Quantcast

Justin Bieber Tops Billboard's '21 Under 21' List: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?

SodaHead Slideshows 2012/09/20 15:00:00

SLIDESHOW: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?

One Direction
2 of 8

One Direction

The boy band comes in second place on Billboard's list, after recently winning Best New Artist at MTV's Video Music Awards. But they kind of sound like every other boy band to us...
  1. Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber

    The Biebs is the "hottest minor" under 21, according to Billboard.com's annual "21 Under 21" list. Quick: Do you know any of his songs other than "Baby"?

  2. One Direction

    One Direction

    The boy band comes in second place on Billboard's list, after recently winning Best New Artist at MTV's Video Music Awards. But they kind of sound like every other boy band to us...

  3. Demi Lovato

    Demi Lovato

    The brand-new "X Factor" judge comes in third place on Billboard's list, and even those of us who aren't teeny-boppers will admit that "Give Your Heart a Break" is catchy.

  4. Scotty McCreery

    Scotty McCreery

    The country cutie and 2011 "American Idol" winner is only 18, but he's already revered for his trademark deep voice. He comes in fourth place on Billboard's list.

  5. Selena Gomez

    Selena Gomez

    Bieber's "girlfriend" ranks five slots below him in sixth place, but he'd better look out -- with a new perfume and more grown-up movies on the way, Selena's star is on the rise.

  6. Nick Jonas

    Nick Jonas

    Coming in 10th place on Billboard's list, the Jonas Brother has appeared on Broadway this year. That said, we've never understood the appeal of any of the Jonas Brothers (or been able to tell them apart).

  7. Miley Cyrus

    Miley Cyrus

    Miley ranks all the way down at No. 18 on Billboard's list -- maybe thanks to that (frightening) haircut?

  8. Victoria Justice

    Victoria Justice

    Justice takes the No. 21 spot on Billboard's list -- but have you ever watched an episode of "Victorious"? Neither have we.

Justin Bieber Tops Billboard's '21 Under 21' List: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Justin Bieber is the "hottest minor" under 21, according to Billboard.com's annual "21 Under 21" list. Really? We know he's had two No. 1 albums over the past 12 months, but think fast: Do you know any of his songs other than "Baby"?

The Biebs' "girlfriend" Selena Gomez ranks five slots below him, in sixth place, but he'd better look out -- with a new perfume and more grown-up movies on the way, Selena's star is on the rise.

Meanwhile, One Direction is hot on Bieber's heels in second place, after recently winning Best New Artist at MTV's Video Music Awards. But they kind of sound like every other boy band to us ... meanwhile, Miley Cyrus ranks all the way down at No. 18 -- maybe thanks to that (frightening) haircut?

From Bieber to Selena to Miley, click through our slideshow and let us know: Who is the most overrated "Under 21" star?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Stacy F 2012/09/20 17:22:23
    Justin Bieber
    Stacy F
    +16
    And, now he gets to top THIS list, too!
    He's an effeminate little prissy, with no talent to speak of, whatsoever.
    Best performance he ever did was when he got SHOT DEAD on "CSI"... and EVERYBODY wanted some of that action!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Goducks5 2013/02/17 03:20:29
    Justin Bieber
    Goducks5
    +1
    He sucks.
  • The Rock n' Roller Chick 2013/02/16 19:51:48
    Justin Bieber
    The Rock n' Roller Chick
    All of them!
  • ShaySceneDeletion 2013/02/09 18:32:31
    Justin Bieber
    ShaySceneDeletion
    Very accurate
  • hjgb 2012/10/24 18:38:35
    One Direction
    hjgb
    One Direction y Miley Cyrus ♥
  • Bianca 2012/10/10 01:00:30
    One Direction
    Bianca
    Guys, Guys, Guys. Get your heads together. ITS ONE DIRECTION. BIGGEST BOY-BAND EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Dave 007 2012/10/02 02:09:23
    Demi Lovato
    Dave 007
    Where is the "All of the above" choice?
  • Chris 2012/09/28 21:33:24
    Miley Cyrus
    Chris
    +1
    i meant to put jb.... jb is gay meme comic
  • Tre 2012/09/28 13:27:09
    Justin Bieber
    Tre
    +1
    I don't have Bieber Fever.
  • Sheree 2012/09/28 08:34:02
    Selena Gomez
    Sheree
    Honestly I have nothing against her, she's a pretty good actress but her singing is just average and yet people act as if she's the next Christina Aguilera or something.
  • andre.milagrosa 2012/09/26 20:58:53
    Justin Bieber
    andre.milagrosa
    he isn't that bad an artist, but he is way too overrated.
  • nick drake 2012/09/26 11:07:42
  • JayyLoves 2012/09/25 15:38:35
    One Direction
    JayyLoves
    It was a tough pick for me between 1D and JB but I though about it and thought about this girl in my fifth hour going on the whole hour about one direction and I see so many one direction fanfictions, its like holy canole!
  • NJ 2012/09/25 12:16:11
    Justin Bieber
    NJ
    +1
    Were the hell is the All Of These option ?
  • Jess123 2012/09/25 04:10:39
    One Direction
    Jess123
    I like one direction not because I'm some crazy chick but because of their music. I also like JB too.
  • duns 2012/09/25 01:54:14
    Justin Bieber
    duns
    Oh please...
  • Lorelinx 2012/09/24 22:39:48
    Justin Bieber
    Lorelinx
    Sorreh Belibers, but Justin needs to hit puberty. His voice sounds like a girl. And I couldn't even hear him on his song, "Boyfriend". And if he's a celebrity for that horrible singing, then my friend Vainavi should be a celebrity too, and she sings like a dying cat. Literally. And who's Scotty McCreery and Nick Jonas? Sorreh, I'm not good with names.
  • travis 2012/09/24 22:23:33
    Justin Bieber
    travis
    justine beaver of course and maybe one direction theyre both gay
  • Jim 2012/09/24 22:05:04
    Justin Bieber
    Jim
    Every d@mn one of them! We haven't seen real "STARS" in decades! A few old timers, like Harrison Ford, hung in there long past their prime but, they were stars of another time. These young twits are nothing but manufactured psy-op marketing icons.
  • cms1978 2012/09/24 22:03:06
    Justin Bieber
    cms1978
    yep I do
  • Ninou 2012/09/24 20:38:00
    Justin Bieber
    Ninou
    What about Conor Maynard?
  • Lashawn W 2012/09/24 18:51:11
    Justin Bieber
    Lashawn W
    This little boy makes me SICK.... funny thing is I dont know WHY!!
  • darkgami.mitchell 2012/09/24 17:35:55
    Justin Bieber
    darkgami.mitchell
    scroll down slowly, be amazed that he looks so much like a girl. Then you spot that rainbow behind him LOL
  • Thomas 2012/09/24 10:46:48
    Justin Bieber
    Thomas
    This kid is the biggest D Bag that we have been over exposed too. He is a one hot wonder and will fade in next year or so.
  • El Prez 2012/09/24 10:06:07
    Justin Bieber
    El Prez
    His time is coming to an end. His mom is selling an expose book. That is usually a cry for help! Soon his poor voice and limited abilities will be evident to all and he will fade away, like summer dew.
  • SundayS... El Prez 2012/09/24 13:13:02
  • El Prez SundayS... 2012/09/24 21:24:02
    El Prez
    Maybe but I stand by my opinion and prediction. No reflection on your taste. We all like someone that many other dislike at some time in our lives. You are entitled. i just don't care for him.
  • SundayS... El Prez 2012/09/25 13:41:27
    SundayStoleYourCookieDough
    That's the nicest response to my differing opinion I've ever had. o3o Thanks for not being a dick. (:
  • El Prez SundayS... 2012/09/25 18:51:24
    El Prez
    Hey, it's opinions we are expressing not the absolute "word" as some people seem to believe. Who knows, this guy might just hang around and become another Frank Sinatra of his age.
  • SundayS... El Prez 2012/09/26 12:24:50
    SundayStoleYourCookieDough
    Exactly. I like you. o3o

    And oui, that does have a chance of happening, it's my personal opinion that he's not quite THAT good but he's a better singer than most in the business~
  • bruk 2012/09/24 06:26:55
    Selena Gomez
    bruk
    kid pelse stop crray
  • SundayS... bruk 2012/09/25 13:41:35
    SundayStoleYourCookieDough
    ...hm?
  • Nickolie 2012/09/23 22:37:29
    Justin Bieber
    Nickolie
    Does anyone else find it ironic that theirs a rainbow behind him?
  • Somkey the Hores 2012/09/23 19:38:12
    Justin Bieber
    Somkey the Hores
    +3
    I don't pay attention to kiddy stars.
  • Mr. Won... Somkey ... 2012/09/24 16:24:03
    Mr. Wonderful
    +1
    Its hard not to notice Bieber, since he's way over exposed. I guess he's more a creature of Youtube, was "discovered" on that medium and you know the rest of the story.

    I got some years on me so I remember other teen "stars" that actually had some talent could sing, not be tone deaf, and didn't hurt my ears listening to like Rickey Nelson, David Cassidey, others, a long list. The sad reality is aside from what teen and pre teen girls like in the way of looks department, sorry Beep, your singing voice is about on a par with me singing in the shower and your muscial "talent" badly faking you know how to play several musical instruments is sub par and that's being kind.

    That said, he seems like a nice enough kid trying to grow up in the spotlight, doesn't appear to be into drugs or other bad conduct, he seems to be handling his star status quite well considering his young years. As always, much of the negative comments are coming from JEALOUS posters. I'm just being objective. He's just another kid that got lucky. He'd be a damn fool not to milk his brief time in the limelight for whatever he can get out of it. I would, and so would everyone else reading this... if you were given the opportunity.
  • Cunning... Somkey ... 2012/09/25 11:24:59
    Cunning Stunts
    I had a weak spot once. The boys from Silverchair.

    When teen idols were kings.

  • Let'sGoToLondon 2012/09/23 18:10:43
    Selena Gomez
    Let'sGoToLondon
    +1
    ALL OF THEMMM!!! What the heck?
  • Who wants a cupcake? 2012/09/23 15:06:25
    Justin Bieber
    Who wants a cupcake?
    Selena and Justin. many ppl think selena is pretty many ppl think justin is gay when they both went out more ppl started 2 talk about them : /
    Selena and Justin. many ppl think selena is pretty many ppl think justin is gay when they both went out more ppl started 2 talk about them : / slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin slena and justin
    (more)
  • Vikki 2012/09/23 13:35:14
    Justin Bieber
    Vikki
    +1
    I am so tired of hearing about this kid. I don't even hate him or his music, I'm just tired of seeing his face whenever I bring up my Mozilla Firefox because Yahoo is my homepage -.-
  • Oreo 2012/09/23 07:35:43
    Justin Bieber
    Oreo
    +1
    he is just horrible!
  • Mini Twuby 2012/09/23 05:47:05
    Justin Bieber
    Mini Twuby
    +1
    2nd One Direction O.O I really don't like their music either O.O!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/22 02:14:43

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals