I give Eli a ____% chance of ending his career as the greatest Manning of all-time.

Kyle 2012/07/04 00:05:34
Related Topics: Sports, Ending, Manning, Career
Add Photos & Videos

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest

  • Common Sense Conservative 2012/07/13 19:44:51
    Common Sense Conservative

    he was already been picked as probably being the better QB before he even came out of college by many scouts and he is living up to that billing already with 2 Super Bowl wins. To me you can throw out ALL of the stats out but one when it comes down to it.
  • Mike The Country Musicologist 2012/07/13 03:37:22
    Mike The Country Musicologist
    15%, but I'm a little biased, admittedly, being a Colts fan.
  • JaxJaguarsFan 2012/07/12 17:44:36
    40, I think Archie and Peyton are still in the conversation. Peyton carried his team which has rarely had a good defense outside of their DE's. Eli has had a good D to back him up for his career. Archie created these two guys, shouldn't he be the greatest of all time just for conceiving and mentoring them?
  • wolf sloan 2012/07/11 16:55:28
    wolf sloan
    75%. Peyton is on the down hill side of his career and Eli should be in his prime. Plenty of time to pass Peyton, if he stays healthy.
  • Common ... wolf sloan 2012/07/13 19:45:52
    Common Sense Conservative
    1 vs 2, Eli already leads
  • wolf sloan Common ... 2012/07/13 19:48:50
    wolf sloan
    Only in Super Bowl wins at this point.
  • Common ... wolf sloan 2012/07/13 20:20:20
    Common Sense Conservative
    Peyton...9-7 total playoff record

    Eli....8-3 total playoff record
  • wolf sloan Common ... 2012/07/13 20:23:06
    wolf sloan
    16 play off games to 11. I'd be happy with the losers' share from all 16.
  • Common ... wolf sloan 2012/07/13 20:36:26
    Common Sense Conservative
    Peyton has 11 years in the playoffs

    Eli has 5 years in the playoffs
  • Quietman ~PWCM~JLA 2012/07/09 23:24:30
    Quietman   ~PWCM~JLA
  • mal 2012/07/07 21:09:49
    not as good as his brother.
  • joe mauro 2012/07/07 07:10:09
    joe mauro
  • luisofsuburbia 2012/07/06 22:28:36
  • fireware0062 2012/07/06 21:37:31
    95% he's Mr Comeback! Mr. Clutch!
  • boneman1 2012/07/06 18:39:46
    ZERO% Chance. Peyton Manning may be the best QB to ever play in the NFL. He's the standard all other QBs are compared to now. Eli Manning is a good QB, but he's not in the same league with his brother.
  • Common ... boneman1 2012/07/13 19:46:36
    Common Sense Conservative
    How many Superbowl wins does Eli have? Peyton?
  • boneman1 Common ... 2012/07/13 21:37:30
    Based on that logic you'd put him ahead of Dan Marino. If you take away David Tyre's catch in his first Super Bowl and Manningham's in the last Super Bowl he probably wouldn't have any rings. He's a good QB, but he's not in the same league with Peyton, Brees and Brady.
  • Common ... boneman1 2012/07/13 22:00:58
    Common Sense Conservative
    You are correct, Brady has 3 rings. And I would put him ahead of Marino. 8-10 record in the playoffs. To me it wouldn't matter if he owned EVERY passing record in the book because football is about winning football games and winning in the playoffs, and he fumbled pretty bad in that category. To me, you could almost go right down this list and say that these QB's are in order of how they good they were in their careers.

  • shansera 2012/07/06 04:57:20
    50%. I don't believe Eli has a much talent as his older brother even though he has 2 rings over Peyton's one. It takes a lot more than just the quarterback to win a Super Bowl.
  • Common ... shansera 2012/07/13 19:47:25
    Common Sense Conservative
    Tell me the last QB in the NFL that won a Superbowl that you didn't think had much talent?
  • shansera Common ... 2012/07/14 03:03:57
    I didnt say Eli doesnt have talent- I love the Giants and Eli, I said that i thought his brother had MORE talent. Thats all.
  • Common ... shansera 2012/07/14 03:10:20
    Common Sense Conservative
    I hear ya, but having more talent doesn't always equate to being a better QB. BTW, a lot of NFL scouts were saying that the best Manning was still in college when Peyton was already in the NFL.
  • wildcat 2012/07/06 03:01:28
  • Grant Straka 2012/07/05 21:50:39
    Grant Straka
    -5% chance, negative intended
  • Steve Boston 2012/07/05 20:06:38
    Steve Boston
    0% The only reason he got two was because the Pats suck bad playing 9-7 teams.
  • Common ... Steve B... 2012/07/13 19:57:58
    Common Sense Conservative
    They finished the season beating the Jets,Cowboys, Falcons, Packers, 49ers and then the Patriots. They were by far the best team in football last year and their QB was the better Manning.
  • Steve B... Common ... 2012/07/14 02:09:18
    Steve Boston
    Jets over rated, Cowboys and Falcons suck. They ran the table with great defense. He's good but he still carries Peyton's gym bag. My Pats just can't beat 9-7 teams.
  • Common ... Steve B... 2012/07/14 02:25:07
    Common Sense Conservative
    LOL, how many teams beat the 49ers, Packers and the Patriots last year?
  • Patric 2012/07/05 12:26:39
    100 %
    Archie... good but no cigar.
    Peyton... great QB , just could not get his team to win the biggest prize ( once is not enuff) , Eli got 2 already , and probably 10 more seasons to add to the list..
  • The_Miz 2012/07/05 00:44:58
    45 % chance, IMO
  • Eric 2012/07/04 13:07:04
    It is unfortunate that so much credit comes from winning a Super Bowl. Winning a super bowl depends on the other 44 players on the team, coaching, and a certain amount of luck. In my book, Archie was the best, Peyton second, and Eli a distant 3rd. But he could catch up.
  • Patric Eric 2012/07/05 12:28:21
    hmm,, and winning in the regular season ?
    same thing.. need the whole team, not just 44 , coaches, trainers, etc.. everyone ....
  • Eric Patric 2012/07/05 16:48:30
    Obviously. That is why I would rate Archie because the highest despite his losing record he arguably had the best talent of the 3. Followed by Peyton, for one reason because we all saw what happened when 1 (Peyton) of the 44 people changed last season. And the NY Giants have won more Super bowls in the past 25 years than anyone. They are a good organization, with or without Eli.
  • Common ... Eric 2012/07/13 20:03:03
    Common Sense Conservative
    Who would be the QB if not Eli?
  • cmdrbnd007 2012/07/04 12:28:31
    Unless Payton can come back and win at least one more Super Bowl then I think you have to give it to Eli. It's kind of unfortunate but the rings do matter.
  • boneman1 cmdrbnd007 2012/07/06 18:49:08
    Trent Dilfer has a Super Bowl ring and nobody tries to say he's an elite QB. Statistically Eli Manning isn't even the best QB in the NFC East. Amani Toomer just came out and said he'd take Tony Romo over Eli Manning and he won a Super Bowl with him. I agree that great QBs should make their team better, but rings aren't the only criteria to judge by. If they were Dan Marino wouldn't be considered one of the all-time greats.
  • cmdrbnd007 boneman1 2012/07/07 13:24:26
    I know that but Tony is no Dan Marino either. Personally, I think that a lot of the quality coaches refuse to work there because the don't want to put up with Jerry.
  • boneman1 cmdrbnd007 2012/07/07 23:08:05
    I agree with you 100% about the coaching options being limited because of Jerry.
  • cmdrbnd007 boneman1 2012/07/09 14:05:03
    I don't know how much longer the fans are going to put up with it. Maybe, if he starts getting hit in the pocketbook he will back off and let the coaches coach.
  • Common ... boneman1 2012/07/13 20:04:35
    Common Sense Conservative
    I think Trent Dilfer was the best that year. Look how many more Championships the ravens have won since letting him go.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.


2016/02/09 22:41:00

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals