Quantcast

PUBLIC OPINION > Don't Let Rihanna Play Whitney Houston

SodaHead Celebs 2012/02/28 23:26:56
Rihanna is better known for her raunchy lyrics and outrageous outfits than for her singing voice, but producers keep trying to peg her as Whitney Houston. At least, that's what the media would have us think. Last year, rumor had it she might reprise Houston's role in a "Bodyguard" remake, but she publicly "declined" the role before it was offered. We're still not sure where the rumor came from, or if it was even true. Now a similar rumor is going around, suggesting she's at the top of a list of singers who might get to play the late diva in an upcoming biopic. We asked the public if she would be a good pick.

Should Rihanna Play Whitney Houston in Upcoming Biopic?

riri whitney

76% Are Against It

That's a great, big, operatic "No!" There are so many things wrong with this idea... Where to begin... First of all, the whole idea of making a Whitney Houston biopic right now is a little off. Let's give it more than a month, please. Second of all, there are so many singers out there with better voices. Jennifer Hudson is also rumored to be on the list -- why isn't she at the top? What about Jordin Sparks? Even Beyonce would be a better pick. Finally, the Top Opinion summarized the most immediate reason Rihanna shouldn't get the role: "Houston was far from perfect, but she deserves better than that."

chart

Women Don't Want Her at All

No one wants Rihanna to play Whitney. Not a single substantial demographic sample. All we can do here is tell you who hates the idea the most, and on the gender scale, that would be the women. Only 16% of them are okay with the idea, compared to 29% of men. The "eye candy" factor doesn't work on the women.

Smokers Are a Little More Receptive

Houston's substance abuse issues were well-known, so we thought there might be some correlation there. Smokers were more likely to entertain the idea, but only by 15%. Drinkers were also more likely to accept RiRi, but even less so with a difference of 6%.


Fandom in the 40s

Oddly enough, voters in their 40s were the only age group to vote any differently. Most ages, from 13 to 34, as well as 55 and up, ranged in support from 16% to 23%. However, a third of people in the 35-54 group thought RiRi would make a good Houston. Is that RiRi's target audience? We had no idea.

If you'd like to vote on this question, dig deeper into the demographics, or engage in existing discussion about the topic, visit our original poll about Rihanna. We'd love to hear from you!
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

  • NPC 2012/02/28 23:32:13
    NPC
    +12
    Do us all a favor. Do not make any movie about Whitney Houston. Let this subject alone for now.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • taicho musonda 2012/05/02 14:12:45
    taicho musonda
    Rihanna can try but she will never be no whitney
  • Minda Snyman 2012/04/04 18:31:38
    Minda Snyman
    Why not? She does not have that strong voice but surely she does have the style!
  • Neesha 2012/03/19 16:33:26
    Neesha
    +3
    no one wants a remake of the bodyguard. the movie is fine as is; no one can take whitney houstons place and their are no vocals like hers.. and people please stop hatingin rihanna she is talented and beautiful so please if you have nothing good to say then dont say nothing at all. I and Rihanna will very much appreciate it. thank you
  • Djanet 2012/03/09 02:04:40
    Djanet
    i don't think so i mean sure rihanna has a good voice and i like her but shes not but up to sing as good as WHITNEY and wat don't they get can't they just discuss this later whitney just died and i'm gonna miss her voice http://www.bittenandbound.com...
  • Jada_Ringo 2012/03/05 06:22:27
    Jada_Ringo
    I'm okay with a Whitney Biopic, but having Rhianna play her would be stupid.
  • zcberry 2012/03/05 03:07:13
    zcberry
    NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Yazell 2012/03/04 22:25:45
    Yazell
    You can be made up to look like Whitney, But you cant sing like her even if they made you lip sink. The World Knows its not the best choice to choose Rihana worst choice.
  • jools 2012/03/04 21:51:11
    jools
    No.
  • Quazar 2012/03/04 19:08:36
    Quazar
    Hold on, they both like a good beating, they both like the night life, they both like men of questionable character, they both sing, they both have money. WOW did I actually make all of those comparisions?
    BUT the answer is still NO!
  • Nicole Thomas 2012/03/04 06:31:24
    Nicole Thomas
    NO.
  • Luver 2012/03/03 19:55:57
    Luver
    She hasn't got the pipes for it, and not only that, but whitney wouldn't have wanted some sympathy life story movie. She was a legend and legends speak for themselves.
  • ♌βļąƈʞƦơșƐ3033♌ 2012/03/03 00:28:29
    ♌βļąƈʞƦơșƐ3033♌
    +1
    Do we really need a movie at all?
  • Sonia the Stoner!i!i ♥ 2012/03/02 19:42:20
    Sonia the Stoner!i!i ♥
    I don't really care for there to be a movie about her anyway, no matter who it stars.
  • Glenn Mitchell 2012/03/01 19:07:07
    Glenn Mitchell
    +1
    Seriously? I thought my own taste in music allowed me to select who sings like who.
  • jabo 2012/03/01 10:50:32
    jabo
    I would like to never see Rhianna again, period.
  • Medulla Oblongata 2012/02/29 23:38:37
    Medulla Oblongata
    +1
    Whitney Houston just died. Quit trying to capitalize on that, Hollywood. It's like Michael Jackson all over again.
  • AMarie 2012/02/29 22:19:50
    AMarie
    No. NO NO NO NO NO NO NO. NO NO NO. NO. .....no. Seriously. No.
  • mia 2012/02/29 20:48:37
    mia
    duuuuyy
  • ♛Littlɘ Ǫuɘɘn~ƿɦɐɘϯ 2012/02/29 18:46:54
    ♛Littlɘ Ǫuɘɘn~ƿɦɐɘϯ
    Too soon for a movie about Whitney.

    Will always be too soon for Rihanna to portray Whitney.
  • peggy 2012/02/29 17:51:45
    peggy
    +1
    I dont care. Why don't they leave Whitney and her family alone for a while. She hasn't been gone long enough for this. Please remember how her family must feel. I would say boycott the whole thing until family makes the choice. Let the family decided.
  • Lanikai 2012/02/29 17:40:26 (edited)
    Lanikai
    Well, DUH she shouldn't play her (even though her personal life appears to be similar) HOW ABOUT they scour the churches and find another great singer who has Whitney's range and make another success story, rather than using a retread?
  • Yazell Lanikai 2012/03/04 22:27:06
    Yazell
    Awesum observation retread
  • Lanikai Yazell 2012/03/05 15:08:54
    Lanikai
    Retread-1. To fit (a worn automotive tire) with a new tread

    A not as good copy of an original/
  • Southern Man 2012/02/29 17:06:50
  • Troy 2012/02/29 16:35:47 (edited)
  • SodaBrain 2012/02/29 16:27:52
    SodaBrain
    I agree with NPC... Too soon to discuss.
    Not related, but important news for upcoming days/weeks. Please excuse interruption
    Spread the Word:
    Dark people are being and about to be arrested for crimes against Mankind. Fear is unwarranted: these herald Great and Beneficial Changes. The Galactic Federation is about to Contact Us (and eventually Land) and usher in Prosperity, Abundance, and Health. Technology will be introduced and it will Completely Upgrade Our Society Permanently. Wars will never be permitted on Earth again.
    Love and Light,
  • The Br-o-ken Kid From Yeste... 2012/02/29 16:27:12
    The Br-o-ken Kid From Yesterday
    +1
    Hay Whitney was a woman who was abused by her man Bobby Brown. Rihanna was beaten by her man Chris Brown. I think she could tap into it better than a woman who hasn't been beaten by a husband/boyfriend.
  • Kezzi Rose Lavigne Biersack 2012/02/29 16:13:24
    Kezzi Rose Lavigne Biersack
    I won't
  • Chantal Eyong 2012/02/29 15:19:47
    Chantal Eyong
    +1
    omg what are these producers smoking?? Even Rihanna knows better than to play Whitney
  • Dahvie 2012/02/29 08:54:39
    Dahvie
    +2
    She looks just like her.. so yes.
  • Lerato ... Dahvie 2012/02/29 11:17:48
    Lerato Maseko
    +1
    no she doe not. they jst have the same hairdo in the above pic.
  • Dahvie Lerato ... 2012/02/29 11:49:02
    Dahvie
    Yes she does.
  • Lanikai Dahvie 2012/02/29 17:42:19
    Lanikai
    +2
    But she cannot act, and doesn't have even 1/10th of the vocal range or control. Does talent NOT matter?
  • Dahvie Lanikai 2012/03/01 06:06:23
    Dahvie
    That is true (:
  • MOMMA THOMAS 2012/02/29 07:13:34
    MOMMA THOMAS
    +3
    NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, ........NEVER!
  • Lady D.J 2012/02/29 03:08:44
    Lady D.J
    +4
    let the leeching begin... let the woman rest in piece and NOT make a movie about her tragic life
  • Lanikai Lady D.J 2012/02/29 17:43:17
    Lanikai
    She was the sole breadwinner for several families-they need money, what else are they going to do? get a job after this many years on the gravy train? Get real, they will pimp her as hard as Joe Jackson pimped MJ.
  • Lady D.J Lanikai 2012/03/02 20:46:20
    Lady D.J
    it's just so sad that they will leech off those they profess to love
  • Pablo 2012/02/29 03:05:18
    Pablo
    +1
    Crack is wack.
  • kyle 2012/02/29 02:59:10
    kyle
    +1
    no that wouldnt be a good idea right now she just died leave it alone

Entertainment

2013/06/19 14:45:05

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals