Quantcast

Should Films With Smoking Be Rated R?

SodaHead News 2012/07/15 19:37:35
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Smoking cigarettes is not good for you. It is safe to say many people realize that whether they smoke or not. In states such as New York, it has become harder for people to smoke in public places due to various restrictions. And now, the authors of a study that will appear in the August issue of the journal Pediatrics want to extend restrictions against smoking to the world of cinema.

According to the study, children who watch famous actors smoke in films are significantly more likely to try cigarettes down the road. As such, the suggestion bounced around was that films with cigarette smoking should be rated R. (Currently most are PG-13.) The authors of the study predict that making this change would reduce the proportion of children under 17 who try cigarettes by 18%.

"The movie industry [should] treat smoking like it treats profanity and sex and violence," said the study’s lead author Dr. James D. Sargent, a cancer-prevention specialist and professor of pediatrics at Dartmouth Medical School. "If saying the 'F' word twice gets you an R rating, certainly something as important as smoking should get you an R rating."

Tobacco can lead to health problems, as can the other chemicals found in cigarettes. If you smoke, especially for a long time, you are at great risk for emphysema, lung cancer, among other terrible illnesses. That being said, smoking cigarettes and smoking in general, is a personal choice people make themselves. Millions of Americans choose not to smoke. Millions of others do smoke for reasons specific to them. Whether you think smoking is good or bad, people are still going to make their own personal choices on the matter and there's nothing that can change that--even film ratings.

What do you think SodaHeads? Should films with smoking be rated R?

Should Films With Smoking Be Rated R

Read More: http://www.cnn.com/2012/07/10/health/smoking-trigg...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • jrci1 2012/07/15 20:45:09
    No
    jrci1
    +12
    Im really getting tired of people telling me what to like and what not to like man let me decide for my self
    free speech

    free speech

    free speech

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • norma.j.wertz 2012/07/16 15:03:40
    No
    norma.j.wertz
    +2
    Liberty PLEASE look it up in the Dictionary REMIND yourself what it means. Especially if you answer Yes to these type of questions!
  • ★earthbound_misfit★ 2012/07/16 15:03:34
    No
    ★earthbound_misfit★
    +2
    You can't keep your kids from seeing smoking. You can tell them why it's bad for you, but you can't pretend it doesn't exist. I think smoking should earn a movie a PG rating rather than G, but R is going to far. PG means "parental guidance." I think that's all kids need when seeing someone smoke in a movie.
  • jacktown kid 2012/07/16 14:53:45
    No
    jacktown kid
    +2
    Forget that nonsense
  • Character 2012/07/16 14:46:19
    Yes
    Character
    +2
    In fact, most PG-13 movies should be rated R. I get so sick of renting a decent looking PG-13 movie and seeing a half-naked woman running around in lingerie involved it what is clearly a scene of hot intercourse. It ruins the entire experience of what is otherwise a great movie.

    Smoking doesn't bother me as much, but I know for a fact that it influences children to see movie stars smoking on-screen.

    I look at a movie and think - do I want a 13-year-old to see this stuff?

    The answer is NO.
  • brunyon Character 2012/07/16 15:26:47
    brunyon
    you know you could rent the movie and watch it before your kids, or grow a pair and get over it?
  • Character brunyon 2012/07/16 21:12:36
    Character
    Or they could rate it according to its actual content so I don't have to waste my time....
  • brunyon Character 2012/07/16 21:34:03
    brunyon
    or don't see any movies ever or read any books... close your eyes you are safe that way
  • Opinions4Free 2012/07/16 14:39:32
    No
    Opinions4Free
    +1
    I would be OK with PG.
  • Luke 2012/07/16 14:27:40
    No
    Luke
    +1
    Back off BITCH!!!!!
  • V~POTL~PWCM~JLA 2012/07/16 14:25:40 (edited)
    No
    V~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +3
    Not for just smoking. People do that in public view all the time. The movie should have a tobacco warning before it starts. That would be enough.
  • cat 2012/07/16 14:18:51
    No
    cat
    +3
    People are being regulated to death. Wake up guys, your personal freedoms are going away fast. The pathetic part is the generations coming up will never know the difference. Smoking is not good for you but, it is a personal choice.
  • mikeyavelli 2012/07/16 14:18:20
    No
    mikeyavelli
    +1
    no...just vintage.
  • TheCouchF*cker 2012/07/16 14:15:06
    No
    TheCouchF*cker
    +1
    That's just stupid.
  • britbiker 2012/07/16 14:12:40
    No
    britbiker
    +1
    What kind of stupid question is that?
  • chuck 2012/07/16 14:06:46 (edited)
    No
    chuck
    +3
    Thank you o good and wise government for always knowing what is best for me .for without your protection i might have had to suffer the evils of freedom
  • Dion Prince 2012/07/16 14:04:50
    No
    Dion Prince
    +3
    I believe in personal responsibility. Movies will not make a teenager smoke. they all know its bad for them.
  • Bronar 2012/07/16 14:01:01
    No
    Bronar
    +2
    Get the Bloombergs out of our lives please!
  • Dave**Gay for Girls** 2012/07/16 13:57:10
    No
    Dave**Gay for Girls**
    +2
    Well how about rating walking down the street R? You can see people smoking just about anywhere! Maybe we can issue blinders so no one can see them....
    anti smoking foolishness
  • alex 2012/07/16 13:56:34
    No
    alex
    +1
    Are movies with drinking rated r?
  • harley oldman 2012/07/16 13:50:48
    No
    harley oldman
    +1
    NO.........Rate them "S".
  • mealzizhere(: 2012/07/16 13:32:17
    No
    mealzizhere(:
    Kids see it every day in reality....
  • Scooter 2012/07/16 13:26:19 (edited)
    No
    Scooter
    +1
    R for ridiculous!!!
  • Jiorgia 2012/07/16 13:23:29
    No
    Jiorgia
    +2
    Films with drug references aren't rated R...
    People are allowed to drink (even underage) in films rated M and violence is allowed to be shown in PG rated films.
    Smoking should be taken into account when rating a film, but it should not be rated R because one person had a cigarette.
  • Kwaku Tuffour 2012/07/16 13:23:03
    Yes
    Kwaku Tuffour
    +1
    R for Realness maybe.
  • Giacomo Skeate 2012/07/16 13:13:30
    No
    Giacomo Skeate
    +2
    For the love of god... facepalm
  • Angel* 2012/07/16 13:08:44
    No
    Angel*
    +2
    If we keep this up soon we will not have any movies that are ok to see
  • James 2012/07/16 13:03:02 (edited)
    No
    James
    +2
    Not unless you want you to also remove the sex and cursing from pg-13 movies as well. Should also require DL for all R rated movies. I'm tired of trying to watch a movie while a snot nosed brat talks/texts on their cell phone the entire movie.
  • Kigan 2012/07/16 12:58:31
    No
    Kigan
    +1
    That is a dumb reason for an R rating.
  • bmxschoolbus 2012/07/16 12:44:00
    No
    bmxschoolbus
    +1
    who ever comes up with the rating system needs to re do it
  • Sopinum 2012/07/16 12:40:14
    No
    Sopinum
    +3
    Smoking is everywhere. You don't need to watch a film to be tempted to smoke.
    Compared to vintage films, not much smoking is going on in PG-13 films. R rated films aren't going to prevent a teenager from seeing it, it might tempt them all the more.
    Perhaps a deeper study should've been done. One that would compare the temptation to smoke due to films to that of books, families and friends.
    You can't protect juveniles from everything you consider "bad". If you do, you're doing more harm than good.

    Tobacco can lead to health problems? So can people.
  • Jiorgia Sopinum 2012/07/16 13:26:03
    Jiorgia
    +3
    Teenagers smoke because they are not supposed to, it makes them feel naughty.
    Making smoking seem more rebellious is just going to make teens want to smoke more.
  • Beef 2012/07/16 12:27:09
  • Defend ... Beef 2012/07/16 13:33:37
    Defend Western Civlization
    +1
    the only scams is from the government who the real scamer's
  • Gio 2012/07/16 12:02:08
    No
    Gio
    +1
    Rated R isny going t
  • KB 2012/07/16 12:01:06 (edited)
    No
    KB
    +3
    People who complain about movies with smoking in them are same people who let their kids watch violent movies such as Friday the 13th.
  • Jiorgia KB 2012/07/16 13:27:02
    Jiorgia
    +1
    a bit off topic but I love the people that tell me that if I swore around their kids they would punch me...
  • notokand 2012/07/16 11:54:16
    No
    notokand
    +2
    Growing up I watched movies like All Dogs Go to Heaven; they drink and smoked... and tried to kill each other. Rated G. I don't excessively drink, I don't smoke. I don't kill people. Personally, I don't think many people use the rating system anymore. When I saw Ted the movie was packed with little kids and they laughed at all the adult humor sooooo. Yeah.
  • bmxscho... notokand 2012/07/16 12:43:04
    bmxschoolbus
    +1
    ya I thought that was messed up I go and snowwhite and the hench men a few weeks earlier and there is kind of killing in it but its only rated pg 13 the movie rating sucks ass.
  • Gaven Small 2012/07/16 11:40:33
    No
    Gaven Small
    Im a cigar smoker anytime i see a cigar in a movie i like to try it myself
  • PandoraBoxe 2012/07/16 11:40:10
    No
    PandoraBoxe
    +2
    Maybe they should come up with a new rating "Rated C" for cigarettes/cigars or "Rated S" for smoking ;-}

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/21 11:30:29

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals