Mariah Carey in 'Serious Talks' to Join 'American Idol': Would She Be a Good Judge on the Show?

by The Big Question Posted 2012/07/14 00:48:20

Related Topics: American Idol, Judge, Mariah Carey, Mariah, Idol, Carey, Join, celebtv, American

Read More

209 votes
Read all 74 opinions
Lightning Report View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Yes	138 votes	66%
	No	71 votes	34%

Add a comment above

Elisa ✦ Knockout™ 2012/07/14 16:47:31 (edited)

Yes

+3
Anything to not here J-hoe say vibrato.
>> See Replies

More polls by The Big Question

jeremy catastrophe 2012/07/18 22:36:27

No

you know who'd be better?
satan

reply
weirdchickalert 2012/07/17 08:17:52

No

because well she do what paula does...and get emotional on every show

reply
YOUR EARTH ANGEL'S REDEMPTION 2012/07/15 09:05:42

Yes

I love her.

reply
Johnny 2012/07/15 01:26:26

Yes

with eminem on her side hahaha

reply
JERSEYDUDE 2012/07/15 01:18:27

Yes

better than that b***h named Jennifer and MUCH better than whatever that gay guys name is that the sodahead public picked on a pervious similar question

reply
Alethia 2012/07/15 00:55:42

Yes

She's got the credentials and the potential draw.

reply
mae 2012/07/15 00:12:22

Yes

She would be a great choice.

reply
amysmeade 2012/07/14 23:42:14

Yes

I hope see will be mean

reply
Charmaine 2012/07/14 23:36:55

Yes

She would do okay, HER MUSIC SUCKS THOUGH!!!

reply
mikewonaus 2012/07/14 23:14:36

Yes

Of course she'd be a great judge! [But when we actually ever tune into American Idol, please, pull the plug!]

reply
Jimmy Z 2012/07/14 23:08:12

No

Better than Adam Lambert, but no.

reply
jaxn-butterfly 2012/07/14 21:49:08 (edited)

Yes

HELL YEAH! Do you know who she is?

THE VOICE!

reply
banzaibuckaroo 2012/07/14 20:17:37

Yes

But they need to hire another anal retentive. grumpy British person.

reply
Dime Bag Bruce (JSC) 2012/07/14 19:57:51

Yes

she is awesome

reply
RawRsaurus 2012/07/14 19:31:45

Yes

She can shatter glass with that vocal range.

reply
SJG 2012/07/14 19:11:41

No

Entirely too stupid!

reply
lurx: the soda jerk 2012/07/14 19:04:01

No

reply
Amy.[: 2012/07/14 18:59:36

Yes

i think so

reply
joe 2012/07/14 18:47:56

Yes

Very qualified

reply
MOMMA THOMAS 2012/07/14 18:43:32

Yes

YES!

reply
frank 2012/07/14 18:40:13

Yes

I think Mariah will make a good judge

reply
Horace Nick 2012/07/14 18:28:31

Yes

She's be a good contestant i'm sure.

reply
Medulla Oblongata 2012/07/14 18:21:26

No

Honestly, I'm just waiting for Randy to quit and walk away. I prefer The Voice, anyway, even if Christina is a self-righteous diva-bitch.

reply
SJG to Medulla... 2012/07/14 19:12:07

Yea, but don't you like her boobs?

reply
Medulla... to SJG 2012/07/15 02:38:20

No. That's another reason why I don't like Christina: the cleavage-baring outfits. And, well, the obvious lack of support her boobs have, too.

reply
SJG to Medulla... 2012/07/15 15:36:57

Geeezz. I never met and anti-boob person before.

reply
Medulla... to SJG 2012/07/15 16:59:49

I'm not anti-boob. I'm anti-Christina Aguilera. There's a difference.

reply
SJG to Medulla... 2012/07/15 19:09:52

I stand corrected!

reply
Katt 2012/07/14 18:19:35

Yes

As much as I love Jennifer Lopez I think Mariah Carey is a wayyy.......better choice.

reply
Max7 2012/07/14 17:47:07

Yes

+1
There's no denying, she does know music and talent.

reply
Papillon 2012/07/14 17:45:56
Music Addict ♫ 2012/07/14 17:00:33

Yes

+1
Maybe. At least she can actually sing.

reply
Elisa ✦ Knockout™ 2012/07/14 16:47:31 (edited)

Yes

+3
Anything to not here J-hoe say vibrato.

reply
Papillon to Elisa ✦... 2012/07/14 17:47:10

+1
J-hoe! HAHAHAHA!

reply
Elisa ✦... to Papillon 2012/07/14 18:19:10

+3
Lol it's true atleast for me Mariah Carey is far more inspiring then J-hoe. Atleast for me Mariah deserves more credablity and deserves her title as diva. As for J-hoe no comment, SERIOUSLY.

reply
тrisʜɑ to Elisa ✦... 2012/07/14 19:18:08

+1
I agree! :)

reply
adeenmc... to Elisa ✦... 2012/07/14 21:14:25

I agree.

reply
L1 2012/07/14 16:25:02

Yes

She could be. Who knows? I'd wait and see.....

reply
BlackwinterG36C 2012/07/14 16:09:15

Yes

+1
She's a good replacement for Paula Abdul. Because all American Idol is........."That was bangin dog!" "That song was SO special" "That was asolutely THE worst singing I've heard today. Have you EVER sung in your life before coming here?"

reply
Tigger Too 2012/07/14 15:42:40

Yes

+1
I think Mariah Carey would be a GREAT addition to the judging panel of "American Idol." Of course, I think this show may be on its last leg, with Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler leaving, and there are even whispers that Randy Jackson may be bidding adieu to the program. The last couple of years, AI has gotten pretty irrelevant. Winning contestants have gone on to be...nobodies. The caliber of the performances has gone downhill, and the show isn't the ratings juggernaut it used to be. If the producers have any brains at all, they'll cancel the show after next season and give it a decent burial in syndication. AI has run its course, and then some.

reply