Question Entertainment

Harry Potter series or Twilight series?

Claire Holland February 13, 2009 04:14:39

Harry Potter
Twilight
Both
Undecided
All of the above
None of the above
You!
Add Photos & Videos

Top Comment
Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Comments
  • folie a deux July 26, 2009 19:41:47
    folie a deux

    Harry Potter

    I've been a fan of the Harry Potter series ever since I can remember. twilight just bores me to death lol.
  • tibby cullen May 04, 2009 18:51:21
    tibby cullen

    Twilight

    TWILIGHT SERIES,Honestly Of Course Twilight is Better Itss Bigger Badder Andd Better Itss Amazing And words Cant Describe How Utterly Irrevocubly And Uncondittionaly mazingg Everysingle thing to do with bella and edward and every one from the series is Its Amazing WOWW Itss Youu want More And Moree Itss Like Edward Everything about it invites you In Harry potters Good Butt Nothing Compers to TWILIGHT,NEWMOON,ECLIPSE AND BRAEKING DAWN i Think All Of Them Are Amazing.

    Edward*-Bella*
    Carlisle-Esme
    Renesmee*
    Alice*-Jasper*
    Rosealie-Emmett

    Kachiri
    Senna
    Zafrina*

    Eleazer*-Carmen
    Irina-Laurent-Killed
    Kate*
    Sasha-Killed
    Tanya
    Vasili-Killed

    Amun-Kebi
    Benjamin*-Tia

    Stefan
    Vladimir

    VOLTURI.

    Aro*-Sulpicia
    Caius-Athendora
    Marcus*-Didyme*-Killed

    VOLTURI GUARD.
    Alec*
    Chelsea*-Afton*
    Corin*
    Demetri*
    Felix
    Heidi*
    Jane*
    Renata*
    Santiago

    Garret
    James*-Victoria*-Both Killed
    Mary
    Peter-Charlotte
    Randall

    Alistair*
    Charles*-Makenna

    Jacob-Renesmee
    Sam-emily
    Jared-Kim
    Paul-Rachel
    leah
    Seth
    Brady
    Collin
    Quil-Clair
    Sue
    Billy
    Charlie
    Renee-Phil

    Angela-Ben
    Mike-Jessica
    Lauren-Tyler
    Eric

    ALL LEGENDS
    ALL HERE THE
    MAGIC OF THE TWILIGHT SERIES.

    THANKS FOR READING VOTE TWILIGHT (:
    TWILIGHT SERIES,Honestly Of Course Twilight is Better Itss Bigger Badder Andd Better Itss Amazing And words Cant Describe How Utterly Irrevocubly And Uncondittionaly mazingg Everysingle thing to do with bella and edward and every one from the series is Its Amazing WOWW Itss Youu want More And Moree Itss Like Edward Everything about it invites you In Harry potters Good Butt Nothing Compers to TWILIGHT,NEWMOON,ECLIPSE AND BRAEKING DAWN i Think All Of Them Are Amazing.

    Edward*-Bella*
    Carlisle-Esme
    Renesmee*
    Alice*-Jasper*
    Rosealie-Emmett

    Kachiri
    Senna
    Zafrina*

    Eleazer*-Carmen
    Irina-Laurent-Killed
    Kate*
    Sasha-Killed
    Tanya
    Vasili-Killed

    Amun-Kebi
    Benjamin*-Tia

    Stefan
    Vladimir

    VOLTURI.

    Aro*-Sulpicia
    Caius-Athendora
    Marcus*-Didyme*-Killed

    VOLTURI GUARD.
    Alec*
    Chelsea*-Afton*
    Corin*
    Demetri*
    Felix
    Heidi*
    Jane*
    Renata*
    Santiago

    Garret
    James*-Victoria*-Both Killed
    Mary
    Peter-Charlotte
    Randall

    Alistair*
    Charles*-Makenna

    Jacob-Renesmee
    Sam-emily
    Jared-Kim
    Paul-Rachel
    leah
    Seth
    Brady
    Collin
    Quil-Clair
    Sue
    Billy
    Charlie
    Renee-Phil

    Angela-Ben
    Mike-Jessica
    Lauren-Tyler
    Eric

    ALL LEGENDS
    ALL HERE THE
    MAGIC OF THE TWILIGHT SERIES.

    THANKS FOR READING VOTE TWILIGHT (:
    (more)
  • Vivian tibby c... August 17, 2009 14:26:44
    Vivian
    That is just plain ridiculous. You can describe twilight with 1 word. Stupid. Wasn't that easy. Unconditionally amazing? It is poorly written, lacking a real plot, the "love" is shallow lust, the charecters are flat, and it promots stalking and pedophilia. The fact that the whole story revolves around 2 terrible developed annoying main charecters makes the story even poorer. Also what is with you posting every charecter from the twishit series?
  • Donny the great☺ May 03, 2009 17:43:46
    Donny the great☺

    Harry Potter

    raw passion and unconditional love" does not exist. We are never given any reason or instance where Edward and Bella fall in love. She loves him because he's beautiful and he loves her because she smells good to him. If you could, please find me an example in any of the books where Bella thinks of Edward and how much she loves him without thinking of how 'chiseled' or 'adonis-like' or 'dazzling' he is. Fyi, there are over 100 references in just the first book alone of how amazingly hawt he is, but there's never a personality given to him. They are obsessed with each other, quite unhealthily, I might add. If you think that is love, than I do apologize, but I completely disagree. And while we're on the subject of unconditional love, a good example of what real love looks like is Lily Potter dying to protect her son.
    As for fantasy, both books are fantasy. There is nothing more realistic about vampires and werewolves than there is about wizards.
    As far as being something I can relate to, of course people relate themselves to Bella or Edward. They were written with no personalities, something she admitted herself. (and might I add, what kind of self-respecting writer does that?!)
    Harry Potter is very easy to relate to. That's why it draws fans of all ages, men and women alike, in countless c...">
    raw passion and unconditional love" does not exist. We are never given any reason or instance where Edward and Bella fall in love. She loves him because he's beautiful and he loves her because she smells good to him. If you could, please find me an example in any of the books where Bella thinks of Edward and how much she loves him without thinking of how 'chiseled' or 'adonis-like' or 'dazzling' he is. Fyi, there are over 100 references in just the first book alone of how amazingly hawt he is, but there's never a personality given to him. They are obsessed with each other, quite unhealthily, I might add. If you think that is love, than I do apologize, but I completely disagree. And while we're on the subject of unconditional love, a good example of what real love looks like is Lily Potter dying to protect her son.
    As for fantasy, both books are fantasy. There is nothing more realistic about vampires and werewolves than there is about wizards.
    As far as being something I can relate to, of course people relate themselves to Bella or Edward. They were written with no personalities, something she admitted herself. (and might I add, what kind of self-respecting writer does that?!)
    Harry Potter is very easy to relate to. That's why it draws fans of all ages, men and women alike, in countless countries all over the world. Twilight draws in teens. And mostly girls. Furthermore, HP actually deals with real issues such as racism, death, and bullies. What does Twilight deal with? How to obsess over your hawt boyfriend? Yeah, incredibly realistic."

    This was also in reply to another poster about people being able to relate more to twilight than Potter which is totally not true. >:o
    (more)
  • Donny t... Donny t... May 03, 2009 17:44:39
    Donny the great☺
    This isnt mine... LETS HEAR IT FOR VAMPIRE DIARIES!!
  • A Person April 26, 2009 03:46:09
    A Person

    Harry Potter

    My gosh, there are about fifty copies of this question. Literally.

    And Harry Potter wins. Every. Single. Time.

    It takes immense imagination to write Harry Potter, but Twilight takes little creativity to write. It's plot is cliche and overused. It's quite unoriginal. How many vampire love stories have we heard?

    I'm amazed how J.K. Rowling managed to tie in every single detail strung throughout the series. It's astounding. The first three books, were admittedly kiddish, but the tone darkened in the 4th book. The series transformed from a childrens' series to a teen series. But many adults can read it, too.

    Twilight didn't make any sense at all. How could Nessie have been born if all of Edward's sperm was dead? How did Edward and Bella fall in love after two weeks of knowing each other? How is it possible for Jacob to suddenly become a shapeshifter (and not a werewolf)? How is it that the vampires won in every single book without a single bit of loss?

    Twilight was quite unrealistic in a lot of ways...Harry Potter presented many real-life situtations that us people go through.

    In conclusion, Harry Potter will always be the winner here. He will be remembered in 100 years, 200 years...I think Harry will take his place with Frodo, Dorothy, and the other remembered. He's the boy who lived, and he will continue to live throughout literature.
  • little_firebird April 23, 2009 21:20:22
    little_firebird

    Harry Potter

    Harry Potter series, the Vampire Chronicles, Hellsing series... anything with REAL vampires is better than the meyerpires : D
  • Shelly April 21, 2009 00:34:13
    Shelly

    Twilight

    moderated...
  • DarkAngel5887 April 21, 2009 00:08:46
    DarkAngel5887

    All of the above

    Stephanie Meyers did a GREAT job on Twilight, all of the books were AWESOME!! Each book held my attention, I didn't want to put them down.
  • Vivian DarkAng... August 17, 2009 14:30:00
    Vivian
    Smeyer did a terrible job with twishit. She can't write. The crapped out Mormon fanfiction with a Mary Su center. The books were terrible. The fact that all the did was hold your attention doesn't make them good. Shitty things hold people's attentions. Read a real book.
  • Sidney Valentine April 20, 2009 10:38:30 (edited)
    Sidney Valentine

    Harry Potter

    Harry Potter series is so exciting to read and full of magic..



    unlike Twilight because Twilight series is so boring and lame..
  • Denise April 19, 2009 23:14:21
    Denise

    Harry Potter

    I'm going with Harry on this one. Twilight just didn't hold that much interest for me.
  • Emmett's Girl! & in Nyx I t... April 19, 2009 19:16:58
    Emmett's Girl! & in Nyx I trust

    Twilight

    twilight
  • vg April 19, 2009 17:50:59
    vg

    None of the above

    twilight is cooler than harry poter
  • +1
    fatalrob0t April 18, 2009 23:01:44
    fatalrob0t

    Harry Potter

    Harry Potter is better written. It's actually got plot before the seventeenth chapter and it's fleshed out. Unlike Twilight. Because Meyer is a horrible writer and a horrible woman.
  • Sanjana fatalrob0t April 18, 2009 23:05:04
    Sanjana
    I agree with every word you just said.
  • Sidney ... fatalrob0t April 20, 2009 10:39:19
    Sidney Valentine
    I agree with that!!Ü
  • +1
    Twizted Lady April 18, 2009 03:29:39
    Twizted Lady

    Harry Potter

    why are we even comparing the two harry and twilight have absolutely nothing in common story wise...its like comparing apples and oranges...BUT Harry still wins in my book..!!!!
  • Claire ... Twizted... April 18, 2009 15:58:55
    Claire Holland
    WHAT ARE U TALKING ABOUT?! u don't like Twilight?!
  • +1
    Sidney ... Claire ... April 20, 2009 10:39:46
    Sidney Valentine
    Twilight is so boring..
  • Sanjana April 18, 2009 03:20:58
    Sanjana

    Harry Potter

    I chose Harry Potter, because it has a much more interesting plot (in my opinion) and JK Rowling actually made some pretty interesting characters. Again, this is just my opinion (I'm saying this because the person who asked this question keeps on bashing HP fans). SMeyer's characters are just...ugh...Edward's abusive, and Bella is weak. Plus, SMeyer's grammer isn't impressive either.

    Though, I also don't really like most of the fan-base either. Twilighters have attacked me personally by calling me a retard and an idiot for not liking Twilight. I find that riduculous. IT'S JUST A DAMN BOOK.

    If you bash me, that just shows how immature you are. But then again, flames are so entertaining and so much fun to laugh at...

    Flames are welcome! XD
  • Claire ... Sanjana April 18, 2009 15:59:13
    Claire Holland
    u are weird!
  • Sanjana Claire ... April 18, 2009 21:50:13
    Sanjana
    So are you and Edward Cullen. :)
  • @ll!€ April 17, 2009 23:10:08
    @ll!€

    Twilight

    I like Twilight better than harry potter
  • Claire ... @ll!€ April 18, 2009 15:59:40
    Claire Holland
    yeah!!
  • kayla April 17, 2009 21:30:23
    kayla

    Twilight

    Twilight is way better than freakin harry potter
  • Claire ... kayla April 18, 2009 15:59:48
    Claire Holland
    YEAH!!
  • Sidney ... kayla April 20, 2009 10:40:21
    Sidney Valentine
    impossible!!LOL
  • Ashley~Lady of Socks February 14, 2009 23:28:51
    Ashley~Lady of Socks

    Harry Potter

    HP easily.
  • Claire ... Ashley~... February 16, 2009 21:10:43
    Claire Holland
    well...
  • Ashley~... Claire ... February 16, 2009 21:30:24
    Ashley~Lady of Socks
    well what? O.o
  • kayla Ashley~... April 17, 2009 21:31:10
    kayla
    Have u seen twilight its awsome
  • Ashley~... kayla April 17, 2009 21:53:02
    Ashley~Lady of Socks
    No, I haven't...and don't particularly wish to.
  • +1
    Mikomi February 13, 2009 05:34:30
    Mikomi

    Harry Potter

    Definitely Harry Potter. It was much more well written than Twilight.
  • Claire ... Mikomi February 16, 2009 21:11:00
    Claire Holland
    you are mean destroy my future!!!
  • Mikomi Claire ... February 17, 2009 02:35:11
    Mikomi
    Don't ask if you don't want an opinion. I answered and that doesn't make me mean; far from it actually.
  • Sidney ... Mikomi April 20, 2009 10:40:44
    Sidney Valentine
    Yeah! You're right!
  • folie a... Mikomi July 26, 2009 19:44:25
    folie a deux
    it's so weird how all the harry potter fans are actually giving reasons as to why harry potter is a better series than twilight while twilight fans keep saying things like, "twilight is better because it is amazing" lol
  • Mikomi folie a... July 29, 2009 05:59:16
    Mikomi
    Lol right?
  • +1
    ╚».:☆♥Emo Vampire Tiff Tiff... February 13, 2009 05:22:10
    ╚».:☆♥Emo Vampire Tiff Tiff♥☆╚».:

    Twilight

    defently the twilight series!~ twilight defently twilight series
or
Cancel