet covering her chest. Through her publicist on Sunday, Miley attempted to explain herself. "I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be 'artistic' and now, seeing the photographs and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed. I never intended for any of this to happen and I apologize to my fans who I care so deeply about." Vanity Fair countered back with their own statement. "Miley's parents and/or minders were on the set all day. Since the photo was taken digitally, they saw it on the shoot and everyone thought it was a beautiful and natural portrait of Miley." So, do you think it was right of Miley to have done the photo?

+146

Add a comment above

tanga-reen 2008/04/28 21:35:10

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

+123
Can't believe she did this, she's only 15!
>> See Replies

More polls by SodaHead Gossip

jordynvduran 2011/08/05 16:19:30

Here's what I think....

I honestly do not think this is miley there is such thing as adobe photo shot i dont think miley would ever take those kind of shots

reply
jordynv... to jordynv... 2011/08/05 16:22:01

+1
And If you look at the pictures closely there is a white line around her head

reply
Lauren Hopkins 2011/07/18 15:59:37

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

She Shouldn't do it she Has Fan's as young as 6 or younger

reply
VerlinU.ChuckGilliam 2010/04/19 01:41:02

Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artis...

+2
Seeing anyone's naked back cannot be, and should not be construed as anything but a naked back. That is surely NO BIG DEAL. When very young girls are on the beach with 'G-strings' that is a big deal. I once saw a girl no older than 12 or maybe 13 with a very tight and very short short pair of shorts, and a very titty tight polo shirt that had an arrow pointing downward toward her vaginal area with the words saying, "Eat Me". Miley Cyrus is a saint in comparison to some of the things I've seen with younger girls.

reply
devilvirus007 2009/12/09 14:59:20

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

hello!

reply
starrrrrrrrrr 2009/11/26 00:01:32

Here's what I think....

+1
i think she is the b word and that she i a terrible artist and she is the future britney spear.x)
you know wat i mean

reply
Freeranger 2009/10/24 22:30:55

Here's what I think....

I think she's a young gold digger suffering from bad parenting and role models.....very reminiscent of a Lindsay Lohan type----today it's Disney, tomorrow Playboy.
A young iconic sitting on the downside shoulder of capitalism.

reply
andy 2009/10/01 23:39:38

Here's what I think....

+3
she is fit wen shes nacked

reply
wolfsan11 2009/09/22 04:47:37

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

+4
Its artistic and stuff...but a lot of girls look up to her and we never know what they'll do. I think her parents should have been more responsible. I mean what parent lets their 15 year old take a shot like this?

reply
partyoftwo 2009/09/09 06:48:01

Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artis...

+2
So tell me something. How many 8 and 9-year-olds read Vanity Fair? How would any of our children ahd known about this If people hadn't made such a big deal about this?

reply
simone 2009/08/29 20:10:42

Here's what I think....

+2
leave the poor girl alone!! we all make mistakes come on guys are all of your lives perfect?? its because of all of you that so many of these young celeb girls go down. you and ur criticism. you dont know anything so just shut up and focus on getting your own lives sin free. this is none of ur business

reply
donnafaithh 2009/08/25 11:28:05 (edited)

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

Well, whats done is done and all we can do now is say... "ALL ABOARD THE SKANK TRAIN!"

reply
partyoftwo to donnafa... 2009/09/09 06:20:35

+2
and u would be the first on board pervert

reply
donnafa... to partyoftwo 2009/09/09 07:46:32

Not really you immature creatin. I happen to like guys, what about you?

reply
the right to donnafa... 2009/12/23 15:19:19

+2
i think its ok for her to ake those pics but its not ok to let her fan know

reply
donnafa... to the right 2009/12/23 23:06:01

Well, since it was for a published work and she knew that before she even took the job, I think it is safe to say that she doesn't give a flying fuck about her fan's thoughts.

reply
Erika 2009/08/18 15:42:03 (edited)

Here's what I think....

+3
I think that the way she is acting, she should just rip her cloathes off on stage! I mean for heavens sake, her young fans ARE going to find out! Keep your cloathes on! And her parents could step in a little too!

reply
partyoftwo to Erika 2009/09/09 06:20:12

+3
learn to spell moron

reply
partyoftwo to Erika 2009/09/09 06:21:02

+1
and her parents were there with her when she got the pictures done

reply
wolfsan11 to partyoftwo 2009/09/22 04:40:10

Well that sure highlights their responsibility doesn't it? NOT.

reply
vanessa 2009/08/17 21:04:40

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

+2
guys she is a normal teen i mean ppl think she bad cause she wearing a binkin like wth what bad about that like u dont have a biniki or saw one like u should get a life and she taking those pics cause she thinks she sexy or something like leave her alone and btw im not a fan and im 12 years old so get a stupid life!!!!!

reply
stephanie 2009/08/14 21:20:08

Yes. Miley Cyrus looks beautiful. She's not naked. It's a beautiful and artis...

+2
she aint doin nothin rong she is a beautifull little girl i would do the same thin at least she aint showing any thing else if you know wat i mean!!!! :-)

reply
Todd 2009/07/19 16:42:09

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

+4
if 1 of her young fans sees this im so gonna kill Miley

reply
partyoftwo to Todd 2009/09/09 06:21:40

+3
well that doesnt sound like a serial killer at all now does it

reply
john 2009/04/26 04:08:34

Here's what I think....

+1
wow what a whore she is 15 teen whats next at the age of 16 she is going to be fully nude if my daughter did that at age 15 i would be so pissed and i would kill the guy that took the photo

reply
partyoftwo to john 2009/09/09 06:22:25

funny thing is you were probably having sex at 15. does that make you a whore?

reply
katie davis 2009/04/18 22:40:56

Here's what I think....

+1
miley was retarted to do thet get a brain miley

reply
steve 2009/03/01 14:27:51

Here's what I think....

+1
it was great

reply
max 2008/12/31 08:17:07

Here's what I think....

who?

reply
AmandaJune 2008/12/31 08:07:09

Here's what I think....

+1
Miley is a teenage girl. We teenage girls take slutty pics and send them to our boyfriends. its really no big deal. But, because she is in the spot light and a role model of so many young children, she should have been more cautious.

reply
angel 2008/12/01 17:49:04

No. Miley Cyrus is setting a terrible example for all of her young fans.

+1
no my sister will turn in to her

reply
partyoftwo to angel 2009/09/09 06:22:56

+1
not if you little sister has a mind and can think for herself

reply
Leopluradon [Not-So... 2008/09/29 11:21:43

Here's what I think....

+2
She can pose while she's slitting her wrists! That's probably what she'll stoop to next. From Slutty to Slitty in less than...How long it takes for her to finally off herself :)

reply
partyoftwo to Leoplur... 2009/09/09 06:24:04

yea? how many years have you been trying now? takes an emo kid to call others out

reply
Leoplur... to partyoftwo 2009/09/22 01:26:30

+1
< sarcasm > Oh wow, that really hurt me! I'm gonna go kill myself now. Whaa whaa whaa. Go cry to your idol when she's turning your little girl into a whore at the age of 11 < /sarcasm >

reply
dana.taylor.! 2008/09/27 16:37:32

Here's what I think....

+4
Slut.

reply
Blank 2008/09/03 20:31:01

Here's what I think....

+1
Really she shouldn't have done that!!!Now I hate her.My mom thinks cuz she dated Nick Jonas . . . And that is absolutly not true.Or is it . . . ?JK but she did this now i totaly hate her.

reply
partyoftwo to Blank 2009/09/09 06:25:17

o boo-hoo if one person for every mistake you made hated you, you'd be waaaaayyy in the negatives

reply
Blank to partyoftwo 2009/09/17 00:02:30

i posted this lik 2 years ago and u finally reply on this. i rlly dont care anymore bout her

reply
Steve 2008/09/02 16:54:43