Do You Want To See Mariah Carey on 'American Idol'?

She's pretty, but not near that much.

My God no Mariah Carey. Isn't this show supposed to be about the contestants? When it started, we barely knew the judges, it was about the "kids". She would take over the spotlight, ..not something I would like to see. I would much rather have someone on who knew what the process was like for the contestants. -- someone like Clay Aiken. Smart, talented, quite funny, and who would know what they were going thru.

Ah she seems so sweet. Like, a younger Paula without pain pills making her say yes to everything.

Should I? Would that make me cool?

No thanks.

Finally a judge with high caliber talent

Charlie sheen

she is rather boring. Get someone better.. I loved Steven Tyler he should stay

Then again, like Mariah Carey about as much as I like Idol...

Not really,because there'd be nights when she would be competing directly against her husband's show on a different network! I don't watch those shows any way because it's only another variation of "reality tv programming."

NO. Get Simon back.

Love her

I don't even want to see AI

I don't care either way I quit watching after about the 3rd season

I do still watch the first few episodes while they are finding people though but thats it.

God no!

Just end the whole thing!

Another useless tv show.

Wait, I change my answer. If she's on the show that means less time she'll have to make records & try acting. Yes, she should be on the show.

I think she would make a great choice. She is certainly knowledgeable enough about the music business.

Sure why not.

Nothing against her, just American Idol needs to just end already. It's gone downhill, can't compete against The Voice & X Factor, it's done.. Lost its appeal..

I'd rather not see American Idol at all.

She'll just damage her career like the others.

She doesn't need anymore Press or popularity

...KIDS NEED THEIR MOM AND DAD EMPLOYED.

I love listening to Mariah's talking voice. It's very soothing/warm. So, just for that, I'd watch just to hear her talk. But beyond that, yes, as a LOOOOONGtime fan of hers to know that in her prime she knew how to REEEALLY sing, I think she has authority to judge someone's singing, as opposed to someone like J-Lo or Steven Tyler, or even Britney Spears who will be judging this year's "X-factor". She shouldn't have authority to judge ANYBODY'S singing (presence on the stage, maybe but NOT singing). That also goes for J-Lo & Steven. I think it would be an honor for Idol to get an icon and one of the best selling artists of all time. I think she'd be able to give the contestants some good advice.

It won't make a difference. Idol is losing its appeal.

I'd have to agree. It's losing its appeal, no matter who they have on there. Shoot, I stopped watching after maybe season 3?

I'd rather see Clay Aiken as judge.

no i hate her i think if she was a judge i would never wacth American Idol ever agan i mean how can someone with no talent judge talent?

..and this coming from someone who loves eminem..lol......riiiiiiiiight.

ok ur right most of the reason that i hate her is because she dissed eminem (but i did hate her befor that) and if u think eminem has no talent you obviously dont listin to lyrics whcth is what i judge on eminem has MUCH better lyrics than mariah just look at her songs "touch my body" "obsesed" then eminems songs "when im gone" "mocking bird" he writes songs that have meaning and come from the heart she writes songs about how hot and amazing she is mariah may have a better voice but he is better lyrically.

lol! You will not read any post of mine saying how I know everything about eminem or his music, however, it seems like I know a bit more about Mariah's music than you do. Come on man,.. she doesn't just talk about "touch my body"..lol! I can go from the past to present.. She wrote a very emotional song I was just listening to the other day called "bye bye".. she also wrote "one sweet day". Both talk about the loved ones you've lost. She wrote "Fly like a bird" which talks about the next life (Heaven). She wrote the song "Hero" which encourages everyone to look inside themselves and they will find a hero within'. She wrote "Anytime You Need a Friend (I will be here)".. which is self explanatory. She wrote a song called "Butterfly" which is a story of how she must let her love go and if that person is meant for her he will come back to her OR you could relate that song to a lost loved one, (which many do). There are PLENTY of songs she wrote that haven't been radio songs but are on her records that touched me and I'm sure lots of others. I can go on, but if I did, I'd be here all day. Those are just to name a few off the top of my head. Shoot, how do you think she's one of the best female selling artists of all time. Great melody along w/ great voices and GREAT LYRICS (that SHE wrote) must come together to do that.

i dont know aneything about her and i dont lisitn to her and i think shes fake i havent looked on ur profile or aneything so i diddent know you know alot about eminem i just dont like her personality nor do i like her songs its my opinon (and im not alone) if u chose to like her its ur opinon.

I'd rather see Idol end, it's ran it's course. I'm tired of all the competition shows on TV now. they should go back to the way TV was before all this and make real shows and movies.

I love her. She would be an awesome judge

i think she is so talented and i like her :D

I hardly watch, but I don't like Mariah..