Quantcast

MOVIES: Ridley Scott's Hits And Misses: Where Does Robin Hood Fall?

SodaHead Film 2010/05/14 18:01:16
The early word on Ridley Scott’s version of “Robin Hood,” starring his favorite actor Russell Crowe, is mixed. Metacritic gives the film a 62, and Rotten Tomatoes rates it at only 44%. The New York Times praises the film’s cast and impressive set pieces, but bemoans the film’s flat, self-serious tone. A.O. Scott writes, “This Robin is no socialist bandit practicing freelance wealth redistribution, but rather a manly libertarian rebel striking out against high taxes and a big government scheme to trample the ancient liberties of property owners and provincial nobles…So is “Robin Hood” one big medieval tea party? Kind of, though that description makes the movie sound both more fun and more provocative than it actually is.”

Be on the watch for lots of tea party/Robin Hood cross referencing in weeks to come...

Here’s a look at the earlier, less impressive work of stars Russell Crowe, Cate Blanchett and director Ridley Scott.

WATCH Proof Of Life

Russell Crowe burst onto the scene with his performance in “Romper Stomper” and went on to win an Oscar for “Gladiator,” directed by Ridley Scott. Crowe also starred in “Proof of Life,” which not only tanked at the box-office, but also led to an (alleged) on-set romance with co-star Meg Ryan, effectively ending her marriage to Dennis Quaid and miring her in an image-changing scandal from which she never quite recovered.

After getting an Oscar nomination for her work in “Elizabeth,” Cate Blanchett chose to star with Billy Bob Thornton in “Pushing Tin.” There were no Oscar nominations for this one.

WATCH Pushing Tin

Early in his career, director Ridley Scott had one of the most astonishing one-two punches in modern cinema history, with the back-to-back releases of “Alien” and “Blade Runner.” He broke his own streak with “Legend,” featuring a badly miscast Tom Cruise and lots of unicorns.

WATCH Legend

WATCH Robin Hood
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • DavidCech 2010/07/04 11:42:40
    DavidCech
    +1
    dude! 35 bucks that's a lotta scratch unless you know the flick is going to be spectacular. Besides when you pay 3.50 to rent a movie you got your girl in free! and plenty of quiet time on the couch to have fun, you can pause the movie if she is a hottie like my wife and on top of it you can head to the kitchen for a cold beer @ food
  • Superman 2010/05/17 15:50:47
    Superman
    It was superb. Characterization was off the charts. Drama was well built up. And they did a fantastic job of tying a legend/fictional character into actual history - the passing of Richard Lionhearts power to his brother John and the discussion of the Magna Carta.
  • DJ Squid 2010/05/17 14:58:00
    DJ Squid
    my friend saw it and he said it was a good but very long almost as long as avatar
  • it'skrissie!d:) 2010/05/17 11:47:25
    it'skrissie!d:)
    It won't be like the real movie.....I think the cartoon is going to be better than this. real movie cartoon
  • Jen 2010/05/17 09:28:07
    Jen
    I loved Robin Hood the cartoon when I was younger and read the children's book then when I was older I watched Robin Hood: Men In Tights and fell in love. It is like the most epic movie ever! Its hilarious my brother and I used to act out like all the scenes lol and the other day I saw Robin Hood with Russell Crowe with my boyfriend and it was actually good! Like I didn't think I'd be that into it, but I did like gladiator and Robin Hood was good aswell.
    Guys must love it if I actually liked it!
  • daylight 2010/05/17 09:17:07
    daylight
    Robin Hood, who knows the History???? What a joke on people who don't know the true history......................the joke is on you, that is if you don't know
  • bashar 2010/05/17 07:35:27
    bashar
    i love Robin Hood
  • bashar bashar 2010/05/17 07:37:42
  • mstock 2010/05/17 05:47:50
    mstock
    Sounds mildly interesting. I actually do like the cast, so that would the main reason I'd see it. Certainly not for the very tired story that I know has been done better and...looking at other attached names...

    Well, sure I'll see it. Why not? I wouldn't spend my money on it, though. Someone else can pay for my ticket or I'll borrow the dvd some time down the road.
  • Homunculus 2010/05/17 02:56:55
    Homunculus
    Epic fail... I went to see it with my girl last night. Too slow, bad story line, too much set up for the sequel while missing focus on the current story line, too fricken long. And the most unforgivable of all...horrible action scenes and few of them IN AN ACTION MOVIE. Horrible! And whats with the wooden ww2 d-day style landing craft? Stupid. I want my money back dammit! fricken 35+ bucks for two tickets a small popcorn and two waters for a shitty movie. Ugh. We shouldve stayed in the bar next door.
  • DarthDe... Homunculus 2010/05/17 03:26:04
    DarthDefault
    +1
    $35?! That is a good reason to torrent movies from now on.
  • DavidCech DarthDe... 2010/07/04 11:45:05
    DavidCech
    +1
    Yes torrent is great for all the movies u would not dare take a chance at either the theater or the video store. Who knew computers would kick the crap out of the music and acting industry. although the things computers create in movies are pretty nice.
  • DarthDe... DavidCech 2010/07/06 03:51:33
    DarthDefault
    Yes, I still buy movies, and go see them in theaters. Though, where I live, it's still only $10-$15 for a night at the theater (for one person)
  • Superman Homunculus 2010/05/17 15:53:52
    Superman
    You're a moron. It wasn't an action film. It was a drama. A well built drama piecing together the formative situation that created Robin Hood. The story was fantastic. The film well cast. The historical elements perfectly integrated.

    If you want a dumb action flick go see the new Predator movie when it comes out. Leave the intelligent stuff alone.
  • Homunculus Superman 2010/05/17 20:01:04
  • Superman Homunculus 2010/05/17 20:16:23
    Superman
    Uh Richard died after being shot in the neck by a crossbow bolt outside the Château de Châlus-Chabrol in 1199 while holding it under seige.

    Further, it maintains the weak status of John as King and introduces the magna carta which John DOES eventually sign.

    Idiot.

    The fact is the Robin Hood has always been a legend, often told from various points of view with different caricatures of each legendary character. While the shitty Costner movie left out John and important roles like Allen A'Dayle, this movie keeps them intact. Not only that but with the intense political intrigue that occured during the period.

    This film serves as a fantastic warm up to further adventures of the character - in a realistic background.

    About the only thing you have correct is the use of a reverse invasion - this time by the Normans on British soil. The landing craft was an homage to the reverse situation. But if thats the only fault of the film I'll take it.

    I don't think I'll trust the word or opinion of someone that uses an outdated and dimwitted epithet like fag. What are you, a douche in high school?
  • Homunculus Superman 2010/05/17 21:49:23
  • DavidCech Superman 2010/07/04 11:49:46
    DavidCech
    +2
    I often wonder how many people think today's movies are even close to historical truth. funny how today people also think online research actually counts as true research when half the info online is incorrect as well. I enjoy comparing movies today to history to find the errors.
  • Superman DavidCech 2010/07/04 15:26:57
    Superman
    Without actually being at most historical events its literally impossible to completely recreate a situation. So I'm happy when films get close to what we read in history books. And I read a lot of history.

    Anyone that wants complete perfection from films is unreasonable.
  • sm237 2010/05/17 02:30:02
    sm237
    I like Russell Crowe and I always enjoyed the RH story so who cares what the critics say...
  • DavidCech sm237 2010/07/04 11:51:21
    DavidCech
    +1
    Yes. he looks the part of a bad dude and I have enjoyed his part in a few flicks. The rough face helps a lot
  • love 2010/05/17 01:28:18
    love
    jrfnkdsfjsdkfklsdkfldskfl
  • clock 2010/05/17 01:25:39
    clock
    I saw it this weekend. I enjoyed the Kevin Costner version better.
  • Superman clock 2010/05/17 16:03:32
    Superman
    California Robin Hood?
  • Trooping_the_Colour 2010/05/17 01:03:35
    Trooping_the_Colour
    It's only half the story though... this film ends where the legend we all know and love begins.
  • zcberry 2010/05/17 00:07:50
    zcberry
    I am not. I mean how many version they going to keep coming out with. This story has already been done a hundred time over please move on to the next!!!!!!!!
  • CarrieUAAG 2010/05/16 23:33:33
    CarrieUAAG
    Robin of the Hood!!!
  • Libertarian Right 2010/05/16 22:32:31
    Libertarian Right
    +1
    If I want to hear about the exploits of Robin hood, all I have to do is turn on the news! LOL!

    hear exploits robin hood turn news lol

    Sorry, I couldn't help myself!
  • Rachel ~In HP I Trust~ 2010/05/16 21:36:44
    Rachel ~In HP I Trust~
    Aww. I hope when I go see it I'll like it. Critics are wrong alot of the time...
  • dream-hair! 2010/05/16 21:28:50
    dream-hair!
    god no! and we're from la
  • R.P. Bliss.::ρнαɛт::.►Ѳиɛ Ħιт Яαɢɛ Ǫʋιт◄
    I'd definitely see it. I love anything with Cate Blanchett.
  • xMCRx 2010/05/16 20:21:43
    xMCRx
    robin hood makes me proud to be from Nottingham
  • GOODBYE SODAHEAD 2010/05/16 19:46:34
    GOODBYE SODAHEAD
    Why would Hollywood liberal critics like a movie where the main character strikes out against high taxes and out of control government? Had the theme been "screw the rich", they would be talking Oscar.
  • EagleEye 2010/05/16 18:59:35
    EagleEye
    +2
    ....Disaster!
  • Steford doesn't follow 2010/05/16 18:45:36
    Steford doesn't follow
    +1
    What ruined it for ME was the interveiw with Matt (the dweeb) Lauer. Russell said he had a hard time making the film , cause he had to wash his hands SO many times with PURACEL anti- biotic soap. WHAT A PUSS!
  • Ken "Don't tread on me!" 2010/05/16 18:07:43
    Ken "Don't tread on me!"
    I liked the new "Robin Hood" much more than the critics. I have seen it given between 2 and 3 stars (out of 4), while my personal grade would be 3½ stars. The only area in which I would short it would be in a sort of "choppiness," because it jumps between three separate parts of the plot to tell the story -- and also the final scene which has Cate Blanchett's "Marion" fighting like a knight, which was far-fetched to say the least.
  • Catita 2010/05/16 17:56:15
    Catita
    never liked this russell crowe, therefore is no way on hearth I will go to the movies or rent it.
  • sakljdadjslfkj 2010/05/16 17:49:58
    sakljdadjslfkj
    +1
    I saw it, totally sucked.
  • Sallana 2010/05/16 15:41:40
  • Raindropkitten™~the author ... 2010/05/16 15:41:36
    Raindropkitten™~the author of þhαετ~
    I have yet to see it and I can't wait. I don't ever listen to movie reviews because more than half of the time they hate everything that I find good and praise the movies that I think don't deserve half the attention they get.

    And hey, Legend was a great movie and Tom Cruise did a great job in it.

Entertainment

2013/05/22 19:55:03

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals