Quantcast

Rock or Rap?

Stone.Cold.Krazy 2011/09/07 03:08:29
Related Topics: Rap, Rock
Rock
Rap
Undecided
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Comment... Shadow'... 2011/09/08 19:18:58
    Comment Removed
    +1
    Common sense is not so common, especially among the academics.
  • Shadow'... Comment... 2011/09/08 19:19:47 (edited)
    Shadow's Companion
    +1
    “Surely ‘the average man,’ as everyone knows him, is not very wise, not very learned, not very good. It seems to me that the average man is very much a fool, and something of a rogue as well. He has only a smattering of education, knows virtually nothing of political history, nor history of any kind, is incapable of logical, that is to say clear, thinking, is subject to the suasion of base and silly prejudices, and selfish beyond expression.” – Ambrose Bierce (1842-1914)

    Mine is not common sense. It's uncommon sensibility.
  • Comment... Shadow'... 2011/09/08 19:20:51
    Comment Removed
    More proof.
  • Shadow'... Comment... 2011/09/08 19:22:50
    Shadow's Companion
    +1
    Anti-intellectualism will get you nowhere, good buddy.

    “You despise books; you whose lives are absorbed in the vanities of ambition, the pursuit of pleasure or indolence; but remember that all the known world, excepting only savage nations, is governed by books.” - François-Marie Arouet de Voltaire (1694-1778)
  • Chris - The Rowdy One! #187 2011/09/07 12:34:44
    Rock
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    +3
    Shouldn't we be comparing two forms of music in this poll?
  • Shadow'... Chris -... 2011/09/08 18:23:12
    Shadow's Companion
    We are.
  • Chris -... Shadow'... 2011/09/08 19:20:37
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    +1
    Uh-huh.
  • apachehellfire65 2011/09/07 11:39:07
    Rock
    apachehellfire65
    +1
    don't see the big deal about rap.
  • Doc. J 2011/09/07 10:46:26
    Rock
    Doc. J
    +5
    GNARLY!

    gnarly Devil Horns Sign
  • dandieselonian 2011/09/07 09:07:17
    Rock
    dandieselonian
    +2
    all that rock and roll rockabilly too
  • Valia-chan 2011/09/07 08:18:38
    Rock
    Valia-chan
    +1
    Rock all the way!
  • D.G.rocks 2011/09/07 08:05:46
    Rock
    D.G.rocks
    +1
    no question bout it!
  • Cory 2011/09/07 06:49:08
    Rock
    Cory
    +4
    Its not even a fair fight. Rock has the ultimate weapon. The guitar solo.



    You won't hear anything like that in a rap song.
  • Shadow'... Cory 2011/09/08 18:25:29
    Shadow's Companion
    +1


    You were saying?
  • Chris -... Shadow'... 2011/09/08 19:22:36
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    Who is performing the guitar work? A full time member of Run DMC?
  • Shadow'... Chris -... 2011/09/08 19:27:27
    Shadow's Companion
    +1
    Many of Kiss' albums feature guitar and drum tracks credited to Ace and Paul while played by others. The guitar leads on The Rolling Stones' "One Hit (to the Body)" were performed by Jimmy Page and their albums feature tons of guests on vocals, piano, clavinet, etc.: Ian Stewart, Merry Clayton, Marianne Faithfull, Billy Preston, etc. All of the guitars on Warrant's first album were played by Mike Slamer.

    There are countless other examples of rock songs that feature session or guest musicians.
  • Chris -... Shadow'... 2011/09/08 19:41:20
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    I agree with you on those examples but they are more often the exception and not the rule.
  • Shadow'... Chris -... 2011/09/09 04:51:22
    Shadow's Companion
    I could give a list of 200 more "exceptions." At a certain point, you simply have to concede that your argumentative point is a false one. :)
  • Chris -... Shadow'... 2011/09/09 11:35:54
    Chris - The Rowdy One! #187
    All I can say is....rock on.
  • Cory Shadow'... 2011/09/09 10:49:36
    Cory
    What I should have said was, "In general, you won't hear any guitar solos in rap". I'm sure there are some rap artist/groups who do or did use guitar solos, but its not a typical characteristic of the genre, while guitar solos are a prominent feature in rock music.
  • Shadow'... Cory 2011/09/09 21:52:49
    Shadow's Companion
    That in itself is debatable. You'd be hard-pressed to find guitar solos in any rock music before 1964 or so, not to mention within the realms of punk, hardcore, alternative, shoegazer, black metal and many others.

    I could also add that I don't consider guitar solos to be a necessary ingredient of ANY form of music, but that's taking the discussion off to a whole other tangent, which serves this one no good.
  • Cory Shadow'... 2011/09/10 06:03:37
    Cory
    True not all forms of rock music uses guitar solos, but when most people hear the words "guitar solo" they instantly think rock music. That is because the guitar solo played a big part in the popularity of rock music, especially in the 70's and 80's, with bands such as Aerosmith, Judas Priest, Iron Maiden, Scorpions, Black Sabbath, KISS, AC/DC etc. using them heavily.
  • Shadow'... Cory 2011/09/10 17:06:40
    Shadow's Companion
    Indeed, and believe me, I love all of those bands, but I'm just as happy with Neurosis or Faith No More or Discharge playing disparate forms of rock music and shunning the solo entirely!
  • Παναγιώτης 2011/09/07 06:20:41
    Undecided
    Παναγιώτης
  • The Br-o-ken Kid From Yeste... 2011/09/07 05:18:05
    Rock
    The Br-o-ken Kid From Yesterday
    +2
    HANDS DOWN
  • rustyshackelford 2011/09/07 05:16:20
  • Heavy Hands 2011/09/07 05:06:45
    Undecided
    Heavy Hands
    +3
    doesnt matter to me
  • <3<3kitty<3<3 2011/09/07 05:01:34
    Rap
    <3<3kitty<3<3
    +3
    i LOVE rap!!
    but i love rock too but mostly rap

    love rap love rock rap

    love rap love rock rap lil wayne and nicki minaj
  • Wrinkleranch 2011/09/07 04:53:22
    Rock
    Wrinkleranch
    +4
    Rock all the way. I can't stand rap. To me it is like finger nails on a blackboard.
  • Poet003 2011/09/07 04:47:35
    Rock
    Poet003
    +3
    I prefer rock n roll to rap. I do however like hip hop, soul, funk, blues, jazz, fusion, r and b etc.
    It doesnt matter to me if rock n roll originated with Elvis, Fats Domino, Bo Diddley, Chuck Berry,
    or Bill Hailey they were all gifted and I prefer rock to rap. I have a huge collection of rock and blues
    cds. I dont have any of my rap cds anymore.The best rapper I know of was Gil Herron (I think)
    who rapped the "Revolution will not be televised". I need to go to a slam poetry fest I might like
    rap if I thought it was better poetry.
  • Poet003 Poet003 2011/09/07 04:49:16
    Poet003
    +2
    I like rap mixed with other genres some like a heavy metal guy rapping but not as a genre by itself.
  • Xinea 2011/09/07 04:47:16
    Rock
    Xinea
    +2
    I love rap but I've grown up with rock and am more partial to it.
  • MJ 2011/09/07 04:41:29
    Rock
    MJ
    +3
    I prefer rock
  • bman~AVA 2011/09/07 04:28:01
    Rock
    bman~AVA
    +3
    Rock for sure. I can't stand rap.
  • qz333 2011/09/07 04:22:57
    Rock
    qz333
    +3
    I love rock and dislike rap
  • WickedPippy 2011/09/07 04:19:34
  • Ty ~ PHAET 2011/09/07 04:17:56 (edited)
    Rock
    Ty ~ PHAET
    +3
    I love both. I've noticed that the strongest criticisms of rap come from people who've never actually taken time to listen to it.
  • ~FallenAngel~ </3 2011/09/07 04:13:56 (edited)
    Rock
    ~FallenAngel~ </3
    +2
    rap is ok, but i love rock <3
  • Damaris 2011/09/07 04:06:20
    Undecided
    Damaris
    +3
    I like both.
  • ♥SocialOutcastshavemorefun♥ 2011/09/07 04:04:39 (edited)
    Rock
    ♥SocialOutcastshavemorefun♥
    +3
    It's a billion times better

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/19 09:12:20

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals