Quantcast

Justin Bieber Tops Billboard's '21 Under 21' List: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?

SodaHead Slideshows 2012/09/20 15:00:00

SLIDESHOW: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?

Justin Bieber
1 of 8

Justin Bieber

The Biebs is the "hottest minor" under 21, according to Billboard.com's annual "21 Under 21" list. Quick: Do you know any of his songs other than "Baby"?
  1. Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber

    The Biebs is the "hottest minor" under 21, according to Billboard.com's annual "21 Under 21" list. Quick: Do you know any of his songs other than "Baby"?

  2. One Direction

    One Direction

    The boy band comes in second place on Billboard's list, after recently winning Best New Artist at MTV's Video Music Awards. But they kind of sound like every other boy band to us...

  3. Demi Lovato

    Demi Lovato

    The brand-new "X Factor" judge comes in third place on Billboard's list, and even those of us who aren't teeny-boppers will admit that "Give Your Heart a Break" is catchy.

  4. Scotty McCreery

    Scotty McCreery

    The country cutie and 2011 "American Idol" winner is only 18, but he's already revered for his trademark deep voice. He comes in fourth place on Billboard's list.

  5. Selena Gomez

    Selena Gomez

    Bieber's "girlfriend" ranks five slots below him in sixth place, but he'd better look out -- with a new perfume and more grown-up movies on the way, Selena's star is on the rise.

  6. Nick Jonas

    Nick Jonas

    Coming in 10th place on Billboard's list, the Jonas Brother has appeared on Broadway this year. That said, we've never understood the appeal of any of the Jonas Brothers (or been able to tell them apart).

  7. Miley Cyrus

    Miley Cyrus

    Miley ranks all the way down at No. 18 on Billboard's list -- maybe thanks to that (frightening) haircut?

  8. Victoria Justice

    Victoria Justice

    Justice takes the No. 21 spot on Billboard's list -- but have you ever watched an episode of "Victorious"? Neither have we.

Justin Bieber Tops Billboard's '21 Under 21' List: Most Overrated Under-21 Star?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Justin Bieber is the "hottest minor" under 21, according to Billboard.com's annual "21 Under 21" list. Really? We know he's had two No. 1 albums over the past 12 months, but think fast: Do you know any of his songs other than "Baby"?

The Biebs' "girlfriend" Selena Gomez ranks five slots below him, in sixth place, but he'd better look out -- with a new perfume and more grown-up movies on the way, Selena's star is on the rise.

Meanwhile, One Direction is hot on Bieber's heels in second place, after recently winning Best New Artist at MTV's Video Music Awards. But they kind of sound like every other boy band to us ... meanwhile, Miley Cyrus ranks all the way down at No. 18 -- maybe thanks to that (frightening) haircut?

From Bieber to Selena to Miley, click through our slideshow and let us know: Who is the most overrated "Under 21" star?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Stacy F 2012/09/20 17:22:23
    Justin Bieber
    Stacy F
    +16
    And, now he gets to top THIS list, too!
    He's an effeminate little prissy, with no talent to speak of, whatsoever.
    Best performance he ever did was when he got SHOT DEAD on "CSI"... and EVERYBODY wanted some of that action!

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Allen 2012/09/20 18:47:08
    Justin Bieber
    Allen
    +2
    Justin Bieber doesn't even write most of his songs, yet he gets all the credit. He's essentially a puppet who's paid to do whatever his management team tells him to. Yes, his songs are catchy, but he shouldn't get that much credit for them. Give some credit to the actual writers and producers of these songs for once.
  • Lordoftheringsrox 2012/09/20 18:46:22
    Demi Lovato
    Lordoftheringsrox
    I'm a fan of Miranda Cosgrove over Demi and Selena. Demi and Selena both got cocky in my opinion.
  • thє вluє wαndєrєr 2012/09/20 18:42:32 (edited)
  • J.MaisOui thє вlu... 2012/09/20 19:19:19
    J.MaisOui
    +1
    Shes under 21? ...she looks about 40.
  • thє вlu... J.MaisOui 2012/09/20 19:39:04
  • glass_butterfly ~YSU~ 2012/09/20 18:42:06
    One Direction
    glass_butterfly ~YSU~
  • Kigan 2012/09/20 18:41:54
    Justin Bieber
    Kigan
    As overrated as many or all of the rest combined.
  • Emily Barrington 2012/09/20 18:21:08
    Justin Bieber
    Emily Barrington
    They are all :S
  • andrew.micheals.353 2012/09/20 18:19:42
    Miley Cyrus
    andrew.micheals.353
    +1
    I haven't even heard of most of them that shows my age.
  • Osk The... andrew.... 2012/09/20 18:33:14 (edited)
    Osk The Great Guru
    +1
    I am 2 ages older and I know all except for 1... guess you need to read the gossip more ;-) OR date someone that has kids
  • Alexander T Steward 2012/09/20 18:17:21
    Justin Bieber
    Alexander T Steward
    +3
    God forbid he'll be the most overrated star over 21 in a few years.
  • adeenmc... Alexand... 2012/09/20 19:52:32
    adeenmckenziekennedy
    I don't think he would last very long. He is just a tween idol. Nothing more nothing less. He will be forgotten in 30 years.
  • Maya Za... Alexand... 2012/09/20 22:53:04 (edited)
    Maya Zauberman
    The horror...
    Oh God
    Just the thought of him lasting for another year
    Irritating the f***k out of me with his horrific "singing"
    Sends my brain into a cataclysm of extreme
    Agony, disillusionment and despair
  • Ana Novaković 2012/09/20 18:15:52
    Justin Bieber
    Ana Novaković
    +2
    My answer is: ALL OF ABOVE (stupid little posers)!! Justin looks so gay ewhhh!!
  • adeenmc... Ana Nov... 2012/09/20 20:02:18
    adeenmckenziekennedy
    +2
    I know right. Don't worry Justin Bieber will fade away in a few years time. He will be forgotten in 30 years time. He wouldn't become a legend.
    P.S. Most of the singers listed are not real musicians in the sense of the word. They use autotune to make their voice sound better. They can't play an musical instrument or sing without autotune.
  • teamboo... adeenmc... 2012/09/20 20:30:25
    teamboobooseth
    +1
    Scotty McCreery can play guitair and I believe he doesn't use any auto tone.
  • adeenmc... teamboo... 2012/09/20 20:40:00
    adeenmckenziekennedy
    I said ''most'' not all.
    I don't know who Scott McCreery is. Is he a Country singer? If he is, then I wouldn't know because I don't listen to Country music.
  • teamboo... adeenmc... 2012/09/20 20:57:33
    teamboobooseth
    Yeah he's country.
  • adeenmc... teamboo... 2012/09/20 21:45:54
    adeenmckenziekennedy
    Oh I see. I am not going to lie but I am going to check him out on youtube to see if he is good.
  • adeenmc... teamboo... 2012/09/20 21:49:21
    adeenmckenziekennedy
    Wow this guy is very very talented. I like his voice and he can actually play a musical instrument.
  • Lucy Krueger 2012/09/20 18:12:34
    One Direction
    Lucy Krueger
  • heartsonfire 2012/09/20 18:05:12
    Justin Bieber
    heartsonfire
    +2
    None of them are really that special to me.
  • Osk The Great Guru 2012/09/20 17:58:29
    Justin Bieber
    Osk The Great Guru
    +1
    I don't think Victoria Justice should be on the list
  • Alexand... Osk The... 2012/09/20 18:20:33
    Alexander T Steward
    +2
    Yeah she's just been lumped in because she's a young preformer. The difference between her and JB is she's an OK singer.
  • devil bitch 2012/09/20 17:52:23
    Justin Bieber
    devil bitch
    out of all these choices i think Scotty McCreery is the best.. i <3 country music and hes cute
  • teamboo... devil b... 2012/09/20 20:31:26
    teamboobooseth
    He's the best.
  • devil b... teamboo... 2012/09/21 18:17:08
    devil bitch
    Scotty is amazing, if i cud meet him i wud die
  • teamboo... devil b... 2012/09/21 19:59:21
    teamboobooseth
    Me too. He has an AMAZING voice.
  • devil b... teamboo... 2012/09/25 17:50:02
    devil bitch
    Hes sexy as hell.. i wud love to be with that
  • teamboo... devil b... 2012/09/29 14:14:41
    teamboobooseth
    Me too
  • Kat 2012/09/20 17:44:14
    One Direction
    Kat
    +1
    All of them.
  • Stacy F 2012/09/20 17:22:23
    Justin Bieber
    Stacy F
    +16
    And, now he gets to top THIS list, too!
    He's an effeminate little prissy, with no talent to speak of, whatsoever.
    Best performance he ever did was when he got SHOT DEAD on "CSI"... and EVERYBODY wanted some of that action!

  • J.MaisOui Stacy F 2012/09/20 19:25:44
    J.MaisOui
    +2
    Lol.... Meanie !! :0)
  • Terranc... Stacy F 2012/09/21 17:34:31
    Terrance Earle
    +2
    I don't know why I like watching that scene over and over. Perhaps it happens to deal with the disappearance of an annoying pubescent singer. Not that I'd want him to go out in a hail of bullets or anything. Just go somewhere else.
  • Jenni Stacy F 2012/09/21 23:54:05
    Jenni
    No talent whatsoever? Bully. His songs aren't that great, but he can sing.
  • Stacy F Jenni 2012/09/22 02:13:32
    Stacy F
    +2
    Are you saying that because you genuinely believe he has talent... or, because you're only 14?
    Young lady, I have been around far longer than you, and I have seen, and HEARD, REAL talent. If you want to hear some great talent, try Charlotte Church, or some of Frank Sinatra's old stuff. Maybe even some Harry Connick, Jr.
    But, hey, don't take my word for it... I listen to everything from AC/DC and Led Zepplin, to Toby Keith, Brad Paisley, and Trace Adkins.
    I'm eclectic, I listen to almost everything. Rock, blues, classical, opera, country, jazz, funk... Like I said almost everything. EXCEPT "gangsta" rap, that crap sucks!

    And, I don't listen to Justin Bieber, because he has no genuine talent. He sounds just like most of the other "has-beens" out there that got into the music industry before their first pube sprouted.

    But, you are entitled to your opinion.
  • Jenni Stacy F 2012/09/24 07:43:57
    Jenni
    I'm not saying that he is as talented as vocal legends. I listen to just about everything, old stuff included. Some of my favorite singers include Ella Fitzgerald, Etta James, Patti labelle, Cher, and endless others. I am in no way comparing bieber to them. But it bothers me when people make such a big deal out of him. You're entitled to your opinion as well. But, he does have a voice, and I don't think it's terrible. He does make use of some modern vocal stylistics such as riffs, runs, curls, etc. Not to mention his vocal range is pretty impressive. Overall he has a decent voice, and despite the negativity people spread about him, if he lacked talent then why would Usher and Justin Timberlake both fight to sign him? If you look at his covers from when he was a child, you can see he truly was/is talented. I don't listen to his music, but all I'm saying is those who say he has no talent obviously haven't listened to singers who truly have no talent. (Selena Gomez, William hung, and in my opinion, nicki minaj.)
  • darkgam... Stacy F 2012/09/24 17:38:40
    darkgami.mitchell
    +1
    ROFL!!! I think they should have mad that longer XD I was about to make some popcorn and enjoy the hell out of this.
  • Stacy F darkgam... 2012/09/26 16:19:16

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/26 06:08:33

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals