Quantcast

Guillen Suspended Five Games Over Pro-Castro Comments. Fair or Foul?

ProudProgressive 2012/04/10 17:04:35
Yes 5 games is an appropriate suspension
1 vote
7%
No he should have gotten a longer suspension
1 vote
7%
No he should have been fired
2 votes
13%
No he should not have been suspended at all
10 votes
67%
Undecided
0 votes
0%
None of the above
1 vote
7%

Marlins Suspend Manager for 5 Games Over Pro-Castro Comments
By THE NEW YORK TIMES

Ozzie Guillen, brought in to manage the Miami Marlins as part of an effort to court the city’s Latino population, was suspended for five games by the team for his recent remarks that seemed to laud Fidel Castro. Guillen, who left his team in Philadelphia to fly back to Miami, publicly apologized Tuesday in a televised news conference, saying his remarks about Castro were “the greatest mistake of my life.”

“I’m on my knees,” Guillen, speaking in Spanish, said.

Guillen, who had developed a reputation for incendiary public comments — a homophobic slur, among them — in his tumultuous tenure as manager of the Chicago White Sox, said in an interview with Time magazine that he admired Castro’s survival skills.

“The Marlins acknowledge the seriousness of the comments attributed to Guillen,” the team said in a statement. “The pain and suffering caused by Fidel Castro cannot be minimized, especially in a community filled with victims of the dictatorship.”

For Guillen, who often seemed to teeter on the brink of being fired in Chicago, the remark seemed meant to be funny, maybe even self-deprecating. But in Miami, with its politically active and passionately committed community of Cuban emigres, many of whom fled Castro’s authoritarian rule in Cuba, Guillen’s remarks set off the kind of firestorm he had never before faced.

People, including local elected officials, were calling on him to resign. Protests were being planned. And Miami’s management was reeling. It was, then, unclear whether Guillen, even with his suspension, could survive the flap.

“I say a lot of things and I never apologize,” he said at the news conference. “But now I have to because I did the wrong thing. I’m behind the Cuban community.”

For the Marlins, Guillen’s predicament represented a marketing nightmare. The team opened its season in its expensive new stadium last week — a $634 million, retractable-roofed monument in Miami’s Little Havana neighborhood, home to many Cuban immigrants. The team boasts a number of multimillion-dollar acquisitions and was clearly intent on at last tapping into the city and state’s enormous number of Latino residents and baseballs fans.

“My family’s in Miami and I’m willing to do everything to try to make it better,” Guillen said at the news conference. “I will help the Cuban community, the Latino community, like I always do. I hope I get better and people understand my situation and I’m willing to do everything in my power and the Marlins’ power to help this community.”

Read More: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/11/sports/baseball/...

Question Closed

Top Opinion

  • elijahin24 2012/04/10 17:28:58
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    elijahin24
    +4
    Let me sa first, I don't think he should have said what he said. It was INCREDIBLY poor judgment. I also don't agree wit what he said. And I understand why people, particularly Cuban-Americans would be HIGHLY offended by it...that is: I understand it as much as a white guy from Missouri possibly can.
    But Major League Baseball (nor any other sports legue) should not be suspending people over political opinons. His statement was not racist, or hateful. It was a political opinion. It would be similar to a person who playes in Kansas City, saying that they are pro-choice, or pro-same-sex-marriage; or a person who plays in San Francisco, promoting Prop 8. It's not a good move from a PR standpoint, but it is their right to voice those opinions, if someone wants to listen.
    Ozzie Guillen is not an elected official. He's not empowered to set forign policy. He's a baseball manager; and he needs to shut up, and manage his team; and the community needs to shut up and let him.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • wildcat 2012/04/19 01:09:55
    Yes 5 games is an appropriate suspension
    wildcat
    He works for the Marlins, it is their decision.
  • Talmadge Monroe 2012/04/18 16:04:05
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    Talmadge Monroe
    ...and Castro DID have great survival skills. Not making a call as to their morality, but great none the less. Just like Voldemort.
  • Prime Time Lime 2012/04/15 23:50:40 (edited)
    No he should have been fired
    Prime Time Lime
    I HIT THE WRONG BUTTON,,,,,,yikes. He should NOT have been suspended at all. His freedom of speech is compromised.He has a right to say what he believes even if local Cuban disagree with him.
  • gregaj7 2012/04/15 23:16:08
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    gregaj7
    +1
    No "freedom of speech", eh?
  • jacktown kid 2012/04/13 20:43:44
    No he should have gotten a longer suspension
    jacktown kid
    LONGER
  • unclepat 2012/04/10 21:30:08
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    unclepat
    +1
    Welcome to the rough and tumble world of Miami's exile politics, Ozzie. tough break on the suspension. I don't necessarily agree with it but one thing you DON'T do in Miami is say ANYTHING that remotely sounds pro Castro!
  • Orangedragan 2012/04/10 20:51:35
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    Orangedragan
    +2
    I don't see what his political views, misguided as they are, have anything to do with being a coach.
  • elijahin24 2012/04/10 17:28:58
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    elijahin24
    +4
    Let me sa first, I don't think he should have said what he said. It was INCREDIBLY poor judgment. I also don't agree wit what he said. And I understand why people, particularly Cuban-Americans would be HIGHLY offended by it...that is: I understand it as much as a white guy from Missouri possibly can.
    But Major League Baseball (nor any other sports legue) should not be suspending people over political opinons. His statement was not racist, or hateful. It was a political opinion. It would be similar to a person who playes in Kansas City, saying that they are pro-choice, or pro-same-sex-marriage; or a person who plays in San Francisco, promoting Prop 8. It's not a good move from a PR standpoint, but it is their right to voice those opinions, if someone wants to listen.
    Ozzie Guillen is not an elected official. He's not empowered to set forign policy. He's a baseball manager; and he needs to shut up, and manage his team; and the community needs to shut up and let him.
  • lstl5 2012/04/10 17:20:09
    No he should not have been suspended at all
    lstl5
    +3
    What happened to freedom of speech?
  • Pablo lstl5 2012/04/11 02:40:19

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/25 11:07:54

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals