Quantcast

IDOL WATCH: Paige Miles' Disastrous Performance of 'Against All Odds' [VIDEO]

Paige Miles' performance on Tuesday night of Phil Collins’ “Against All Odds” was “honestly terrible,” as Randy put it, even if you like ’80s elevator music. You know it’s bad when the only nice thing Ellen could think to say was “You didn’t fall down.” We don’t think anyone was surprised to see Paige go home — just surprised that she lasted as long as she did.

You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • PEG March 26, 2010 02:14:26
    PEG
    well you could tell her voice wasn't up to par, so i think she tried to play it safe but just couldn't make it... sad because at first she belted those songs out. she can't help it if she gets sick!! just her bad luck... i feel sorry for her..
  • Quin March 25, 2010 21:49:28
    Quin
    +2
    The judges backed themselves into a corner this season. They sent home some good artists and kept around a few who didn't really have the potential the judges thought they had in the early rounds.
  • Knightrider March 25, 2010 20:16:23
    Knightrider
    +1
    She destroyed it far better than anyone could have destroyed it. She's the Marine of singing!!!! Strap some C-4 to her cause she's done.
  • Poetess March 25, 2010 18:41:19
    Poetess
    +1
    I was wondering when the public was going to dicontinue voting for Paige when she clearly was the weakest link @ this stage in the competition,much love to Paige maybe she can recieve some lessons & audition again next season......
  • Angie March 25, 2010 17:35:01
    Angie
    +2
    absolutely horrible!!!!
  • belinda bell March 25, 2010 16:36:47
    belinda bell
    +2
    OMG this is awful.I would have been embarassed if I were her.She's so off key that no one has done this bad at this portion of the Idol 12 that she'll probably be gone tonight..in a flash!!!
  • Eric March 25, 2010 14:32:05
    Eric
    +2
    I was expecting a lot worse from the comments from the article. People are a little harsh on her in my opinion.
  • beechbug March 25, 2010 13:47:58
    beechbug
    +2
    Im sorry people! The girl has an awesome voice and she did the song HER way! Just because she didnt sound exactly like a copy of the song did not make it terrible!
  • Joel March 25, 2010 13:41:10
    Joel
    +3
    Painfully painful..thats too bad.
  • Tom March 25, 2010 12:52:49
    Tom
    BTW,
    Had the judges been doing the eliminating, Lilly would still be on the show!!
  • Tom March 25, 2010 12:51:19
    Tom
    While I have no problem with Paige getting the boot, this audience voting is rediculous. The judges should decide who goes every week. Maybe the aggregate vote could count as 1 judge vote, so people still feel involved. ( So the top-half vote getters would be a "yes" vote and the bottom-half would be a "no" vote.)
  • Sharon March 25, 2010 11:31:59
    Sharon
    I still think she was way better than Tim. I can't believe he's still there. This was the first time I've ever watched AI and it will be the last - who stays and who goes is absolutely ridiculous.

About Me

Idol Watch 2010

Idol Watch 2010

CA, US

January 07, 2010 20:01:22

View complete profile

The Latest From SodaHead

Celebs

Film

Music

TV