IDOL WATCH: Does Andrew Garcia Deserve to Be Sent Packing?

by Idol Watch 2010 Posted April 14, 2010 06:49:21

10 votes
Read all 7 opinions
View Results and Demographics View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Yes	8 votes	80%
	No	2 votes	20%

Nobody let the King down as much as Andrew Garcia did on "Elvis Night." The extremely likable guest mentor (and Season 8 runner-up) Adam Lambert warned Andrew that his performance of “Hound Dog” was boring, and it appears that Andrew didn’t take Adam’s advice to “step his game up” in time for the show.

The slowed-down arrangement zapped the soul right out of the song — as Simon put it, it was as if all of Andrew’s “coolness was being sucked out of him.” Andrew was in the bottom three last week, and we’d be surprised if he didn’t go home Wednesday night.

More polls by Idol Watch 2010

Add a comment above

RAINA April 30, 2010 23:22:10

No

I LOVE HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...

reply
✩Angel in the Night✩~Cobalt❤ April 16, 2010 21:28:33

Yes

I never really liked him.

reply
DJ April 15, 2010 16:23:31

Yes

It was time . . . They're all fantastic singers, but it was Andrew's time to go.

reply
PEG April 15, 2010 04:38:33

Yes

YES,,ANDREW HAD TIME TO DO BETTER AND DIDN'T. HE DIDN'T PICK GOOD SONGS, AND HE DIDN'T TAKE THE ADVISE HE WAS GIVEN.
I DID FEEL FOR HIM. I WISH THEY COULD ALL BE WINNERS, BUT THATS NOT HOW IT IS, SO YOU HAVE TO WORK HARD !!!!! TO WIN. SORRY ANDREW.

reply
kayla April 15, 2010 02:28:00

Yes

i think he has to go i had enough of the judges being mean to him we should just vote him off
no offense to the people who like him
i think TIM URBAN (the first guy from texas) should win i <3 u tim!!!!

reply
emma April 14, 2010 22:23:32

No

No way I think the two geeks from TX should be sent packing. Two have to go home tonight and I hope those two leave.

reply
plpsrp April 14, 2010 19:55:10

Yes

Yes, Its time for him to go.

reply