Should Constantine Maroulis go to jail for murdering "Unchained Melody" tonight, on American Idol?

by wildcat Posted April 08, 2011 00:34:18

Related Topics: American Idol, Idol, Criminal, jail

112 votes
Read all 8 opinions
View Results and Demographics View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Yes, and throw away the key.	96 votes	86%
	No, Come on, Wildcat it wasn't that bad.	7 votes	6%
	No, he did a good job, I don't know why you're griping.	9 votes	8%

I'm not sure it was criminal, but it was bad.

More polls by wildcat

Add a comment above

xsparklex3 April 09, 2011 01:53:12

Yes, and throw away the key.

+1
from what everyone is saying i guess. i didn't actually see it though.
but the only cover of Unchained Melody that i've absolutely loved is this one
(ignore the crazy fangirls screaming)

reply
Sue Reu April 08, 2011 19:39:57

Yes, and throw away the key.

+1
It is very difficult to cover a song that it so ingrained in our consciousness and so associated with a specific singer (in this case, The Righteous Brothers). Because of that, I have no problem with people taking the classics and trying making them "their own" - as long as it's done well. That rendition of Unchained Melody was unrecognizable and, unfortunately, not well executed live. Thank you for posting Clay Aiken's version - it remains true to the original with a few unexpected spins.

reply
wildcat to Sue Reu April 08, 2011 19:48:35

Thank you for those comments. Excellent job. Two thumbs up.

reply
Magical_Music April 08, 2011 18:47:44 (edited)

Yes, and throw away the key.

+1
I didn't like Constantine's version at all. Clay's version that was posted in the comments was really good. Guess they picked the wrong idol graduate to sing UM last night.

reply
wildcat to Magical... April 08, 2011 18:52:19

I agree

reply
2shidtzuthewind April 08, 2011 17:13:27

Yes, and throw away the key.

+1
That was the worst version I've heard of this song. I agree with Sam, they should have had Clay Aiken sing his new version. Now that's powerful.

reply
Sam April 08, 2011 10:12:26

Yes, and throw away the key.

+2
AI should have had Clay Aiken sing his version--it's beautiful!

reply
wildcat to Sam April 08, 2011 17:34:20

reply