Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > Guns N' Roses Is This Year's Top Rock and Roll Hall of Famers

SodaHead Music 2011/12/09 00:00:00
In April, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame will be inducting six new artist into their repertoire: The Beastie Boys, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Guns N' Roses, Donovan, and two lesser-known artists better known for their influence than their oeuvre (The Small Faces and Laura Nyro.) Since music is an enormously subjective field of work, inductees typically receive a good deal of criticism. With the exception of a few top-ranking artists, like Michael Jackson, it's inevitable.

But they're not all bad, are they? We asked SodaHeads who their top pick for the upcoming induction would be (excluding the two lesser-known artists for the sake of simplicity). It was close, but we found our winner.

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Announces Inductees: Who's Your Favorite?

gnr

39% Favor Guns N' Roses

"Chinese Democracy" wasn't quite the powerhouse we expected, but that doesn't detract from their past greatness. Their guitarist, Slash, is the reason thousands of kids picked up the guitar in the late '80s and early '90s. They reinvented the rebellious rock 'n' roll image honed by The Rolling Stones in the '60s with top hats, bandanas, torn denim and leather. Sure, frontman Axl Rose has some issues, but you just can't ignore the cultural immensity of songs like "Sweet Child o' Mine" and "Welcome to the Jungle."

chart

Red Hot Conservative Peppers

Chili Peppers frontman Anthony Kiedis isn't exactly the most conservative musician out there -- he's been actively involved in Obama's campaign, though Kiedis admits he's not a "politician" -- but conservative voters were able to look past that and give the Peppers the majority of their vote.

Mellow Yellow for the Mature

Most age groups voted for Guns N' Roses, but the oldest respondents strongly preferred Donovan -- the least popular artist of the four. Only 2% of teens voted for him, and 9% of voters aged 18-24. Maybe younger voters just aren't as familiar with "The Hurdy Gurdy Man."


Relationships Are Red Hot

Interestingly, singles were one of the only relationship-based demographic who preferred Guns N' Roses. Voters who were in a relationship were way more into the Peppers, and even married voters liked the Peppers slightly more than GnR. Divorcees, on the other hand: 67% for GnR.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our original poll about the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Nitzan Havoc 2011/12/21 05:05:12
    Nitzan Havoc
    I'm definitely routing for Axle, Slash and the rest, but WAY TO GO for Beastie Boys!!! As for RHCP - I guess they've earned it, though I like them less.
  • jimf 2011/12/19 18:35:49
    jimf
    Where do I get to vote? I want to say NO
    I prefer Rammstein
  • babydracula 2011/12/18 18:53:12
    babydracula
    I dont find respectful that rock n roll hall of fame, better said game
  • Lolly Cullen 2011/12/16 19:54:07
    Lolly Cullen
    Guns 'N' Roses will always be awsome and never die out there music will always be full of talent and ya they will always be one of the best bands ever! and you know they did something right if a 16 year old in the year 2011 almost 2012 still likes them (thanks mom for showing me the band!!!! XD)
  • bundy 2011/12/15 06:48:51
    bundy
    gnrs deserve to be in the hall of fame because they were good at what they didback then now without duff,slash and matt they sux.....
  • Für immer jetzt 2011/12/12 07:52:52
    Für immer jetzt
    +1
    I love Guns and Roses!!
  • Thalia 2011/12/11 16:27:50
    Thalia
    OMG! I love Guns N Roses!
  • whispering hands 2011/12/11 04:23:05
    whispering hands
    I like GnR, don't get me wrong, but I give WAAAY more fuccks that RHPC was finally put in it. In my opinion, RHPC is way more underrated than most people think. I was pissed when I saw a show on VH1 listing the Greatest Artists of All Time, and they weren't even on there! RHPC created their very own sub-genre of music that didn't even exist before. They are a one of a kind band, and I don't think they get that sort of recognition enough.
  • ♥♥BVB♥♥ 2011/12/10 21:14:28
    ♥♥BVB♥♥
    oh guns n roses is one my favorite bands !!!!!! i love em !! they rock :)
  • jackdaniels07 2011/12/10 04:58:56
  • Mark5610 2011/12/10 01:12:57
    Mark5610
    G&R; had 2 hit songs and that’s it. Good for the moment but not RRHOF material. The RRHOF board members induct people based on style points and if they are in vogue at that time. fat axel rose
  • cali 2011/12/09 20:22:46
    cali
    Guns n' Roses rock
  • The Elitist Libtard SodaJerk 2011/12/09 20:20:59
    The Elitist Libtard SodaJerk
    If You discard The Spaghetti incident, or Chinese Democracy, You can make a case for GNR. However, we've got another year Where Kiss is over looked again, Rainbow never existed, but it's good that Laura Nyro finally gets some credit, She only died 13 years ago. And influenced a bunch of artist also overlooked the The RNR HOF, Three Dog Night, Blood Sweat & Tears, the list goes on. How much you wanna wager that NSync gets in before Iggy Pop.
  • you 2011/12/09 20:08:41
    you
    http://rock.about.com/od/top1...

