Quantcast

Fantasy Football: Cam Newton vs JAX Jaguars or Philip Rivers vs KC Chiefs?

Fef 2011/09/20 22:54:56
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Fantasy Football Dilemma! Whom do I start at quarterback on my fantasy football team this weekend? Philip Rivers or Cam Newton? Both quarterbacks face easy teams and could get me lots of points. I know many of you out there don't care about football or football fantasy leagues, but you should! More people watch NFL than any other television program -- even Oprah. ESPN NFL has a 9.7 Household rating in 2010 compared to Oprah's 5.7 or Two and a Half Men 6.1.

Philip Rivers ranks among the top two or three NFL quarterbacks -- especially with Petyon Manning watching from the sidelines with his neck injury. Philip Rivers plays for the San Diego Chargers and amassed more passing yards than any other quarterback in the 2010 season. Rivers threw the pigskin for 4,710 yards in 2010 and nearly 13,000 yards the past three seasons combined.

Philip Rivers has thrown 713 yards and four touchdown passes in 2011. He allowed four sacks, threw four interceptions and fumbled once. Rivers has decent numbers considering he faced good opponents -- Minnesota Vikings and New England Patriots. On a side note: Rivers looked like the rookie when QB Tom Brady marched the Patriots up/down the field in Gillette Stadium in Foxboro, MA.

Philip Rivers faces the Kansas City Chiefs. The Chiefs have a 0-2 record and allowed more touchdown passes (8 TD) than any other defense. The Chiefs have sacked the opposing quarterback only once this year -- the worst in the league. They have the 20th best passing defense in yards, allowing 261 yards per game in the air. Philp Rivers has averaged 20 fantasy points per game.

Cam Newton and his Carolina Panthers face an easy pass defense this weekend and also threw four picks, but the similarities end there. Cam Newton has only played two games in the NFL. The #1 draft pick out of Auburn has thrown for more than 400 yards in each of his first games -- a feat no other rookie in NFL has accomplished. Cam Newton has thrown for 854 yards, three touchdown passes, got sacked eight times and hasn't fumbled the ball. Newton also rushed for 71 yards and two touchdowns. Rookie Cam Newton has over 30 fantasy points per game.
71 yards touchdowns rookie cam newton 30 fantasy points game

The Jacksonville Jaguars have allowed 215 passing yards per game ranking them at 14th spot. The Jags allows four TD passes and intercepted the ball three times. The opponents only threw the ball 58 times against the Jaguars.

Help me out... what to do? Put in the veteran Philip Rivers against a softer KC Chiefs? Or bench the stable Rivers and start the rookie sensation Cam Newton? My son wants to start Cam Newton -- so maybe that factor will override anything else. After all, I don't want to pick Rivers and have Cam Newton outscore him again.
Add a comment above

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • BAMACRUSADER 2011/09/22 13:13:48
    Cam Newton
    BAMACRUSADER
    I am a big Bama fan, as my screen name hints, so I say this from a close perspective watching and fearing this guy. Cam is a great QB and Athelete. He is as mantaly tough as any player i have ever watched. He is a natural winner. I would never bet against him. This doesn't mean he won't have some bumps in the road along the way, but all in all, I bet he turns out to be one of the great ones.
  • Ramon 2011/09/22 09:46:10
    Philip Rivers
    Ramon
    Funny I have the same choice and I'm starting Phillip Rivers. Cam Newton has done well but he is still an unproven rookie. Phillip Rivers is a proven commodity going against the league's worst defense...they have allowed over 40 points per game over the first two games. I'm 2-0 so far so I'm making the correct choices up until now.
  • dlsofsetx 2011/09/21 19:06:15
    Really Fef?
    dlsofsetx
    Fantasy sports are absurd.
  • misterz 2011/09/21 16:43:39
    Really Fef?
    misterz
    Jax.
  • The Hairwizard 2011/09/21 11:23:34
    Philip Rivers
    The Hairwizard
    gotta go with Rivers the experience alone should tell it all. Newton is hobbling on one foot and should he injure it more could hamper is mobility so with that said, Rivers should have a better performance!
  • JenSemPa 2011/09/21 10:13:22
    Cam Newton
    JenSemPa
    I'm going with Newton this week because my other QB (Vick) is all banged up and may not play.

    Actually, if I had gone with Newton instead of Vick this past weekend, I would have won this week. Newton looks like the real deal.
  • Shadow's Companion 2011/09/21 04:54:06
    Really Fef?
    Shadow's Companion
    +1
    What ever happened to just watching TEAMS play?
  • Fef Shadow'... 2011/09/21 06:14:21
    Fef
    +1
    boring.
    Just kidding. I like watching the NFL, and Fantasy Football makes it far more interesting.
    I learn far more about the players, the "drama" behind the scenes, etc...
  • Shadow'... Fef 2011/09/21 06:21:27
    Shadow's Companion
    +1
    I think it distorts spectatorship into rooting for individual players, eschews team support in favor of personal stats and, worst of all, evokes a quasi-slavery model in the way people brag about "owning" one athlete or another.
  • JenSemPa Shadow'... 2011/09/21 10:16:47
    JenSemPa
    My husband and I still do that, even though we also do fantasy football. He's from Virginia and is a Redskins fan. I lean toward the Raiders but am not into football as much as he is. (Hockey is much more my thing.)

    He'd definitely want the Redskins to win, even if it meant that an opposing player who was on his fantasy team didn't have a good game.
  • Ramon Shadow'... 2011/09/22 09:48:01
    Ramon
    The games are more interesting when you have an investment in who wins.
  • Shadow'... Ramon 2011/09/22 13:37:09
    Shadow's Companion
    No, the games are incidental when you have an investment in who wins. They become just another consumerist abstraction. What a sad comment on where our society is headed.
  • Ramon Shadow'... 2011/09/23 09:46:27
    Ramon
    I guess....I just see it as entertainment.
  • Fresno State Fan CB-05 2011/09/21 04:29:38
    Philip Rivers
    Fresno State Fan CB-05
    +2
    Kansas City is an absolute horror show right now. Maybe the next Oh for 16 team, the way they've been playing. Rivers is going to torch them for huge numbers.
  • carlton999 2011/09/21 01:20:22
    Cam Newton
    carlton999
    +1
    Cam - back to back 400 yard games and he is going against the Jags, how can you not.

    Rivers - the Chiefs sucking big time right now but its an AFC West Division game, all stats and records have to be thrown out the window. this will not be a game, it will be a fight like all AFC West Division games.
  • ☆SPIDERPIECES☆ 2011/09/20 23:13:07
    Philip Rivers
    ☆SPIDERPIECES☆
    +2
    Proven top 5 NFL QB.
  • Frank 2011/09/20 23:10:00
    Philip Rivers
    Frank
    +2
    I'm from Kcity and a chiefs fan.. Bet your house on Phillip Rivers, he may throw for 500 yeards..........
  • ..::localeye::.. 2011/09/20 23:01:52
    Really Fef?
    ..::localeye::..
    +1
    really...
  • Chris D 2011/09/20 22:59:09 (edited)
    Cam Newton
    Chris D
    +1
    Cam Newton will light up the points!!

    cam newton panthers

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/06/19 00:07:11

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals