Quantcast

IDOL WATCH: Will James Durbin Win 'American Idol'?

PopNews Wire 2011/04/28 14:02:27
You!
Add Photos & Videos
With less than a month to go until the "American Idol" finale, Randy Jackson has a prediction about James Durbin:

"This guy just might win the whole thing."

Randy was inspired by James' performance of "Will You Love Me Tomorrow," which opened with a stunning a cappella that was among the highlights of Wednesday night's Carole King-themed show.

VIDEO: Watch the latest "Idol" performances.

"No marching band, no flaming piano, I believe I can put in just as good of a show by myself," James predicted.

He pulled it off . . . and Jennifer Lopez correctly noted that James has had a strong week every week since the Top 13 were announced (notwithstanding his duet with Jacob Lusk, "I'm Into Something Good").

Scotty McCreery also gave a moving performance, expanding beyond his usual country shtick with "You've Got a Friend." The opening was soft and lovely, and as Ryan Seacrest pointed out, when Scotty sings, it's like he's singing to one person. "Scotty's in it to win it!" an impressed Randy declared.

Lauren Alaina also stepped it up a notch with "Where You Lead," challenging herself to hit the high notes as per the judges' advice. Her voice cracked a little, but the judges' loved seeing her "pushing" and "going hard for it" … and it helps to have Miley Cyrus rooting for you.

Back to Jacob Lusk, it seems like he had a much better night than anyone expected him. Jacob admitted that being in the bottom three is getting him down, but he then gave one of his best performances to date with "Oh No Not My Baby." It was fun and upbeat and Jacob seemed comfortable and relaxed -- and like Steven, we enjoyed seeing him "shake his tail-feather." Jimmy Iovine predicted that he'd be in the most trouble this week, but we're not 100 percent sure.

That honor could also go to Haley Reinhart, who sang "Beautiful." Steven "heard God" in Haley's voice, and we agree with Jennifer that she has one of the best voices in the competition, but the performance was a little boring. She made up for it with her duet of "I Feel the Earth Move" with her not-even-bothering-to-deny-it boyfriend Casey Abrams, who admitted that he "likes growling with her … onstage." Among other places.

Speaking of "weird beard," as he will now be known thanks to Steven, Casey made his unique mark on "Hi-De-Ho," giving a confident, stylish performance that kept us wanting more. He's not as good of a singer as his leggy gal pal, but as Randy put it, "He keeps this show different."

Our prediction: We'll say goodbye to Jacob or Haley on Thursday, barring the unexpected Pia Toscano-esque surprise.

--Jennifer D'Angelo Friedman, PopNews Wire
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • RawRsaurus 2011/04/28 18:13:52
    Yes
    RawRsaurus
    +6
    James Durbin is the most talented of the group. Vocally, he is extremely gifted, BUT he's also an outstanding performer. I find myself giving him a standing ovation week after week...something I rarely do. He is my pick! I mean, come on! He sang a JUDAS PRIEST song and nailed it!



Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • shlyeblade 2011/08/04 18:53:43
    Yes
    shlyeblade
    I LOVE YOU JAMES DURBIN!!!!
  • not that 2011/05/03 14:31:42
    Undecided
    not that
    it is either James or Scotty

  • joe mauro 2011/05/02 00:40:07
    Yes
    joe mauro
    yes he is imply the best and the most marketable,scotty comes a fadind second and the rest of the phillies are far back thats james durbin in front
  • L K 2011/04/29 09:43:16 (edited)
    Yes
    L K
    +2
    I hope so for a variety of reasons. First of all he has the best voice and is the most consistent performer. Secondly, he would be a great role model for kids who have special needs. James has Tourette syndrome and Asperger disorder, a mild form of autism. I have taught students in my gifted program with both conditions and they usually are of high intelligence and are mortified by their condition. James turned a negative into a positive and has the voice of an angel. Plus, I love rock and roll! I truly hope he wins as I feel he deserves it. The others are indeed talented, but none have the range of his voice. And i never really thought Casey was a good singer. He was an amazing musician, but I just didn't think his voice could compete with the others. My kids and I go see the idols tour ever year when they come to Florida and the performers who get the most fanfare are ALWAYS the rockers. My favs were Bo Bice, Adam, David Cook, Kelly....they rocked the house down. .
  • Lily247 2011/04/29 06:10:46
    Yes
    Lily247
    +2
    He is the only talented person American Idol has had in a LONG time. James is going to take this home. I liked Haley, but after she completely ruined "Rolling in the Deep" for me, I realise just how annoying and irritating her voice is. She sounds like she has something stuck in her throat.
  • garyt212 2011/04/29 04:38:52
    Yes
    garyt212
    +3
    He sure seems to be the most talented!
  • POETRY 2011/04/29 03:26:44
    Yes
    POETRY
    +2
    Well with Casey gone now there is no doubt in my mind that James will win this thing....
  • Jareth Majere 2011/04/29 03:00:32
    Yes
    Jareth Majere
    +3
    Unless he really screws up
  • LLL 2011/04/29 02:56:25
    Undecided
    LLL
    +2
    I love James but like Seabon last year his screaming at the end of a song could do him in. I think though James, Lauren, Scotty and Haley are all great. And too bad Pia isn't in the mix. But judging on the votes here, I'm guessing James will win it. And that's all right with me.
  • JoeBtfsplk 2011/04/29 02:42:01
    Undecided
    JoeBtfsplk
    +1
    Who knows.
  • MIRANDDAAA :) 2011/04/29 02:22:36
    Undecided
    MIRANDDAAA :)
    +1
    I don't think I'll watch the show anymore now that Casey is off because I don't really want anyone else to win.
  • TasselLady 2011/04/29 00:42:16
    Undecided
    TasselLady
    +1
    I don't know. I don't watch the show. May the best person win!!!!
  • ReconMarine~AVA/POTL/JLA/PWCM 2011/04/29 00:04:09
    Yes
    ReconMarine~AVA/POTL/JLA/PWCM
    +2
    This is my pic of the ones left.........
    Jacob, is the next to go........tonight........
    It will come down to James and Scotty........
    I think the majority of those that vote, are Girls, not in their teens yet.
    That is whay Pia went. The pre-teen girls love James and Scotty.......
    Next time they pan the audience, take a look at the makeup of those there.......
    Just MY opinion, so don't start a rowe like last time IDOL came up........
  • L K ReconMa... 2011/04/29 09:57:28
    L K
    +2
    I agree....tween girls vote more than any other demographic. I still don't get Scotty. His voice to me is BORING. James gives an exciting performance every week. Remember when they kept in that terrible singer...the kid Sinjay? (Was that his name?) Think about who they sent home, Jennifer Hudson!!!!!! They like those cute little boys. Yep, I agree 100%!
  • ReconMa... L K 2011/04/29 15:17:13
    ReconMarine~AVA/POTL/JLA/PWCM
    +1
    Yes, that was his name and he was terrible.........
  • L K ReconMa... 2011/04/29 22:36:06
    L K
    +1
    The worst! And what was up with his hair???
  • ReconMa... L K 2011/04/29 23:19:29
    ReconMarine~AVA/POTL/JLA/PWCM
    Some form of Statement, I guess........
    Didn't work.......
  • kitkat42 2011/04/28 23:43:17
    Yes
    kitkat42
    +1
    He has an excellent chance, he's awesome!
  • Unicornz sh*t rainbowzzzzz 2011/04/28 23:34:10 (edited)
    Yes
    Unicornz sh*t rainbowzzzzz
    +3
    if he dosent im gonna break my tv>.<
  • Puzzler ~Sodahead's 32nd Guru~ 2011/04/28 23:01:53
    Yes
    Puzzler ~Sodahead's 32nd Guru~
    +3
    I especially loved this preformance...:
  • Luver 2011/04/28 22:48:28 (edited)
    No
    Luver
    +1
    I really don't think so, only because Randy said he probably would. That's how it always happens, the really good one gets eliminated and a lesser talented but still pretty talented contestant wins.
    (Plus I want Scotty to win. :P)
  • :) 2011/04/28 22:45:44
    No
    :)
    +1
    All he does is scream.
  • ernest debrew 2011/04/28 22:26:54
  • All American 2011/04/28 22:22:42
    Undecided
    All American
    +1
    I like Durbin, Reinhart and Abrams in the final 3.
  • ♥Hannah♥~GSA 2011/04/28 22:15:35
    No
    ♥Hannah♥~GSA
    +1
    Hes not "pop" enough.
  • Hunter 2011/04/28 22:09:29
    Yes
    Hunter
    +2
    If he don't something is wrong that boy has talent that rocks the stage.And the best part he's straight.
  • Helen Hunter 2011/04/29 03:24:08
  • Hunter Helen 2011/04/29 15:37:11
    Hunter
    +1
    Lol what's wrong did I hit a nerve?
  • Helen Hunter 2011/04/29 18:16:11
    Helen
    +1
    Yeah you really did, being straight has NOTHING to do with winning American Idol. Straight does not mean talent, same as gay does not mean you are going to be a interior decorator or makeup artist.
  • Hunter Helen 2011/04/29 18:37:04
    Hunter
    +1
    Did I say it did?I was a HUGE Adam Lambert fan when he was on idol but after the career path he chose after idol really made me sick.He could have been anything but he would rather give lap dances to other guys on live tv.You have your opinion I have mine but I NEVER want to see a american idol like that.
  • Helen Hunter 2011/04/29 18:43:33
    Helen
    +1
    That just proves that you are a small minded person, you liked him when he was what the producers of American Idol wanted him to be.

    But you srink away when he becomes the artist he was going to be all along, Adam is perfect the way he is, and he doen't need people like you to support him.

    He has so many great fans that love every part of him.
    Oh and he doesn't give lap dances on live tv.
    Like it or not this world is changing, people are thankfully opening their minds, and I for one am very glad :)
  • Hunter Helen 2011/04/29 19:27:52
    Hunter
    +1
    WTF am I doing arguing with you?Your 17 and don't even know what the hell your talking about and by the way NOBODY on idol wanted adam to take that path.All the judges and everyone wanted Adam to do rock or classic rock.Maybe you should know what your talking about before you write it but your still a kid and im done with you.
  • Helen Hunter 2011/04/29 20:57:59
    Helen
    +1
    Age does not necessarily equal wisdom.

    Thats kinda my point, thats what "they" wanted him to do, he is his own person he should do what makes him happy. Not what other people want him to do.

    He seems to be making a good living for himself, eventhough "everybody" wanted him to do other things.
    I know what I am talking about hon, trust me. I have read and read about Adam Lambert since he first got on AI, I know what the people on AI wanted of him....and he made a choice to go his own way.

    He has do a great job breaking away from that, and people love him.
  • tonya~~BN0~~ 2011/04/28 21:54:12
    Yes
    tonya~~BN0~~
    +3
    ~~~YES~~~
  • tonya~~... tonya~~... 2011/04/28 21:56:12
  • dhellew2 2011/04/28 21:51:46
    No
    dhellew2
    +1
    It is still too early to tell. James is good but others could still be better. They are all winners.
  • BH1701 "In Kirk We Trust" 2011/04/28 21:35:50
    Undecided
    BH1701 "In Kirk We Trust"
    +3
    Rarely does the most talented performer win. I had no clear favorite all season, but in the past two weeks, James Durbin has made a believer out of me!
  • Helmholtz 2011/04/28 21:30:33
    Undecided
    Helmholtz
    +1
    Don't care. Seriously, if I learned that tomorrow would get to 67º instead of 68º, then that would be more interesting.
  • DiViews2013 2011/04/28 21:24:23
    Undecided
    DiViews2013
    It has never been more obvious that he is the judges pick. It does not matter. All the contestants that were selected for the top 13 will more than likely fare well in entertainment. It is as obvious as they are pushing for Jacob to be voted off tonight.
  • LilMissManners 2011/04/28 21:10:50
    Undecided
    LilMissManners
    +1
    It generally seems as if the sure-to-win contestant finishes anything but 1st! There are more contestants this year, specifically 4 that fall into a category in which I wouldn't be disappointed or confused to see them win it all. I do wish, though, that we can go back to the Adam Lambert days and hear them change the arrangements more... especially James Durbin - he could DEFINITELY have magical moments by doing that and he had me excited at the beginning of his song last night.. Still he has an amazing voice!!

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/18 15:51:36

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals