Quantcast

Jay-Z Called 'Overrated': Who Is the Most Overrated Music Star?

SodaHead Slideshows 2011/08/18 15:15:58

SLIDESHOW: Who Is the Most Overrated Music Star?

Justin Bieber
8 of 8

Justin Bieber

The big question: Will Bieber still be popular when he's not a "Baby" anymore?
  1. Jay-Z

    Jay-Z

    It hasn't been a good week for Jay-Z. First, he lost Rolling Stone's "King of Hip-Hop" title to Eminem. Then, pop singer Sabrina said he was "overrated."

  2. Beyonce

    Beyonce

    Beyonce is both beautiful and talented … but comparing her to Michael Jackson is a stretch.

  3. Lady Gaga

    Lady Gaga

    Gaga is definitely original and she really can sing, but some critics say she's just a weirder version of Madonna.

  4. Rihanna

    Rihanna

    Rihanna is the queen of auto-tune, and sometimes it does sound like a robot is singing her songs.

  5. Jennifer Lopez

    Jennifer Lopez

    We love looking at J-Lo, but who decided she was a talented enough singer to judge "American Idol"?

  6. Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift

    Critics have slammed Swift's live performances, including her duet with Stevie Nicks at the 2010 Grammys. However, we think she -- and her songs -- are very cute.

  7. Katy Perry

    Katy Perry

    Perry knows how to have fun with a pop song, but sometimes we want to blow our brains out after listening to "California Gurls."

  8. Justin Bieber

    Justin Bieber

    The big question: Will Bieber still be popular when he's not a "Baby" anymore?

Jay-Z Called 'Overrated': Who Is the Most Overrated Music Star?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
It hasn't been a good week for Jay-Z.

First, he lost Rolling Stone's "King of Hip-Hop" title to Eminem. Then, pop singer Sabrina said he was "overrated."

(Full disclosure: We've never even heard of Sabrina, but apparently she wrote a song called "I Want to Shoot Lady Gaga.")

"I can tell you who I think is overrated," Sabrina told SOHH.com. "Jay-Z. Definitely. My fiance is a huge fan and he quotes lyrics and I'm just like, 'Dude, that's not even smart.'

"I miss his old stuff," she continued. "[I saw] videos of him when he was just starting, when he wasn't really well-known and he can really rap. I didn't realize he could. He always sings off beat, you know? He can really rap but I just wish he could go back to that style that he first started out with. That was hot. What he does now, I don't feel it at all -- I really don't feel him at all."

Whoa -- she really didn't mince words.

But Jay-Z is not the only music mogul who seems a bit, well, over-hyped lately. The rapper recently compared his wife, Beyonce, to the late Michael Jackson, which had some people crying foul.

Click through our slideshow and let us know: Who is the most overrated music star?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • lawlerskates 2011/08/18 18:16:24
    Beyonce
    lawlerskates
    +16
    I'm so over Beyonce and her "girl power" bull crap. Her marriage to Jay-Z was a complete and utter business decision. That video is the worst music I've ever seen....whoever produced that or thought it was good is a fool.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • brittmarr 2012/03/08 01:47:42
    Rihanna
    brittmarr
    +1
    Dislike them ALL!!!!
  • SomeoneElse 2011/11/03 21:07:00
    Jennifer Lopez
    SomeoneElse
    +1
    They're all overrated
  • Toby 2011/10/09 22:47:56
    Rihanna
    Toby
    +1
    The Beatles
  • Gasbagmike 2011/10/03 21:42:28
    Justin Bieber
    Gasbagmike
    all of them
  • MaX PowerS 2011/09/12 14:07:38
    Jay-Z
    MaX PowerS
    JAY Z IS JUST LIKE ANY OTHER TALENTLESS RAPPER THAT JUST WALKS AROUND ON STAGE IN CIRCLES AND GRABS HIS BALLS WHEN HE RAPS!! HELL, I CAN DO THAT!!
  • Bellatrix232 2011/08/30 10:38:34
    Rihanna
    Bellatrix232
    she can't sing. She has proved it millions of times performing live. What this poll needs is a 'undecided' option, cause I think Bieber,JayZ and JLo are as bad musicians as RiRi. And you can't compare Gaga to Madonna, cause Gaga can actually sing while Madonna sucks, she's 50 and she sings like a 5-year-old
  • Rita Long Bellatr... 2011/08/31 15:55:17
    Rita Long
    Well she has Beyonce man she must have something going
  • Roxxi 2011/08/24 10:53:06
    Rihanna
    Roxxi
    Way too much auto-tune for me to think that she'd be a decent singer live.
  • D.G.rocks 2011/08/24 08:08:53
    Justin Bieber
    D.G.rocks
    why even ask...?
  • Nicklover 2011/08/24 04:13:17
    Justin Bieber
    Nicklover
    Pretty much everyone one this list cept for Rihanna, Katy Perry, and Lady Gaga. I love their music
  • ** BAMA CHICK ** 2011/08/24 03:15:15
    Beyonce
    ** BAMA CHICK **
  • ««Gingey, the Master Debate... 2011/08/24 03:04:17
    Jennifer Lopez
    ««Gingey, the Master Debater of Þ|-|Дэ†»»
    They all suck balls in my opinion (except Lady Gaga)
  • MarkelFaith 2011/08/24 02:57:35
    Beyonce
    MarkelFaith
    Beyonce and Gaga would somebody please slap em off stage....pls do it 4 me
  • Joe Falzone 2011/08/24 02:29:48
    Jay-Z
    Joe Falzone
    I never liked a person who consider themselves an entertainer when they can only entertain a segment of the people...............
  • Rita Long Joe Fal... 2011/08/31 15:57:39
    Rita Long
    LOL! You got that right overrated along with is partner in crime
  • You brightened up my world!!! 2011/08/24 02:02:46
    Justin Bieber
    You brightened up my world!!!
    +1
    Actually I think Lil wayne is, I don't think he's as good as the world does. Jay-Z is genius, listen to how he puts words together, tells stories, makes business moves, puts couplets and entondres together like no one else can and make every song on an album a hit. Pure Genius.
  • You bri... You bri... 2011/08/24 02:07:28
    You brightened up my world!!!
    +4
    Also somebody can't keep the same style forever, in order to stay relevant you have to change with times. I don't see how he raps offbeat. Have you heard Otis, Empire state of mind, and so many others everything he makes is a classic. Period.
  • Jrogers 2011/08/24 01:28:14
    Katy Perry
    Jrogers
    She is not a very good singer - she does dress like a pop star but she does not sing very well at all
  • Xinea 2011/08/24 01:19:39
    Taylor Swift
    Xinea
    I didn't even know Jennifer Lopez sang...

    And Taylor Swift's music is glorified.
  • MaX PowerS Xinea 2011/09/12 14:08:25
    MaX PowerS
    STUPID YOUNG PEOPLE!
  • Xinea MaX PowerS 2011/09/12 22:53:48
    Xinea
    That's a lot of anger you have there.
  • zombie 2011/08/24 00:35:26
    Justin Bieber
    zombie
    damnnnnnn!
  • boots 2011/08/24 00:10:18
    Justin Bieber
    boots
    +1
    followed by everyone on there except jay-z . Ive got 99 problems but jay-z an't one .
  • trismegistus 2011/08/23 23:32:47
    Justin Bieber
    trismegistus
    Jay Z is far from overrated, he is going through what all hip hop artist eventually go through. Hip hop artist eventually lose their shine. Other artist of rap who hung on long but eventually died out was LL Cool j, lil wayne, ludacris, ice cube, ice t, geto boys, run dmc... and your beloved eminem will eventually lose his status too.
  • Rita Long trismeg... 2011/08/31 15:59:49
    Rita Long
    Some of us thinks he is overrated and his wife. You don't have to agree you like them some people think they are both wack
  • trismeg... Rita Long 2011/08/31 19:15:55
    trismegistus
    Okay, i haveread this whole question/answer series, i responded to something you said like you responded to someone elses, no problem, i respect all opinions..
  • Rihanna
    (¯`·._.·[Dear Maria]·._.·´¯)
    +1
    I really could have used an all of the above option
  • ryuu khan 2011/08/23 20:17:01
    Justin Bieber
    ryuu khan
    +1
    justin bieber took the damn cake
  • Rollo Goodlove 2011/08/23 18:46:06
    Lady Gaga
    Rollo Goodlove
    Any of these folks, and dozens of others could make this list, but the person who is so successful, that I wonder about is LIL WAYNE ?!?!? I just don't see at all why that kid has such a cult like following. Nursery school rhyming, about ...nothing. Rick Ross too, and of course, the kings of the media room..NICKELBACK !!
  • Blue Meanie 2011/08/23 17:31:21
    Jay-Z
    Blue Meanie
    Kid Rock should be on this list
  • You bri... Blue Me... 2011/08/24 02:08:40
    You brightened up my world!!!
    +1
    Didn't even know he still made music
  • Rita Long Blue Me... 2011/08/31 16:01:35
    Rita Long
    No the Rock of Love a hole is a thorn in my butt
  • Patrick Casey 2011/08/23 16:18:04
    Justin Bieber
    Patrick Casey
    sorry jb....but imma tell u 1 time that even if u never say never ur still just a baby
  • You bri... Patrick... 2011/08/24 02:09:11
    You brightened up my world!!!
    +3
    I think Justin will be great
  • logan48227 2011/08/23 14:00:47
    Jennifer Lopez
    logan48227
    +1
    Other than her ass, she has nothing to contribute to entertainment. Jay-Z at least used to be good at what he does, J-Lo......notsomuch.
  • Genesis 2011/08/23 13:17:28
    Justin Bieber
    Genesis
    They're all overrated, except beyonce I think ...
  • rusty 2011/08/23 12:24:57
    Justin Bieber
    rusty
    +1
    In five years he'll be a drunk lounge lizard.
  • zcberry 2011/08/23 10:20:31
    Lady Gaga
    zcberry
    I'm still trying to figure out who she really is? Never could get into her music.....:~|
  • TheCaptive 2011/08/23 09:04:36
    Lady Gaga
    TheCaptive
    +1
    She has a good voice, and I don't know why they auto tune it, but she's still not that good.
    Although, she creates her own hype with her outlandish outfits and lifestyle.
  • Mini Twuby 2011/08/23 05:35:49
    Justin Bieber
    Mini Twuby
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 12 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/21 11:49:02

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals