Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > Megan Fox Would Make a Better Elizabeth Taylor Than Lindsay Lohan

SodaHead Film 2012/01/19 14:00:00
There weren't a whole lot of hallelujahs when rumor got out that Lindsay Lohan might be playing Elizabeth Taylor in a Lifetime movie, but have no fear. Megan Fox is here. At the same time the movie's producer confirmed Lohan's candidacy, he revealed they've been in talks with Fox, too. Are we supposed to be... relieved? Neither of these actress have good track records, but they're the only leads we have. So, we asked SodaHeads: Who should it be?

Would Megan Fox Make a Better Elizabeth Taylor Than Lindsay Lohan?

megan fox taylor

70% Think Fox Would Do Better

We're actually kind of surprised at this one. Sure, Lindsay Lohan's career is on a one-way road to nowhere, but once upon a time she was a pretty decent actor. Nope, the public is siding with Fox on this one. Quite a few voters think the former "Transformers" actress has a chance at making a comeback -- not a common sentiment for LiLo. There is that whole legal-emotional trainwreck Lohan is still picking through, so maybe Fox was a good choice after all. She does look more like Taylor. At the end of the day, they're both disappointing picks. Maybe one of them will pull it off, but hopes are not very high for either.

chart

Women Want Fox

Even more surprising that the overall results was the discovery that women were more likely to pick Fox by 11%. Married voters backed her by about the same amout. It looks like women don't mind their husbands ogling Fox as long as it gets them out of watching Lohan. A testament to LiLo's reputation.

Smokers Side With LiLo...

We did a demographic breakdown on Lohan's Playboy cover back in December and found that smokers were her most supportive group. Once again, smokers step out for Lindsay and give her one of the few majority votes. It's a small one (52%), but she needs all the encouragement she can get.

...Drinkers Don't

Again, like the last LiLo breakdown we did, that support did not carry over to the drinkers. It probably has something to do with her legal trouble. She definitely doesn't do alcohol a favor by "spilling" it on her SCRAM bracelet, and she doesn't do drinkers a favor by being associated with the substance.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our original poll about the Elizabeth Taylor casting. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • Yaati 2012/01/19 17:16:27 (edited)
    Yaati
    +5
    Meh. I still think Camilla Belle would be a better choice.

    meh camilla belle choice

    meh camilla belle choice

    meh camilla belle choice
    She's got a more vintage-y look to her and I think she could pull off the role.

    Now, I'm not naming any big time actresses because this is just Lifetime (ya know?) and so realistically, I think Camilla would be a possibility. 'Cause Lifetime isn't exactly known for spinning out award-winning performances or movies...

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • lisa.goike 2012/01/25 09:57:34
    lisa.goike
    I don't think either of them could pull it off
  • Ghostie Of the Night 2012/01/21 22:39:57
    Ghostie Of the Night
    +1
    I think none of them is proper for Liz Taylor. I think Camilla Belle is looking a lot like her she only needs blue eye contacts and she's perfectly similar to her.
    camilla belle
  • Little Miss Unicorn 2012/01/21 01:47:34
    Little Miss Unicorn
    None of them has the glamour, class and majestic beauty of Liz Taylor.
    If you really want a young actress, go for Emma Stone with darker hair.
    People who are saying Camilla Belle.... she's a wonderful actress, but doesn't look like Elizabeth at all.
    liz taylor
    liz taylor
    liz taylor
    emma stone teen vogue
  • Piwan 2012/01/20 16:14:39
    Piwan
    I don't think either is a good choice because of their extreme lack of grace and class, but Fox would be a very slight improvement over Lohan!
  • Deleting Account 2012/01/20 09:20:45 (edited)
  • ian 2012/01/20 06:53:26
    ian
    +3
    Megan fox love her
  • wtw 2012/01/20 04:04:07
    wtw
    OK!
  • Jack's Pearl 2012/01/19 23:25:59
    Jack's Pearl
    +4
    Camilla Belle would be much better then either of these women!

    camilla belle
  • WhereIsAmerica? ~PWCM~JLA 2012/01/19 23:22:28 (edited)
    WhereIsAmerica? ~PWCM~JLA
    Neither one does Elizabeth (who was a very beautiful woman) justice.

    Meagan Fox would be better, but that is not saying much. She looks somewhat like her, but if she can't act, does it matter?

    Lohan is just a train wreck, why are they even considering her?
  • Freeranger 2012/01/19 22:14:34
    Freeranger
    They're equally atrocious selections.
  • Rebecca 2012/01/19 22:11:43
    Rebecca
    Absolutely Megan Fox would make a better Elizabeth Taylor than Lindsay Lohan. I think that Lindsay's behavior of late should put the kibosh on her career. She doesn't deserve the job, or any acting job, until she straightens herself out.
  • Kigan 2012/01/19 22:05:33
    Kigan
    They were both terrible options to begin with.
  • Depsycho 2012/01/19 21:49:46
    Depsycho
    +1
    Actually this wasn't all that fair of a vote if it's to decide who would make a better ACTOR. If it was strictly a look-alike contest, then I do go with Fox.

    Problem is with this though is the obvious - Megan Fox CANNOT act for beans. She's a hot girl, but should stick with modeling, or take some more acting classes.

    And forget Lindsay, if she ever comes back successfully, even if it's a TV series or voice acting, I will be very surprised. Sorry to say this, but she's pretty much through with show business.
  • moiraregis 2012/01/19 21:44:34
    moiraregis
    elizabeth taylor would make a better elizabeth taylor. watch her movies and be glad she left around so much of herself for the world to enjoy. rip, liz.
  • venus 2012/01/19 21:40:30
    venus
    neither of them are qualified to play Elizabeth Taylor nobody can people like Elizabeth Taylor , elves Presley and other actors like them , nobody can ever be like them or act them
  • Callaway 2012/01/19 21:34:08
    Callaway
    Megan Fox is closer to Liz Taylors skin coloring than Freckles.
  • Gracie ~Gun Totin' Gracie~ 2012/01/19 21:21:20
    Gracie ~Gun Totin' Gracie~
    +1
    I don't think that either one could EVER play Elizabeth Taylor,matter of a fact there isn't anyone in hollyweird that could.
  • Kat Elliott 2012/01/19 21:14:17 (edited)
    Kat Elliott
    Lohan is trash and is never going to recover if we constantly give her any attention to her schemes. What happened to her? Yes I know has nothing to do whether she is qualified as an actress. But I think she should put her life in order before she goes out and make a movie. Unfortunately for her no one wants her to be in their movies because of her image.



    lohan drunk



    lohan drunk
  • cass Kat Ell... 2012/01/20 16:27:00
    cass
    Elizabeth Taylor was no angel...Drugs,alcohol and 7or 8 marriages.Nuff said
  • Jack's Pearl 2012/01/19 20:57:49
    Jack's Pearl
    +2
    I know we can do better! There are better actresses out there that could pull this off. There has to be. Even trying out new people who are lookalikes would be better.
  • Jack's ... Jack's ... 2012/01/19 21:01:00
    Jack's Pearl
    +3
    How about Emma Stone?

    Emma Stone

    Darken her hair and she's a pretty good match too.
  • CarrieAnne Jack's ... 2012/01/19 21:07:47
    CarrieAnne
    +1
    Now I have to agree with that one! She has shown decent versatility and she's absolutely gorgeous, so....yeha that would be awesome!
  • katie macfarlane 2012/01/19 20:38:12
    katie macfarlane
    +1
    Megan fox all the way baby xx
  • moviebuff 2012/01/19 19:40:38
    moviebuff
    If it's between these two then Megan. But I feel Zooey deschanel looks more like her. She just has to get rid of those bangs. She can really transform.
  • harley oldman 2012/01/19 19:05:24
    harley oldman
    MEGAN.......Baby.....!
  • sodabox 2012/01/19 18:17:17
    sodabox
    Fox is long and thin. Tayor was never long and thin. Lohan has a closer body type but a wet cat would make a better human being then Lohan.

    Lohan
  • harley ... sodabox 2012/01/19 19:08:55
    harley oldman
    Did you ever see the Movie ..."GIANT"...........Lizzy, long and thin.....!
  • Mario 2012/01/19 17:47:23
  • moiraregis Mario 2012/01/19 21:49:24
    moiraregis
    like raising zillions of dollars for aids research? sticking up for aids patients when the world tried to turn them into pariahs? being a kind and decent human being when she was gorgeous enough to get away with literal murder? so she was a drunk and went to betty ford; nobody's perfect, and you should stop expecting that of anyone--you sound jealous, frankly--
  • Mario moiraregis 2012/01/20 03:29:03
    Mario
    lol. and you sound extremely obsessive to a psychotic point. Notice how many raves you got for attacking me,
  • ryan.noh1 2012/01/19 17:41:06
    ryan.noh1
    You can say whatever you... hell I'm going to just look up pictures of both and fap...
  • misterz 2012/01/19 17:39:42
  • Firekitty ∞ijm♥G☮F♀U∞ 2012/01/19 17:25:08
    Firekitty ∞ijm♥G☮F♀U∞
    +1
    Oh my gosh yes Megan Fox would on any given day.
  • devious joker 2012/01/19 17:24:59
    devious joker
    i would like lohan to have a shot but im siding with taylor
  • Rakohammas 2012/01/19 17:23:18
    Rakohammas
    +1
    Lohan is a mess....I think she can ...sometimes be an actress
    but Megan Fox is a pathetic actress, she should be a model only, she really sucks
  • Artist 2012/01/19 17:22:53
    Artist
    +1
    Food for thought.
    Um, isn't Fox a bit ungifted in the rack department? Let's not worry about her acting skills that don't exist.
    Troubled as Lohan is, she can act.
    Liz must be spinning...no wait, about to vault out of her cast (sarc!) that either of these women are in the race.
  • CarrieAnne Artist 2012/01/19 21:09:05
    CarrieAnne
    +1
    If Fox gains a little weight for the role, she would be perfect.
    I know, I know....unheard of!!
  • David 2012/01/19 17:22:52
    David
    They both make better Taylors than Elizabeth!
  • Zomba Fett 2012/01/19 17:18:03
    Zomba Fett
    +3
    I think Angelina Jolie would be better Taylor than Fox and Lohan combined!

    Angelina Jolie as Elizabeth Taylor
  • WhereIs... Zomba Fett 2012/01/19 23:24:19
    WhereIsAmerica? ~PWCM~JLA
    I am getting really tired of Jolie and she is no Elizabeth Taylor.

Entertainment

2013/05/19 14:52:58

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals