Quantcast

Pippa Middleton’s Book Gets Backlash: Do You Think She Knows What She’s Talking About?

SodaHead Celebs 2012/11/06 18:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Pippa Middleton has received widespread criticism for her book about entertaining, "Celebrate: A Year of Festivities for Families and Friends." The reluctant celebrity, famous for being Kate Middleton’s sister, has had her party planning tips accused of being “the wrong way to celebrate” by The Daily Telegraph.

Getty Images

In response, Pippa has written an article – again for the Daily Telegraph – defending her book against her critics, including the Daily Mail, who called her tomato soup recipe “terrifying.”

She explains that despite the book's simple recipes and sometimes obvious tips, she’s actually “a real foodie,” who has cooked dishes like slow-braised pig’s cheek, pigeon-breast salad and venison stew.

However, she wanted the book to have “something that was achievable,” that “people would have on their shelves for years,” that wasn’t “too fussy.” She adds that the book was “a labor of love,” and that she obsessed “over every detail.” Do you think Pippa knows what she’s talking about?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • macy 2012/12/17 03:06:50
    No
    macy
    Oh my God, WHO CARES.
  • Edwin Diaz 2012/11/11 22:05:43
    Yes
    Edwin Diaz
    'perhaps >.< !!!
  • mikewonaus 2012/11/11 04:47:01 (edited)
    Yes
    mikewonaus
    We'd much prefer a Pippa Party to Martha Stewart, any 'gender challenged', 'Democratic', 'Republican', or 'Green' Party Planners! [we git yer widespread criticism so spread wide] mo betta dan rosie mcdonald
  • Dave 007 2012/11/10 16:45:26
    No
    Dave 007
    She's hot but stupid and getting bad advise. And why should we care about her?
  • wrs 2012/11/10 03:18:34
    Yes
    wrs
    I guess she knows as much as anyone else who lives a life of privileged connections. I'm willing to give her an A for effort. Only time will tell if the book actually becomes a bestseller or ends up in a bookstore bargain basement sale.
  • Tre 2012/11/09 20:12:15
    Yes
    Tre
    Who gives a damn. Leave the woman alone.
  • Miss Fiona 2012/11/09 01:17:24
    Yes
    Miss Fiona
    Someone published her book. Of course, she must understand the material to some capacity.
  • jimrthy BN-0 2012/11/08 23:27:57
    Yes
    jimrthy BN-0
    Look at those legs and that figure! This is *obviously* a woman who loves her food (*snicker*)

    Honestly, I don't know the first thing about her or her book. I just couldn't resist being snarky.
  • Oli 2012/11/08 23:15:30
    Yes
    Oli
    Yeah, but i don't.
  • Amber Fredrick 2012/11/08 21:57:58
    No
    Amber Fredrick
    I read parts of the book about children's birthday and Halloween party ideas. I saw one or two cute ideas but the rest of the stuff was pretty blah and ideas that are already blasted all over Pinterest. The book doesn't provide anything new or interesting.
  • Sister Jean 2012/11/08 21:03:01
    No
    Sister Jean
    no
  • scarfy 2012/11/08 18:57:17
    No
    scarfy
    +1
    But at least she wants to work which is more than I can say for 50 percent of Americans.
  • Proggy 2012/11/08 18:24:04
  • fluffymarshmellow 2012/11/08 17:32:43
    No
    fluffymarshmellow
    +2
    she said "a good idea: if you live close to the beach, a trip to the sea would be fun". man clapping proudly
  • wrs fluffym... 2012/11/10 03:08:11
    wrs
    Love the video clip. Too too funny
  • fluffym... wrs 2012/11/10 18:26:13
    fluffymarshmellow
    thanks buddy.
  • hey you! 2012/11/08 17:19:47
    Yes
    hey you!
    +2
    It sounds sweet. God, if anyone else published this book no one would give a care. But, because someone in the limelight did it she is ridiculed. Admit it, your mom has at least one book like this she oft looks back to everynow and then. Did you ever think to attack the author of that book?
  • nicesteve 2012/11/08 05:53:12
    No
    nicesteve
    +1
    Pippa, I realize that you're trying to fulfill your obligation to serve society, however you
    need to let go of your older sister's coattails and find a more legitimate way to make your
    contribution to society.
  • Kiki,Pixie,Worm 2012/11/08 03:16:27
    No
    Kiki,Pixie,Worm
    +1
    No probably not, but at least she tried. People shouldn't be so harsh, she was just trying to accomplish something!! When you fail, get back up :D!
  • paygai1 2012/11/08 02:53:33
    Yes
    paygai1
    +1
    it's her book so she knows what she's talking about for the simple fact that she is the author of her own book if u dont like what she's talkin about then dont read it
  • Azrael-In GOD we trust 2012/11/08 02:11:47
    Yes
    Azrael-In GOD we trust
    +1
    What a bunch of ranters on here!
    Doesn't matter what her name is.
    I'm sure if she's knowledgeable in cooking and putting together foods that she likes, it's simply a book of foods and things she likes. Nothing wrong with that. Not everyone likes the same things. Not everyone likes what I like, but it doesn't bother me. They can take it or leave it.
  • Tennessee3501 2012/11/07 22:58:07
    Yes
    Tennessee3501
    +1
    Pippa's advice is to get naked and invite everbody to come over. Sounds good to me!
  • kate 2012/11/07 21:31:51
    Yes
    kate
    +2
    well,she has worked for the family bussiness so she must know a few things about party organising but if she thinks that just because she's kate middleton's sister she can write a few crap and everyone will go crazy to buy them she's too arrogant!!!
  • DP 2012/11/07 20:51:29
    No
    DP
    +1
    Stay on your back where you belong, you dumpster.
  • ticlo7 2012/11/07 18:12:34
    Yes
    ticlo7
    +2
    She does have experience from the family buisness and almost nobody here has read the book, so who knows if it's good? Just because she's famous doesn't immediately render her a complete idiot.
  • Gloria 2012/11/07 16:46:41
    Yes
    Gloria
    +1
    Surely she knows how to entertain. She's a young & wealthy woman. Her family is in the party planning business. I didn't read the book & it isn't on my wish list because if I have $ I know how to throw a bash.
  • Earl Hickey 2012/11/07 16:17:51 (edited)
    No
    Earl Hickey
    shes a woman

    so naturally she has no freaking idea what she's on about

    i think she ought to change her name to Simpleton
  • Emmy Earl Hi... 2012/11/07 21:38:31
  • Azrael-... Earl Hi... 2012/11/08 02:07:38
    Azrael-In GOD we trust
    +1
    Do you belong to the "He Man Woman Haters Club?"
  • Jackster12 2012/11/07 15:34:52
    Yes
    Jackster12
    +1
    Of course you realize her family made their fortune running a party planning business. And now pipit runs that same business.
  • Rdtourist 2012/11/07 15:07:47
    Yes
    Rdtourist
    +2
    As much as any celebrity writing out side her specialty (being a cute wealthy girl).
  • POWERSHAKER 2012/11/07 15:03:38
    No
    POWERSHAKER
    +2
    She probably doesn't know what she's talking about, but she's pretty none the less. :)
  • kerrtoons 2012/11/07 14:44:43
    Yes
    kerrtoons
    +1
    The next questions are, is it relevant to us, will we buy it and do we care? I agree that I would be happy for her to read selected excerpts to me, but beyond that, who cares?
  • SuperCee 2012/11/07 14:36:02
    No
    SuperCee
    +2
    I'm not sure who this women is!
  • wtw 2012/11/07 14:22:56
    Yes
    wtw
    +1
    I would think!
  • Ashley 2012/11/07 14:20:07
    No
    Ashley
    +1
    Her 15 minutes should be over.
  • David 2012/11/07 13:26:30 (edited)
    No
    David
    +1
    The entire British royalty are just leeches that suck precious government money to fund their stupid fairy tale lives. Valuable contribution to society: 0.
  • seance 2012/11/07 12:51:48
    No
    seance
    +1
    was not sure who she was until i read the paragraph below.
    but you can't let big sis out do you don't you know!
  • Roxxi 2012/11/07 12:46:35
    Yes
    Roxxi
    +1
    Isn't her family in the party/event planning business and the daughters follwed? And run a pretty big corperation in the industry?
  • Avi Rosen 2012/11/07 08:17:50
    No
    Avi Rosen
    +1
    Come on...

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/06/19 01:17:54

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals