Harry Potter and Twilight fan fight: Which fans are better?

by Twilight HQ Posted 2009/07/16 23:14:37

1,659 votes
Read all 2,071 opinions
Lightning Report View Results and Demographics + View Demographics

Loading Demographics... Click an icon to see demographic results Display unknown and private
	Harry Potter fans	690 votes	42%
	Twilight fans	771 votes	46%
	Both are annoying.	58 votes	3%
	I think...	140 votes	8%

Harry Potter and Twilight are both known for their die hard fans! Call them obsessed, annoying, devoted, or just plain weird, but they're here!

Vampire fans had their day in the sun...er, moon... for half of '09, obsessing over all things Cullen. Now, wizard fans are taking the torch, with Harry Potter super fans showing Twilight fans how it's really done. But which flick's fans do you think are cooler?

+24

Add a comment above

Marina 2009/07/16 23:37:49 (edited)

Harry Potter fans

+22
-Because the points they make, make sense.
-Don't just like the series because Harry is "hawt".
-Use proper grammar.
-More HP fans are sane than most Twilight fans. (Not saying ALL twilight fans are crazy, just the twihards)
-Has a larger variety of fans; both genders, and all sorts of ages. Twilight fans are usually just girls between 11-16 years old.
-Understand real literture.
-It was a better movie, too many reasons why to list.
-The book was written with more thought and research.
-The book actually made sense, and was written very well.
-Most fans don't cuss you out and act really immaturely for not liking the book.
-Don't spam the site with the same questions over and over!

I could go on but I have things to do.

Edit: Haha, see what I mean? I already got a downrave from some twilight fan JUST for expressing my opinion...whoever just did that proved my point.
>> See Replies

More polls by Twilight HQ

Brittany to HarryPo... 2009/07/17 13:41:07

I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU!!!!!!!!!!!

reply
Brittany to kfenn97 2009/07/17 13:40:15

+4
that's why harry potter fans are better they have real lives and use proper grammer and spelling not thinking of a stupid statement for 10 hours then go on the computer because they have nothing better to do

reply
laura 2009/07/17 12:43:31

I think...

i think both are great with actions in the them even though some parts are stupid in both movies and books.(no offense to HP fans an TWILIGHT fans!!!)

reply
HarryPo... to laura 2009/07/17 13:29:48

I think you have a point. But I still like HP WAY better! :)

reply
Lenny07luv 2009/07/17 12:37:16

Harry Potter fans

+1
umm definately no question: Harry Potter. Firstly, twilight has 4 books, Harry Potter has 7. Sure, its popular now but in 5 years ppl will prolly remember Harry Potter over twilight.

reply
Brittany to Lenny07luv 2009/07/17 13:42:01

yup great comment about the 5 years thing that was great!

reply
Lenny07luv to Brittany 2009/07/17 13:50:19

thanks i put alotta thawt into it! :) hahaa

reply
twilight lover 2009/07/17 12:36:08

Harry Potter fans

GOOOOO Twilight!!!!!!!

reply
HarryPo... to twiligh... 2009/07/17 13:46:40

You answered HP but say go twilight.....? hmm...... not sure what to make of that....

reply
kt 2009/07/17 12:31:12

I think...

they are both great

reply
HarryPo... to kt 2009/07/17 13:45:46

Yep they both have different traits that the other doesn't have. Which in a sence makes them both good, but it depends on what traits you like better. For HP it's more in depth and it's a whole different world. For Twilight it's more a romance and it's like it could happen to us beause it's set in the world we know and love. BUt for me I think the depht and time that JK Rowling have put into her books and how she sucked me in makes me like HP over twilight.

reply
erin 2009/07/17 12:31:10

Twilight fans

twilight rules! any1 who doesnt think so can go read Harry Pothead

reply
teh_noo... to erin 2009/07/17 13:06:48

+1
Nice argument. Spectacular. That really made me think.

reply
erin to teh_noo... 2009/07/31 21:36:00

well thank u. @ least some people dont make me feel bad just 4 expressing miself.

reply
HarryPo... to erin 2009/07/17 13:38:13

+1
Wow. Really? Hmm..... Offensive.... That's just great......! Just because YOU don't like it and a few other people don't doesn't mean that the books/movies suck! The world does NOT go by what YOU day! Geez.... Sham on you.

reply
erin to HarryPo... 2009/07/31 21:33:30

hey, im just stating mi opinions. plus, ive barely been out of Ill. so dont tell me bout da world!

reply
Diomedes to erin 2009/07/17 13:39:30

Figures.Another Twitard extremist brat who fell for the cheesy fake Vampire-dork.

reply
dancongpangl 2009/07/17 12:24:23

Twilight fans

+1
well I like Twilight better so I would put this. But stating the facts Harry Potter has made WAAAAAYYYYY more money.

reply
Jehnyhal~ Hope Not Hate~the... 2009/07/17 12:23:22

Twilight fans

+1
Harry Potter fans can actually restrain themselves- despite the fact that the movie premiered just yesterday, there have been a minimum of questions and most have been spelled correctly. Twilight fans are frequently hysterical, overload the site with identical, badly-typed questions which mainly centre around how attractive you find the leads. Oh yeah, and Potter fans have been around MUCH longer.

reply
aly 2009/07/17 12:22:35

Twilight fans

Twilight fans are soooooooooooo much better!

reply
Jehnyha... to aly 2009/07/17 12:24:39

How so?

reply
Kelster 2009/07/17 12:21:12

I think...

I love both! I cannot wait to watch the new Harry Potter movie, and I also can't wait until New Moon comes to theaters.

reply
Amie 2009/07/17 12:19:15

Harry Potter fans

Dont forget Draco and how magical everything is......Twilight arnt even real vamps!!all well...Edward is still Hott. (so is Draco)

reply
allyface 2009/07/17 12:17:17

Twilight fans

twilight rox ur sox

reply
D 2009/07/17 12:12:53

Twilight fans

+3
Harry potter sucks!

reply
pg 2009/07/17 12:04:04

Both are annoying.

i hate both of them

reply
Alex 2009/07/17 11:55:11

Harry Potter fans

+1
HP FTW! SCREW TWILIGHT! Sorry for the obnoxious comment and caps.

reply
EatMeWhileImHot 2009/07/17 11:53:55

I think...

+3
Obviously Twilight Fans Stoopit :L

reply
ryan0014 2009/07/17 11:49:42

I think...

both of them are great movies.

reply
The Roses Thorn 2009/07/17 11:49:03

Harry Potter fans

+1
It's ok to be a fan, but some hardcore fans are just creepy...

I still haven't seen any crazy Potter fans, but those Twilight-fans are not normal. I don't feel safe around Emos..

reply
Alice_Cullen 2009/07/17 11:48:19

I think...

You can't choose, they're two completly different things and I like both books equaly

reply
Vampire/Werewolf Girl 2009/07/17 11:48:07

Twilight fans

Twilight is beter but i stil love HP

reply
alexis 2009/07/17 11:47:30

Twilight fans

i luv twilight

reply
kay2164 2009/07/17 11:43:35

Harry Potter fans

+1
Harry Potter is the best series ever. Twilight is pretty boring. Harry Potter will always be better. The writing, the characters, the story... It's well written, whereas Twilight isn't.

reply
candice 2009/07/17 11:42:46

Twilight fans

twilight is so much hotter than harry potter.

reply
~♠♀She-Ninja-PandasaurusRex♀♠~ 2009/07/17 11:30:54

Harry Potter fans

+2
Harry Potter applies to a much weirder auidience and has been popular since it came out. Twilighit is no longer as popular as it used to be.

reply
leena aboutaleb 2009/07/17 11:24:41

Harry Potter fans

+2
twilight is a stupid romance between freaks.

reply
The Hell's Keeper 2009/07/17 11:21:51

Harry Potter fans

+1
harry potter

reply
blushn1980 2009/07/17 11:12:25

I think...

I am a fan of both so either way I WIN!!!

reply
ShayShay 2009/07/17 11:00:37

I think...

i like them both except twilight has hotter people!

reply