Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > Mark Wahlberg's 9/11 Comment Was No Big Deal

SodaHead Celebs 2012/01/19 22:13:21
You may or may not know that actor Mark Wahlberg was scheduled to be on United 93, the hijacked flight the went down over Pennsylvania on September 11, 2001 -- the flight passengers bravely fought on, and died in, to prevent another terrorist attack. Would things have been different if the "Three Kings" star had been on the flight? Marky Mark thinks so. When Men's Journal asked him about the tragic day, he explained that he would have drawn blood in the cabin and gotten those passengers home safe. However, some have taken his statement as something of a one-up on the victims who tried to do the same. We asked SodaHeads if the statement was in poor taste.

Was Mark Wahlberg's 9/11 Comment Insensitive?

mark wahlberg

55% Let It Slip

It might have been a little presumptuous, but the majority of respondents didn't take offense to Wahlberg's comment. Some even admired it. The Top Opinion read, "Anything but insensitive. Only manly and full of awesome. Awesome like Wahlberg always is." But the vote was far from unanimous. Critics are accusing him of confusing reality with his film career. One commenter wrote, "Someone's a little confused with the difference between an action movie and reality. Does he really think no one else would have done the same if they could have? Life doesn't work like that."

chart

Men Are More Offended

Who says women are the sensitive ones? Maybe it just depends on the topic. Men were 10% more likely than women to find Wahlberg's comment insensitive. Male comments were also a bit harsher than female comments, using words like "ignorant," "mindless," and a few others we'll leave to your imagination.

Teens Tolerate the Comment

Younger voters were significantly less bothered by the comments. The majority of voters over 45 were offended, but as voters got younger they were more accepting. By the time it got to the teens, only 14% thought it was insensitive. And that makes sense, because some of them wouldn't even remember the day, but even voters in their 30s let Wahlberg off the hook.

Homosexuals Won't Have It

We're not sure how sexual orientation plays into all this, but homosexual voters were far more likely to find Wahlberg's comments insensitive -- 88% compared to 43% of straight voters. That's more than double. Bisexual voters, on the other hand, were even less offended than straight voters.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our original poll about Mark Wahlberg. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • katie 2012/01/19 22:24:14
    katie
    +7
    This whole thing is stupid. He shouldnt have felt complied to apologize for his statement. He was meaning no disrespect

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Little ... Tina 2012/01/21 09:32:24
    Little Fawn
    +1
    Did I say that I didn't think people on the plane didn't risk their lives? No, I was only saying that that's what Mark Wahlberg was pretty much saying. That he probably would've tried to do the same.
  • jsbustaman 2012/01/20 10:03:57
    jsbustaman
    His stupid remarks prove a famous person can put a foot in his/her mouth, too!
  • alex 2012/01/20 07:49:46 (edited)
    alex
    +5
    Oh yes, its so offensive for someone to have wanted to save lives. I'm sure hell think long and hard before he feels that way again *rolls eyes*
  • Tina alex 2012/01/20 15:54:46
    Tina
    +1
    No, he didn't say he wanted to save lives. He, basically, said, "Those guys were pussies and I'm a superhero. I WOULD have gotten it done"...
  • alex Tina 2012/01/20 18:35:03
    alex
    +1
    youve never had that feeling after reading a tragic story? where your heart swells and it effects you so deeply emotionally that you actually belive you might have been able to save the day? thats all it was, he didn't mean anything offensive by it.
  • mitch 2012/01/20 07:20:42
    mitch
    +3
    I don't think Mark would have went downwith out a fight, but we will never know what the out come may have been.
  • Tina mitch 2012/01/20 15:55:28
    Tina
    +2
    The passengers on the flight didn't go down without a fight!!! That's why the plane went down in Pennsylvania and not Washington.
  • irish -... Tina 2012/01/21 13:05:34
    irish -liberty or death!
    please,thats all a govt tale anyway. eyewitness's say it happened differently.
  • judge 2012/01/20 07:06:22 (edited)
    judge
    No, but uninformed. Lt. Col. Rick Gibney reported no one flying the Shanks-ville passenger plane before he shot it down.
    The pilot who shot down flight 93, according to infowars.com it was the lettsroll forum who found out his name: Lt. Col. Rick Gibney .

    What Rick Gibney really witnessed was a ghost airplane with crew and passengers either unconscious or dead due to the effect of incapacitating gas, and no Arabs in sight.

    John: Was it shot down because the airline pilots actually regained control of the hijacked autopilot or was it the unmanned drone that was shot down?

    DGP: No, it was the aircraft, you see, it had totally unconscious people on board. There were no hijackers
    There were no hijackers. The planes were being flown remotely.

    If Mark Wahlberg had been on-board, he would have been unconscious like the rest.
  • Andrea 2012/01/20 06:55:49
    Andrea
    +1
    Maybe he would, and maybe he wouldn't. Ordinary people have done extraordinary things. Just look at 93 anyway. THEY did not lose any lives but the ones on the plane, THEIR actions saved lives. Why not his?
  • DebraJMSmith 2012/01/20 06:45:13 (edited)
    DebraJMSmith
    +1
    If he wants to be a hero, then let's put him to the test. --Let's see if he would be willing to fight the giant mosque shaped "memorial" that the parents of Tom Burnett Jr. (a real Flight 93 hero) are trying to stop from being built: http://www.debrajmsmith.com/f...

    I wonder if we could some how get a note to this man, Mark Wahlbergs.
  • Tennessee3501 2012/01/20 06:27:57
    Tennessee3501
    Our daughter worked on Capitol Hill as a Congressional Staffer on September 11. 2001. She still does. She lives, together with her husband and our grandson on Capitol Hill. We believe that the passengers and crew on Flight 93 may very well have saved her life and the lives of everybody in and near the Capitol that day! They are great national heroes! Mark Wahlberg's remarks were insensitive and should offend all Americans. If he is sincerely sorry, let him make a substantial financial contribution to help complete the Memorial to the Fight 93 heroes in Shankesville, Pennsylvania
  • Resp 2012/01/20 06:15:16
    Resp
    +1
    Mark Wahlberg, as is everyone, is entitled to his opinion. And who's to say? He may just be right!
  • NoobGotPowned 2012/01/20 05:55:22
  • Keith 2012/01/20 05:33:57
    Keith
    +6
    It wasn't insensitive, he was just being a little delusional to think he would have stopped it, maybe all this action movies rubbed off on him and he thinks he can really do that in real life or something.
  • Dub 2012/01/20 05:03:50
    Dub
    +1
    What a douche bag.
  • pjwinkler65 2012/01/20 04:36:20 (edited)
    pjwinkler65
    +2
    I didn't hear him say it so I haven't a clear idea of the tone or context but just reading the quote kind of makes him sound like a douche bag. Perhaps he has genuine confidence in his basic survival instinct and perhaps, due to his experiences with preparing for roles, he has indeed become more learned in this area than your average person. That said, it's always easier to spout off about how you would have handled something when you weren't there. I don't take it as an insult to anyone, not many could have changed the outcome. Maybe Mark is among those few and maybe he is not but I can tell you this, whether he would actually be capable or not is not the question; It's kind of juvenile to assume that you could have handled it successfully when so many factors would have been at play. It would have made him sound a lot cooler if he had said something like, "Maybe if I had been there I could have helped; I would like to think that I would have been able to do the right thing."
  • carlton999 2012/01/20 04:34:58
    carlton999
    +1
    Im with Mark, I feel the same way. beside the Plane was shot down any way so it wouldnt have made a difference.
  • iamthemob ~ the 444th Guru ~ 2012/01/20 03:42:56
    iamthemob ~ the 444th Guru ~
    +1
    I disagree with the public opinion in terms of "letting it slip."

    (1) The comment was something that I'm sure that a lot of people have said to each other in private.

    (2) However, this was in an interview - and the context means that it is something that he should have to stand behind. Casual, off-hand comments like this are things you should know...especially late in your career...not to make to a large-scale publication.

    (3) But, in the end, he's apologized. Therefore, all is well for me.
  • irish -... iamthem... 2012/01/21 13:06:42
    irish -liberty or death!
    he has nothing to apologize for.
  • iamthem... irish -... 2012/01/21 13:14:08
    iamthemob ~ the 444th Guru ~
    A lot of people think he did. If I were a family member of one of the victims of that flight, I don't know how I would feel hearing him claim that if he'd been there, he would have stepped up and saved them all...

    So he apologized to people who were offended. If you don't think that he had anything to apologize for, there doesn't seem to be a need to disagree, no?
  • irish -... iamthem... 2012/01/21 13:22:58
    irish -liberty or death!
    right.
  • I NEED A HORSE 2012/01/20 02:48:15
  • Jersey Roze ♥Jwon's Cyar'ika ♥
    +1
    ABSOLUTELY NOT!!! Yet another example of how celebrities are under higher scrutiny than your average Joe. His comments don't differ from societies everyday hypothesis that "If I had been there..." Followed by whatever miraculous thing they swore they would have done to save lives. Shoot, I probably would've said the same thing....
  • wtw 2012/01/20 02:32:53
    wtw
    +2
    Just shows the arrogance of ignorant people in hollywood who live in some fantasy world and are out of touch with reality.!
  • Aqua Surf 2012/01/20 02:14:26 (edited)
    Aqua Surf
    In a certain mood, I could say that I would've done the same thing. No need to defend your opinion Mr Wahlberg.
  • ShamshirMkII 2012/01/20 01:56:15
    ShamshirMkII
    +5
    I find it astounding that some people were actually offended by him voicing his desire to protect people in a hypothetical situation.
  • Wayzuns 2012/01/20 01:48:32
  • andrew Wayzuns 2012/01/20 04:16:50
    andrew
    According to this poll, it's the gay and lesbian demo. Interesting.....
  • ♌βļąƈʞƦơșƐ3033♌ 2012/01/20 01:45:40
    ♌βļąƈʞƦơșƐ3033♌
    He said something without thinking, clearly. People do it all the time. He's fine. I forgive him. Mark is forgiven.
  • wolfshadow 2012/01/20 00:57:16
    wolfshadow
    +1
    Not sure what he meant by the comment... but I for one... am very glad he missed the plane.
  • Linnster 2012/01/20 00:38:34
    Linnster
    Not offended at all. While it seemed to exude bravado, he was a bit of a rebel growing up and sometimes you go back to your old ways. :) He made a proper apology for those who thought he needed to and that should be the end of it.
  • flowercivic 2012/01/20 00:31:17
    flowercivic
    +1
    Really, this is considered insensitive? Nope, not offended in the least.
  • Louisa - Enemy of the State 2012/01/20 00:26:59
    Louisa - Enemy of the State
    An actor must immerse himself in the roles he plays so that he can portray the subject believably. So, I think it may be easier for someone like Mark to 'imagine' what he would do in any situation and the role he would play and how he would play it.

    He didn't mean any disrespect.
  • OzSurfer 2012/01/20 00:18:21
    OzSurfer
    The comment sounds more ignorant than anything else. There are way to many unknown variables that went on that day to even contemplate a statement like he came out with.
  • Arinn 2012/01/20 00:15:34
    Arinn
    ??not sure
  • All American 2012/01/20 00:12:14
    All American
    Sounds to me like some 20/20 armchair quarterbacking.
  • Sinister Ken Doll™ 2012/01/20 00:11:08
    Sinister Ken Doll™
    +1
    he's still a doucher
  • Mamaknows 2012/01/20 00:08:30
    Mamaknows
    +2
    He was saying what he thought...and I think he is one of the hollywood types that could handle himself not just "pretend" to.
  • StevenWilliamHirsch 2012/01/19 23:51:00
    StevenWilliamHirsch
    +2
    Stupid comment by him .... it implied that the passengers didn't do everything they possibly could to avert the tragedy and that he Mark Wahlberg would have been able to do MORE than they could ...... VERY INSENSITIVE!!

Entertainment

2013/05/20 07:25:29

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals