Quantcast

Mariah Carey Named As American Idol Judge. Yay or Nay?

jt 2012/07/25 07:59:27
Yay
Nay
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Quazimoto 2012/08/03 16:08:01
    Nay
    Quazimoto
    I would have to watch to care!!!!!!!
  • Tin Man 2012/07/29 21:53:21
    Yay
    Tin Man
    Wow, great pics, guess you're a fan. Ha,ha...ha. I think she'll make a good judge. I'm a fan too. But like others also will miss the often dourer Simon.
  • ttfndude 2012/07/28 03:14:57
    Nay
    ttfndude
    +1
    I was reading all the comments and someone said they didn't care if the muppets were judges....and I agree how awesome would that boring show be with Walter and Statler as judges!!! I would totally watch!
  • ☆stillthe12c☆ 2012/07/28 00:56:25
    Yay
    ☆stillthe12c☆
    Why Not?
  • Claybern 2012/07/27 20:40:56
    Yay
    Claybern
    She is hot.
  • RobbyRhodes88 2012/07/26 07:21:33
    Yay
    RobbyRhodes88
    +1
    Mariah Carey is my #1 or #2 female artist of all time. I have loved her music since I was around 5 (I'm 24 now), and have always had her in my life growing up. While it's great she's going to be seen on television every week, I haven't watched Idol since season 7. And this news will not have me tuning in - after the first week out of curiosity.
  • Triniti 2012/07/25 23:01:37
    Nay
    Triniti
    +1
    It has nothing to do with her, it's i just don't watch tv i work to much, and actually I gave my tv to my daughter when she went to college so I have no tv..
  • brittany 2012/07/25 22:28:32
    Yay
    brittany
    +1
    but i wouldnt look at the show anyhow.
  • RepubliTurd Hater 2012/07/25 21:24:11
    Nay
    RepubliTurd Hater
    +1
    Don't care about Americon Idle, it's dumb
  • jt Republi... 2012/07/25 22:48:55
    jt
    I was basically asking about her? lol
  • Ron in Oregon 2012/07/25 20:31:08
    Nay
    Ron in Oregon
    +1
    I voted nay because I do not care if they have the Muppets as judges.
  • Shonny 2012/07/25 19:05:20 (edited)
    Yay
    Shonny
    +1
    At least she is a Real artist. I think she'll do good as a judge.
    Most of the people auditioning are young and I think, as the pics indicate above, she will relate to young aspiring artist very well.
  • jackibuck 2012/07/25 18:13:47
    Yay
    jackibuck
    +1
    I don't watch American Idol, but Mariah Carey can carry a tune for sure. I think she'll make a good judge.
  • mustangluver 2012/07/25 18:12:41
    Yay
    mustangluver
    +1
    Since i have been a huge fan since her day one, i say yes yes yes. She has everything it takes to be a judge.
  • jujunme 2012/07/25 18:06:20
    Yay
    jujunme
    +2
    Quit watching Idol 2 years ago so, IMO in doesn't matter who becomes a judge Mariah's a great vocalist and a professional, so why not?
  • greg 2012/07/25 17:09:35
    Nay
    greg
    +1
    i can hear the final nail being driven into the idol coffin. AHH there is a heaven
  • Kingarthurup 2012/07/25 17:02:23
    Nay
    Kingarthurup
    +1
    just one more idiot not to watch between pig hollering contests
  • Caedus01 Sith Lord of the P... 2012/07/25 16:13:17
    Nay
    Caedus01 Sith Lord of the PHAET
    +1
    Maybe its time to realize that it had its run and pull the the plug. I'm just saying
  • eminemfan 2012/07/25 16:03:57
    Nay
    eminemfan
    +1
    im NEVER wacthing American Idol ever agan i hate her >:(
  • ajracestables1 2012/07/25 16:01:36
    Yay
    ajracestables1
    +1
    Does it matter? I am not much for American Idol.
  • L.A. woman 2012/07/25 14:55:19
    Nay
    L.A. woman
    +1
    Perhaps she can do for it what she did for Sparkle or whatever that movie was that she opened on Sept 11....Go away Idol
  • Conniespk 2012/07/25 14:06:25
    Nay
    Conniespk
  • fabobsesson 2012/07/25 14:04:03
    Nay
    fabobsesson
    +2
    I didn't think American Idol could get any worse.... wow
  • gaylehelen 2012/07/25 12:59:56
    Nay
    gaylehelen
    +1
    Never watched so I don't care.
  • Black_Rose 2012/07/25 12:40:08
    Nay
    Black_Rose
    +1
    I stopped watching after Simon left.
  • Brian 2012/07/25 12:12:55
    Nay
    Brian
    +1
    Couldn't care less very tired of all the Idol worship, and I'm not talking about the show. crowds of people going Nuts  over a movie stars
  • raine 2012/07/25 12:08:29
    Nay
    raine
    +1
    Not important to me either way really. I don't like the show
  • Racefish 2012/07/25 11:58:10
    Yay
    Racefish
    +1
    Nick could give her some pointers on judging since he's on AGT. I think she'd be great.
  • tff~PWCM~JLA 2012/07/25 10:18:15 (edited)
    Nay
    tff~PWCM~JLA
    +2
    I've got15 year old chuck's smarter than her. The sad thing is she thinks she's still a sexy "little" number when she's turned into a dumb-ass guernsey cow! Nick Cannon say's he's financially in love!
  • eminemfan tff~PWC... 2012/07/25 16:07:18
    eminemfan
    +1
    hahaha i couldn't agree more she tries way too hard.
  • tff~PWC... eminemfan 2012/07/25 16:16:01
    tff~PWCM~JLA
    +2
    It's a good thing someone else writes her songs for her! I truly wonder if she can read or write!
  • eminemfan tff~PWC... 2012/07/25 16:34:12
    eminemfan
    +1
    ahahaha!!! oh me too 90% of the things that come out of her mouth are ridiculously stupid, i like the way you think :)
  • Kaola 2012/07/25 09:20:54
    Yay
    Kaola
    +1
    Like her and she is good at it
  • Harjot 2012/07/25 09:12:23
    Yay
    Harjot
  • edlie 2012/07/25 09:11:50
    Yay
    edlie
    +2
    why not? i think she's as talented as jennifer lopez!



    mariah carey
  • 'Zedd 2012/07/25 08:47:48
  • mrdog 2012/07/25 08:14:24
    Yay
    mrdog
    +2
    Gal is just as good as the others on this stupid show.... hello America...this is a waste of time.... find a life.... go fishing...watch paint dry....do something...bark
  • jt mrdog 2012/07/25 08:16:17
    jt
    +2
    Hahaha..this all part of life ... lol
  • sarahholmwood 2012/07/25 08:06:35
    Yay
    sarahholmwood
    +2
    If it's wrong to love you, then my heart just won't let me be right ♪
    I'd give my all to have just one more night with you ♫

    you gotta love her!
  • Dzeeng 2012/07/25 08:04:03
    Yay
    Dzeeng

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/24 17:32:43

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals