Blogs Lauren Fritsky's

Should kids ever be allowed in rated R movies?

Today on TheFrisky.com, writer Jessica Wakeman talks about her appall over going to see the movie Precious in a theater in New Jersey and finding herself seated next to a toddler and his mom.

The tot wasn't the only kid in the theater, she says. Pre-school aged children and even babies could be heard throughout the seats. Wakeman's main problem is with the fact the these parents thought it was OK to bring their children to a film whose subject matter is supposedly pretty rough--Precious deals with incest and physical and verbal abuse:

Really, people? You (couples, single parents, whoever these people were) just had to see this movie so badly that you brought someone in diapers along with you? Even if references to incest would go over little kids’ heads, there’s so much physical violence and verbal abuse in “Precious.” Do some parents really think their small children just don’t notice it, or aren’t going to be affected by it? When Amelia saw “Precious,” she said there were a handful of elementary schoolers in the theater—7-to-10-year olds! They actually are old enough to grasp what’s going on in the film, but definitely not mature enough to process it. How do you explain incest and rape to a 3rd grader?

Wakeman goes on to suggest that movie theaters ban children from moves rated R (some apparently already do, but don't enforce it, according to someone who commented on the article). If that can't be done, parents should have enough sense to leave their kids with a sitter or wait till the movie comes out on DVD.

Have you ever taken your child to a rated R movie? Do you think there should be restrictions against it?

Read more: http://www.thefrisky.com/post/246-frisky-rant-plea...

You!
Add Photos & Videos
Top Comment
  • +5 NoNmr November 28, 2009 05:14:17 (edited)
    NoNmr
    No. What's the point of the movie rating system if it won't be followed? =)



    movie rating
    View thread
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • +3
    megan January 21, 2010 14:15:27
    megan
    no i think that the kids can watch r rated films because it cant teach them anything that the outside world would
  • Naui December 02, 2009 07:13:05
    Naui
    Most R rated movies are full of violence, abuse and foul language. That is why they are rated R. And constructed in such a way that they can be played on broadcast TV with the words cut and the gore censored but not lose the plot. That shows that the movie can be made without the violence or gore or swearing. It's all about the shock value. Some directors drop in an "F word" or two just to get the R and to them that means more sales than PG or PG-13. I think the Saw movies should be NC-17 because they are horror porn. But NC-17 is only for movies that have sexual situations and maybe female full frontal nudity and simulated sex under the covers. And aren't made at all because no theater would play them. The clause in the R rating is there to delude parents to think they can bring the kiddies in if they talk about the disturbing parts later. That said I found Ol' Yeller the most disturbing movie I have seen in the last 20 years. That and "A Very Long Engagement" (Which was rated R for realistic depictions of war conditions and that scene on the table with Jodie Foster)

    No, I have not taken my kids to see an R rated movie, unless I had seen it first. They know about movie makeup and special effects and so blood and guts are not so shocking to them. But we tend to stay away from those movies anyway.
  • Ay[me!] December 02, 2009 01:35:46
    Ay[me!]
    I think that they should be allowed to if the parents are ok with it. After all, they would have to buy your tickets. I've seen a lot of R-rated movies, and I'm only 14, but I think I'm ok. But it would matter on your maturity and what the movies are rated R for.
  • taravati December 01, 2009 17:44:56
    taravati
    I pondered this question for a while...
    Should you be able to take a minor to see a movie at a public movie theatre that is rated above their age range? I say no, that would be a simple rule that people should not be able to argue legally.
    Other than that, it is up to the parents or guardians of a child to make the decision as to what their child should be exposed to and at what age. I do not always agree with the decisions that parents make in this regard, but it is still their right.
  • ♥Aphrodite Zoey Rose- In Ny... November 29, 2009 17:40:32
    ♥Aphrodite Zoey Rose- In Nyx I trust♥
    it is weird i mean i am 13 and i go see those movies because i know not to do anything that happens but pre schoolers shouldnt be allowed
  • antoniob27 ♥Aphrod... November 30, 2009 23:34:17
    antoniob27
    I agree totally
  • ♥Aphrod... antoniob27 December 02, 2009 01:31:04
    ♥Aphrodite Zoey Rose- In Nyx I trust♥
    ya
  • Deanna 12960 November 29, 2009 14:28:21
    Deanna 12960
    Absolutely NOT!!!!!!!!!! My daughter just turned 11 and in our house we don't watch any "r" rated anything. I myself don't care for blood, guts, and gore. Nor do care for all the violence in movies. This world is truly scary enough without watching on T.V. I think kids should be kids as long as possible. That's what's wrong everybody is in a big hurry to "grow-up" too fast. I'm not so sure that even if my daughter was 18 that we would see a "r" rated film. We watch comedy or family kinds of movies. Sometimes I think even pg13 is too much.
  • +1
    twistedtrucker November 29, 2009 13:19:20
    twistedtrucker
    Almost every comment that I've read is about the inconvenience of children being in a theatre. You people are either missing the point or awfully self centered. Children should be banned from "R" rated movies, not because of some distraction they might cause, but because its our job as parents and adults to raise our children with morales, and shield them from the sex and violence that is for some strange reason thought to be acceptable in our society.
    I personally would not allow my children to view anything stronger than "G" upto the age of 14, and "PG" untill they were old enough,and mature enough, to make their own choice.
  • Deanna ... twisted... November 29, 2009 14:30:16
    Deanna 12960
    Yes I so agree with what you said. Well spoken!!!!!!!! Can I have an AMEN? Kudos to you.
  • taravati twisted... December 01, 2009 17:47:55
    taravati
    You know, this reminds me, I saw Where the Red Fern Grows when I was about 5 or 6 and I still remember scenes from that movie. Old Yeller even has some pretty mature content and at the age I saw it for the first time it absolutely broke my heart. I can't imagine growing up now with the subjects that children are exposed to and expected to process. Parent's don't seem to really parent anymore...
  • freedom November 29, 2009 04:36:42
    freedom
    I really wish people would not bring preteens to a rated R movie. Parents are only punishing themselves for paying for ticket for a movie a kid will not understand. HOWEVER, I think a lot people misjudge the ages of some people's children. I know adults had a real hard time figuring out my age when I was a teen. Also, again, this depends on the movie and the kid.
  • Katherine November 29, 2009 04:19:33
    Katherine
    Kids should never be in R movies, regardless of age, out of respect to other moviegoers as much as in the child's best interests. Hell, the scene in UP! where the dogs chased the main character scared quite a few kids out of the theater, and that movie is rated PG!
  • Vaius November 29, 2009 04:16:24
    Vaius
    Depends on the maturity level of the child. Which usually means NO.
  • milesrose November 29, 2009 03:50:36
    milesrose
    I say let teens watch R-movies. At 11 or 12 they should be mature enough to see R rated action movies and such.
  • milesrose milesrose November 29, 2009 03:51:08
    milesrose
    and XXX should be 13 and up. Especcially with guys. They'll find a way to get it XD
  • Deanna ... milesrose November 29, 2009 14:32:56
    Deanna 12960
    milesrose do you have children? Isn't there enough violence in the world now, why add insult to injury?
  • milesrose Deanna ... November 29, 2009 18:58:19
    milesrose
    No, and I doubt I ever will. I'll never let small kids watch R movies though. 12 and up should be able to handle it.
  • Saunders (Philo is my daddy) November 29, 2009 01:20:54
    Saunders (Philo is my daddy)
    I think we can't tell parents how to raise their kids, but I saw The Hills Have Eyes in the theatre a few years ago, and a couple brought their 5 year old daughter with them. At the end of the movie when the guy stabs the American flag into the mutants forehead, the little girl stood up and yelled YAY America! It was funny and sad all at the same time! flag mutants forehead girl stood yelled yay america funny sad

  • TheReverend November 28, 2009 23:47:29
    TheReverend
    It's annoying to hear crying babies or have some brat kid behind you kicking the back of your seat, no one likes that. As far as the content they're exposed to..... well you can't hide them from the waiting world forever. I grew up watching R rated movies at a very young age. I was able to watch whatever I wanted and I turned out ok.
or
Cancel