    I just had to look what was being considered their top 10 songs
  • Anna E 2011/12/09 18:54:48
    Anna E
    I think GnR would have been a lot better if they'd had a lead singer with a voice instead of a squeal. Great tunes, though. I like the Peppers better. Not so big a fan of Donovan, although I like a few of his tunes.
  • Randy 2011/12/09 17:20:48
    Randy
    Guns and roses SUCK. And the Rock and Roll hall of fame is a friggen joke. Abba is in but Rush and Heart aren't, are you kidding me? Effen joke. It's not who you are it's who you suck up to.
  • Ivor Bi... Randy 2011/12/11 07:47:10
    Ivor Biggun
    in fairness, ABBA were more succesful than the others worldwide. Far greater popularity
  • Randy Ivor Bi... 2011/12/12 17:02:03
    Randy
    It's the rock and roll hall of fame, not the pop hall of fame. And how long were ABBA around? A few years at best? Compare thet to the like of Rush. No comparison. It is a joke. Too many politics involved and there isn't supposed to be any. So I get a good laugh everytime they come out with the new list of inductees.
  • retrograve 2011/12/09 16:59:12
    retrograve
    I think they're good but I only know their most popular songs. I remember the guys from 'That Metal Show' complaining that the right groups never get into the hall of fame.
  • Get Bashed 2011/12/09 16:32:28
    Get Bashed
    GUN'S N' ROSES....The band could have remained a full-time force to be reckoned with if their Diva (Axl Rose) could have kept his trap shut until it was time to go on stage!
  • Arel 2011/12/09 15:40:50
    Arel
    +1
    Guns N Roses was one of the best bands ever!
  • Randy Arel 2011/12/12 17:02:40
    Randy
    Buncha heroin addicts.
  • Arel Randy 2011/12/12 19:00:03
    Arel
    but a great band none the less.
  • Randy Arel 2011/12/12 21:56:05
    Randy
    Can't stand them. First time I saw Axl on tv I thought he was a women. His cat stuck in a vise voice is like fingernails on a chaulkboard to me. Not only that he's a jerk. Slash is a good guitarist i'll give you that, but as far as their music goes, hate it.
  • FYI 2011/12/09 14:55:50
    FYI
    +1
    Rush,Kiss,Journey,Bad Company,ELO,Moody Blues.
    All much more worthy than ANY of these inductees.
    The Beastie Boys? Please.
  • Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA 2011/12/09 14:30:40
    Torchmanner ~PWCM~JLA
    GnR was a really good band.
  • mark 2011/12/09 14:15:17
    mark
    These were the choices? Has the R & R Hall Of Fame run out of really excellent artists to induct?
  • Randy mark 2011/12/09 17:22:26
    Randy
    +1
    No. Google bands they haven't even considered and you'll find out the hall is a joke.
  • SlipKnoT-M.F.K.R 2011/12/09 13:56:17
    SlipKnoT-M.F.K.R
    +1
    tbh i hate GnR i dont think they deserve to go to the hall of fame for one good album that gets old the second time you hear it...i dont think they should get what there gettin
  • danielria 2011/12/09 13:40:43
    danielria
    +1
    Motley Crue was way better than these guys.
  • danielria 2011/12/09 13:39:27
    danielria
    One great album and they are deserving of the hall of fame? lol
  • jacob crim 2011/12/09 13:16:23
    jacob crim
    +2
    I'm sorry but a band that only has one good album should not be voted in over the groups that have multiple releases that even surpass the one GNR album.
  • gone i guess 2011/12/09 13:04:25
    gone i guess
    i like them
  • Retard Buggsy 2011/12/09 13:01:41
    Retard Buggsy
    Guns N Roses are cool. Shame that they split up. At least Slash is still in the music business......!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • wamcalif 2011/12/09 10:47:00
    wamcalif
    I wonder if any of the people who took that poll know the songs that sprung from the mind of Laura Nyro? I thought she was in the Hall a long time ago. The rest pale in comparison to her talent.
    stone soul picnic
  • Randy wamcalif 2011/12/09 17:23:07
    Randy
    Who?
  • wamcalif Randy 2011/12/10 00:09:05
    wamcalif
    By age 17, she had written the classic “And When I Die,” popularized by Peter, Paul and Mary, and later Blood, Sweat and Tears. The radio airwaves of the late ‘60’s and ‘70’s were filled with her songs. “Wedding Bell Blues,” “Stoned Soul Picnic,” “Blowin’ Away,” “Save The Country,” and “Sweet Blindness,” a bouquet of compositions, all became hits for The Fifth Dimension, as did “Eli’s Comin’” for Three Dog Night, and “Stoney End” for Barbra Streisand. “She wrote the most unexpected songs,” observer Stereo Review, “a dazzling display of lyrical and musical innovation that gave her music a fresh feeling….”
    Laura’s work draws from soul, jazz, blues, R&B, and folk-rooted music, along with a modern classical influence. Her songs have been recorded by artists as diverse as Carmen McCrae, Suzanne Vega, Phoebe Snow, Roseane Cash, Sweet Honey in the Rock, Jane Siberry, Mongo Santamaria, Junior Walker and the All Stars, Chet Atkins, Frank Sinatra, Linda Ronstadt, George Duke, Maynard Ferguson, Thelma Houston, Patti Larkin, The Roches, and many, many others. The prestigious Alvin Ailey Dance Company includes Laura’s music in their performance piece “Cry.” And the Canadian Ballet has danced to “Emmie.”

    Born in New York on October 18, 1947, Laura was brought up on city life and summers s...






    By age 17, she had written the classic “And When I Die,” popularized by Peter, Paul and Mary, and later Blood, Sweat and Tears. The radio airwaves of the late ‘60’s and ‘70’s were filled with her songs. “Wedding Bell Blues,” “Stoned Soul Picnic,” “Blowin’ Away,” “Save The Country,” and “Sweet Blindness,” a bouquet of compositions, all became hits for The Fifth Dimension, as did “Eli’s Comin’” for Three Dog Night, and “Stoney End” for Barbra Streisand. “She wrote the most unexpected songs,” observer Stereo Review, “a dazzling display of lyrical and musical innovation that gave her music a fresh feeling….”
    Laura’s work draws from soul, jazz, blues, R&B, and folk-rooted music, along with a modern classical influence. Her songs have been recorded by artists as diverse as Carmen McCrae, Suzanne Vega, Phoebe Snow, Roseane Cash, Sweet Honey in the Rock, Jane Siberry, Mongo Santamaria, Junior Walker and the All Stars, Chet Atkins, Frank Sinatra, Linda Ronstadt, George Duke, Maynard Ferguson, Thelma Houston, Patti Larkin, The Roches, and many, many others. The prestigious Alvin Ailey Dance Company includes Laura’s music in their performance piece “Cry.” And the Canadian Ballet has danced to “Emmie.”

    Born in New York on October 18, 1947, Laura was brought up on city life and summers spent in the lush greenery of the Northeast. She began playing music very early, and enjoyed a wide range of influences through her high school years at Manhattan’s Music and Art. Laura listened to the late ‘50’s and ‘60’s girl groups, Nina Simone, John Coltrane, Miles Davis, Smokey Robinson and the Miracles, Curtis Mayfield and The Impressions, Mary Wells, Dusty Springfield, and the early Burt Bacharach-Hal David songs of Dionne Warwick, among many others. Laura read poetry and at home her mother played records by Leontyne Price and impressionist classical composers such as Ravel, Debussy and Persicetti.

    Throughout high school Laura also listened to the protest music of Pete Seeger, Joan Baez, early Bob Dylan the Beatles and others. Laura always "adored" the music of Van Morrison. “I was always interested in the social consciousness of certain songs. My mother and grandfather were progressive thinkers, so I felt at home in the peace movement and the women's movement, and that has influenced my music.”

    Laura made her first extended professional appearance at age 18, singing at the legendary Hungry i coffeehouse in San Francisco Sound.” The following year (1966) saw the release of her debut album More Than A New Discovery on the Verve/Folkways label. It’s still interesting to note that her Verve label-mates then included The Blues Project, Tim Hardin, Richie Havens, Janis Ian, and Dave Von Ronk; other seminal New York peers included Tim Buckley and Kenny Rankin.


    "This an excerpt from her bio page.."
    (more)
  • Randy wamcalif 2011/12/10 00:55:38
    Randy
    The defense rests. ABBA is in and Laura Nyro is not. The hall sucks monkeys.
  • wamcalif Randy 2011/12/10 02:23:15
    wamcalif
    Nyro is an inductee.
  • Randy wamcalif 2011/12/10 21:46:54
    Randy
    You made it sound like she wasn't, sorry.

Entertainment

2013/05/23 19:04:38

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals