Quantcast

Is 'Teen Mom' to Blame for Making Teen Pregnancy Trendy?

SodaHead TV 2011/01/21 14:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Earlier this week, we told you about a high school in Memphis that reportedly has about 90 teen pregnancies or new moms on its campus. Now, reality star Kim Kardashian is speaking out against what she believes to be a negative influence on potential teen mothers: MTV's "Teen Mom."

Kardashian wrote about the issue on her Celebuzz blog on Wednesday, pointing out the show turns teen moms into superstars by putting them on television and magazine covers, and creates the impression that getting pregnant that young is the cool thing to do.

"It seems that shows like Teen Mom are all of a sudden making teen pregnancy seem cool in the eyes of young girls," Kardashian wrote. "The kids from these shows are all over the news, even on the covers of magazines, and have been become almost like celebrities, but girls, these are not people you should idolize!"

"Teen Mom" star Amber Portwood, who was recently accused of domestic violence after repeatedly attacking her boyfriend on the show, disagrees.

Portwood told E! News, "Last time I checked, Kim Kardashian had a sex tape floating around on the Internet and I'm pretty sure she made a lot of money off of it ... There's actually a study that shows since the original '16 and Pregnant' aired, the number of teen pregnancies have gone down."

Decent point, Amber. Whose side are you on?

Read More: http://kimkardashian.celebuzz.com/2011/01/19/kim-k...

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • Vic~*PHAET*~ 2011/01/21 16:27:29 (edited)
    Yes
    Vic~*PHAET*~
    +19
    Hold the phone -- Kim Kardashian said something sensible?! Wowza! hold phone kim kardashian wowza shocked emoticon

    It's always argued that the media influences girls to "be rail thin" or "anorexic," right? So why shouldn't it be argued, rather well actually, that seeing a bunch of girls who went out and got knocked up, only to become famous, makes the idea seem cool to some girls?

    Most of the time, you see girls who are pregnant in high school made the butt of cruel rumours or whispered about in the halls when they pass by -- but these girls received fame instead. And realistically, most people wouldn't mind being famous and "known," especially teenage girls.

    Not every person is smart enough to realise that by becoming pregnant at such a young age, they permanently change their own lives. Not every person realises that the baby they have will not be a doll they can just set aside or pawn off on their parents (though, alas, some parents do let this happen).

    Some may just believe that by becoming pregnant, MTV will swoop down upon their house, armed with legions of reporters and big bucks, to make them, their baby daddy, and their baby stars.

    edit: grammar

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • mm61675 2012/05/01 20:41:15
    Yes
    mm61675
    the teens see that these girls are getting knocked up and getting tv shows so they think that could possibly happen to them, sadly.
  • dashchundnana 2012/04/03 17:55:28
    No
    dashchundnana
    take the opportunity to talk to your child after the show about what might happen in their world should they become pregnant. Use every opportunity you can to talk and educate teens and kids.
  • Bettina 2011/08/25 11:16:36
    Undecided
    Bettina
    Probably not, but I remember just how idiotic I was as a teenager...so, you can never be sure what will influence a teen girl.
  • Tank 2011/08/02 00:48:09
    No
    Tank
    It's the parents' fault for letting their daughter be a whore.
  • KB 2011/08/01 20:33:32
    Yes
    KB
    +1
    Obviously
  • hayate 2011/05/26 00:53:15
    Yes
    hayate
    I know they'll make it look like a happy ending that was a good decision after all...one of my relative loves her kids but she seriously regrets having them when she was 16, and she's 30 now and just got married... babies take away your FUN life -.- Portwood is either an idiot or she's trying to protect herself/job...
  • Kimmay 2011/04/05 23:32:22
    No
    Kimmay
    I say no because that's not what the show is about.It's to show how hard it is to be a teen mom or just being a parent period whether you're 16 or 30.A lot of these Teen Mom girls have said that it's not glamorous and are encouraging girls to wait.Most of them have jobs too and are going to college so they are also encouraging teens to get an
    education.Yeah,I do think this show has a lot to do with why the teen pregnancy rate has gone down.In school,they tell you to use a condom but teens don't get an in-depth look at what it's really like to be a parent so I'm happy there's a show that does that.I'm lucky I didn't get pregnant as a teenager because I very well could have.
  • hayate Kimmay 2011/05/26 00:55:28
    hayate
    Kimmay, hmmm....I see completely different...looks fun to me, lol..conclusion is, everyone is happy...
  • Callyislove 2011/03/29 21:49:40
    Yes
    Callyislove
    yes it does. if i wasnt in my right mind i would say "hey all i have to do is get prego and I can be famous" but I'm not that stupid.

    and Kim Kardashian needs to sit her ass (no pun intended) down. Last time I check you got famous by havin sex on camera and all you do now is prance around half naked so STFU!!!
  • chelsea 2011/02/10 20:53:55
    Yes
    chelsea
    MTVS teen mom has not been a show long enough for it to have made a significant difference in the US's high teen pregnancy rate. Pregnancy rates have gone down but there is no evidence to how it has- the US is still has one of the highest pregnancy rates in the world. Kim Kardashian is right, these girls and MTV producers are creating a culture of teen pregnancy. Anything you put on TV looks okay- especially reality tv- but MTV is to blame! They do not care about the young viewers or its participants- producers just want to keep their top ratings!
  • JesseGreathouse 2011/02/03 14:34:39
    No
    JesseGreathouse
    +1
    Parents shouldn't let their kids watch MTV in the first place. It's garbage TV.
  • lยภค☾ 2011/01/30 01:21:50
    No
    lยภค☾
    kim is such a hypocrite!
  • tinta 2011/01/26 23:28:11
    Yes
    tinta
    I meant to vote No. If Kim actually watched the show, she would know that the show absolutely does not glorify teen pregnancy. If anything, it shows how difficult being a teen mom is. I like Kim, but she is an idiot sometimes.
  • SANDERS 2011/01/24 23:55:00 (edited)
    No
    SANDERS
    +1
    When did teen pregnancy become trendy? I'm a teenage dad and my baby momma didn't become pregnant become it's "trendy." That's sad if that's why girls have kids, real sad.
  • Meggies1104 2011/01/24 21:53:53
    Undecided
    Meggies1104
    I see both of there points. But Kim Also made it seem that you can make a sex tape and become famous and which isnt helping any. And really the only teen mom's on the magazine's are ones who are getting introuble with the law.... And personally I think the show is the only one that some what shows what it is like for teen mothers.. sadly I also realize that they don't pay much attention to the struggles of taking care of the kids expect fighting with the baby daddy.. But Mean what else is showing girls what might hapen.. and I also think that we need to stop talking to just girls.. Because we only are talkuing about the girls that are pregnant, Well what about the guys who knocked them up. they aren't talked to about the responibilities of a kid- And i think thats because they n dont have to stay with the kid like the mom would ( if they keep the child) there is nothing keeping them there because they don't have the feeling a mother gets toward a baby
  • 16saywhat 2011/01/24 21:51:14
    Undecided
    16saywhat
    I saw this same issue discussed earlier today on Daily Dose blog at kablog.com...

    It's possible it serves to strengthen one's preexisting beliefs rather than completely form new ones. If a teen wants to have a baby and watches a few shows that, for whatever reason, they may deem to be 'positive' towards teen mothers, it may strengthen the teen's desires to have a baby. If a teen that has no desire to have a baby watches these same shows, they may be more likely to concentrate their attention to the more negative aspects and choose to wait to have a baby.
  • Willy Trombone 2011/01/24 21:11:33 (edited)
    Yes
    Willy Trombone
    I think a lot of the "no" comments are really missing the point of the criticism here. Yes, sane, intelligent people realize that being a teen mom is not a fun, carefree dance through the rainbows. The problem is that most people, especially in today's culture, are not sane and intelligent. Let's be realistic here. Half of the population has below average intelligence. Take the dumbest teenage girl you know. Now, let's say the only images of pregnant women she's ever seen in media are positive, optimistic, upbeat, and glosses over the very serious negative consequences of being a teen mom. Would you trust her to separate fantasy and reality and realize that the media portrayal is not the right one? Let's bear in mind we're talking about the same kind of people naive enough to believe that they can nab a good boyfriend by putting out.



    This isn't just something to do with Teen Mom either- it's all over the media, usually in subconscious ways most of us don't even realize. Take all of the upbeat consequences of pregnancy you see on http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pm.... Now try to come up with shows where pregnancy was portrayed with nuance, ambiguity, and the general message that hey, unplanned pregnancy can really screw up people's lives. It's a pretty darning ratio.
  • tecknotron BN-0 RP2012 2011/01/24 20:24:59
    No
    tecknotron BN-0 RP2012
    My answer is "no" for now. "There's actually a study that shows since the original '16 and Pregnant' aired, the number of teen pregnancies have gone down". That is possible. Maybe most teens who are getting pregnant would be getting pregnant anyway.
  • Alex(: 2011/01/24 20:01:04
    No
    Alex(:
    +1
    The chick has to open her legs, so unless anyone from Teen Mom is coming to hold them open, its the teenager's own damn fault if they get pregnant.
  • tsweetbabii14 2011/01/24 19:55:14
    No
    tsweetbabii14
    +1
    i think on the real people need to stop blaming the show b?c this has happened before ... teen mom is supposed to show a REALISTIC VIEW of what happens when teenagers get pregnant. it's not easy and besides teen mothers don't get pregnant by theirselves.
  • chrisjay 2011/01/24 19:25:51
    Yes
    chrisjay
    They make i seem like it really not that hard to have a kid and t. True Kim Kardashian may have a sex tap floating around...but she's an adult. She's no different than any other porn star (no offense) but the teen girls are easier to relate to than Kim being that she's an adult. Which is more impressionable to teenagers adults drinking at a party or kids....yeah that's what I thought
  • Dan Hood 2011/01/24 18:37:14
    Undecided
    Dan Hood
    +1
    I think people should stop blaming media so much for today's issues. Sure, media does have influence on culture and I think producers should be responsible in what they may be exposing teens to, but parents need to be more responsible about teaching their kids right from wrong. Kim is probably right (for once), it's not unlike MTV to glorify something like this.
  • Chris 2011/01/24 17:47:14
    Yes
    Chris
    I'm in agreement with Miss K on this one.
  • PapaBC 2011/01/24 16:03:06
    Yes
    PapaBC
    Time to get back to morals in America. Where are they?
  • Greta PapaBC 2011/01/24 17:33:07
    Greta
    in your pants
  • Maxi Dove 2011/01/24 15:54:09
    Undecided
    Maxi Dove
    Maybe it is, maybe its not. Maybe its because there are a lot more sluts about these days than there used to be and the sluts are getting younger. Thats not a criticism. i'm a slut and i'm proud of it and I have a lot of fun all the time, without getting pregnant. I guess these little teen sluts need to learn about contraceptives!
  • Koatz 2011/01/24 15:38:48
    Yes
    Koatz
    I'm split on this one.

    On one hand, the teen did participate in the MTV Teen Mom show. By doing so, she did contribute to making teen-pregancy seem trendy.

    But, on the other hand, she was probably manipulated to appear on the show by her by her adult "handlers" - people who work for the show.

    What I can't figure out is what got into Kim Kardashian? I mean, this is totally opposite of her public persona. If she can think, and reach those conclusions, there may be hope for this country, after all.
  • David850 2011/01/24 15:32:16
    No
    David850
    +1
    The kids are ultimately responsible for teen pregnancy. Their parents need to do a better job raising them.
  • future blk 2011/01/24 09:29:36
    Yes
    future blk
    good for Kim! She telling the truth. kim telling truth kim kar
  • DebraJMSmith 2011/01/24 08:01:45
    Undecided
    DebraJMSmith
    It is very possible, even though the show shows how hard it is to have a child as teen. This is because a lot of girls would see it as an attention getter. And they long for attention, which is often why they are having sex to begin with.
  • mc4life 2011/01/24 06:14:04
    No
    mc4life
    +1
    I think kim is just a bit pissed because it took her this long to get pregnant. personally i think the reason why there is more teen pregnancies is because of the modern life. parents have no control over their kids because of the laws that have been passed. they see extremely slutty people on tv who people worship. ex. britney spears, lindsay lohan, christina aguelera, and more. hell they have songs now talking about going out and getting drunk and having sex. so this is the reason i think teen pregnancy is up. so when kim decides to open that mouth with those fake ass lips she better have something worth while to say, because she is on the same list as slutty people on tv.
  • sabbatha mc4life 2011/01/24 16:45:08
    sabbatha
    "so when kim decides to open that mouth with those fake ass lips she better have something worth while to say, because she is on the same list as slutty people on tv."

    You said it! That's exactly what i think too. It's the pot calling the kettle black. She's not a good influence either. That's why it's up to US to raise our kids and not TV and celebrities.
  • thє вluє wαndєrєr 2011/01/24 05:27:42
  • Huki68 2011/01/24 05:14:35
    Yes
    Huki68
    sad
  • Amy 2011/01/24 04:15:46
    No
    Amy
    +1
    It was definitely a problem before the show happened. Stop blaming MTV for providing reality checks to teens! They aren't glorifying being a teen mother. All those girls are broke and have relationship problems. They're not happy and carefree.
  • Arika 2011/01/24 04:06:48
    Undecided
    Arika
    Its mostly to show how hard it is for the teens but then again if you get prego then you can call MTV to get on TV
  • Knight Of Blood 2011/01/24 03:58:24
    Undecided
    Knight Of Blood
    after that one disgusting health class ive decided i can wait......a loooooooooooooooong time
  • Montana 2011/01/24 03:48:22
    No
    Montana
    +1
    Teen idiocy is to blame for the new "trend".

    I saw someone kill another person on tv once. But I didn't think "Oh that's cute, I'm going to do that!"

    Because I'm not stupid.
  • mc4life Montana 2011/01/24 06:15:11
    mc4life
    +3
    Love that answer! ;)
  • Montana mc4life 2011/01/24 06:16:53
    Montana
    Thanks

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/19 05:36:24

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals