Quantcast

Is Islam a religion of peace?

Chaya2010 2010/09/23 10:14:06
Yes
No
You!
Add Photos & Videos



Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • lalouisiane 2010/10/12 17:03:21
    No
    lalouisiane
    +57
    Trick question.

    Islamic meaning of peace: As almost every account of Islam will explain, the word Islam (self-surrender) derives from the same root as salam (peace). In its self-definition Islam is primarily a "religion of peace." The problem consists not in the idea of peace as a good, but in the means deployed to achieve it. In the Quranic discourse, as in the legal formulations derived from the Quran and the Prophet's traditions, the very notion of peace is conditional on the acknowledgment of the Islamic idea of God.

    http://www.citizenwarrior.com...

    In other words, Islamic "peace" means subjugation to Allah and the violent and barbaric laws of Islam and Sharia.

    In contrast.....

    Merriam-Webster's definition of "peace": 1 : a state of tranquility or quiet: as a : freedom from civil disturbance b : a state of security or order within a community provided for by law or custom *a breach of the peace*
    2 : freedom from disquieting or oppressive thoughts or emotions
    3 : harmony in personal relations
    4 a: a state or period of mutual concord between governments b : a pact or agreement to end hostilities between those who have been at war or in a state of enmity
    5 — used interjectionally to ask for silence or calm or as a greeting or farewell
    –at peace : in a state of ...







    Trick question.

    Islamic meaning of peace: As almost every account of Islam will explain, the word Islam (self-surrender) derives from the same root as salam (peace). In its self-definition Islam is primarily a "religion of peace." The problem consists not in the idea of peace as a good, but in the means deployed to achieve it. In the Quranic discourse, as in the legal formulations derived from the Quran and the Prophet's traditions, the very notion of peace is conditional on the acknowledgment of the Islamic idea of God.

    http://www.citizenwarrior.com...

    In other words, Islamic "peace" means subjugation to Allah and the violent and barbaric laws of Islam and Sharia.

    In contrast.....

    Merriam-Webster's definition of "peace": 1 : a state of tranquility or quiet: as a : freedom from civil disturbance b : a state of security or order within a community provided for by law or custom *a breach of the peace*
    2 : freedom from disquieting or oppressive thoughts or emotions
    3 : harmony in personal relations
    4 a: a state or period of mutual concord between governments b : a pact or agreement to end hostilities between those who have been at war or in a state of enmity
    5 — used interjectionally to ask for silence or calm or as a greeting or farewell
    –at peace : in a state of concord or tranquility


    Islamic "peace" includes rape, beastiality, pedophilia, murder and thievery.
    Western "peaced" includes tranquility and quiet.

    See the difference?

    So... the word "peace" with two such far ranging and opposite meanings, results in this question being... impossible to interpret for ALL, much less answer accurately.
    (more)

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Linda 2012/04/07 15:37:21
    Undecided
    Linda
    +1
    There is good and bad in all religions.
  • Chaya2010 Linda 2012/04/09 23:30:11
    Chaya2010
    Have you ever thought that there are good and bad people/ideas and religion exacerbates?
  • **StarzAbove** 2012/04/07 02:07:47
    No
    **StarzAbove**
    No.
  • Rick 2012/04/06 03:11:33 (edited)
    No
    Rick
    Death for islamist extremists! Come on over, We have something waiting for you !!! Pig skins and blood! Enjoy liberal loving supporters of islam!!!!
  • Vitalani 2012/04/05 04:10:38
    Undecided
    Vitalani
    +1
    Every religion is subject to interpretation.
    It is up to it's followers to decide.
  • ACE 2012/04/05 02:43:32
    No
    ACE
    thats funny
  • JudgeRight 2012/04/05 02:16:07
    No
    JudgeRight
    People, we are ten years into a war against------ what? A tactic? A country? No, we're at war with an ideology and it's way beyond time you get to know them. And don't blow off this warning with, "Well not all of them!" Of course not all of them. ALL of them is not the issue. The issue is where do they get their values and what are those values.

    Sharia finance is being practiced in our own banks. Sharia finance siphons off some of the profits for 'cleansing' and sends it to Islamic charity which sends it to Hamas and other terrorist organizations. CAIR and unindicted co-conspirator in the Holy Land Foundation trials and prosecution is welcomed into the FBI, CIA, State dept. Pentagon and White House to council our leaders and protectors in how to work with Muslims and Islam. CAIR has been the filter which approves what is in our grade-school kids text-books about Islam. Sheiks teach in their Madrases they will destroy America 'the GREAT SATAN' Islamic regimes run jihad programming on state run TV for kids as young as kindergarten complete with marching and military drills and drumming into their heads the virtue of dying for jihad. The liberals join Islamists on the street in protest against America and repeat the jihadi's call to arms "Allahu ackbar" being tra...
    People, we are ten years into a war against------ what? A tactic? A country? No, we're at war with an ideology and it's way beyond time you get to know them. And don't blow off this warning with, "Well not all of them!" Of course not all of them. ALL of them is not the issue. The issue is where do they get their values and what are those values.

    Sharia finance is being practiced in our own banks. Sharia finance siphons off some of the profits for 'cleansing' and sends it to Islamic charity which sends it to Hamas and other terrorist organizations. CAIR and unindicted co-conspirator in the Holy Land Foundation trials and prosecution is welcomed into the FBI, CIA, State dept. Pentagon and White House to council our leaders and protectors in how to work with Muslims and Islam. CAIR has been the filter which approves what is in our grade-school kids text-books about Islam. Sheiks teach in their Madrases they will destroy America 'the GREAT SATAN' Islamic regimes run jihad programming on state run TV for kids as young as kindergarten complete with marching and military drills and drumming into their heads the virtue of dying for jihad. The liberals join Islamists on the street in protest against America and repeat the jihadi's call to arms "Allahu ackbar" being translated incorrectly on the news as Allah is great. What it actually translates into is "Allah is greatER" Their Qu'ran and the traditions of Mohammad called the Hadith, wreak of hate and death threats against the Kafir or unbelievers. This is not a misunderstanding of culture, this is a value system that lauds death and destruction and rule by the sword and intimidation over it's own people much less that of foreigners. Now, does that sound like a religion of peace?!!!
    (more)
  • paulyman 2012/04/05 00:44:43
    Yes
    paulyman
    Islam with be peaceful when it is the only religion on the planet.
  • Diana 2012/04/04 23:13:35
    No
    Diana
    No
  • Heisenberg 2012/04/04 21:57:17
    Yes
    Heisenberg
    +1
    Yes, it is. Indonesia is the largest Muslim country in the world, and there are no extremists or Al-Qaida members there.
  • Thor American EXPAT n New G... 2012/04/04 21:28:07
    No
    Thor American EXPAT n New Guinea
    YOU FUNNY
    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
  • The_Infidel_Atheist 2012/04/04 21:12:17
    No
    The_Infidel_Atheist
    Their religious texts are certainly not peaceful!
  • sglmom 2012/04/04 20:54:17
    No
    sglmom
    Ask those who were tortured (vilely, gruesomely) then beheaded and /displayed/ ..
    Ask the women .. girls .. who are raped, tortured, acid attacked, murdered by their own family members too ..
  • shultzhound 2012/04/04 20:46:21
    No
    shultzhound
    Wow I have never seen so many brain washed people in one area before.
  • safari 2012/04/04 20:27:16
    No
    safari
    +1
    Islam is a system of laws - I find calling it a religion not to be the most accurate description of what it is. The only peace they can envision is not the peace of tolerance that any true meaning would include - but rather a meaning of that there will be peace when all are subjugated to their laws - which will still leave no peace for women who are treated horrifically in so many incidences and are not seen as equals. I think the best way to figure out the answer here is to look at what the definition of religion and peace are and then decide.
  • HAITHEM 2012/04/04 19:35:17
    Yes
    HAITHEM
    yes, it is a religion of peace as well as the other religions, becuase these religions are made, sent or created by the God, and THE GOD sends only the peace, never make us suffering.
  • Dee4mee 2012/04/04 19:32:02
    No
    Dee4mee
    +1
    Unfortunately, a few bad slices of bacon spoiled the whole package for me!
  • Linda Dee4mee 2012/04/09 23:39:04
    Linda
    Yes, that's the sad part.
  • Billyk75 2012/04/04 19:18:10
    Undecided
    Billyk75
    +1
    Some followers are and some aren't.
  • **me against the world** 2012/04/04 18:42:19
    Undecided
    **me against the world**
    dnt knw bout tht..srri
  • JP 2012/04/04 17:54:07
    Undecided
    JP
  • Dave0626 2012/04/04 17:18:11
    No
    Dave0626
    +1
    Wow..Chaya2010...hasn't been on here since 11/22/11.
    Anyhow, from all I've seen of Islam..peace would be the last thing it is about.
  • Bucky aka KINGPIN 2012/04/04 17:17:26
  • Momena (mema) 2012/04/04 17:14:22
    Yes
    Momena (mema)
    islam a religion where can found what is missing on your life not only islam and the other religion to the thing is if you love the one you worship sincerely you will live happy and on peace that what i think
  • Lydecho Rain (Лидия) 2012/04/04 17:08:09
    Undecided
    Lydecho Rain (Лидия)
    +1
    It usually is. But no religion can be completely peaceful.
  • michael 2012/04/04 17:05:18
    Undecided
    michael
    +1
    This is really a hard question for me since I know many Muslims from the Middle East ( Mostly Egyptians and Kurds) plus I have many Jewish friends ( who now chose to live in Israel) as well as the fact I grew up in Miami-Fl which does have rich cultural tradition of both racial diversity AND toleration for people who are different. But I will try to answer this question..........I think as a religion Islam does not say in the Koran to go out and kill the non-be leavers rather it refers to both Christians and Jews as "people of the book" and advises the followers merely to leave them ALONE in peace. In fact, one of the 5 pillars of Islam is the concept of Jihad-in which the Prophet encouraged his followers to overcome their sins though this internal struggle within their spirit. However, I think one should also look at the tribal society in which converted to Islam for the seeds of the violence that has recently brought back to the forefront of Islam --it was Osama Bin Laden who changed the whole nature of Islam -even though he had NO legal standing within Islam to issue a Fatwa as a sign of the rising chaos caused by this tribal origins .
  • Rick Armin michael 2012/04/04 17:49:27
    Rick Armin
    I didn't know that the CIA was a tribe. Thanks for the info.
  • michael Rick Armin 2012/04/04 18:02:18
    michael
    Are you suggesting that the CIA plotted with Bin Laden???
    I was addressing the larger issue namely the fact that Islam has been around since 632AD and in particular the theological questions within Islam. Yes I totally ignored the fact that the CIA wasn't founded until 1948 ( the same law also Established both the US Air Force and the National Security Agency, too) since Islam has been around longer than the CIA
  • Rick Armin michael 2012/04/04 23:37:06
    Rick Armin
    Quite a few people have suggested that Bin Laden was a CIA operative. It is certainly not beneath the CIA to use who and what it can to destabilize those areas someone in power wants destabilized. There are a lot of things that have been around longer than the CIA, but that doesn't mean the CIA doesn't influence them in any way.
  • michael Rick Armin 2012/04/05 15:05:08
    michael
    +1
    Well, it is fact mentioned in Ronald Reagan's memiors and published diary as well as the public memiors of several other American officals that the US government along with the governments of the UK, Egyptains, Saudies, and even the Isrealies both funded and armed the fighters in Afghanstan following the 1979 Soviet invasion of that country in the 1980s which is around the same time Al Qede was founded by Bin Laden.
    As for your comment " There are a lot of things that have been around longer than the CIA, but that doesn't mean the CIA doesn't influence them in any way." it is exactly the same type of thinking the British and the French imperalist thinking they could CONTROL Islam. For example, T.E. Lawrence was sent into Arabia promising the Arabs a "homeland free of British influence" at the sametime they issued the Balfour Declaration promising the Jews a "homeland in Palestine". Controling and influencing a native religion by an outside government is much easier said than done.......just simply read your Bible/Torah how it worked for the ancient Romans in Judah against the Jews and Christians.
  • Rick Armin michael 2012/04/05 18:44:09 (edited)
    Rick Armin
    Certainly it does not always work, but that definitely doesn't mean it never works. The likely reason why the Jews got their "homeland" and the Arabs didn't was the influence they were able to exert on the British and American public.

    Speaking of the Bible. Zionists today control a large segment of what is called "Christianity." In this instance, I'm referring to the "fundamentalist Christians" or "Millenialists," who have been influenced by the Scofield "bible" and now seek the early kingdom sought by the Pharisees. Few of these "Christians" realize that the reason those priests and scribes of old rejected Jesus as the Messiah was because he said his was a spiritual kingdom. They wanted an earthly kingdom. Now, influenced by Scofield who himself was influenced by New York Zionists, these "Christians" are seeking the earthly kingdom of the Pharisees rather than the heavenly kingdom promised by Jesus. So religions most definitely can be influenced by outside sources.
  • Paige 2012/04/04 17:01:04
    Undecided
    Paige
    Asking the wrong person because I have no clue at all.
  • JaknHarely 2012/04/04 16:47:07
    Undecided
    JaknHarely
    I have not personally read the koran cover to cover so I can not answer. I can say that certain leaders in the religion, as has been true with christianity as well, propogate a very violent agenda.... talk about hostile witnessing practices! I see a lot of whats going on as a mirror to the catholic churches positions during the inquisition. It was wrong then and it's wrong now. And no matter who G-d is I am certain, G-d is pissed about the abuse in G-d's name.
  • Steve 2012/04/04 16:43:16
    Yes
    Steve
    People just hate
  • All American 2012/04/04 16:38:57
    No
    All American
    It's one of conquest and subjugation.
  • C-455 2012/04/04 16:37:47
    No
    C-455
    +1
    Then again, can that be said about any religion?
  • Soup Man 2012/04/04 16:16:15
  • Jackal 2012/04/04 16:15:05
    Yes
    Jackal
    Yes it is.
  • Undecided
    Jersey Roze ♥Jwon's Cyar'ika ♥
    +1
    What religion is?...
  • Sage 2012/04/04 16:04:16
    Yes
    Sage
    +1
    Even the name Islam comes from the word Salam wich means peace in Arabic.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 32 Next » Last »

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/26 06:00:41

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals